IPR call reminder:
|
"I draw your attention to your
obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations' IPR policies. Every
Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner
Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the
Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become
essential to the work of 3GPP. Delegates are asked to take note that they
are thereby invited:
|
Antitrust policy Reminder:
|
"I
also draw your attention to the fact that 3GPP activities are subject to all
applicable antitrust and competition laws and that compliance with said laws
is therefore required of any participant of this TSG/WG meeting including the
Chairman and Vice Chairman. In case of question I recommend that you contact
your legal counsel. The
leadership shall conduct the present meeting with impartiality and in the
interests of 3GPP. Furthermore,
I would like to remind you that timely submission of work items in advance of
TSG/WG meetings is important to allow for full and fair consideration of such
matters." |
| AI | TD# | Type | Doc For | Subject | Source | Rel | Comments | e-mail_Discussion | Result |
| 0 | - | - | - | All Agenda Items | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 1.1 | - | - | - | Opening of the meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 2 | - | - | - | Agenda | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 2 | S2-2106987 | AGENDA | Approval | SA WG2 #147E Meeting Agenda | SA WG2 Chair | Approved | Approved | ||
| 2.1 | - | - | - | IPR Call and Antitrust Reminder | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 3 | - | - | - | SA2#145E Meeting report | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 3 | S2-2106988 | REPORT | Approval | Auto-Generated Report of SA WG2 meeting #146E | SA WG2 Secretary | Approved | Approved | ||
| 4 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 4 | S2-2107632 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3201 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update Network Function/NF Service Context Transfer Procedures | Samsung | Rel-17 | WI Code should be TEI17, 5GS_Ph1. Noted | Devaki (Nokia) comments that Nokia objects to the paper as this proposal removing the essential technical restriction, furthermore this proposal is unnecessary as data sharing is well covered for NFs within the SET using UDSF. Magnus H (Ericsson) object to this CR. It is not category F, and it assumes contexts are not available to all NF instances in a NF Set (SMF Set) Devaki (Nokia) comments that this CR is not even in scope of the agenda for SA2#147E (i.e. not related to any incoming LS). Either way, our objection based on technical reason remains. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== Kisuk (Samsung) notes this CR. | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Common issues and Incoming LSs | - | - | Docs:=69 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | For information (proposed to be noted) | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107012 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Small data transmissions | SA WG3 (S3-213034) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105372 from S2#146E. Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this LS as it is CC'd to SA2 with no action to us. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107009 | LS In | Information | LS from ITU-T SG13: LS on the new work item ITU-T Y.NGNe-IBN-arch: 'Functional architecture of NGN evolution by adoption of Intent-Based Network' | ITU-T SG13 (SG13-LS221) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2105368 from S2#146E. Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note this LS for information ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107019 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: LS on backoff timer handling when NSSAA is not completed | CT WG1 (C1-214887) | Noted | Noted | ||
| 4.1 | S2-2107027 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on Small data transmission | CT WG1 (C1-215152) | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this LS as it is CC'd to SA2 with no action to us. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107034 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG4: LS on Guidelines on Port Allocation for New 3GPP Interfaces | CT WG4 (C4-214848) | Rel-17 | Noted | Pallab (Nokia) proposes the NOTE the LS ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107035 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG6: LS to SA2 on mandatory SSC modes supported by UE | CT WG6 (C6-210258) | Rel-15 | Postponed | Antoine (Orange): We should reply that all SSC modes are optional. Haris(Qualcomm) comments and proposes to postpone the LS Chris Joul (T-Mobile USA) - Suggests postponing this LS and Comments indicating all SSC modes should be supported. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also proposes to postpone the LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107056 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG3: LS to SA WG5 on model deployment and update from OAM to NG-RAN | RAN WG3 (R3-214481) | Rel-17 | Noted | As there is no action to SA2, Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS. Jungshin (Samsung) also proposes to note the LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107060 | LS In | Information | Reply LS on Alignment concerning 5G RG requirements and its remote management | SA WG1 (S1-213260) | Noted | Noted | ||
| 4.1 | S2-2107065 | LS In | Information | Reply LS to GSMA on prevention of attacks on sliced core network | SA WG3#104-e (S3-213209) | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS (SA2 already answered to GSMA) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107068 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG3: LS on User Plane Integrity Protection for eUTRA connected to EPC | SA WG3 (S3-213272) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107069 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG4: Reply LS on the mapping between service types and slice at application | SA WG4 (S4-211225) | Rel-17 | Noted | Given there is no action to SA2, Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107070 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG4: LS on the definition of EAS and EAS context | SA WG4 (S4-211231) | Rel-17 | Noted | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) is OK with nothing this LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107071 | LS In | Action | LS on PSCELL ID availability in SGW CDR | SA WG5 (S5-214069) | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this LS as the SA2 task related with this LS is already completed. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) supports to the NOTE the paper as the work is completed in SA2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107072 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG5: Reply LS on (de)activation and failure handling of NR QMC | SA WG5 (S5-214186) | Rel-17 | Noted | As there are no actions to SA2, Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107077 | LS In | Information | LS from TSG SA: Reply LS to 5G-ACIA on 5G capabilities exposure for factories of the future | TSG SA (SP-211134) | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note this LS for information Qianghua (Huawei) agrees to Note this LS ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | For action, no input (proposed to be postponed) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107006 | LS In | Action | LS from GSMA 5GJA: LS on Traffic Categories in URSP | GSMA 5GJA (5GJA17_104) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2105356 from S2#146E. Postponed | Pallab (Nokia) proposes to POSTPONE the LS reply until we have a CR agreed in SA2 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107016 | LS In | Action | LS from Automotive Edge Computing Consortium (AECC): LS on Prioritized Vehicle to Cloud Technical Solutions | AECC (AECC_3GPP_LS_final) | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to note this LS because no action is considered necessary in SA2. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with LGE and also proposes to note this LS, no action is needed in SA2. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107033 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on creating a new stage 2 TS for SMS-SBI | CT WG4 (C4-214540) | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) asks whether SA2 should allocate a tdoc number for LS out as reply seems to be requested? Hui(Huawei) supports for a LS out reply. Hannu (Nokia) proposes an LS from this meeting to allow CT4 work to proceed. Antoine (Orange) supports sending a reply at this meeting and supports the draft posted by Hannu. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also supports sending a reply LS at this meeting and asks for update of proposed LS. Hui(Huawei) also supports Hannu's proposal. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) agrees the proposal to assign the task to only CT4 and shares r01 proposing it should be brought up in CC. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107052 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on RACS capability detection with S1 and NG handover | RAN WG3 (R3-214373) | Rel-16 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) proposes to Postpone the paper since RAN3 is still working on the issue Andy (Samsung, VC): Asks if noting is a better way forward. Chris (Vodafone) prefers to postpone as SA2 need to align stage 2 with RAN 3 outcome, and, decide what to do about Release 16. Qian (Ericsson) responds. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Binding Indication for multiple contexts | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2106989 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on update a Binding Indication for multiple contexts | CT WG4 (C4-211709) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2105228 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107138. Final response in S2-2107790 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107138 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to LS on update a Binding Indication for multiple contexts | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2106989. Revised to S2-2107790. | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107790 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS to LS on update a Binding Indication for multiple contexts | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107138. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107139 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3246 (Rel-17, 'C'): Update of clause 6.3.1.0 related to binding | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | User plane integrity protection | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107022 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on user plane integrity protection for UE not supporting NR as primary RAT and supporting E-UTRA | CT WG1 (C1-214952) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107493 and S2-2107510. Final response in S2-2107794 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107493 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on user plane integrity protection for UE not supporting NR as primary RAT and supporting E-UTRA | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107022. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107794, merging S2-2107510 Revised to S2-2107794. | Haiyang (Huawei) objects to the original version of this draft LS and proposes to use (the content of) S2-2107510 as basis instead Haris(Qualcomm) comments Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) supports taking this LS as baseline. Stefan (Ericsson) also supports taking this LS as a baseline Chris Joul (T-Mobile USA) also supports taking this LS as a baseline Chris (Vodafone) is OK using 7493 as baseline but provides r01. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 based on r01 Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r02 Stefan (Ericsson) is OK with r01, cannot accept r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to R02 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2107794 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on user plane integrity protection for UE not supporting NR as primary RAT and supporting E-UTRA | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107493r01, merging S2-2107510. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107510 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on user plane integrity protection for UE not supporting NR as primary RAT and supporting E-UTRA | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107022. Merged into S2-2107794 | Laurent (Nokia): suggests to take 7493 as baseline for discussion Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the approval of this draft LS and instead proposes to use S2-2107493 as basis Haiyang(Huawei) provides comments/reply to Haris(Qualcomm) and Laurent (Nokia), and thinks this 7510 is better. Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Haris and Laurent and proposes to use S2-2107493 as a basis. Chris (Vodafone) is also OK to use S2-2107493 as a basis. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of 7510 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | S2-2107511 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3310 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on user plane integrity protection for UE not supporting NR as primary RAT and supporting E-UTRA | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the approval of this CR Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to endorse this CR as also discussed in 7493 thread Haris(Qualcomm) comments that we cannot endorse the CR since we don't know the scope of support of UPIP in E-UTRA Haiyang (Huawei) provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) objects to the approval of this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | LCS MO-LR procedure | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107032 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS Out on LCS MO-LR Procedure in 5G | CT WG4 (C4-214537) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2107123, S2-2107436 and S2-2107683. Final response in S2-2107795 | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS in. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2107123 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on LCS MO-LR Procedure in 5G | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2107032. Revised to S2-2107795, merging S2-2107436 and S2-2107683 | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to postpone the LS reply as the planned attachment to the LS is not agreed. Åke (Ericsson) Suggest to try to get LS agreed to enable CT4 to progress stage-3. Åke (Ericsson) Informs that Leo (Deutsche Telekom) has accepted to endorse CR (S2-2107124) and to agreed this LS. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) confirms that the LS can be sent. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2107795 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on LCS MO-LR Procedure in 5G | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2107123, merging S2-2107436 and S2-2107683. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107436 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response LS on LCS MO-LR Procedure in 5G | CATT | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107032. Merged into S2-2107795 | Åke (Ericsson) propose merge into S2-2107123 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | S2-2107683 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on MO-LR | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107032. Merged into S2-2107795 | Åke (Ericsson) propose merge into S2-2107123 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | S2-2107124 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0193 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on use of service type and service identity in MO-LR procedure | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r02 endorsed. Revised to S2-2107864. | Yunjing (CATT) provides comments. Åke (Ericsson) Respond to comment from CATT Åke (Ericsson) provide r01 and respond to CATT Yunjing(CATT) seeks clarification on r01. Åke (Ericsson) clarify on r01 to Yunjing Cai Simon (Nokia) clarifies to Åke (Ericsson) Stephen (Qualcomm) supports the r01 Åke (Ericsson) clarification to Yunjing Yunjing (CATT) provides comment and r02. Åke (Ericsson) Accept r02 but not r01 & clarify ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) comments Yunjing (CATT) replies and accepts r02. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to postpone the CR to the next SA2 meeting as there is still one error to be corrected. Åke (Ericsson) Suggest accept r02 to enable CT4 to progress stage-3. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides comments. Åke (Ericsson) accept to endorse r02 if LS (S2-2107123) can be agreed. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) accepts the way forward proposed by Ericsson, LS (S2-2107123) can be agreed. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2107864 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0193R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on use of service type and service identity in MO-LR procedure | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2107124r02. Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107125 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0194 (Rel-17, 'A'): Clarification on use of service type and service identity in MO-LR procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yunjing (CATT) provides comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | PDU Session ID assignment | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107031 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS on PDU Session ID assignment for the Interworking scenario | CT WG3 (C3-214527) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107165, S2-2107485 and S2-2107641. Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) responds to zhendong (ZTE) zhendong (ZTE) request for clarification. Judy (Ericsson) proposes to use this thread to discuss solution proposals and LS out in 7164, 7165, 7485, 7486 and 7641. zhendong (ZTE) confirm judy understading. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks questions zhendong (ZTE) responds to sebastian. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Sebastian (Qualcomm) Susan (Huawei) replies. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Susan (Huawei) Laurent (Nokia): answers Judy (Ericsson) comments on Option-3 in 7641 zhendong (ZTE) respond to judy. Irfan (Cisco) also supports solution based on (Option-3) in 7641 Susan (Huawei) responds to Judy (Ericsson). Susan (Huawei) clarifies. zhendong (ZTE) prefer irfan proposal. Laurent (Nokia): Comments Judy (Ericsson) would like to check views whether there is a real issue to solve. zhendong (ZTE) ask for the clarificaiotn. Susan (Huawei) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Irfan (Cisco) comments on scenario occurrence probability Laurent (Nokia): supports Irfan point Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with Irfan and proposes to postpone the discussion to the next meeting ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Irfan (Cisco) also suggests to postpone the LS and CRs to next meeting Judy (Ericsson) agrees to postpone the LS and CRs. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107165 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply to LS on PDU Session ID assignment for the Interworking scenario | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107031. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): suggest to take 7641 as support to discuss the LS (and the solution) to be sent by SA2 while using 7164 (Ericsson) as baseline for a CR Judy (Ericsson) propose to discuss in 7031 thread Susan (Huawei) cannot agree with the proposal from Laurent (Nokia) on using 7641 and 7164 as baseline for the LS and the CR, at this stage. zhendong (ZTE) propsoe to discuss the solution first. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107164 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3135 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF+PGW-C assigned PDU Session ID | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Source to WG incorrect. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): prefers the solution defined in 7641 and asks Ericsson to consider it Judy (Ericsson) propose to discuss in 7031 thread ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107485 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on PDU Session ID assignment for the Interworking scenario | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2107031. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): objects to the solution Judy (Ericsson) propose to discuss in 7031 thread ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107486 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3190 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on PDU Session ID assignment by SMF+PGW-C | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): objects to the solution and any version of this CR Judy (Ericsson) propose to discuss in 7031 thread Susan (Huawei) asks Laurent (Nokia) for clarification. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107487 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3191 (Rel-17, 'A'): Correction on PDU Session ID assignment by SMF+PGW-C | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): objects to the solution and any version of this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107641 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on PDU Session ID assignment for the Interworking scenario | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107031. Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) propose to discuss in 7031 thread Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Susan (Huawei) objects to both r00 and r01. zhendong (ZTE) propsoe more discussion. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107054 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS On ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | RAN WG3 (R3-214414) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2107591 and S2-2107769. Final response in S2-2108171 | Haiyang (Huawei) provides comments to Jinhua(Xiaomi). Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments and prefer Option2. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2107264 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107054. Revised in S2-2107769 | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107769 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS On ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107264. Response to S2-2107054. CC~2: r03 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2108171, merging S2-2107591 Revised to S2-2108171. | Laurent (Nokia): Supports Fenqin remarks in 7770 and starts having concerns with the full topic Fenqin (Huawei): propose to merge this paper into 7591 Qian (Ericsson) comments that we shall ask questions in the reply LS and conclude the issue after further response from RAN. R01 is provided. Laurent (Nokia): Comments to use 7591 as the baseline for Ls out on this topic Qian (Ericsson) comments that it's more reasonable to use this LS out. Fenqin (Huawei ): also suggest to use 7591 as the baseline for Ls out on this topic Qian (Ericsson) responds and provide r02 to address the concern Fenqin (Huawei ): responds Qian (Ericsson ) asks questions Fenqin (Huawei ): responds and provides r03 Qian (Ericsson) comments and says ok with r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version apart from R03 Laurent (Nokia): suggests a rewording for R03 Qian (Ericsson): provides r04 in draft folder with change from 'aware by RAN by' to 'made aware to RAN by' on top of r03. Flag this to CC#2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2108171 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS On ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107769r03r03 + changes, merging S2-2107591. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107770 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3669 (Rel-17, 'C'): ACL support for S1 HO with indirect data forwarding | Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) asks for clarification Qian (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Fenqin (Huawei) comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) further replies to Qian (Ericsson) Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Fenqin (Huawei) responds Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides further responses. Jinguo(ZTE) comments Laurent (Nokia): Supports Fenqin remarks and starts having concerns with the full topic ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107771 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3218 (Rel-17, 'C'): ACL support for NGAP HO with Indirect Data Forwarding | Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): asks questions Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Laurent (Nokia): answers Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments Laurent (Nokia): Supports Fenqin remarks and starts having concerns with the full topic ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107591 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on ACL support for Indirect Data Forwarding | QUALCOMM JAPAN LLC. | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2107054. Merged into S2-2108171 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Qian (Ericsson): comments that we shall ask for some feedback from RAN3 before we conclude the issue. It's proposed to use 7769 as the base Laurent (Nokia): Comments to use 7591 as the baseline for Ls out on this topic Qian (Ericsson) comments that it's more reasonable to use 7769. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) propose to mark this paper as merged into 7769. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) confirms this proposal is merged into 7769. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | UPF reporting for redundant transmission | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107073 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on UPF reporting for redundant transmission on transport layer | SA WG5 (S5-214667) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107385. Final response in S2-2107862 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107385 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on UPF reporting for redundant transmission on transport layer | Huawei | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2107073. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2107862. | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107862 | LS OUT | Approval | LS reply on UPF reporting for redundant transmission on transport layer | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2107385r00. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Offline charging only indication | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107074 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS Reply on offline charging only indication | SA WG5 (S5-214668) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107512. Final response in S2-2107863 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107512 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on clarification on the offline charing only indication | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107074. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2107863. | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107863 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on the offline charging only indication | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107512r00. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107513 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0639R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on offline charging only indication | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2106559 from S2#146E. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Inclusive language review | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107078 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG SA: Reply LS on Inclusive language review | TSG SA (SP-211140) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | IP address to GPSI translation | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2106990 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on IP address to GPSI translation | SA WG6 (S6-211082) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105235 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107003 | LS In | Action | Reply LS on IP address to GPSI translation | SA WG3 (S3-212355) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105296 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107247 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3024R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): AF Specific UE ID retrieval | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2105501 from S2#146E. Postponed | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) asks if this should be considered as merged into 7653. Magnus O (Ericsson) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107248 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2926R2 (Rel-17, 'B'): AF Specific UE ID retrieval | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2106726 from S2#146E. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): suggests this CR to be considered as merged in 7654 (R01) Magnus O (Ericsson) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107653 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2385R5 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105346 from S2#146E. Postponed | Magnus (Ericsson): comments Dario (Qualcomm) replies and provides r01 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r02 Dario (Qualcomm) provides r03 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r04 Laurent (Nokia): r03 looks better than r04 !!! Laurent (Nokia): Comments, I cannot live with 7653 R04 and suggest we go ahead with R03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Magnus O (Ericsson) Comments and can only accept r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2107654 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2329R4 (Rel-17, 'F'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105347 from S2#146E. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r02 Dario (Qualcomm) doesn't think r02 is correct and prefers r01. Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 (please can skip it) and r04 Hui (Huawei): asks question on r04. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r05 Laurent (Nokia): provides r06: R06 proposes a compromise : GPSI that may contain an AF specific UE Identifier as defined in clause 4.15.3.2.X ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Magnus O (Ericsson) Comments and can only accept r05 Dario (Qualcomm): description of how identifier is made unique per-AF is needed. If not re-inserted, we need to go with 7248 Dario (Qualcomm) not OK with r05 as is now. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107592 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3068R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): UE specific subscription proposal for AAA Server | China Mobile, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106219 from S2#146E. Noted | alessio(nokia) ask questions and believes this CR is NOT NEEDED and in fact incorrect, so we object to this CR Aihua(CMCC) replies and provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) cannot agree r01 as the requirement is not clear ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2107593 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3172R4 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSSAAF Discovery and Selection based on S-NSSAI or UE ID Range | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of (Revised and agreed) S2-2106593 from S2#146E (Postponed at SA#93E). r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107796 Revised to S2-2107796. | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. alessio(nokia) provides comments and r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r02, but would prefer r02+changing 'VPLMNs' with 'AMFs'. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2107796 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3172R5 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSSAAF Discovery and Selection based on S-NSSAI or UE ID Range | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107593r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2107175 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3253 (Rel-17, 'F'): Reserving some reference point numbers | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107797 Revised to S2-2107797. | Mirko (Huawei) provides r01. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to note. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on wrong AI in the subject Mirko (Huawei) provides r01 (resending with right AI in subject). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Belen (Ericsson) asks to approve r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2107797 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3253R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Reserving some reference point numbers | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107175r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | - | - | - | P-CRs/CRs related to use of inclusive language in 3GPP | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 4.2 | S2-2107761 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3351 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes - Inclusive terminology | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107798 Revised to S2-2107798. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that IEEE 1588 to our understanding have explicitly ruled out Primary/Secondary as an alternative for Master/Slave so we should not go down that path. Provides alts being discussed. Devaki (Nokia) wonders if we should go with leader/follower that is under consideration at the moment in IEEE (but not listed as an option in 3GPP drafting rules)? Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments that 'leader/follower' together with a NOTE to reflect the mapping to master/slave would be ok Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 - terms changed to leader/follower with a Note to reflect the mapping, also added the missing annex to fix Master -> leader. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments it is a good compromise revision and can be endorsed, provides r02 with the NOTE enhanced to state until IEEE makes final decision on the terminology and cosigns. Comments on 3GPP vs IEEE terminology. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2107798 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3351R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes - Inclusive terminology | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107761r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2107762 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3217 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes - Inclusive terminology | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107799 Revised to S2-2107799. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that same input as document 7761 applies for this case, i.e. not to use Primary/Secondary and prefer to postpone the CR and focus on LS to IEEE. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 - terms changed to leader/follower with a Note to reflect the mapping. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 aligned with 23.501 in 7761. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03 to align the note with 23.501. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2107799 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3217R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes - Inclusive terminology | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107762r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2107299 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on use of inclusive terminology for Time Synchronization | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107800 Revised to S2-2107800. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that we will need to align what we propose as alternative terminology knowing IEEE has ruled out Primary/Secondary already. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Puneet provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04 - added 3GPP TSG SA to CC and removed Rel-16/Vertical_LAN from the header. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r05 to update the action. Devaki (Nokia) provides r06 with hyperlink. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2107800 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on use of inclusive terminology for Time Synchronization | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107299r06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8 | - | - | - | Rel-17 WID | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 2 (eNA_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=82 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107293 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0444 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment and corrections related to accuracy, confidence, and normative wording in notes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107801 Revised to S2-2107801. | Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Wang Yuan (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to comments David (Samsung) comments Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for further clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to comments Wang Yuan (Huawei) still has concerns. Wang Yuan (Huawei) cannot agree r00 and provide r01 based on previously expressed concerns. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wang Yuan (Huawei) is fine with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107801 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0444R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment and corrections related to accuracy, confidence, and normative wording in notes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107293r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107349 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0449 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Analytics target period | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107802 Revised to S2-2107802. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r00 Wang Yuan (Huawei) agrees with Gerald (Nokia) and provide r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107802 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0449R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Analytics target period | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107349r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107594 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0467 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections for eNA_ph2 on TS 23.288 | vivo, Huawei, Ericsson, Nokia, LG Electronics, CATT | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2107633 | Revised | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107633 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0467R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections for TS 23.288 on eNA_ph2 | vivo, Huawei, Ericsson, Nokia, LG Electronics, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107594. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107803, merging S2-2107675 Revised to S2-2107803. | Zhang (Ericsson) proposes merge CR S2-2107174 into this CR Andy (Samsung, VC) points out 07633 is ,marked not handled. Yang (OPPO) comments Xiaobo(vivo) provides r02 and clarifies that, per offline guidance from chair, S2-2107174 (due to exceeding quota) should be merged into S2-2107633 when the revision of S2-2107633 is provided. Megha(Intel) provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107803 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0467R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections for TS 23.288 on eNA_ph2 | vivo, Huawei, Ericsson, Nokia, LG Electronics, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107633r03, merging S2-2107675. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107595 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3320 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous correction for eNA_Ph2 on TS 23.501 | vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107804, merging S2-2107668 Revised to S2-2107804. | Yingying(CATT) considers the change contents of this CR is the same with S2-2107668 and needs to be merged with it. Vivian (vivo): merges S2-2107668(intel) to Mega CR S2-2107595(vivo), and provides r01. Megha(Intel) proposes to merge S2-2107668 into S2-2107595. Vivian(vivo) replies to Intel and requests to cease discussion in this email list . ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107804 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3320R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous correction for eNA_Ph2 on TS 23.501 | vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107595r01, merging S2-2107668. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107596 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3196 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous correction for eNA_Ph2 on TS 23.502 | vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107597 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0664 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous correction for eNA_Ph2 on TS 23.503 | vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107250 | CR | Agreement | 23.288 CR0442 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to ML model provisioning and AnLF / MTLF split functionality | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01 and co-sign the CR Soohwan (ETRI) provides r03 and adds ETRI as co-source company Dimitris (Lenovo) supports the proposal provides r04 Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. David (Samsung) provides r06. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r06 and provides comments Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments and provide r07. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Wang Yuan (Huawei) on NRF part and asks further clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r08 and replies to comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) commented. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to NTT DOCOMO. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks further clarification. Wang Yuan (Huawei) cannot accept r08 and provides r09. Aihua(China Mobile) provides r10. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments David (Samsung) comments on r10 Aihua(China Mobile) provides r11. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r12 with changes to clause 5.2. Soohwan (ETRI) asks further clarification on the neccessity of registering ML model filter information to NRF Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on Huawei's reply and asks for further clarification. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Soohwan(ETRI) and Yannick(Nokia), accepts r11 but objects r12. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to r10 and r11. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) As we see some differences in understanding of registration, we prefer to postpone the CR. Wang Yuan (Huawei) also suggest to postpone the CR for next meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107533 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0461 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the NWDAF (MTLF) and NWDAF (AnLF) | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107805 Revised to S2-2107805. | Zhang (Ericsson) proposes to merge this CR into S2-2107250 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments and also suggests to discuss these changes via S2-2107250 thread. Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and Zhang(Ericsson), and provides r01. China Mobile provides r02. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) asks China Mobile to provide r02 with correct file name. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wang Yuan (Huawei) finds there is an issue in r02/r03/r04, and provides r05 for CC#2. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is ok with r04. Andy (Samsung, VC): The Chair has given guidance that 'Rel-17 topics should be resolved by the revision/final comments deadline and not pushed to CC#2.' Wang Yuan (Huawei) can accept r04 to follow the guidance. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107805 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0461R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the NWDAF (MTLF) and NWDAF (AnLF) | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107533r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107668 | CR | Agreement | 23.501 CR3332 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to filter information in NWDAF discovery and selection | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107804 | Yingying(CATT) considers this CR is the same with S2-2107595 and needs to be merged with it. Vivian (vivo): proposes to merge S2-2107668(intel) to Mega CR S2-2107595(vivo). Megha(Intel) is ok to mark S2-2107668 merged with S2-2107595. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107142 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0438 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving EN and correct inconsistencies for analytics transfer | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107806 Revised to S2-2107806. | Xiaoyan (CATT) disagrees with r00 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107806 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0438R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving EN and correct inconsistencies for analytics transfer | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107142r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107143 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0439 (Rel-17, 'F'): UDM-based discovery of NWDAF in Analytics Aggregation procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107807 Revised to S2-2107807. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments and provide r01 Yingying (CATT) provides comments. Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Zhang (Ericsson) and cannot accept r01 as it is. Zhang (Ericsson) object r02 and provide r03 Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Zhang(Ericsson) and provides r04. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r04 and r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107807 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0439R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UDM-based discovery of NWDAF in Analytics Aggregation procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107143r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107294 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0445 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment, clarifications, corrections related to KI#2 and KI#11 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107808 Revised to S2-2107808. | Zhang (Ericsson) asks questions Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to E// and CATT Mehrdad (Samsung) has concern on changes in clause 6.1A.3.1 in original version and r01. Soohwan (ETRI) provides r02 with a comment. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r02 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia can live with r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107808 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0445R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment, clarifications, corrections related to KI#2 and KI#11 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107294r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107397 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0456 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update on Analytics context transfer and clarification on Termination Request | CATT | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107809 Revised to S2-2107809. | Yingying(CATT) replies to Zhang (Ericsson) Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01 and co-sign the CR Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original and r01 and provides r02 (cosigned by Nokia) Zhang (Ericsson) provides r03 Yingying(CATT) agrees with most of r02, and requests a clarification on only one question from Gerald (Nokia). Yingying(CATT) agree with r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r04 Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Yingying(CATT) agrees with r04 and provides r05 based on Zhang(Ericsson)'s suggestion. Wang Yuan (Huawei) further provides r06 and also co-signs this CR. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r06 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r06 Yingying(CATT) agrees with r06. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107809 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0456R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update on Analytics context transfer and clarification on Termination Request | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107397r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107399 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0457 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on transfer of analytics context and analytics subscripton | CATT | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107810 Revised to S2-2107810. | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides clarification to Zhang (Ericsson). Zhang (Ericsson) ask clarification Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Gerald (Nokia). Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo). Soohwan (ETRI) provides r02 with a comment. Zhang (Ericsson) provides r03 Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments and asks for clarification. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides clarification to Jungshin (Samsung). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04 and r05. Soohwan (ETRI) objects to r05. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r04, objects to r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107810 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0457R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on transfer of analytics context and analytics subscripton | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107399r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107400 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0458 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on prepared analytics transfer | CATT | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107811 Revised to S2-2107811. | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. Zhang (Ericsson) has concerns on the CR Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Zhang (Ericsson). Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r03. Wang Yuan (Huawei) asks question. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Huawei Zhang (Ericsson) object the original version, r01, r02, r03 and provide r04 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r05. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia prefers r04, is okay with r05 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107811 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0458R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on prepared analytics transfer | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107400r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107401 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0459 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on analytics aggregation | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107812 Revised to S2-2107812. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) is ok with r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107812 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0459R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on analytics aggregation | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107401r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107544 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0463 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the UE aggregated mobility analytics exposure to NF | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107813 Revised to S2-2107813. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on original China Mobile replies to Nokia and provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01 China Mobile is fine and provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r02 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107813 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0463R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the UE aggregated mobility analytics exposure to NF | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107544r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107763 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0471 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NWDAF reselectioin | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107814 Revised to S2-2107814. | Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01 and co-sign Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original and r01 Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to E// and Samsung Jungshin (Samsung) provides r02. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r02 Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107814 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0471R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NWDAF reselectioin | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107763r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107030 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS on Network Slice (Instance) load level related Analytics | CT WG3 (C3-214444) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107087. Final response in S2-2107815 | Replied to | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107087 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Network Slice (Instance) load level related Analytics | Samsung | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107030. r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107815 Revised to S2-2107815. | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments David (Samsung) requests clarifications from Ericsson Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on initial version. David (Samsung) replies to Nokia Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides views on Rel-15 Nnwdaf_Analytics_Info. David (Samsung) comments Belen (Ericsson) replies to Samsung Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung. David (Samsung) provides r02 Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides r03, correcting the next meeting information, also with some editorial changes. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r04. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides r05 with a correction. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107815 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Network Slice (Instance) load level related Analytics | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107087r05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107351 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0451 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Slice load level analytics | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2107816 Revised to S2-2107816. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on initial version and assumes a revision would be needed. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 David (Samsung) corrects email subject David (Samsung) replies to some comments. Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson), Yannick(Nokia) and provides r02. David (Samsung) provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) provides r05. Wang Yuan (Huawei) cannot accept r05 and replies to Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) object to r04,r03,r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia clarifies that we have defined analytics subsets in Rel-16 already, so cannot agree with Huawei's statement. Also wonders whether existing text in 6.1.3 in TS 23.288 already addresses the issue. David (Samsung) provides r07 with minor modification in Table 6.3.3A-2. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia previously forgot to mention that r06 was provided. Nokia is fine with r07. Wang Yuan (Huawei) is fine with most of r07 and further provide r08 with minor modification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r08. Clause 6.1.3 does not seem to have any change though. David (Samsung) disagrees with r08 and asks Yuan a question. Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Yannick(Nokia) and David(Samsung), and provides r09. David (Samsung) is OK with r09. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107816 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0451R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Slice load level analytics | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107351r09. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107362 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Analytics affected by URSP enforcement - DP | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Yang (OPPO) responds to Yannick ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2107365 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0454 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Service Experience statistics and pridictions | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on initial version. Vivian (vivo): provides comments on initial version. Yang (OPPO) replies to vivo Vivian (vivo) replies to Yang(OPPO) Yannick (Nokia): Current proposal is unclear as to which entity should satisfy the requirement, hence it cannot be accepted. Yang (OPPO) responds to Yannick Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks further clarification. Yang (OPPO) replies and provides r01 and 02. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r01, r02 and the initial revision. Yang (OPPO) ask Belen (Ericsson) to recheck the wording and withdraw the objection to r02. Belen (Ericsson) objects to this CR Yang (OPPO) responds with more confusion Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is confused about intention with this CR. Yang (OPPO) replies. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia further replies to Yang (OPPO). Yang (OPPO) provides r04 (pls ignore r03). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Belen (Ericsson) objects to r04, asks to pospone. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia prefers to postpone this discussion. We are still unsure about the intention with this CR and which problem is tried to be solved. Yang (OPPO) is okay to postpone it ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#8 | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107067 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: Reply-LS on security aspects for the method of collection of data from the UE | SA WG3 (S3-213271) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107013 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG4: LS on UE data collection and reporting | SA WG4 (S4-211221) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105373 from S2#146E. Responses drafted in S2-2107586 and S2-2107702. Final response in S2-2107817 | Replied to | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107586 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on UE data collection and reporting | QUALCOMM JAPAN LLC. | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107013. Merged into S2-2107817 | Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge this LS into S2-2107702. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) confirms this proposal is merged into S2-2107702. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2107702 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on UE data collection and reporting | Samsung | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107013. r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107817, merging S2-2107586 Revised to S2-2107817. | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Tricci (OPPO) corrects the agenda for this email thread. Yang (OPPO) corrects the agenda to AI#8.1. Yang (OPPO) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Qualcomm and OPPO and provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) completes reply to Qualcomm and OPPO. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107817 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on UE data collection and reporting | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107702r05, merging S2-2107586. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107004 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG4: Reply LS to SA2 on UE Data Collection | SA WG4 (S4-210961) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105299 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107817. Final response in S2-2107817 | Replied to | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107367 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0455 (Rel-17, 'F'): Restriction for 5GC to provide UE IP address to untrusted AF | OPPO | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107818 Revised to S2-2107818. | Susan (Huawei): Propose to merge this CR to S2-2107489. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Yang (OPPO) replies to Juan why the CR is needed Yannick (Nokia): Nokia shares the views from Huawei. This CR does not really solve the problem as it does not specify how NWDAF or NEF knows which IP addresses can be exposed to the untrusted AF. Yang (OPPO) replies. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes clarification from Yang (OPPO) Yang (OPPO) replies to Juan (Qualcomm) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Yang (OPPO) Yang (OPPO) replies to Juan (Qualcomm) and provides r02 Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Susan (Huawei) Belen (Ericsson) comments on r03 Yang (OPPO) provides r04 considering the comments from Juan and Susan. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) replies to QC Yang (OPPO) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r05. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is ok with r05 but asks that some terminology alignment is done in next meeting as regards to DCAF, Data Collection AF. Susan (Huawei) is OK with r05. Yang (OPPO) is fine to agree it this meeting and further update it in next meeting. Yang (OPPO) replies to Susan (Huawei) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107818 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0455R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Restriction for 5GC to provide UE IP address to untrusted AF | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107367r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107488 | DISCUSSION | Decision | Discussion on UE Data Collection with UE IP address. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to mark this discussion paper as NOTED. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2107489 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0460 (Rel-17, 'F'): Data Collection from the UE Application with UE IP address | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Yang (OPPO) comments no new solution is needed Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment. Susan (Huawei) replies. Susan (Huawei) replies further to Yang's comment. Yang (OPPO) replies to Susan (Huawei) Susan (Huawei) replies to Yang (OPPO). Belen (Ericsson) objects to this CR, will agree to postpone it too. Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107574 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0465 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up for UE data reporting procedure | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107819 Revised to S2-2107819. | Yingying(CATT) asks for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Yingying (CATT) Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) replies to QC Yang (OPPO) comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107819 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0465R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up for UE data reporting procedure | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107574r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107707 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3339 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to NEF Discovery and Selection | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#10 | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107536 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0462 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Redundant Transmission Experience related analytics | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Peretz (Spirent) is proposing some changes in r01 China Mobile replies to Ericsson and provides comments. Zhang (Ericsson) asks questions Aihua (CMCC) comments that r01 provided by Peretz (Spirent) has 0 byte, and asks for uploading again. Peretz (Spirent) is proposing some changes in r02 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification China Mobile replies and provides r03. Antoine (Orange) provides r04 adding subsets. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia re-states general comments on all revisions Peretz (Spirent) addresses one of Nokia's question: Zhang (Ericsson) still has questions Gerald (Nokia): Nokia proposes to POSTPONE ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#11 | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107140 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0653 (Rel-17, 'F'): Retrieval of analytics using DCCF | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2107820 Revised to S2-2107820. | Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides comments and asks for clarification. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) request clarification Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided r02 Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments Vivian (vivo) provides some editorial comments Belen (Ericsson) thanks vivo for comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 with some suggested changes. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. Mirko (Huawei) comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Huawei and leave the final decision to Ericsson as this is Ericsson's CR. Belen (Ericsson) proposes some text to address Huawei comments. Yang (OPPO) provides comments Belen (Ericsson) provides r06. Yang (OPPO) object to r06 Belen (Ericsson) provides r07 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107820 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0653R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Retrieval of analytics using DCCF | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107140r07. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107141 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0437 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add mute to DataManagement service | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107821 Revised to S2-2107821. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with this CR. Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is ok with the new direction for the CR, but provides r02 to be more specific in the new text. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107821 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0437R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add mute to DataManagement service | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107141r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107209 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0441 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of NWDAF services Example Consumers with corresponding procedures | Oracle, Ericsson, Verizon UK Ltd. | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107598 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0468 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for analytics exposure via NWDAF(hosting DCCF) | vivo | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107822 Revised to S2-2107822. | Zhang (Ericsson) provides concerns Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Vivian (vivo) replies to all your concerns Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Vivian (vivo) replies to Zhang (Ericsson) and provides r02. Antoine (Orange) provides r03. Vivian(vivo): replies to Zhang (Ericsson) and Antoine(Orange), and provides r04. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r04 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r05. Vivian(vivo) is also fine with r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107822 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0468R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for analytics exposure via NWDAF(hosting DCCF) | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107598r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107675 | CR | Agreement | 23.288 CR0470 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction in Data collection and Coordination - Data collection profile | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107803 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01. Megha(Intel) proposes to mark this document merged with S2-2107633 as the changes in S2-2107675 is merged with the mega CR S2-2107633. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#12 | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107075 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on RAT type for network monitoring | SA WG6 (S6-212146) | Rel-17 | Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107224 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0656 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on PCF behaviour based on OSE analytics | China Telecom Corporation Ltd., Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107266 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0443 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the OSE analytics per RAT type and/or per Frequency | China Telecom, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107823 Revised to S2-2107823. | Jiahui (ChinaTelecom) provides r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Jiahui (China Telecom): China Telecom replies to Nokia and provide r03. Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments and asks for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides further comments. Jiahui (China Telecom): replies Nokia and Samsung's comments and provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107823 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0443R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the OSE analytics per RAT type and/or per Frequency | China Telecom, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107266r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107354 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0453 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Per-UE Service Experience Request Procedure | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107824 Revised to S2-2107824. | Antoine (Orange): clauses 6.4.1 and 6.4.3 are not aligned with the proposed changes. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) shares view with Orange and Huawei Yannick (Nokia): Nokia shares the views expressed so far on this proposal. Belen (Ericsson) also think that the CR is not aligned with the scope of Rel-17, propose to NOTE it. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107824 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0453R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Per-UE Service Experience Request Procedure | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107354r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#15 | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107001 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on User consent | SA WG3 (S3-212123) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105288 from S2#146E. See also follow-up LS in S2-2107098. Response drafted in S2-2107296. Postponed | Belen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this LS Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose the NOTE. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia proposes to POSTPONE this CR Belen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia prefers to keep this LS open ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107098 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on user consent | SA WG3 (S3-213689) | Rel-17 | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) suggests to NOTE this LS. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose the NOTE. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia thinks a LS Reply is needed ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to NOTE. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay to NOTE Belen (Ericsson) also supports to NOTE this LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2107296 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on user consent | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107001. Postponed | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) we do not see the need for to send an LS, therefore, propose the NOTE the draft. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107295 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0446 (Rel-17, 'B'): Tracking of distribution and usage of data subject to user consent | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Xiaoyan (CATT) ask for clarifications and provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to CATT Mehrdad (Samsung) has concern on changes in this CR. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Samsung Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r01 and initial revision, provides r02 Vivian (vivo) provides comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to comments Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks further clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Malla (DOCOMO) Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r04 and r05 Belen (Ericsson) provides r06, objects to r05,r04,r03 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson and disagrees with r06 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided comment Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) and Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) replies to Gerald. Belen (Ericsson) provides r07. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Belen (E///) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to postpone the CR. Belen (Ericsson) ok to postpone Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay to postpone ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107553 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0464 (Rel-17, 'F'): Content correction of user consent | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107599 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0469 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for analytics subscription termination request | vivo | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107825 Revised to S2-2107825. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Vivian (vivo): replies to Nokia comments on original and provide r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r02 Vivian (vivo): replies to Nokia comments and accepts r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03 Vivian(vivo): replies to Gerald(Nokia) and Belen(Ericsson) comments, and provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107825 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0469R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for analytics subscription termination request | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107599r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#16 | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107587 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0466 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on including location information for DN performance analytics output | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Postponed | Zhang (Ericsson) asks question Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with this CR Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Gerald (Nokia) Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Zhang (Ericsson) asks questions Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification Antoine (Orange) still doesn't understand the need for UE location. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Antoine (Orange) that still doesn't understand the need for UE location. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides additional clarifications Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided further comment Dimitris (Lenovo) clarifies that no new NWDAF behaviour is introduced. Procedure re-uses what is defined for OSE analytics Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Lenovo Dimitris (Lenovo) requests clarification on the use case provided Malla (NTT DOCOMO) we not agree to include UE location Dimitris (Lenovo) suggest to postpone discussion and address UE location for OSE analytics as well at the next meeting ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Gerald (Nokia): Nokia agrees to postpone ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#18 | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107311 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0447 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Supported Analytics Delay when reporting mode is requested | China Unicom | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107826 Revised to S2-2107826. | Zhang (Ericsson) asks question Chi (China Unicom) replies to Zhang (Ericsson). Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification on original Dimitris (Lenovo) has question for clarification Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Chi (China Unicom) replies to Gerald (Nokia). Chi (China Unicom) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo) and Mehrdad (Samsung). Zhang (Ericsson) ask questions Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 and supports the CR. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02 Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia, Lenovo and Ericsson. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03 and r04. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia prefers r03 Zhang (Ericsson) prefers r03 Chi (China Unicom) is ok with r03 and comments to r04. Dimitris (Lenovo) is ok to proceed with r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107826 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0447R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Supported Analytics Delay when reporting mode is requested | China Unicom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107311r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#19 | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107321 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0448 (Rel-17, 'F'): CR to resolve conflicts in ML model transferring | ETRI | Rel-17 | Postponed | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r00 and provides r01. Soohwan (ETRI) provides r02 and replies to the comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r03. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides r04 and co-signs this CR. Soohwan (ETRI) asks views for way forward and provides comments on r03. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Soohwan (ETRI). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments to r04. Soohwan (ETRI) asks further clarification on r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r05 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r06. Soohwan (ETRI) is okay with r05, and asks further clarification on r06. Soohwan (ETRI) provides further comments on r06. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r07. Soohwan (ETRI) asks further clarification on r07. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r08. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia disagrees with r08 and earlier revisions including the ML model file address ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r00(the original version), r02, r04 and r05. Soohwan (ETRI) also disagrees with r08 and the earlier revisions including the ML model file address. If CATT sustains their objection to r05, it is okay to postpone Xiaoyan (CATT) confirms the objection to r05. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments and also suggest to postpone this CR. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) postpone is fine. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay to postpone ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2107350 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0450 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the content of ML model provisioning | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107827 Revised to S2-2107827. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on original Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r01. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r02 Wang Yuan (Huawei) is fine with r02. Yang (OPPO) asks a question for clarification Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Yang(OPPO) and further provides r03 based on Gerald's comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r04 Wang Yuan (Huawei) is fine with r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Soohwan (ETRI) is okay with r04. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2107827 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0450R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the content of ML model provisioning | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107350r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | Documents exceeding quota | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2107174 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0440 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections of inconsistency in Analytics and Data Specification | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | Zhang (Ericsson) propose to merge the CR into S2-2107633 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | - |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Enhanced support of Non-Public Networks (eNPN) | - | - | Docs:=80 | - | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Mega Editorial CRs (Not counted towards quota) | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107188 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3257 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur's editorial cleanup for eNPN | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108090, merging S2-2107716 Revised to S2-2108090. | Xiaowan (vivo) provides r01 Josep (DT) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides r04 by merging part from 7716 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108090 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3257R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur's editorial cleanup for eNPN | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107188r04, merging S2-2107716. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107189 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3138 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur's editorial cleanup for eNPN | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | LS on scope of Network Slicing | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107026 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | CT WG1 (C1-215137) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2107089, S2-2107115, S2-2107229, S2-2107496 and S2-2107701. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107089 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107026. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) assume we need to note the LS for this meeting ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107115 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107026. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) assume we need to note the LS for this meeting ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107229 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | Samsung | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107026. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and propose to note the proposal ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107496 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | China Mobile | Response to S2-2107026. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and suggests to note the proposal ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107701 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107026. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) assume we need to note the LS for this meeting ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107698 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on Rel-16 and Rel-17 features specified in 5GS applicable to SNPN. | MediaTek Inc. | Noted | Noted | ||
| 8.2 | S2-2107699 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3336 (Rel-17, 'F'): SNPN applicability to 5GS features and fucntionality | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Josep (DT) objects to this CR. Devaki (Nokia) fully supports the proposal as it is best to state that all the features are supported unless specified otherwise. Prefers to cosign. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) objects to this CR. Fei (OPPO) comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications. Yi (China Mobile) objects this CR. Stefano (Qualcomm) would like a technical explanation of how to stop applicability of these features to SNPNs. Yi (China Mobile) asks question. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm). Chia-Lin (Mediatek) respond and ask for technical reasons why the features cannot be applicable to SNPNs Jianning (Xiaomi) provides view. Josep (DT) comments and provides further arguments. Yi (China Mobile) comments. marco (Huawei) comments. Antoine (Orange) objects to this CR. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies. Yi (China Mobile) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107090 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3236 (Rel-17, 'F'): Support of NSAC and NSSRG for SNPNs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) comments that we are supportive of the proposal to add SNPN for network slicing description, can cosign. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) objects to the approval of this CR Josep (DT) also objects to this CR. Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications. Yi (China Mobile) objects this CR. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides view Marco (Huawei) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107116 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3240 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network Slicing scope in relation to SNPNs | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.502. Cover sheet needs correcting to 23.501. Noted | Antoine (Orange) provides r01 to replace 'serving SNPN' by 'SNPN'. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this paper merged with 7090/7700. Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia Malla (NTT DOCOMO) objects to the approval of this CR Yi (China Mobile) objects to the CR. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Josep (DT) comments that there has been no real discussion on SNPN + TNGF/W-AGF. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Josep (DT) comments, provides r04 with some editorial changes to serve as basis for further discussion. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) Object any revision with slicing support for SNPN. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided r05. Antoine (Orange): issues in r03/r04 and r05 . Walter Dees (Philips) responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Marco (Huawei) comment. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r05 is not acceptable. Amanda ( Futurewei ) can not accept r05 and believe network slicing is supported for SNPN Devaki (Nokia) objects to all versions of the CR, actually we could accept first 2 changes of the original CR and we support slicing for SNPN in principle. Unfortunately none of the CR versions reflect that. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107501 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3308 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network slicing support for SNPN | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) comments that Nokia objects to this CR as it imposes an artificial restriction for SNPN, there is no technical restriction to support slicing for SNPN. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) we support the CR, we do not find the technical requirements to enable the feature. Stefano (Qualcomm) also objects to the CR for the same reason as Nokia. Chia-Lin (Mediatek) also objects to this CR for the same reason raised by Nokia and Qualcomm Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and cannot accept the CR for same reasons as expressed by others ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Amanda (Futurewei) cannot accept the CR for same reasons as expressed by others ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107044 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | RAN WG2 (R2-2109114) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107094, S2-2107347, S2-2107520, S2-2107655 and S2-2107714. Final response in S2-2108091 | Replied to | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107024 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | CT WG1 (C1-215046) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107495. Final response in S2-2108091 | Replied to | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107495 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | China Mobile | Response to S2-2107024. Merged into S2-2108091 | Peter (Ericsson) propose to mark this as merged into 07094 Yi (China Mobile) is fine to merge into 7094. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107094 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on limited service availability of an SNPN | vivo | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107044. CC#2: r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2108091, merging S2-2107347, S2-2107495, S2-2107655 and S2-2107714 Revised to S2-2108091. | Xiaowan (vivo) summarizes the LS replis on limited service availability of an SNPN and would like to kick off the discussion Fei (OPPO) is also fine with the principle in 7094. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment and agree to use 07094 zhendong (ZTE) is fine to go with 7094. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the text in this LS and proposes to use the text in S2-2107520 instead Josep (DT) also prefers an answer based on 7094. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Josep (DT) comments. xiaowan (vivo) replies to Haris (Qualcomm)and think the reply in 7094 is aligned with 23122 Fei (OPPO) comments. Yi (China Mobile) support to go with 7094 or other contributions with the same opinion. Yi also provides more comments. Josep (DT) comments that the solution from SA1 is valid and well within their responsibility. Josep (DT) corrects that he meant CT1, not SA1; comments. Chris Joul(T-Mobile USA) comments and agrees with Harris Yi (China Mobile) comments. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Chia-Lin (Mediatek) comments Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01 xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r02 Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r02 Rainer (Nokia) replies. Josep (DT) comments, provides r03. Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r03 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Haris(Qualcomm) asks question and provides r05 xiaowan (vivo) provides comments and r07 Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r07 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== xiaowan (vivo) replies to Haris(Qualcomm) Josep (DT) objects to r01, r05, r06, r07. xiaowan (vivo) provides r08 in the draft Haris(Qualcomm) comments that is fine to reply: 'There is no consensus in SA2' Rainer (Nokia) replies, is ok with r08. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with suggested r08 or with r07+removal of text Chia-Lin (Mediatek) is ok with the provided r08 in draft folder Jianning (Xiaomi) support r08 Josep (DT) finds r08 better also. xiaowan (vivo) proposes r08 to CC#2 for approval (r08: i.e. r07 with removing the text after 'On the other hand,' until and including '...Hence,') ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108091 | LS OUT | Approval | LS reply on limited service availability of an SNPN | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107094r08, merging S2-2107347, S2-2107495, S2-2107655 and S2-2107714. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107347 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on limited service availability of an SNPN | Samsung | Response to S2-2107044. Merged into S2-2108091 | Peter (Ericsson) propose to mark this as merged into 07094 Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts the proposal that this be mared as merged into 07094 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107520 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107044. Noted | Peter (Ericsson) propose to note or mark this as merged into 07094 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Josep (DT) objects. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107655 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | ZTE | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107044. Merged into S2-2108091 | Peter (Ericsson) propose to mark this as merged into 07094 zhendong (ZTE) is fine to merge this into 7094. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2107714 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on limited service availability of an SNPN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107044. Merged into S2-2108091 | Peter (Ericsson) propose to mark this as merged into 07094 Jianning (Xiaomi) is fine to merge this doc into 07094 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2107093 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Discussion on RAN WG2 questions on limited service availability of an SNPN. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107315 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3278 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on SNPN UE in limited states | vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed | Josep (DT) requests clarification on the EPS mentions. Provides r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggest to merge into 07449 xiaowan (vivo) replies and also seeks clarification from Josep (DT) for 01 Josep (DT) replies. Corrects position. Overall, I do not think that the CR is necessary. Proposes to NOTE Rainer (Nokia) comments. xiaowan (vivo) replies to Rainer (Nokia) and provides r02 Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to discuss futher and clarify all cases Antoine (Orange): this CR is not needed . xiaowan (vivo) replies to Haris(Qualcomm) and Antoine (Orange) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Antoine (Orange) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) agrees with Antoine that r03 will lead to EMC failure in certain countries Haris(Qualcomm) objects to all revisions of this CR but believes the problem statement is valid and needs to be addressed at next meeting xiaowan (vivo) is fine to postpone the CR's related discussion to next meeting ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107528 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3314 (Rel-17, 'F'): Support for emergency calls in limited service state | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and suggests to confirm RAN2 understanding and instead move forward with proposal in 07449 as basis Josep (DT) supports not to go with the approach proposed in this CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Josep (DT) objects to this CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107449 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3303 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Clarification on eNPN | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108092 Revised to S2-2108092. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00 and r01 and provides r02 Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r03. Jihoon (ETRI) asks questions. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Nokia Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with OPPO Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r03. Hualin(Huawei) reply to Jihoon (ETRI). Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r04 Devaki (Nokia) comments that the current/proposed text is also misleading as it does not reflect SNPN or PLMN subscription. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments on r05 r05 is ok to Hualin(Huawei). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108092 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3303R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Clarification on eNPN | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107449r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107028 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | CT WG1 (C1-215159) | Responses drafted in S2-2107095, S2-2107117, S2-2107415, S2-2107530 and S2-2107700. Postponed | Postponed | ||
| 8.2 | S2-2107095 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | vivo | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107028. Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this reply LS into S2-2107415 Peter (Ericsson) proposes to mark as merged into S2-2107415 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107117 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107028. Merged into S2-2107415 (Postponed) | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this reply LS into S2-2107415 Peter (Ericsson) proposes to mark as merged into S2-2107415 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107415 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107028. Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) provides a merging proposal for Reply LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Chia-Lin (Mediatek) provides r02 Rainer (Nokia) provides r03. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) pointed out that the LS depends on the outcome of S2-2107026, suggests to put on hold. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r05 as it is but proposes alternative text: 'SA2 understands that the UE is aware of the rejected S-NSSAI due to NSAC when it is signalled by the UE using the 'S-NSSAI not available due to maximum number of UEs reached' in Extended rejected NSSAI. When the UE does not provide any Requested NSSAI (this applies to UE onboarding within SNPN) can the UE associate the 'S-NSSAI not available due to maximum number of UEs reached' in order to avoid attempt for the same rejected S-NSSAI ? If the UE is not possible to associate the 'S-NSSAI not available due to maximum number of UEs reached' with the Onboarding Registration attempt, then it was discussed whether it is better to make exemptions for such cases.' Qianghua (Huawei) agrees the points raised by Haris, provide r06draft in draft folder for reference Ashok (Samsung) comments Qianghua (Huawei) replies Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note 7415 and go forward with 7094. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) replies to Rainer that 7415 and 7094 addresses different topics and input LSes Ashok (Samsung) responds to Qianghua (Huawei) Rainer (Nokia) withdraws the previous comment. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r06 in draft folder or r05+below changes Rainer (Nokia) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to postpone the LS Rainer (Nokia) replies. Qianghua (Huawei) we have not made any decision about NSAC for SNPN, we just ask CT1 some question about the potential issues for this scenario. SA2 will take CT1 feedback as input to have further discussion. Propose to continue this LS. Chia-Lin (Mediatek) comments on r06 Ashok (Samsung) propose to replace 'was' with 'will be ' in ' If the UE is not possible to associate the 'S-NSSAI not available due to maximum number of UEs reached' with the Onboarding Registration attempt, then it was discussed whether it is better to make exemptions for NSAC for SNPN Onboarding.' Malla (NTT DOCOMO) object r07 and any revision with SNPN. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107530 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107028. Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this reply LS into S2-2107415 Peter (Ericsson) proposes to mark as merged into S2-2107415 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107700 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107028. Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this reply LS into S2-2107415 Chia-Lin (Mediatek) is ok with the tdoc merged to S2-2107415 Peter (Ericsson) proposes to mark as merged into S2-2107415 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2107118 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3241 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network slice admission control for SNPN onboarding | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Josep (DT) questions the requirements for exempting SNPN onboarding from NSAC. Proposes to NOTE this CR. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the approval of this CR Malla (NTT DOCOMO) objects to the approval of this CR Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides replies. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Rainer (Nokia) provides r02. Antoine (Orange) provides r03. Marco (Huawei) comments that the changes is generic related to NSAC support for ES and not related SNPN scenario, to CT Ls and no in CR scope as currently stated in coversheet. Josep (DT) prefers to constrain the discussion to the usage of NSAC, as was the LS's question. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggest to ask CT1 question and meanwhile postpone the CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | LS on PWS Support over SNPN | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107053 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG3: Response LS on PWS Support over SNPN | RAN WG3 (R3-214402) | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) propose to note the LS as no action for SA2 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107057 | LS In | Information | Reply LS on support of PWS over SNPN | SA WG1 (S1-213120) | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) propose to note the LS ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107097 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG3: Reply to LS on support of PWS over SNPN | SA WG3 (S3-213609) | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) propose to note the LS ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Other LS | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107058 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on emergency services in an SNPN deployed in an area which does not belong to any country | SA WG1 (S1-213253) | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107521 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on IMEI for Non-Public Networks/Private Networks without using USIM | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108093 Revised to S2-2108093. | Peter (Ericsson) provides a question whether to be more generic in the question Marco (Huawei) asks clarification on 'simultaneously access to PLMN and SNPN is a scenario'? Haris(Qualcomm) responds Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides comments and proposes to note the LS. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) answers to Haris. Marco (Huawei) ask whether this LS issue is related to tdoc S2-2107381 in MUSIM AI? Haris(Qualcomm) replies to Dieter Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) there is no objection to r01 WHY NOTED? Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) is ok with r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108093 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on IMEI for Non-Public Networks/Private Networks without using USIM | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107521r01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs - KI#1 related | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107183 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3136 (Rel-17, 'F'): RID Update for SNPN UEs | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Josep (DT) comments, provides r01. xiaowan (vivo) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply xiaowan (vivo) is OK for the suggested change from Peter Hedman (Ericsson) Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question for clarification Josep (DT) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (original and all revisions) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Antoine (Orange) provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Josep (DT) objects to r00, r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r01 and r04 Josep (DT) replies to Sebastian's comment. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r04 and would ask for r03 to get approved Devaki (Nokia) comments - prefers original version or r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) would be ok with r00, r01 or r03 Devaki (Nokia) objects to r03, r04 but prefers either r00 or r01 is approved. xiaowan (vivo) prefer r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107715 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3340 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on roaming description for SNPN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108094 Revised to S2-2108094. | Josep (DT) objects to this CR. Devaki (Nokia) comments that the proposed change is actually correct to remove the restriction for Rel-17 as we have CH case specified. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Josep(DT) that it is all about wording issue, it is not appropriate to say 'Roaming' is supported for SNPN, but at least it is not wrong for people to believe that 'roaming' like feature is already supported by Rel-17 SNPN. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides proposal Josep (DT) comments that Peter's text proposal would be OK. Provides r01 implementing it. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Josep (DT). Josep (DT) comments that 5.30.9 clearly states that use of CH is not roaming. Devaki (Nokia) supports r01 as well. Jianning (Xiaomi) can live with r01 Hualin(Huawei) think r01 is ok. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Josep (DT) corrects his prior objection to cover only r00. r01 is OK. Jianning (Xiaomi) is ok to go with r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108094 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3340R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on roaming description for SNPN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107715r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs - KI#3 related | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107312 | CR | Approval | 23.167 CR0367 (Rel-17, 'B'): SNPN UE accessing emergency services in PLMN | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Josep (DT) proposes to NOTE. xiaowan (vivo) replies to Haris(Qualcomm) and seek clarification of the comments xiaowan (vivo) replies to George Foti (Ericsson) xiaowan (vivo) replies to Josep (DT) George (Ericsson) comments zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments. xiaowan (vivo) replies to Zhendong (ZTE) Josep (DT) replies to Xiaowan. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Josep (DT) objects to this CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107370 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Correction of IMC definition. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Rainer (Nokia) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107447 | CR | Approval | 23.167 CR0368 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.167 SNPN use IMS service from multiple IMS providers | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01 Ashok (Samsung) comments George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to the CR. Hualin(Huawei) reply to Ashok (Samsung). George (Ericsson) comments Hualin(Huawei) propose r02 and reply to George Foti (Ericsson), Rainer(Nokia) and Ashok(Samsung). Hualin(Huawei) reply to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom). Rainer (Nokia) replies. Rainer (Nokia) provides r03. zhendong (ZTE) provides comments. Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r03. Hualin(Huawei) replied to Zhendong(ZTE). Hualin(Huawei) replied to Ashok (Samsung). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) maintains objection to the CR. Rainer (Nokia) replies, proposes to replace ISH by IMS service provider. Hualin(Huawei) agree with Rainer (Nokia) proposal and suggest to bring it to CC#2. Rainer (Nokia) is ok with the proposal. Hualin(Huawei) propose to agree r03 in this meeting, since there is no technical difference between ISH and IMS provider. Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. Haris(Qualcomm) supports to approve r03 Rainer (Nokia) is also ok with r03. Hualin(Huawei) still propose to agree r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs - KI#4 related | - | - | Docs:=32 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107716 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3341 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction for terminologies | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108090 | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and proposes to merge into 07188 Rainer (Nokia) comments. Josep (DT) proposes to merge with S2-2107188 (Rapporteur's editorial cleanup), change category to D. Jianning (Xiaomi) is ok to merge into S2-2107188 (Rapporteur's editorial cleanup) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2107185 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3256 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE onboarding architecture | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108095 Revised to S2-2108095. | Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Jihoon (ETRI) indicates the tdoc number is wrong in the title. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Rainer (Nokia) comments on r01. Qianghua (Huawei) replies Jihoon (ETRI) asks questions. Rainer (Nokia) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r02 Megha(Intel) provides r02 and proposes to technically endorse the CR in this meeting. Haris(Qualcomm) comments that CR should be considered for approval Megha(Intel) provides r03 and comments Haris(Qualcomm) comments that endorsing the CR and not approving is against the WPs Megha(Intel) provides further comments Rainer (Nokia) replies. Rainer (Nokia) comments and objects to r03. Antoine (Orange) asks questions. Megha(Intel) provides r04 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hualin(Huawei) comments on r06. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Hualin(Huawei) think such improvement in r06 is needed. Otherwise it is confused how to local configure the AUSF. Hualin(Huawei):we may clarify it in future meeting, it is ok. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108095 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3256R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE onboarding architecture | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107185r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107416 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3297 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for UE onboarding and UE access with CH credentials | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2108096, merging S2-2107658 Revised to S2-2108096. | Qianghua (Huawei) replies Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Josep (DT) comments, provides r03. Josep (DT) provides the r03 link. Megha(Intel) provides r04 and comments Antoine (Orange) editorial changes needed on r03 and r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 Rainer (Nokia) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r08 Megha(Intel) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r09 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r09, ok with r08 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) withdraw objection to r09 i.e. r09 is ok ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108096 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3297R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for UE onboarding and UE access with CH credentials | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107416r09, merging S2-2107658. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107417 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3176 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for UE onboarding and UE access with CH credentials | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108097, merging S2-2107659 Revised to S2-2108097. | xiaowan (vivo) provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) replies Rainer (Nokia) replies. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 Josep (DT) provides r04. Antoine (Orange) provides r05. Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment on r06 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108097 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3176R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for UE onboarding and UE access with CH credentials | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107417r06, merging S2-2107659. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107717 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3342 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on network selection for ON-SNPN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | CC#2: r02 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2108098 Revised to S2-2108098. | Josep (DT) sees the proposed text as not really necessary and less clear than the original. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Josep (DT) Huan (vivo) comments Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Huan (vivo), and provides updated version r01 Amanda ( Futurewei ) doesn't agree with the proposal from this CR and think the current text in the spec is enough Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Amanda (Futurewei), Haris(Qualcomm) provides comments and cannot accept r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question Haris(Qualcomm) replies that intention is to say that the same UE implementation-specific logic is used also in second attempt Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Haris (Qaulcomm) and Peter (Ericsson), provides r02 Haris(Qualcomm) is ok with r02, coversheet need to be updated to tick ME box Amanda ( Futurewei ) responses to Jianming ( Xiaomi) and still think existing text in the spec is enough Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Amanda ( Futurewei ) is not ok with r02 and still prefer the original text in current spec Josep (DT) objects to this CR. Jianning (Xiaomi) try to provide r03 to resolve the concerns from Josep (DT) and Amanda (Futurewei) Josep (DT) would be fine with r03 in the drafts folder. Amanda (Futurewei ) can live with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108098 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3342R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on network selection for ON-SNPN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107717r02 + changes. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107182 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3254 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Remote provisioning of credentials - User Plane | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108099 Revised to S2-2108099. | Huan (vivo) comments that this CR has overlap with S2-2107313, and may be conflict with current specification Hualin(Huawei) comments and provide r01. Huan (vivo) comments and provide r02. Haris(Qualcomm) comments that r02 is not solving the problem in the reason for change of the CR Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Hualin(Huawei) reply. Hualin(Huawei) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Huan(vivo) comments and can only accept r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and can accept r02 and discuss if further changes should be done until next meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108099 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3254R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Remote provisioning of credentials - User Plane | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107182r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107184 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3255 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE Configuration Data for UP Remote Provisioning provided by ONN | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108100 Revised to S2-2108100. | Rainer (Nokia) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108100 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3255R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE Configuration Data for UP Remote Provisioning provided by ONN | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107184r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107298 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3274 (Rel-17, 'F'): eNPN corrections to clarify use of DNN and S-NSSAI for onboarding, AUSF discovery | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108101 Revised to S2-2108101. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Josep (DT) asks a question for clarification. Rainer (Nokia) replies. Rainer (Nokia) replies and prefers r00. Qianghua (Huawei) replies Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Rainer (Nokia) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r01, object r02/r00. Ashok (Samsung) comments and shares same view as Qianghua Josep (DT), comments, does not understand the argument of 'unnecessary UDM queries', objects to this CR. Rainer (Nokia) replies and could live with r01. Ashok (Samsung) responds to Rainer (Nokia) Rainer (Nokia) replies to Peter (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply Ashok (Samsung) shares same view as Rainer (Nokia) and Peter (Ericsson) Qianghua (Huawei) states again: only accept r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108101 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3274R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): eNPN corrections to clarify use of DNN and S-NSSAI for onboarding, AUSF discovery | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107298r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107313 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3277 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on remote provisioning of credentials for NSSAA or secondary authentication/authorization | vivo | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108102 Revised to S2-2108102. | Haris(Qualcomm) comments Huan (vivo) provide feedback and points out this CR is Huan (vivo) provide revision01 Huan (vivo) provide revision02 Rainer (Nokia) comments. Huan (vivo) provide feedback to Rainer (Nokia) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. Huan (vivo) provides r04 Haris(Qualcomm) is ok with r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Huan (vivo) prefers r04 but can live with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108102 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3277R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on remote provisioning of credentials for NSSAA or secondary authentication/authorization | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107313r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107314 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3008R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correct the NRF services between SNPN and DCS | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105912 from S2#146E. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108103 Revised to S2-2108103. | Josep (DT) comments, provides r01. Jihoon (ETRI) provides r02 for clarification. Rainer (Nokia) comments. Jihoon (ETRI) replies to Rainer(Nokia) with r03. Megha(Intel) provides comments and proposes to technically endorse the CR Antoine (Orange) provides r04 (editorial fix). Megha(Intel) provides comments and withdraws comments to technically endorse the CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== xiaowan (vivo) is fine with r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108103 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3008R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correct the NRF services between SNPN and DCS | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107314r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107323 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3281 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI#4- Restricted Onboarding PDU session when PLMN is ON | Samsung | Rel-17 | Confirm CR Number - CR states xxxx! r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108104 Revised to S2-2108104. | Josep (DT) requests clarification. Ashok (Samsung) clarifies to Josep (DT) xiaowan (vivo) provides r01 Ashok (Samsung) request clarification from Xiaowan (vivo) Ashok (Samsung) need clarification from Rainer regarding his objections Rainer (Nokia) replies. Ashok (Samsung) responds to Rainer (Nokia) Haris(Qualcomm) comments Ashok (Samsung) responds to Haris(Qualcomm) and thanks Rainer (Nokia) for the response. Provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides suggestion. Ashok (Samsung) provides r03 Josep (DT) comments, provides r04. Ashok (Samsung) is fine with r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108104 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3281R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI#4- Restricted Onboarding PDU session when PLMN is ON | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107323r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107327 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2945R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI#4-SNPN UE Onboarding using existing DNN | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105603 from S2#146E. Noted | Josep (DT) still does not understand the contribution. Requests further clarification. Ashok (Samsung) clarifies Josep (DT) Josep (DT) comments, still does not agree. Ashok (Samsung) still explains why the indication from UE is needed to Josep (DT) Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR Ashok (Samsung) request clarification from Haris(Qualcomm) Antoine (Orange) objects because this is not a Cat. F CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and do not think functionality is needed ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107364 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3168 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update creation of SM Policy Association to include PVS FQDN and PVS IP address as optional inputs | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108106 | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes to merge into 107657 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2107656 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3328 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the UE remote provisioning. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108105 Revised to S2-2108105. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02. xiaowan (vivo) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) suggests Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108105 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3328R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the UE remote provisioning. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107656r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107657 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3206 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding PVS information as imput to SMF and PCF sevice operation. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108106, merging S2-2107364 Revised to S2-2108106. | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and question. Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes to merge into 107657 Josep (DT) comments, proposes r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108106 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3206R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding PVS information as imput to SMF and PCF sevice operation. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107657r03, merging S2-2107364. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107368 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0661 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for PVS address formats | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108107 Revised to S2-2108107. | Josep (DT) asks questions for clarification. Questions whether this changes the current procedure. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Josep (DT). Josep (DT) comments, proposes r01. Rainer (Nokia) cannot accept r01. Mirko (Huawei) comments and provides r02. Rainer (Nokia) cannot accept r02. Josep (DT) proposes to postpone. Rainer (Nokia) replies and prefers to go with r00. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) provides r04. Mirko (Huawei) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r05. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r05 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2108107 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0661R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for PVS address formats | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107368r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107630 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3200 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE with malicious intent for Registration with Onboarding SNPN | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Josep (DT) objects to this CR. Haris(Qualcomm) objects to this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== Kisuk (Samsung) notes to this CR | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2107658 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3329 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification the Onboarding capability in the NRF profile | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108096 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge into S2-2107416 zhendong (ZTE) is fine with the merge proposal. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2107659 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3207 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding onboarding information to NRF service operation | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108097 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge into S2-2107417 Josep (DT) strongly prefers 7417, also suggests to merge with 7417. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with the merge proposal. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Documents exceeding quota | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2107186 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3137 (Rel-17, 'F'): LBO PDU session handling for inter-SNPN or inter-PLMN mobility | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | Huan (vivo) ask for clarifications Peter Hedman (Ericsson) the CR is not to be handled at this meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | - |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5GC (eEDGE_5GC) | - | - | Docs:=84 | - | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Mega Editorial CRs (Not counted towards quota) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107388 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0018 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mega CR for minor fixes to TS 23.548 | Huawei | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108108 Revised to S2-2108108. | Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r01 Hui (Huawei) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108108 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0018R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mega CR for minor fixes to TS 23.548 | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107388r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Resolution of EN - 'How to guarantee that the UE uses the EASDF's IP address for the subsequent DSN Query' | - | - | Docs:=28 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107691 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Way forward proposal for EAS discovery based on DNS query. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica, Verizon, NTT DoCoMo, Telecom Italia, AT&T, Charter, Telstra, KDDI, Matrixx, Convida Wireless, InterDigital, British Telecom, Rogers, Facebook, Orange, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, Ericsson, China Mobile, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, China Unicom, Huawei? HiSilicon, NEC, Sandvine, Amdocs | Revised to S2-2107733 | Revised | ||
| 8.3 | S2-2107733 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Way forward proposal for EAS discovery based on DNS query. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica, Verizon, NTT DoCoMo, Telecom Italia, AT&T, Charter, Telstra, KDDI, Matrixx, Convida Wireless, InterDigital, British Telecom, Rogers, Facebook, Orange, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, Ericsson, China Mobile, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, China Unicom, Huawei, HiSilicon, NEC, Sandvine, Amdocs | Revision of S2-2107691. Noted | Noted | ||
| 8.3 | S2-2107692 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0030 (Rel-17, 'C'): EAS rediscovery: Edge DNS Client based EAS (re-)discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica, Verizon, NTT DoCoMo, Telecom Italia, AT&T, Charter, Telstra, KDDI, Matrixx, Convida Wireless, InterDigital, T-Mobile USA, Rogers, Facebook, Orange, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, Ericsson, China Mobile, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Reliance Jio, China Unicom, Huawei, HiSilicon, NEC, Sandvine, Amdocs | Rel-17 | CC#2: r16 endorsed. Revised, merging S2-2107316, S2-2107317, S2-2107318, S2-2107374, S2-2107377, S2-2107670, S2-2107671, S2-2107672, S2-2107673, S2-2107680 and S2-2107731 to S2-2108177. | Sudeep (Apple) comments: not convinced on the need for EDC to resolve the EN. Points out that alternate proposal is available in 7372, 7374, 7377 and 7380. Huazhang(vivo) provides R01 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) comments on R01 Huazhang (vivo) replies to Riccardo Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Sundeep Aeneas (Google) comments regarding privacy and GDPR implications. Zhuoyun (Tencent) comments and has technical concerns on the solution. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for clarification. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Aeneas and provides r02. Sudeep (Apple) asks for clarification. Susana (Vodafone) responds to Aeneas Aeneas (Google) responds to Susana Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Sudeep Aeneas (Google) question for Dario on user preferences. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provide r03. Hui (Huawei) comments on r03. Huazhang (vivo) provides r04 Dario (Qualcomm) provides r05 Huazhang (vivo) provides r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and suggests to come back after the cc#1b. Hui (Huawei) encourage companies to provide the opinion on the revisions. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Tingfang Hui(Huawei) provided draft r07 Sherry (Xiaomi) provided draft r07v03 to the draft folder. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Dario (Qualcomm) provides r08 (=cleansed r07). | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108177 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0030R1 (Rel-17, 'C'): EAS rediscovery: Edge DNS Client based EAS (re-)discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica, Verizon, NTT DoCoMo, Telecom Italia, AT&T, Charter, Telstra, KDDI, Matrixx, Convida Wireless, InterDigital, T-Mobile USA, Rogers, Facebook, Orange, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, Ericsson, China Mobile, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Reliance Jio, China Unicom, Huawei, HiSilicon, NEC, Sandvine, Amdocs, SK Telekom, Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107692r16,, merging S2-2107316, S2-2107317, S2-2107318, S2-2107374, S2-2107377, S2-2107670, S2-2107671, S2-2107672, S2-2107673, S2-2107680 and S2-2107731. Technically Endorsed. | Endorsed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107693 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3211 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE authorization for 5GC assisted EAS discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Telstra, NTT DoCoMo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, AT&T, Verizon, Orange, Matrixx, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, China Mobile, Amdocs | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108109 Revised to S2-2108109. | Sudeep (Apple) is not clear how this CR is related to the EN on DNS procedure. Also requests to point out study conclusions related to this CR. Shubhranshu (Nokia) Comments and suggests to continue this discussion in corresponding S2-2107694 thread Dario (Qualcomm) provides r01 Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r02 Hui (Huawei) provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dario (Qualcomm) prefers r02 because r03 has some issues. Hui (Huawei) responses. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK with r03, objects r00-r02. Magnus O (Ericsson) Suggest to endorse a version as base for further work in next meeting Shubhranshu (Nokia) proposes to agree with r03, not OK to other revisions Dario (Qualcomm) can live with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108109 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3211R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE authorization for 5GC assisted EAS discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Telstra, NTT DoCoMo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, AT&T, Verizon, Orange, Matrixx, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, China Mobile, Amdocs | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107693r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107694 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0031 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE authorization for 5GC assisted EAS discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Telstra, NTT DoCoMo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, AT&T, Verizon, Orange, Matrixx, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, China Mobile, Amdocs | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108110 Revised to S2-2108110. | Sudeep (Apple) is not clear how this CR is related to the EN on DNS procedure. Also requests to point out study conclusions related to this CR. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Sundeep and provides r01 Magnus O(Ericsson) asks questions Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments Sudeep (Apple) has follow-up questions. Jicheol (Samsung) ask questions Hui(Huawei) comments Jicheol (Samsung) comments. Hui (Huawei) replies. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments Dario (Qualcomm) replies and provides r02 Hui (Huawei) provides r03 Huazhang (vivo) provides r04 Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hui (Huawei) can only accept r05 with an additional change. Dario (Qualcomm) is OK with r05 Magnus O (Ericsson) Suggest to endorse a version as base for further work in next meeting Shubhranshu (Nokia) is OK to r05 with additional text proposed by Hui /Huawei Hui (Huawei) objects r05 but can live with an additional change. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108110 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0031R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE authorization for 5GC assisted EAS discovery | Qualcomm Incorporated, Vodafone, Telstra, NTT DoCoMo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, AT&T, Verizon, Orange, Matrixx, Rakuten Mobile, KPN, TNO, China Mobile, Amdocs | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107694r05. Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107282 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on EDC proposal | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107283 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0011 (Rel-17, 'F'): An informative example of DNS client functionality | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) comments and asks if this paper is merged into 7377 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107372 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Resolving the Editor's Note on DNS procedure for EAS Discovery . | Apple, ASUSTeK, vivo, Sony, Broadcom | Noted | Noted | ||
| 8.3 | S2-2107374 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0015 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving Editor's Note on sending DNS queries to EASDF for EAS (re-)discovery | Apple, Microsoft, vivo, ASUSTeK, Broadcom, CATT, Tencent, OPPO, Samsung, Sony | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) asks questions. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provide r01 to merge S2-2107670. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107377 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0016 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding informative examples for DNS client functionality | Apple, Microsoft, vivo, ASUSTeK, Tencent, OPPO, Sony | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Sudeep (Apple) provides r01 merging content from S2-2107283 Dario (Qualcomm) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107380 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on E2E verification of Edge Application Server Discovery | Apple | Noted | Noted | ||
| 8.3 | S2-2107669 | DISCUSSION | Approval | UE handling of DNS configuration. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107670 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0026 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE handling of DNS configuration via NAS PCO | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107671 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0027 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE handling of DNS configuration via DHCP RDNSS option | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107672 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0665 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE handling of DNS configuration via URSP rule | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107673 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0028 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE handling of DNS configuration via URSP rule | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107316 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0013 (Rel-17, 'B'): Remove EN on UE using MNO DNS configuration | Alibaba, Huawei, HiSilicon, Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107317 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3159 (Rel-17, 'B'): Indication of DNS configuration for edge service | Alibaba, Huawei, HiSilicon, Tencent | Rel-17 | Confirm Spec version used - CR states 17.0.0! Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107318 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3279 (Rel-17, 'B'): Indication of DNS configuration for edge service | Alibaba, Huawei, HiSilicon, Tencent | Rel-17 | Confirm Spec version used - CR states 17.0.0! Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107677 | DISCUSSION | Information | Resolving the Editor's Note on DNS procedure for EAS Discovery . | Google Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107680 | CR | Agreement | 23.548 CR0029 (Rel-17, 'D'): Application selection of DNS Procedures for MEC services | Rel-17 | Confirm CR Number - CR states XXXX! Merged into S2-2108177 | Merged | ||
| 8.3 | S2-2107730 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Discussion on way forward of UE DNS Query using EASDF's IP address. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107731 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0033 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE DNS Query using EASDF's IP address | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108177 | Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107542 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Potential way forward of UE Guarantee DNS setting to application | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107537 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0020 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mechanisms to deliver MNO DNS configuration from 5GC to AF | vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed | Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments Huazhang (vivo) replies to Riccardo Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments Huazhang (vivo) replys to Shubhranshu Huazhang (vivo) provides r01 Huazhang (vivo) provides r02 based on r01, only MNO AF can provide the DNS server IP address to application Dario (Qualcomm) comments Huazhang (vivo) replys to Dario Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Dario's comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs | - | - | Docs:=48 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107234 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0001 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to uniqueness of Update related to a buffered DNS message in EASDF | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108111 Revised to S2-2108111. | Xinpeng (Huawei) Provides r01. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r02 and answers questions Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Xinpeng(Huawei) provides comments. Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r03. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Xinpeng(Huawei) replies. Laurent (Nokia): Comments Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xinpeng(Huawei) comments. Magnus H (Ericsson) we are ok with r04, object r03, prefers r01 or r02 Xinpeng(Huawei) agree to use r04 as way forward, object to r00-r02. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) proposes to postpone this CR and take r04 as baseline and come back next meeting, objects all other versions. . Xinpeng(Huawei) replies to Tingfang Tang (Lenovo). Laurent (Nokia): objects to r03, prefers r00, r01 or r02 but can live with R04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108111 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0001R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to uniqueness of Update related to a buffered DNS message in EASDF | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107234r04. CC#2: Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107236 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0003 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction and removal of missleading Note | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Hui (Huawei) provides comments Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Hui (Huawei) replies to Magnus H. Magnus H (Ericsson) replies Laurent (Nokia): Comments Hui(Huawei): Fine with the original paper. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.3 | S2-2107237 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0004 (Rel-17, 'F'): Monitor when MNO DNS configuration is not used | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108112. CC#2: was then postponed and the revision allocated in S2-2108112 was withdrawn Revised to S2-2108112. | Hui (Huawei) provides r01 Dan(China Mobile) suggest Magnus H (Ericsson) ask Huawei to clarify the revision made Hui (Huawei) replies. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 Hui (Huawei): prefers r03 Magnus H (Ericsson) prefers r03 Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) objects to r02-r04, can live with r05. Laurent (Nokia): prefers R04 as you can guess t for the sake of progress can live with r05 Laurent (Nokia): prefers R04 as you can guess, but for the sake of progress can live with r05 Hui (Huawei): fine with r05 Zhuoyun (Tencent) prefers r05, and objects r02-r04. Dario (Qualcomm) can only accept r05 without the first change. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2108112 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0004R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Monitor when MNO DNS configuration is not used | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107237r05. CC#2: WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107240 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0006 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to AF request for simultaneous connectivity over source and target PSA at edge relocation | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui (Huawei) asks questions on this paper and corresponding S2-2107241 and S2-2107242. Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments to this paper and corresponding S2-2107241 and S2-2107242 Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Hui (Huawei) Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments to this paper and corresponding S2-2107241 and S2-2107242. Hui (Huawei) comments.. Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Shubhranshu (Nokia) Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r14 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r02, for the same update as r01. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r03 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hui (Huawei) objects r04 and can live with r03 or r03 with an additional revision. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) objects r04 and r00, is OK with r02 or r03, can live with r03 with revision suggested by Hui. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to all revision except r00 and r04 Shubhranshu (Nokia) is OK to r03, but not OK to other revisions Hui (Huawei) responses. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107241 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3263 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to AF request for simultaneous connectivity over source and target PSA at edge relocation | Ericsson | Rel-17 | To be discussed with S2-2107240, exempted from quota. Noted | Hui (Huawei) asks questions. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hui (Huawei) objects this paper. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107242 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3145 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to AF request for simultaneous connectivity over source and target PSA at edge relocation | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Should be a CR to 23.503. New CR number needed. To be discussed with S2-2107240, exempted from quota. Noted | Hui (Huawei) asks questions. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r01 Hui (Huawei) asks what's new in r01 Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds Hui (Huawei) comments whether this CR is still needed. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to all revisions except r00 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK r01, objects r00, because the adding one more timer is not agreed in S2-2107240. Shubhranshu (Nokia) is OK to r01, but not OK to r00 Hui (Huawei) propose to either note or postpone the CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107245 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Way forwards for UE not using network provided DNS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107265 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0010 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on the procedure of EAS discovery with EASDF | China Unicom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108116 | Laurent (Nokia): Suggests this Tdoc to be merged in 7387 Tianqi (ChinaUnicom) is OK this paper merged into S2-2107387. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107284 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0012 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean-up of action part of DNS message handling rule | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108116 | Laurent (Nokia): Supports the rapporteur proposal to merge this Tdoc in 7387 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107285 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3155 (Rel-17, 'B'): Correction of UE Policies delivery notification | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108113 Revised to S2-2108113. | Shubhranshu (Nokia) asks for clarification Magnus H (Ericsson) asks if this is in the correct AI Jicheol (Samsung) comments Changhong (Intel) comments Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments Jicheol (Samsung) clarified the CR proposal for Shubranshu (Nokia)'s question. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r01 Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds and provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108113 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3155R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Correction of UE Policies delivery notification | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107285r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107336 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3162 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Updates on I-SMF selection | CATT | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108114 Revised to S2-2108114. | Yuan Tao (CATT) replies and provides r02. Hui (Huawei) provides comments Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments Yuan Tao (CATT) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108114 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3162R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Updates on I-SMF selection | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107336r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107337 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3163 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Add paramters to EAS Deployment service operations | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108119 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Hui (Huawei): proposes to consider this paper as merged into S2-2107468 Yuan Tao(CATT): confirms this paper is merged into S2-2107468 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107341 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0014 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the local AF subscription for the QoS Monitoring during UE mobility | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108115 Revised to S2-2108115. | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification Dan (China Mobile) response Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haiyang (Huawei) can only live with r02 or r03 Dan (China Mobile) OK with r02 or r03,prefer r03. Magnus O (Ericsson) is ok with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108115 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0014R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the local AF subscription for the QoS Monitoring during UE mobility | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107341r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107356 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3166 (Rel-17, 'F'): AF Coordination Information | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107371 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3169 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction output in Nnef_AFsessionWithQoS_create/update service operation | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Magnus O (Ericsson) provides comment Dan (China Mobile) reply Magnus O (Ericsson) comments Dan (China Mobile) answers ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dan (China Mobile) this paper can be postpond Magnus O (Ericsson) Also support postponing the document ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2107386 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3293 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on DNAI based I-SMF selection and removal | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107387 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0017 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates on EAS Discovery Procedure with EASDF | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#2: r17 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2108116, merging S2-2107265, S2-2107284, S2-2107491, S2-2107557 and S2-2107704 Revised to S2-2108116. | Laurent (Nokia): suggests this CR to be taken as the baseline on this topic and provides r01 Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r02. Dan(China Mobile) provides r03 to merge part of S2-2107704 in this paper . Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r04. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r05, DNAI is not good for DNS action information ID due to technical reasons Xinpeng(Huawei)provides r06. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Xinpeng(Huawei) provide r07. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies Laurent (Nokia): provides r08 Xinpeng(Huawei) provides comments and provide r09. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r10. Xinpeng (Huawei) provides comments to Jicheol(Samsung). Jicheol (Samsung) provides r11. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r12. Xinpeng(Huawei) provide r13. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r14 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r15 Xinpeng(Huawei) provides comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r16. Laurent (Nokia): provides r17 Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r18. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r19_draft. Magnus H (Ericsson) suggest an update to r19_draft Xinpeng(Huawei) agree with R19_draft with '...such as the DNAI or a sequence number...' in NOTE3. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version but R01, R08, R15, R17. Can accept R19 = R17 with new Note 3 proposed by Xinpeng. R19/R17 are the best Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to r00-r14 and r18. Accepts r16, r17, and r19_draft where note 3 in r19_draft would be updated as ''...such as the DNAI or a sequence number...'. Prefers r15 Xinpeng(Huawei) objects to r00-r15 and r17. Accepts r16, and r19_draft where NOTE 3 in r19_draft would be updated as ''...such as the DNAI or a sequence number...'. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK with r19_draft. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108116 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0017R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates on EAS Discovery Procedure with EASDF | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107387r17 + changes, merging S2-2107265, S2-2107284, S2-2107491, S2-2107557 and S2-2107704. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107430 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3179 (Rel-17, 'F'): NEF service to support EAS deployment info and updated DNS server address | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108117 Revised to S2-2108117. | Hui (Huawei) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108117 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3179R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): NEF service to support EAS deployment info and updated DNS server address | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107430r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107431 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3299 (Rel-17, 'F'): 501 EASDF Service correction | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108118 Revised to S2-2108118. | Laurent (Nokia): comments on the naming being chosen for the service and provides r01 Hui (Huawei) provides comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments. Laurent (Nokia): answers Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Dario (Qualcomm) supports aligning with CT4 terminology. Hui(Huawei) supports aligning with CT4 terminology. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108118 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3299R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 501 EASDF Service correction | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107431r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107468 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3185 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update Nnef_EASDeployment services | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2108119, merging S2-2107337 Revised to S2-2108119. | Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Zhuoyun (Tencent): provides r03. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments and ask question Dario (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Hui(Huawei) provides r05 Yuan Tao (CATT) comments. Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r06. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for clarification and comments. Laurent (Nokia): provides r07 Hui (Huawei): asks questions to r07 Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r08. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r09 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r10 Hui (Huawei) provides r11 Yuan Tao (CATT) provides r12 Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r13 and r14. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r15 and r16. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to previous comments by Hui Hui (Huawei) repeat question on reference ID. Zhuoyun (Tencent) replies the question on reference ID. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version except R02, R07 or R08 . IF no commonly agreed version is possible, one way forward is to endorse a version as baseline . Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK with r07/r08/r16, can live with r15, objects all the other versions. Zhuoyun (Tencent) prefers r08, and then r16, can also accepts other versions. Yuan Tao (CATT) also prefers r08, and can accepts subsequent versions. Hui (Huawei): can accept R08 though some points may need more discussion in next meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108119 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3185R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update Nnef_EASDeployment services | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107468r08, merging S2-2107337. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107491 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0019 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update DNS handling rules and Node Level DNS Handling Information | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108116 | Laurent (Nokia): supports rapporteur proposal to merge in 7387 Zhuoyun (Tencent) is fine with merging this contribution in 7387. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107538 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0021 (Rel-17, 'F'): Introducing EASDF cache | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): asks questions (Tdoc cannot be accepted as long as there is no clarification on this question) Huazhang (vivo): replys to Laurent(Nokia) Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Hui (Huawei) comments. Dario (Qualcomm) comments. Huazhang (vivo) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to this CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107539 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0022 (Rel-17, 'F'): Local NEF selection | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107646 (Noted) | Laurent (Nokia): I suggest we have a single thread i.e. 7646; I'll comment on that thread Laurent (Nokia): (considering that 7539 and 7646 are very similar, I suggest we have a single thread i.e. 7646; I'll comment on that thread Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 7646 (or noted), as the discussion will be in 7646 thread. Huazhang(vivo) is ok to merge to 7646 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107540 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3023R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure of discovery of local NEF from NRF | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105989 from S2#146E. Noted | Laurent (Nokia): suggests that discussion on 7540/7647 waits for the conclusion on the discussion on 7539/7646 Laurent (Nokia): further explains the concern ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Huazhang (vivo): replies to Laurent why objects, these parameters has already been approved in former SA2 meeting Magnus H (Ericsson) question if this is category F CR Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc as 7646 needs to be postponed ==== Comments Deadline ==== Huazhang (vivo): can't understand this objection with no technique issues or reasons | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107541 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | EASDF cache and Reducing interaction between EASDF and SMF. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Same remark as for 7538 (no need to answer on both threads) Yannick (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with this CR. Hui(Huawei): This discussion paper should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107557 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0023 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update EAS Deployment Information Management procedure and services | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108116 | Laurent (Nokia): supports rapporteur proposal to merge in 7387 Zhuoyun (Tencent) is fine with merging this contribution in 7387. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107560 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0024 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update Neasdf_DNSContext services | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Approved | Laurent (Nokia): supports rapporteur proposal to merge in 7387 Zhuoyun (Tencent) clarifies and suggests to handle this contribution separately. Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r01. Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r02. Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r03. Zhuoyun (Tencent) is fine with r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to all revisions except r00 Xinpeng(Huawei) ask questions. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Xinpeng(Huawei) replies. Zhuoyun (Tencent) is fine with r00, and can also accept r03. Xinpeng(Huawei) agrees with r0. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.3 | S2-2107634 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3202 (Rel-17, 'F'): UPF Service Operation | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to this tdoc, as we never defined Nupf_EventExposure_Subscribe Magnus (Ericsson): Agrees with Laurent, this would go beyond the agreements we have for Rel-17 and would add new functionality Haiyang(Huawei) share similar opinion with Magnus (Ericsson) and Laurent (Nokia) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== Kisuk (Samsung) notes this CR. | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107646 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0025 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure for local NEF selection | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): comments comparing 7539 and 7646 Huazhang (vivo) replys to Laurent Dan (China Mobile) provide comment for this paper and also vivo's paper Huazhang (vivo) replies to Dan Dan (China Mobile) replies to Huazhang Haiyang(Huawei) shares similar view with Dan (China Mobile) and suggests to note this paper. (neither r00 nor r01 is accepted) Huazhang(vivo) replies to Dan and Haiyang Dan(China Mobile) replies Huazhang(vivo) provides R02 Haiyang(Huawei) comments Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r03 Huazhang (vivo) replys to Haiyang Laurent (Nokia): provides r04 Huazhang (vivo): response to Laurent Huazhang (vivo): provides r05 Haiyang (Huawei) further comments, provides r06 and objects to all previous revisions. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r07 Dan(China Mobile) ask Huazhang (vivo) provides r08 as a supplement or compromise to r07, and r07 is also ok Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r09 Huazhang (vivo) still think we should have a procedure and provides r10 and r11 Laurent (Nokia): expresses concerns for any solution that requires AF registration onto NRF Laurent (Nokia): further explains the concern ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haiyang (Huawei) can live with r06 and r09, objects to all other revisions. Huazhang (vivo) propose to go with r09, and go back next meeting whether the procedure is needed Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Magnus H (Ericsson) propose to go with r09, and go back next meeting whether the procedure is needed Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version except R01 R04 R05. I think we need to postpone Huazhang (vivo): comments to Laurent ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107647 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3204 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure for local NEF selection | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): clarifies one aspect Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Haiyang(Huawei) suggests to note this paper (objects both r00 and r01). Laurent (Nokia): further explains the concern Huazhang (vivo):replys to Laurent ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): as we can't converge on 7646, suggests we postpone this paper ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107695 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3212 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of ECS Address Configuration Information | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108120 Revised to S2-2108120. | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) provides r01. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108120 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3212R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of ECS Address Configuration Information | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107695r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107704 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0032 (Rel-17, 'F'): Supplementary Session Level EAS deployment information for EAS discovery method | China Mobile, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108116 | Laurent (Nokia): same concern / question as for 7705 (EAS deployment info in Nnef-traffic-influence) Dan(China Mobile) reply to Laurent Laurent (Nokia): answers ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dan(China Mobile): answers Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) same reply as in the thread of 7705. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version as he suggests we postpone this paper and there is a simpler solution Dan(China Mobile) response to Laurent Dan(China Mobile) request this paper marked as part of it merged into S2-2107387 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2107705 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3337 (Rel-17, 'F'): Supplementary Session Level EAS deployment information for EAS discovery method | China Mobile, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): expresses a concern / question Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Dan (China Mobile) replies to Laurent. Laurent (Nokia): answers Dan (China Mobile): answers Laurent (Nokia): Comment Dan (China Mobile): ask Laurent (Nokia): explains his concerns ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dan(China Mobile): answers Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version as he suggests we postpone this paper and there is a simpler solution Dan (China Mobile) response that the two slices can not work for one application ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2107764 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussing the Procedure for local NEF selection | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Haiyang(Huawei) suggests to note this discussion paper as the discussion will be in 7646 thread. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2107772 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3219 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to AF provided ECS Address Configuration Information related details | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108121 Revised to S2-2108121. | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) provides r01 Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments and is ok with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108121 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3219R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to AF provided ECS Address Configuration Information related details | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107772r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107775 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0034 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updating related to EAS Discovery Procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108122 Revised to S2-2108122. | Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2108122 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0034R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updating related to EAS Discovery Procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107775r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Documents exceeding quota | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107235 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0002 (Rel-17, 'F'): EAS Node level corrections | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | Laurent (Nokia): Suggests this Tdoc to be merged in 7387 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | - |
| 8.3 | S2-2107238 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3144 (Rel-17, 'F'): EAS Node level correction | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107239 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0005 (Rel-17, 'F'): Not all EC scenarios requires EASDF | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107243 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0007 (Rel-17, 'F'): Improving Annex C | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107244 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0008 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updating re-discovery | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2107246 | CR | Approval | 23.548 CR0009 (Rel-17, 'F'): Way forwards for UE not using network provided DNS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 2 (eNS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=77 | - | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Mega Editorial CRs (Not counted towards quota) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107274 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3268 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial Changes on eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107940 Revised to S2-2107940. | Mirko (Huawei) comments Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r02 with editorial modification Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02 Jinguo(ZTE) asks Jinhua(Xiaomi) to provide r03 Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Jinguo(ZTE) r02 is fine, it's already include changes from both of us. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107940 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3268R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial Changes on eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107274r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107275 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3152 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial Changes on eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107941 Revised to S2-2107941. | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r01 with editorial modification Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107941 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3152R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial Changes on eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107275r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | LS In | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107020 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on rejected NSSAI for the maximum number of UE reached when TAIs belonging to different PLMNs | CT WG1 (C1-214895) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107088, S2-2107119, S2-2107227 and S2-2107504. Posponed | Postponed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107088 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on rejected NSSAI for the maximum number of UE reached when TAIs belonging to different PLMNs | QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107020. Noted | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments and prefer Option2. Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. Haiyang proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. Stefano (Qualcomm) can accept any of S2-2107088, S2-2107119 or S2-2107227 as the basis, and cannot accept S2-2107504. Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to use 7088 as basis for further discussion Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments that LS need cleanup. Haiyang(Huawei) cannot accept an version replying Option 1 (at least for now). Haiyang(Huawei) corrects the previous comment: cannot accept an version replying Option 2 (at least for now). alessio(nokia) provides r01 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 to fix some typos in r01 Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r03 with editorial update. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and cannot accept option 1 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao (VC) can we go with r03 or some simplified version on this? Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r01, r02, r03, i.e. can only accept r00 Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with r03, and objects the original version. Alessio(Nokia) is happy with r03, and we should use it even if there is one objecting company because they do not object technically when they want to restrict EPLMN features for common core PLMNs which use NSAC (they do not explain the reason) . alessio(Nokia) cannot accept r0 as it disallows the case of ePLMNs sharing the CN. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107119 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on rejected NSSAI for the maximum number of UE reached when TAIs belonging to different PLMNs | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107020. Noted. Discussion continued with S2-2107088 | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments and prefer Option2. Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. Haiyang proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Peter (Ericsson). Support option 2. Haiyang(Huawei) replies to Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO). Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Haiyang(Huawei). Stefano (Qualcomm) echoes previous comments and can accept any of S2-2107088, S2-2107119 or S2-2107227 as the basis, and cannot accept S2-2107504. alessio(Nokia) cannot accept any of the replies (including this one)... we need one that asks questions on what scenario CT1 is considering and why they are asking this question. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia Alessio(Nokia) replies and proposes to postpone the LS Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge 7119 into 7088 Jinguo(ZTE) comments alessio(Nokia) comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok to mark as merged into 07088 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107227 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on rejected NSSAI for the maximum number of UE reached when TAIs belonging to different PLMNs | Samsung | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107020. Noted. Discussion continued with S2-2107088 | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments and prefer Option2. Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. Haiyang proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107504. alessio(Nokia) cannot accept any of the replies (including this one)... we need one that asks questions on what scenario CT1 is considering and why they are asking this question. Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge 7227 into 7088 Dongeun(Samsung) is fine to merge 7227 into 7088 and use 7088 as a basis ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107504 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on rejected NSSAI for the maximum number of UE reached when TAIs belonging to different PLMNs | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107020. Noted. Discussion continued with S2-2107088 | Jinguo (ZTE) correct the title(Tdoc number is 7504) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment and proposes to use another LS reply suggesting option 2 Haiyang (Huawei) provides comments to Peter (Ericsson). Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Peter (Ericsson). Support option 2. Do not mind to use which one as a basis for LS Reply as long as the answer indicating option 2. Stefano (Qualcomm) echoes previous comments and can accept any of S2-2107088, S2-2107119 or S2-2107227 as the basis, and cannot accept S2-2107504 or anything that clearly does not indicate option2. Krisztian (Apple) supports option 2. Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Haiyang for clarification, and have no mind to use which doc for LS Reply. Haiyang (Huawei) comments with more information. Jinguo (ZTE) comments alessio(Nokia) comments alessio(Nokia) comments that if each PLMN in EPLMN list has its own quota, when we provide TAIs of the EPLMN do we also adjust the quota in each of the ePLMNs as in principle the Ue is registered in a RA including the EPLMNs? Jinguo(ZTE) answer Haiyang (Huawei) comments, thinks now it is clear we should go with Option 1. Alessio(Nokia) we need to pick one LS to be basis for response and work on that... for now it is difficult to conclude as we have so many threads. can jinguo pick one at random and tell us to concentrate on that one LS response text? Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge 7504 into 7088 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107011 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on Cell reselection with band-specific network slices | RAN WG2 (R2-2108868) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105371 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107062 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on NSAC procedure | SA WG3 (S3-213036) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107121, S2-2107228 and S2-2107280. Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107121 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on NSAC procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107062. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107942, merging S2-2107228 and S2-2107280 Revised to S2-2107942. | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments Haiyang (Huawei) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r04, but if 07427 is not approved some minor cleanup needed ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107942 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on NSAC procedure | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107121r04, merging S2-2107228 and S2-2107280. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107228 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on NSAC procedure | Samsung | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107062. Merged into S2-2107942 | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments. Dongeun (Samsung) is ok to merge this into 7121. But regarding Q2, prefers 7122 than 7122r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and for CR plz use revision of 07427 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2107280 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS response to SA WG3 S2-2107062 (SA WG3) | ZTE | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107062. Merged into S2-2107942 | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and suggest to merge into 07121 Jinguo(ZTE) agrees to merge into 07121 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2107427 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3178 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.502 Correction of NSAC for network slice subject to NSSAA | NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | George Foti (Ericsson) provides r01. See additional comments Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments George (Ericsson) comments Ashok (Samsung) comments Iskren (NEC) answers George (Ericsson). George (Ericsson) provides comments. The LS 7122r01 has the same sentence. The CR will also be attached Ashok (Samsung) responds to George (Ericsson) George (Ericsson) responds. Please look at 7427r01. It has the same text. Iskren (NEC) responds to George (Ericsson). Iskren (NEC) answers comments by George (Ericsson) and provides r02. George (Ericsson) objects to r02. Additional comments Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments for the clarification, when the S-NSSAI is subject to both NSSAA and NSAC, with EAC mode active and de-active. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from George (Ericsson), Ashok (Samsung) and Jinhua (Xiaomi). Alessio(Nokia) believes this CR is not needed Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Prefer r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a question Iskren (NEC) replies to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) George (Ericsson) provides r03 Genadi (Lenovo) comments to r03. The changes are not needed. Iskren (NEC) answers to George (Ericsson) Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides comments to Iskren (NEC) , when the EAC mode active, S-NSSAI subjected to NSSAA will be performed the NSAC with others. George (Ericsson) provides comments. That basically saying what I just send. As I said I can remove the note but the note is correct Iskren (NEC) answers Jinhua (Xiaomi) and )George (Ericsson). George (Ericsson) comments. What is provided by 7427 is simple, and clear. NO more interpretation. What is the problem. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Jinguo (ZTE) provides r05 Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r06 with rewording and co-signer. Iskren (NEC) comments Jinguo(ZTE) reply to Iskren (NEC) Iskren (NEC) answers Jinguo(ZTE) George (Ericsson) provides r07. Ashok correctly stated I believe irrespective of EAC mode, NSAC should be always executed before NSSAA. For the second note the check has to be done before the UPU. This was the original text that got changed. Fenqin (Huawei) comments George (Ericsson) comments. Step 4 is relevant. NSAC is triggered before UCU. For me whether NSAC is executed before or after NSAC does not matter really. If done before and NSSAA fails the AMF reduces the count, If done after that's OK as well. Works either way as long as the implementation is correct. The spec. is clear Ashok (Samsung) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) Jinguo(ZTE) comments on r07. alessio(nokia) this seems to become a Cr that introduces notes to replace normative text and calls itself a FASMO CR? We do not agree this is better than the original text and as Jinguo says there are cases where the NSAC can happen after the NSSAA. or at leas the operator should decide which order makes sense to them... George (Ericsson) What if NSAC failed. U will have to deregister the UE. SO U waisted radio resources for a useless transaction. That's why it has to be done before. Fenqin, and Ashok have the same view as well. George (Ericsson) comments. There is an LS from CT1 asking for clarification. So this is needed. As I said, the issue is if NSAC is to be done before or after UCU. After UCU U would loose radios resources if NSAC return failure, Whether U do NSAC before or after NNSAA is not specified, and we don't care . U missed the point from the email below ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) ask whether we can agree some version or not George (Ericsson) accepts one of the following revisions: 1,3,4,7. We object to the rest (2, 5, and 6). Iskren (NEC) - I am objecting to all revisions other than the initial version, rev01 and rev02. My preference is for the initial revision and rev02 however, I can also accept rev01 which is correct although not complete. Rev 01 would also be good to provide with the related LS. TAO(VC) let's check whether r01 agreeable or not Fenqin (Huawei) - accept only r02 Jinguo (ZTE) - suggest to go with r02 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) accepts only r02. George (Ericsson) accepts R01 Alessio (Nokia) believe r01 has some confusing text. we should not agree it. let's postpone to next meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107408 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3296 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.501_Update of the Functional Description Related to NSAC | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107326 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2944R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC procedure in planned AMF removal case | Samsung, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105601 from S2#146E. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Emergency and priority service | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107786 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3354 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC when emergency/critical/priority service status changes | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR and provides comments Genadi (Lenovo) replies to George Foti (Ericsson) and emphasizes that this CR is not related to session continuity but to counting of all UEs/PDU Sessions in the NSACF. George (Ericsson) comments Kundan(NEC) seeks clarification. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments . Suggest this to be merged into 7726. Genadi (Lenovo) thinks that merging to other Tdoc makes sense if there is an agreement to let the NSACF do the exemption. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) objects to the CR. We accepted r01 of 7726. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107506 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3309 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NSAC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Please see additional comments Haiyang(Huawei) clarifies to George Foti (Ericsson) and provides r01 George Foti (Ericsson) proposes additional comments Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments. Genadi (Lenovo) provides replies to Kundan (NEC). George (Ericsson) comments Haiyang (Huawei) reply to George (Ericsson) comments Haiyang (Huawei) further reply George (Ericsson) comments. In inter-AMF mobility SC is guaranteed by design. So nothing is lost even if the NSACF changes. U don't need to be an MPS UE or anything for that. Ashok (Samsung) comments Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification Ashok (Samsung) responds to Haiyang (Huawei) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) please update your views with offline progress George (Ericsson) accepts one of the following revisions: 1,3,4,7. We object to the rest (2, 5, and 6). George (Ericsson) Please ignore the email below. I answered the wrong CR George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions including original. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107726 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3345 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications of NSAC and NSAC for roaming cases | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#2: r04 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2107943 Revised to S2-2107943. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides r01 and additional comments to clarify r01. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments and asks a clarification. Haiyang(Huawei) provides r02. George Foti (Ericsson) objects to r02. It destroyed the whole CR. Genadi (Lenovo) agrees with r02 and suggests to merge to other CRs changing the same clauses. George (Ericsson) objects to r02. We indicated as well that we object to 7506. Haiyang(Huawei) objects r01. Kaisu (Nokia) objects to r02. We are ok with r01. Jinguo (ZTE) provides r03. George (Ericsson) we are Ok with r03 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments and provides r04. Needs clarification for r01 and r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haiyang (Huawei) objects r03 and r04, (cannot live with the yellow part). Ashok (Samsung) shares same view as Haiyang (Huawei) George (Ericsson) comments. Not all UEs support generating proper RRC priority establsihment cause. Thats the realtiy. Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to postpone Ashok (Samsung) does not agree to the concept of giving exemption based on subscription Kaisu (Nokia) is fine with r03 and r04 Ashok (Samsung) ask Kaisu (Nokia) to give revision without 'or when the AMF subscription data includes priority subscription (e.g. MCS, MPS)' text. With this text it is not Ok Kaisu (Nokia) would be ok to remove the part which is no acceptable to Ashok. Tao(VC) can we go with r04 without the yellow text ('or when the AMF subscription data includes priority subscription (e.g. MCS, MPS)'? George (Ericsson) comments. Agrees to that but we will not accept any more proposals on MPS/MCX at the next meeting before we have agreed on requirements. It is clear that there is no common view for any new proposals. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107943 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3345R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications of NSAC and NSAC for roaming cases | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107726r04 + changes. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | EPC Interworking | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107108 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3126 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of 5GS Registration for Slices subject to NSAC in conjunction with home Routed PDU Sessions | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) provides r01 Alessio(Nokia) cannot accept this CR: NSAC is becoming a monster feature. we need to keep it simple: for EPC conting active -> move all counting to the SMF+PGW-c. and even simplify the counting byut not requiring the separate PDU session/UE counting interactions (the only needed interaction is the indication of PDU session establishment or removal and the NSACF can manage a UE and PDU session count by considering the UE ID. then for case of no EPC counting we can do conting of sessions at SMF and Ue at AMF (if we do not want to just count sessions at SMF) - note I used SMF deliberately as the PGW-C part is unaffected. in short we need to keep this feature simple. George (Ericsson) comments. We will not have EPC IWK. Its as simple as that. We will remove the feature in its entirety George (Ericsson) provides r02, added a note and updated the service description George (Ericsson) provides a response Alessio(Nokia) well no really, we have CRs at this meeting that complete it (one is like yours but it is subscription based not config based). Fenqin (Huawei ) Comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Fenqin (Huawei ) Please note this CR per the comment below. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107112 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3239 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of 5GS Registration for Slices subject to NSAC in conjunction with home Routed PDU Sessions | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(nokia) In our opinion, like we indicate by subscription data which S-NSSAIs are subject to NSSAA, or which PDU sessions DNN can be handed over, we shall provide the indication of what s-NSSAI are subject to NSAC and which need EPC counting. this is imple and not subject to configuration negotiations. and dependencies on other operators to not do mistakes in configuring all their AMFs per S-NSSAI of HPLMN!!!!!!!!!!! Iskren (NEC) provides comment. AMF need to be made aware of which S-NSSAI is subject to NSAC in EPC. The AMF can not be configured for that. Alessio(Nokia) cannot agree with this approach in the CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107279 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3270 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on EPC interworking | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. See additional comments Iskren (NEC) proposes to note this CR. It does not work without a companion CR against TS23.502. Alessio(Nokia) cannot agree to approve this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107328 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3282 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC procedure for EPS | NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | George Foti (Ericsson) The CR is OK but there is small editorial to fix. 'SMF+PGW-C the SMF+PGW-C' is repeated twice Alessio(Nokia) this CR shows that our specification is flawed as when EPC counting is done the only thing we should worry about should be to report to NSACF that a new PDU session is added or one is removed from the slice. we should use this CR to implement this different way of doing things. of course once we agree to remove AMF based UE counting when EPC counting is active. George (Ericsson) comments . U ignore the fact that there cases where multiple NSACFs can be used; it called different service areas. U need to consider that for any proposal. That why what U are proposing does not work. alessio(Nokia) is not agreeing with george that we need different service areas for NSACF with EPC conting George (Ericsson), This is what the spec. says. Nothing to do with me. Kundan(NEC) responds to Alessio and provides v1 fixing the typo indicated by George. This NEC CR bringing a valid change based on the existing specification which states there is a separate request of no. of UE count and no. of PDUs count. It is valid change. Kundan(NEC) clarifies that the proposed CR follows the procedure captured in the specification. alessio(Nokia) replies ==== Revisions Deadline ==== alessio(Nokia) requests to postpone this CR as we need to have a complete review of how EPC interworking with EPS counting happens based on offline discussion on what the requirements are, and hopefully converge on an approach that does not require the type of adjustments identified here. Kundan (NEC) responds to Alessio. Alessio, As my CR is based on the current principle captured in the specification, kindly accept the CR in this meeting. If anything changes in next meeting then this CR will be dropped. Tao(VC) further check can we go with r01 in this meeting? alessio(Nokia) replies we can only postpone this CR Kundan(NEC) replies to Alessio. Alessio, I don't understand why you are saying an agreed CR cant be withdrawn or noted in next meeting. There is one more meeting before plenary meeting. If your proposal of single counting flies in next meeting then you can object this CR there. The status in that meeting will be changed to noted. I don't see any problem in that. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107329 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3283 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC procedure when multiple APNs associated with same S-NSSAI | NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Kundan(NEC) provides response to George. The CR is needed to reduce the unnecessary signaling between the AMF and NSCAF. George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Hoyeon (samsung) shares the view with Ericsson. Fenqin (Huawei) support the idea and propose to merge this paper into 7472. George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments. Can U please make it a note. It is obvious. There are also other CRs having the same clarification George (Ericsson) provides comment. All what we need is a note. Jinguo(ZTE) asks Fenqin (Huawei) Kundan (NEC) provides response to Hoyeon and George. George (Ericsson) comments Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Kundan(NEC)provides revision. Updated the CR based on Huawei CR S2-2107472 and added Huawei and HiSilicon as co-signing company. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments Alessio(Nokia) this is yet further evidence the current framework where the SMF/+PGW-C intereacts independently for UE counting and PDU session counting juis broken. a single NSACF should handle both based on the number of PDU session for a UE ID! can we use this CR to implement this simple way of doing things? (or another CR!) Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments Kundan(NEC) responds to Srisakul. Thanks Srisakul. I will modify according to your comment. Kundan(NEC) provides revision 2 to address Srisakul comments. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Kundan (NEC) is fine with r03. George (Ericsson) would like to postpone this CR for next meeting. The wording needs rework. George (Ericsson) proposes to note for the next meeting Hoyeon (Samsung) objects to the CR as the duplicated functionality is not needed. Alessio(Nokia) also requests to postpone to identify the requirement better. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107456 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3058R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.501 Correction to the NSAC to maintain service continuity | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of (Agreed) S2-2106661 from S2#146E (Postponed at SA#93E). Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. We already addressed all the cases. This just creates more confusion. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments. Iskren (NEC) answers comments by Hoyeon (Samsung). alessio (Nokia) objects to this CR as it has been rejected conceptually already at SA#93 Iskren (NEC) disagrees with Alessio (Nokia) as this CR has been return for disc to SA2 and the related issue is still open and is being discussed at this SA2 meeting ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) Please note the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107478 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2950R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.502 Correction to the NSAC to maintain service continuity | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of (Agreed) S2-2106662 from S2#146E (Postponed at SA#93E). Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Additional comments below. alessio(Nokia) as already stated for the related 23.501 CR: we object to this Cr also as it is against the principle of not creating exceptions to quota enforcement just because of mobility events. this has already been discussed at SA level also. Iskren (NEC) provides r01 where the service continuity required parameter is now per S-NSSAI. George (Ericsson) objects to r01 as this approach allows bypassing EPC counting and still getting service Continuity which has been rejected at SA#93. In addition there is no update to any counts, and as such more UEs than allowed will be able to access a slice. Iskren (NEC) disagrees with George (Ericsson) and clarifies that the counting is not impacted, it is still ON. George (Ericsson) comments. There are mail exchanges detailing the no counting proposed here and what it means, and why it is wrong Iskren (NEC) answers George (Ericsson) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Please note the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107472 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3307 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on NSAC for interworkign with EPS | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes. Please see additional comments Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments and asks a clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides responds. Iskren (NEC) comments that the CR does not work. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this CR. Alessio(Nokia) clarifies this CR in S2-2107726 that Kaisu handles resolves the LBO+non LBO mix issue and complements the CR in S2-2107678 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Please note the CR Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to note the CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107678 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3333 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC in presence of EPS counting | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Iskren (NEC) proposes to note the CR as it breaks the requirement for UE registrations with a network slice counting. Alessio(Nokia) replies ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments Please note the CR. Iskren (NEC) Please note this CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107735 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3347 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC for maximum number of PDU Sessions for EPC IWK | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Postponed | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR Iskren (NEC) comments alessio(Nokia) agrees with this CR and also remarks this is applicable only to the case of EPC counting active. George (Ericsson) comments. We will only agree to a note for such clarification. It is redundant. This info is already captured Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Iskren (NEC). Genadi (Lenovo) replies to George (Ericsson). Iskren (NEC) supports this CR and would like to co-sign. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r01 adding NEC as co-signer and a small clarification addition to better differentiate the paragraphs for NSAC for max. nr. of UEs and max. nr. of PDU Sessions. George (Ericsson) We would like to postpone this to next meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Iskren (NEC) suggests we agree this CR as there is nothing wrong with it. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Iskren (NEC). Do not see the reason why this CR should be postponed. CR fixes the case, which has not been described yet, and there is nothing wrong technically. Jinguo (ZTE) agrees to approve this CR George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson will not agree to the CR. It has to be made more generic from the way it is written right now. Too late for this meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107736 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3348 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF+PGW-C behaviour during UE mobility between 5GC and EPC | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | CC#2: This was postponed. | Alessio(nokia) by accident I thought I had sent a comment on this one but I found it not sent in my outbox. this CR also should be postponed. please add to CC#2 for discussion (I think we postponed the matching CR in 7735 for the same reason) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Early Admission Control | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107407 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3295 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.501_Update of the Early Admission Control mode | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107945 Revised to S2-2107945. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to George Foti, and provides r01. George (Ericsson) comments. Please replace as with is. Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to George Foti, and provides r02. George (Ericsson) accepts r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107945 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3295R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.501_Update of the Early Admission Control mode | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107407r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107409 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3172 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.502_Clarification on EAC Mode Threshold and the Pocedures | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107946 Revised to S2-2107946. | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Additional comments below Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to George Foti, and provides r01 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and agree with George to note this CR or if possible to merge it into S2-2107409. Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Srisakul with clarification Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r02, within comments from Srisakul, and keep align with 7427. George (Ericsson) I don't understand why we need this CR. Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to George (Ericsson) for clarification Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments. George (Ericsson) comments. Please fix this text: which may be same or different vs. with the activation threshold. Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to George and Srisakul, with r03 provided. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson can accept r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107946 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3172R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.502_Clarification on EAC Mode Threshold and the Pocedures | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107409r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107439 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3181 (Rel-17, 'F'): EAC mode status notification | CATT | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107947 Revised to S2-2107947. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Yunjing(CATT) provides r01 based on comments from George Foti (Ericsson). Jinguo(ZTE) comments George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments. Please elaborate on the internal logic. Ashok (Samsung) feel the CR is not needed Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments Ashok (Samsung) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) George (Ericsson) comments Ashok (Samsung) requests for clarification from Yunjing (CATT) Yunjing (CATT) replies to comments and provides r02. Ashok (Samsung) comments. Yunjing (CATT) replies to Ashok (Samsung) . George (Ericsson) asks a question. What if the NSACF supports multiple slice. This means a separate notification per slice ? Yunjing (CATT) replies to George (Ericsson) George (Ericsson) comments. Right now it is not. Are U proposing it to be changed Yunjing (CATT) provides r03 and r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) can accept r03 or r04 Ashok (Samsung) can accept r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107947 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3181R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): EAC mode status notification | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107439r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107440 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3182 (Rel-17, 'F'): Remove the Notification endpoint for EAC notification | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. This is way too much implementation and can't be verified. May be stage 3 can add these details Kaisu (Nokia) also proposes to note the CR and to consider such details in stage 3. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Yunjing(CATT) accepts to consider the issue in stage 3. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107703 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3213 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on NSAC procedure | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR, and merge it in 7122. Please see additional comments George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Heng (China Telecom) provide clarification and propose it be specified. George (Ericsson) comments Kaisu (Nokia) thinks this clarification is not required. Heng (China Telecom) agrees to leave this scenario for stage 3 consideration. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107708 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3214 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on EACNotify service | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Noted | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR and provides comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Access Type | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107226 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3261 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC clarification | Samsung | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107948. CC#2: Postponed and the revision allocated in S2-2107948 was withdrawn. Revised to S2-2107948. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to George Foti (Ericsson). Yunjing (CATT) provides questions for clarification. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments. Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments. George (Ericsson) provides comment. Actually I am now also questioning the need to configure the AMF. This can be optimization of course. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides responses. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r01. George (Ericsson) comments Hoyeon (Samsung) provides response. George (Ericsson) comments. Now I understand what U are saying. Please see additional comments below Hoyeon (Samsung) provides a response. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r02 for clean-up. Kaisu (Nokia) has the same view as Lenovo that the AMF does not need to be aware of NSACF counting policy wrt AT. We propose to note the CR. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question to Kaisu (Nokia). George (Ericsson) comments. I think the NSACF can safely return success without increasing the count if the access type is not subject to admission. The logic of both AMFs and NSCACF is correct as long as we capture this I the procedure itself in 23.502 and we need to check. This would work even in case U choose to have the info configured in AMF or not. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r03 implementing the concept that the NSACF sends the AT in the reject message to the AMF. George (Ericsson) provides r04. Minor linguistic changes. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r03/r04. Genadi (Lenovo) is OK with r03/r04 and addition by Hoyeon (Samsung). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107948 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3261R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC clarification | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107226r04. CC#2: WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107277 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3154 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Access Type for NSAC | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question for clarification. Jinguo (ZTE) reponse to both Hoyeon(Ericsson) and George(Ericsson) Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Hoyeon (Samsung). Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments. George (Ericsson) comment. I am not disagreeing with the requirement. The NSACF logic is changing anyways so why don't we do it cleanly, correctly and make update parameter optional, so it is only used in case there is a change to an existing session. Jinguo, U are already changing the logic I don't understand Ur arguments. This is more optimized. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to keep the discussion in 7278. 7277 is simple CR to add possibility to update the access type in NSACF ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) proposes to note this CR Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to approve r00 George (Ericsson) Objects to the original revision. This requires NSACF to check on every request and see if there is a match, then decide if it is an update of some info in the existing session such as access type and then ignore the update attribute, or act on the update attribute. Too much additional logic not to mention inefficiency, where we are introducing optimization everywhere else. I offered an approach. Jinguo(ZTE) clarifies that there is no new logic in NSACF. George (Ericsson) comments. The spec has the following NOTE 2 SMFs handling PDU sessions associated with UE Request Type 'Existing PDU Session' for handover purposes do not interact with the NSACF. This does not align with what U state Jinguo(ZTE) comments. The consequence of the NOTE2 is that the NSACF has no knowledge of the target Access type after inter access mobility which makes the Access Type in the NSACF useless. George (Ericsson) comments. We will have to postpone this to make sure everything is well defined. I can't accept any revision including the original. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107278 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3269 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Access Type for NSAC | ZTE | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107949 Revised to S2-2107949. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments and questions for clarification. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments. Fenqin (Huawei) ask a question for clarification Jinguo(ZTE) response and provide r01. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02 to remove the first NOTE George (Ericsson) OK with r02 Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question for clarification and provides r03. Jinguo(ZTE) reply and prefer r02 Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Jinguo Yunjing (CATT) asks a question for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) replies George (Ericsson) asks a question. R02 is OK. For me the NSACF increases one access type count only . Does it matter which one. What difference will it make. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r04. Lets further discuss which one is better. George (Ericsson) comments. What does that really mean. Every time user plane is changed the SMF updates the access type. Can U please reword to clarify the intent Jinguo (ZTE) provides r05 George (Ericsson) comments. We are Ok with this revision Ashok (Samsung) comments George (Ericsson) comments. These are product engineering decisions; nothing to do with a standard. I don't see any confusion. The NSACF deletes it and reduces the count. There is no confusion; the NSACF logic should be aware by design of this if it support MAPDU. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to go with r02. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Hoyeon (Samsung) can accept r05 ONLY IF reason for change is updated accordingly. We provides r06 in draft folder. Jinguo(ZTE) is fine with r06 Hoyeon (Samsung) can only accept r05 with updating 'reason for change' which is r06 in the draft folder, and objects to the other revisions. Proposes to open the CR in the CC. George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson accepts R05 or R06. Objects to all other revisions. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Tao(VC) Let's check r05 with updated reason for change agreeable or not? ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107949 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3269R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Access Type for NSAC | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107278r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107268 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3151 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE-Slice-MBR enforcement during SSC mode 3 operation | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and comments. Dongeun (Samsung) tries to clarify and provides r01. Dongeun (Samsung) further clarifies Jinguo (ZTE) comments Dongeu (Samsung) clarifies and asks questions. Alessio(nokia) believes this CR is not necessary and not certainly FASMO Dongeu (Samsung) clarifies. Alessio(Nokia) repeats in this thread this is not CAT-F but a CT-B as this is not a serious issue as there is no simultaneous transmission of data and the case where GBR admission control fails due to SSC mode being active for the slice is a remote corner case that we should only consider in a future study as a refinement. Dongeun (Samsung) responses to Alessio(Nokia). Belen (Ericsson) objects to initial revision and r01. Dongeun (Samsung) replies to Belen (Ericssion) ? Alessio(Nokia) comments and reconfirms objection as this is CAT B not CAT F. ? ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dongeun (Samsung) responses and proposes to postpone the CR. ? ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107269 | DISCUSSION | Information | Discussion on UE-Slice-MBR enforcement during SSC mode 3 operation. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(nokia) believes the related CR CR is not necessary and not certainly FASMO and this paper can be NOTED ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107079 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4, CT WG3: LS on Clarification on Nnsacf_SliceStatus and Nnef_SliceStatus services | CT WG4, CT WG3 (C3-214481) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107113 and S2-2107505. Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107113 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification on Nnsacf_SliceStatus and Nnef_SliceStatus services | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107079. Merged into S2-2107950 | Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to merge this LS into S2-2107505. George (Ericsson) we need to agree on a CR first Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to merge this LS into S2-2107505 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2107505 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on Clarification on Nnsacf_SliceEventExposure and Nnef_SliceStatus services | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107079. r01 removing attachment agreed. Revised to S2-2107950, merging S2-2107113 Revised to S2-2107950. | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 to add correct CR number Ashok (Samsung) responds to Jinguo (ZTE) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 (on top of r01) in the CC2 folder, request for CC#2 due to the attachment is noted this meeting Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 (on top of r01) in the CC2 folder, request for CC#2 due to the attachment of the LS is noted this meeting George (Ericsson) looks fine to me as well | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107950 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on Clarification on Nnsacf_SliceEventExposure and Nnef_SliceStatus services | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107505r01 removing attachment, merging S2-2107113. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107114 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3128 (Rel-17, 'F'): Using Immediate reply in conjunction with NSACF related events | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) provides comments. George (Ericsson) comments Fenqin (Huawei) comments Jinguo(ZTE) comments and provides r01. George (Ericsson) provide comments George (Ericsson) provides r02 Jinguo (ZTE) comments on r02 George (Ericsson) provides r03 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments. George (Ericsson) provides r05 based on r03 to take care of the repeated step 6. Please see additional comments inline. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r06 Dan (China Mobile) provide r07 Kaisu (Nokia) provides r08 Jinguo(ZTE) provides r09 Jinguo(ZTE) provides r10 since r09 is broken. George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions except r04. Please see comments that have not been addressed. Also the notion of mapping a civic address to a service area by the NEF is unacceptable. This is not PSAP where we have a mega database holding mapping between a PSTN number and a civic address. The input to the NRD gas to be the service are. Read below,. George (Ericsson) A correction objects to all revisions except r05.. Please see comments that have not been addressed. Also the notion of mapping a civic address to a service area by the NEF is unacceptable. This is not PSAP where we have a mega database holding mapping between a PSTN number and a civic address. The input to the NRD gas to be the service are. Read below,. George (Ericsson) provides r11 updating with the latest changes excluding service areas related changes Kaisu (Nokia)comments that rev11 includes errors, thus we object to it. George (Ericsson) provides r12. The problem is that Nokia is only interested in a single node case, trying to jam that in the aggregation procedure. U could have written a separate singe case procedure. Right ?. I did try to accommodate a single case, but really Nokia should write that procedure separately. That is a choice.. The title for this case is clear. Dan (China Mobile) provides r13 based on r10. George (Ericsson) objects to r13. Adding comments Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments and cannot agree to all earlier revisions as the S-NSSAI should not be exposed to outside for the case of non-trusted AF in particular. Also non-trusted AF does not know about S-NSSAI anyway. Provide r14 based on r12 and provide r15 based on r13. Dan (China Mobile) reply George (Ericsson) comments. Given that there are competing interests I showed the roadmap to follow. Please see inline Dan (China Mobile) provide r16 to reflect the AF can provide serivce are based on local configuration. George (Ericsson) comments. What is AF-Service-identifiers. Where is that defined Iskren (NEC) expresses concern with this CR and suggest the reports combining from multiple NSACF by the NEF part is left for the next release. Ashok (Samsung) shares same view as Iskren (NEC) George (Ericsson) immediate reporting has to replace the Req/Resp in this Release. The Service Area can be postponed. The rest is trivial and straight forward. Jinguo (ZTE) response to Iskren (NEC) and Ashok(Samsung) Dan(China Mobile) provide r17 based on R13 Dan(China Mobile) provide r18 based on R17 with a NOTE ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson would accept R12. Ericsson would technically endorse R12, or R17 as a basis for further enhancements. Linguistic cleanup needed, and some steps needs some additional refinement. Tao(VC) latest version is R18. Does r18 agreeable or not? George (Ericsson) R18 Not agreeable. Tao(VC) Let's use R17 for the target possible agreeable version to check Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) objects to r17 due to the reason that the non-trusted AF cannot and should not be able to provide the S-NSSAI to the NEF. So there is a technical issue here. OK with r14 or r15. Also fine to postpone this to next meeting. Dan(China Mobile) suggest to go with r15 Dan(China Mobile) take it back about the previous email and suggest to go with r16.For Srisakul,please check whether r16 is ok. Tao (VC) let's check R12 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) cannot accept R12, as it has the same technical issue on non-Trusted AF providing S-NSSAI to NEF. R14, R15 and R16 do not have this issue. So R16 seems OK. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to go with R12 George (Ericsson) comments. This use of service identifier as a replacement of a S-NSSAI copying other cases makes no sense unless it is completely specified. In the existing spec, it refers to an Application identifier. So this use has to be well specified before I can agree to it. George (Ericsson) objects to R12 Iskren (NEC) - combining many things in this CR was not a good idea. Let's postpone it for the next meeting. George (Ericsson) comments. Correction Ericsson accepts R12 . . Fenqin (Huawei) comments. George (Ericsson) comments. We can easily add it is pre-provisioned by offline means. As Fenqin stated , S-NSSAI ate negotiated and on contract so they are not private info. Kaisu (Nokia) comments. We can live with Rev 12, if we remove the part 'and maintain the overall usage of the S-NSSAI for the entire PLMN' Tao(VC) further check can we try to go with r12, with the clarifications. George (Ericsson) We agreed we need to incorporate one NSAC vs an entire PLMN. We can add to Rev 12. a simple EN: The handling of notifications retuned to an AF in case of one NSACF vs multiple NSCAFs requiring aggregation is FFS. I will update the CR for the next mtg clearly to handle this as well as all issues I send an email about before; Patrice (Huawei) corrects some statements regarding so-called 'non-trusted AF'. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Fenqin's comment. George (Ericsson) comments.; This was intended to be an application identifier. Most AFs are the application owners hence they have this info. The network does not care about such an identifier. It uses it locate record. That said, U can use this, but U need to specify how does the AF get it, how does the NEF get it, how does it map. U can't just copy this from a completely different context, where it is well defined, and ask us to fill in the blank for a new usage that is undefined. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) objects to r12 or postpone r12 to next meeting. There is no hurry to agree on this. Current procedure always assume that any AFs (trusted AF or untrusted AF) is always possible to send S-NSSAI, which needs to be clarified that it is really the case. Ashok (Samsung) comments ==== Comments Deadline ==== Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Patrice (Huawei). Fenqin (Huawei) responds. | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107473 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3187 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC and exposure service | Huawei, HiSilicon, | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107951 Revised to S2-2107951. | George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments Dan (China Mobile) provides comments for this paper Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments George (Ericsson) provides comments. We are not Ok with any service area discussion at this point. I stated it is redundant. On the new dedicated service, I heard no objection except from U. Dan(China Mobile) provides comments. Ashok (Samsung) comments. George (Ericsson) comments Dan (China Mobile) comments Ashok (Samsung) responds to George (Ericsson) Fenqin (Huawei) responds to Ashok (Samsung) Jinguo (ZTE) comments and provides r01. Jinguo(ZTE) comments George (Ericsson) comments. We won't agree to any additions to this in Release 17. Fenqin(Huawei) provides r02 George (Ericsson) comments. This text to me is unrelated to the order of things. It simply stores the result in case the UE requests the slice again, the AMF has the result and does not need to redo the authorization. Please correct me if I am wrong. There is a grammar mistake in r2. The AMF stores Fenqin(Huawei) provides r03 Ashok (Samsung) responds to Fenqin(Huawei) Fenqin(Huawei) responds to Ashok (Samsung) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson is OK with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107951 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3187R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC and exposure service | Huawei, HiSilicon, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107473r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107109 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3127 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of Exposure in mutiple NSACFs Deployments | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107114 (Noted) | George Foti (Ericsson) provides Clarification comments Fenqin (Huawei) comments Dan (China Mobile) suggest this paper merged into S2-2107473 and we can have one thread for discussion George Foti (Ericsson) provides comments. Kaisu (Nokia) provides a comment and asks if we need aggregation functionality in release 17? George (Ericsson) provides Jinguo (ZTE) comments and suggest to merge 7109 into revision of 7114 or 7473 Dan (China Mobile) comments Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments that non-trusted AF cannot provide S-NSSAI. So cannot accept this CR. Anyway, let's continue discussion in 7114, as this CR is merged in 7114. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107221 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3143 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network slice status notifications when multiple NSACFs exist for one S-NSSAI | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Dan (China Mobile) response to George(Ericsson) and provide r01 George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Please see comments George Foti (Ericsson) provides a comment. This is a new requirement to identify a service area as an input. U can do off line processing and extract the service area of interest if U need so there is a way to get the info without needing to support anything new. Finally as I said U did not update the description to reflect that. So this is incomplete. We also need to understand how that service area is identified. SO we this as redundant. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Dan(China Mobile) reply to Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) Kaisu (Nokia) agrees that the use case of retrieving information (via NEF) from a regional NSACF should be supported in rel-17. George (Ericsson) comments. Ericsson will object to aggregation use case if this one is not removed. We have an LS from CT4/CT3 that this is not needed, and can be replaced by immediate reply flag. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to merge 7221 into revision of 7114 Dan(China Mobile) comments and point that this proposal has valid requirement Dan(China Mobile) provide r02 Kaisu(Nokia) asks again, what is the use case which requires aggregation of info from multiple NSACFs. If there is no clear requirement, then we propose not to include aggregation in release 17. Dan(China Mobile) response to Kaisu(Nokia) Kaisu (Nokia) responds to George. Kaisu (Nokia) sees no technical showstopper to use an 'area of interest' configuration for the aggregated report. George (Ericsson) comments. At which point in time do we stop introducing new requirements. AT this meeting I can't accept that. When we agree to what I provided in 7114 r03 then at the next meeting someone can propose a complete solution using area of interest. It is not a simple change as being advocated, but it is doable not on the fly via an email as being proposed. We have to have a stable base. Kaisu (Nokia) provides S2-2107114r04. George (Ericsson) Ericsson objects to r04, and provide comments. There has been request by Alessio to get rid of service area. So please clarify what is the official view here. This revision recognized service area opposite to what has been expressed before in the context of the discussion on EPC interworking, and where Nokia requested we dump service area. Please see additional comments Jinguo(ZTE) clarifies the r04 provided by Kaisu is for 7114, not 7221 Dan(China Mobile) clarifies the r04 provided by Kaisu and objection from George are for 7114. Ashok (Samsung) comments Dan (China Mobile) reply George (Ericsson) comments. 7221 has to be noted. The main discussion is in 7114. Dan (China Mobile) whether this paper is noted or merged to 7114 is under discussion in 7114. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) please note this CR Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) as mentioned in 7114, we should make clear whether it is trusted AF or non-trusted AF to provide S-NSSAI. In our view, it can be only trusted AF to provide S-NSSAI. Let's postpone it and work together for cleaning up this aspect in the next meeting. George (Ericsson) comments. The issue about providing S-NSSAI by a non-trusted S-NSSAI is not a major issue. I did state that the procedure in 7114 was for trusted anyway. If any trusted AF is interested it would have to be provisioned with this info by off line means and we can state that explicitly. This is done so many times, What is the problem. This is the least issue in this procedure. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) comments. The problem of the providing S-NSSAI by a non-trusted AF is an issue. Nowhere in the spec mentions that non-trusted AF is able to provide S-NSSAI to NEF. We had made a mistake when accepting this procedure. But this does not mean that we should make the same mistake again by adding more new texts that are not supported. We have postponed many CRs in this meeting, so I do not see an issue if this one can also be postponed as well. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2107222 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3259 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network slice status notifications when multiple NSACFs exist for one S-NSSAI | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) reply to George(Ericsson) and provide r01 George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR. Please see comments on 7221. George Foti (Ericsson) does not agree. AS stated U with off line processing U extract the info of interest only. This is redundant. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Dan(China Mobile) provides response. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== George (Ericsson) comments. Please note the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107410 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3173 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS23.502_Update of the Monitoring Event Description | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107709 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3215 (Rel-17, 'F'): Threshold reporting mode | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | KI#5 | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107509 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0663 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction for PCF based monitoring of the data rate per network slice | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Dongeun (Samsung) asks for clarifications. Jinguo (ZTE) comments Alessio(Nokia) comments that this is not a CAT-F Cr but a CAT B CR that we cannot accept after the freeze of the release. Alessio (Nokia) repeats in this thread we see this is not a CAT F but a CAT B and cannot agree with it. Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments. alessio(Nokia) comments this is not a CAT F.. for CAT B we need a future work item proposal. Belen (Ericsson) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) withdraws previous comments, and supports the initial version. alessio(nokia) comments that it is not true there is no limit! the MBR>=GBR right? if so then deducting MBR is implicitly hitting the constraints on GBR at same time or earlier than deducting GBR alone for the total quota. so really we see no issue. we retain the objection Mirko (Huawei) responds to Alessio's comment. Jinguo(ZTE) comments Mirko (Huawei) responds to Jinguo's comment. Jinguo (ZTE) replies to Mirko(Huawei) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dongeun (Samsung) comments. Mirko (Huawei) responds to Dongeun's comment. Alessio(Nokia) confirms objection to the CR and any revision thereof. Alessio(nokia) does not agree that the current text assumes all GBR flows are always accepted! the CR shall be noted . ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107111 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0652 (Rel-17, 'F'): Selection of the PCF for network slice related policy control | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107952 Revised to S2-2107952. | Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification Belen (Ericsson) replies to Haiyang. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r01 Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept r01. Alessio(Nokia) proposes this is POSTPONED and more discussion till the next meeting is encouraged Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia comments, Haiyang (Huawei) asks further questions Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107952 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0652R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Selection of the PCF for network slice related policy control | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107111r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | KI#6 | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107330 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3205R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to NSSRG procedure | NEC, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia, Apple, Convida Wireless, Samsung, InterDigital, Cisco, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2106384 from S2#146E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107953 Revised to S2-2107953. | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Patrice (Huawei) provides r02 correcting the note and terminology. Kundan(NEC) indicates that both v1 and v2 are fine but prefer original CR submitted as it has more details in NOTE for stage 3 how to implement the requirement in normative work. NOTE in original CR gives clear guidance. Ashok (Samsung) is fine with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter (Ericsson) Ok with r02 alessio(Nokia) Ok with r02 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107953 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3205R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to NSSRG procedure | NEC, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia, Apple, Convida Wireless, Samsung, InterDigital, Cisco, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107330r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107438 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3300 (Rel-17, 'F'): The decision of target NSSAI based on NSSRG | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107954 Revised to S2-2107954. | George Foti (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR or at most to add a reference to the section describing the NSSRG for consideration by the AMF. No need to describe everything one more time Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 based on comments from George Foti (Ericsson) alessio(Nokia) provides r02 Patrice (Huawei) has questions for clarification. Yunjing(CATT) replies to Patrice (Huawei). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== alessio(Nokia) does not agree we can use a note to solve a FASMO. cannot accept R03 and can only live with r02. if the note is preferred then we should do nothing as this has no normative outcomes which I guess was the intention by CATT. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107954 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3300R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): The decision of target NSSAI based on NSSRG | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107438r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107667 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3331 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on definition of NSSRG | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107955 Revised to S2-2107955. | Patrice (Huawei) proposes r01 correcting the terminology. alessio(Nokia)can live with CR revision 1 but would prefer original Ashok (Samsung) is fine with both r01 and original version Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and do not see the need for the CR r00 or r01, but can accept r02 alessio (Nokia) can live with r02 also. Patrice (Huawei) provides r03, can also accept r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r03 Alessio(Nokia) can live with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2107955 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3331R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on definition of NSSRG | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107667r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | KI#7 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107147 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3249 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment with RAN conclusion on providing Configured NSSAI to the RAN | Convida Wireless LLC, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Orange, Verizon | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and objects to the CR Mike (Convida Wireless) replies. Susan (Huawei) objects to this CR. Genadi (Lenovo) comments. Iskren (NEC) comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply Dongeun (Samsung) has same view with Ericsson alessio(Nokia) replies alessio(nokia) it is up to the ran to select the optimal RFSP. the CN points out the RFSP for configured and for Allowed then the RAN decides what is best to do based on status Dongeun (Samsung) propose to note the CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to the CR with reasons as expressed before ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107286 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3271 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of two Editor Notes for eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) cannot agree to approve this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107679 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | On providing the Configured NSSAI to the RAN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Orange, Convida Wireless LLC | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments Alessio(NoKia) comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply Alessio(Nokia) replies Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments alessio(nokia) explains to Peter Dongeun(Samsung) cannot agree on providing the Configured NSSAI to the RAN proposes to note this. alessio (nokia) points out this is not a redirection mechanism as samsung implies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) comments Alessio(Nokia) provides again the rationale (hoping this is finally understood) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2107290 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3273 (Rel-17, 'F'): Target-NSSAI during Service Request and Handovers | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) cannot agree to approve this CR as it is not FASMO and is certainly not CAT-F (rather CAT-B) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia that the CR is proposing new functionality, proposes to note the CR Dongeun (Samsung) responses to Nokia and Ericsson. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Jinguo(ZTE) provides comments and propose to note this CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Document exceeding quota | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107120 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3129 (Rel-17, 'F'): Rejected NSSAI for NSAC | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2107122 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3130 (Rel-17, 'F'): Relation between NSAC and NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | Jinhua(Xiaomi) provides r01 to clarify the action timing. Dongeun (Samsung) prefers the original version. George (Ericsson) comments. I think the original is sufficiently clear. I hope U can live with it. Alessio(nokia) comments this is a document exceeding quota. cannot be handled ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | - |
| 8.4 | S2-2107110 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3238 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC for priority services | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | Enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (IIoT) | - | - | Docs:=61 | - | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | Mega Editorial CRs (Not counted towards quota) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107304 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3276 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108123 Revised to S2-2108123. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108123 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3276R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107304r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107305 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3158 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Clauses affected missing. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108124 Revised to S2-2108124. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01, removes non-inclusive/inclusive terms related change and adds other editorial changes. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00/r01 as-is but would be ok to approve r01 if the change to Annex F.3 is removed Devaki (Nokia) comments that the change to Annex F.3 in r01 was an oversight, requests approval of r01 minus Annex F.3. Devaki (Nokia) uploaded this as r02 (= r01 minus Annex) for approval in the CC#1b folder. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108124 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3158R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Rapporteur CR for editorial fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107305r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107007 | LS In | Action | LS from IEEE: RE: LS on Time Synchronization | IEEE (reply to 3GPP liaison time sync) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105362 from S2#146E. Responses drafted in S2-2107135 and S2-2107299. Final response in S2-2108125 | Replied to | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107135 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply Time Synchronization | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107007. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108125 Revised to S2-2108125. | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, changes are along the lines of the updated CR in document 7134. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108125 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Time Synchronization | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107135r01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107000 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on Time Synchronization assistance parameters | RAN WG2 (R2-2106560) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105273 from S2#146E. Noted | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to note the LS, we already address the related issues last meeting, no more actions required Devaki (Nokia) agrees that the LS can be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs | - | - | Docs:=53 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107130 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3242 (Rel-17, 'F'): Improved PTP instance configuration management | Intel, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108126 Revised to S2-2108126. | Devaki (Nokia) proposes that this CR and 7515 should be merged (aligned with CT1 outcome), which one is used as the basis, leave it up to the authors to determine. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Nokia and ZTE. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00 but proposes a way forward for a potential r01 Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Sebastian (Qualcomm) for a potential r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Saso (Intel) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. Saso (Intel) replies to Zhendong. zhendong (ZTE) ask further question. Saso (Intel) provides further reply to Zhendong. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Saso (Intel) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108126 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3242R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Improved PTP instance configuration management | Intel, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107130r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107131 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3243 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of the TSCTSF functionality description | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107132 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3131 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updating the description of UE-DS-TT Residence Time delivery to the PCF | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) replies Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r03. (Please ignore r02.) György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Yuan Tao (CATT) provides r05. György (Ericsson) provides r06. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r07 Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to postpone this CR given the discussion under S2-2107418 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) wonders why this CR should be postponed due to 7418? We have worked hard to progress content within 7418 as well. Devaki (Nokia) realizes that the comment is related to TSCTSF discovery part in 7418? György (Ericsson) proposes to go ahead with r07 Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to postpone to allow more time for study. Object to any revisions for records. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107133 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | IEEE 1588 compatibility between editions and support for SMPTE profile | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107134 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3244 (Rel-17, 'F'): Revisions related Time Synchronization | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108127 Revised to S2-2108127. | Shabnam (Ericsson) based on offline comments from DoCoMo, Nokia and Qualcomm, r01 provided clarifying that 3GPP does not support common management. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108127 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3244R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Revisions related Time Synchronization | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107134r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107136 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3245 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on TSN AF and TSCTSF parameter handling | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108128 Revised to S2-2108128. | Haiyang(Huawei) provides r01. György (Ericsson) ok with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108128 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3245R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on TSN AF and TSCTSF parameter handling | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107136r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107223 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3260 (Rel-17, 'F'): Link delay measurement for the end-to-end Transparent Clock | Tencent | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108129 Revised to S2-2108129. | Chunshan (Tencent) questions to the r01. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r04 Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r04. Devaki (Nokia) comments that we are also ok with r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks Tencent to correct the cover page and replace Annex C with H.4, as we believe that is the correct reference for TSC, otherwise the r04 technical content is ok. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108129 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3260R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Link delay measurement for the end-to-end Transparent Clock | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107223r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107300 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3275 (Rel-17, 'F'): Time synchronization - description review | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108130 Revised to S2-2108130. | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, removing the new note since CR in revision of 7134 covers the actual aspect. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108130 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3275R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Time synchronization - description review | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107300r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107301 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3156 (Rel-17, 'D'): Time synchronization - procedure review | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108131, merging S2-2107339 and S2-2107662 Revised to S2-2108131. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01, merges proposal in 7662 and 7339, adds ZTE, CATT as cosigning companies. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and r02 György (Ericsson) asks a question. Devaki (Nokia) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) comments that the CR CAT has to be changed to CAT F as it includes technical corrections. (sorry, current category was a copy/paste error). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108131 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3156R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Time synchronization - procedure review | Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107301r02, merging S2-2107339 and S2-2107662. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107302 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3157 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alternative QoS and TSC fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108132 Revised to S2-2108132. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question Devaki (Nokia) responds to Qualcomm. György (Ericsson) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108132 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3157R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alternative QoS and TSC fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107302r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107303 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0658 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alternative QoS and TSC fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108133 Revised to S2-2108133. | György (Ericsson) provides r01. Mirko (Huawei) provides comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02 as a compromise (although prefer r01). Mirko (Huawei) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== György (Ericsson) prefers r01, but we could live with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108133 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0658R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alternative QoS and TSC fixes | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107303r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107338 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3164 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Updates on TSCTSF discovery and selection | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108134 Revised to S2-2108134. | Qianghua (Huawei) comments Yuan Tao (CATT) replies. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this CR as merged with the CR in S2-2107132. Yuan Tao (CATT) replies to Qianghua (Huawei). György (Ericsson) proposes to consider parts of this CR merged into 7132. Provides r01. Yuan Tao (CATT) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108134 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3164R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Updates on TSCTSF discovery and selection | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107338r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107339 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3165 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Updates on time sync service | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108131 | Qianghua (Huawei) comments Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this CR merged with 7301 as discussed with the authors offline already, will provide a revision for 7301. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Yuan Tao (CATT) replies to Qianghua (Huawei). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) agrees to mark this merged into 7301 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2107340 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3285 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Clarify the interaction between AF and TSCTSF | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108135 Revised to S2-2108135. | Yuan Tao (CATT) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108135 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3285R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Clarify the interaction between AF and TSCTSF | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107340r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107343 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3286 (Rel-17, 'F'): Time Synchronization of the 5GS as IEEE 1588 Boundary Clock | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR Chunshan (Tencent)provides clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to the CR as the changes are not technically correct as per our understanding, comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) also objects to the CR Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02 and clarification on why the CR is needed. Shabnam (Ericsson) also objects to r02, cannot accept any version at this point and provides comments. Chunshan (Tencent) points out that the current text in the NOTE 3 is aligned with 802.1AS but does not align with the Boundary Clock as defined in IEEE 1588. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2107348 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3113R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Principle for Handling of PMIC exchange with UE(s) in idle mode | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105945 from S2#146E. Noted | György (Ericsson) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR for the reasons given Ericsson Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Sabestian and György (Ericsson). György (Ericsson) responds and objects to the CR. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to György (Ericsson). György (Ericsson) responds to Samsung Sang-Jun (Samsung) responds György (Ericsson). György (Ericsson) responds to Samsung. Sang-Jun (Samsung) responds to György (Ericsson). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2107353 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3014R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure for Handling of PMIC exchange with UE(s) in idle mode | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105946 from S2#146E. Noted | György (Ericsson) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR for the same reason as given for 7348 Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm) and György (Ericsson). Haiyang (Huawei) thinks it is OK to have some update in 502 and suggests a way forward György (Ericsson) objects to the CR, don't think any text update is needed. Sang-Jun (Samsung) thanks Haiyang (Huawei) and replies to György (Ericsson). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2107355 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0660 (Rel-17, 'F'): Policy for Handling of PMIC exchange with UE(s) in idle mode | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108136 Revised to S2-2108136. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) replies Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) objects to r03, fine with r02. Prefers to go forward with r02. György (Ericsson) objects to r03 and r00. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Devaki (Nokia) and György (Ericsson). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) points out that this CR changes TSCTSF in wrong clause ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108136 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0660R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Policy for Handling of PMIC exchange with UE(s) in idle mode | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107355r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107357 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3289 (Rel-17, 'F'): Principle for Sync Exposure and Time Distribution | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) does not see the need of this CR. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Atsushi (NTT Docomo) and provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) does not see the need for the CR and proposes to note it zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, cannot accept r01 and r00 also needs some update. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Devaki (Nokia) comments that the current procedure does not allow the AF to trigger both (g)PtP time sync and 5G access stratum based timing distribution at the same time. Also wonders if this is a CAT D CR? Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02, and provides r03 to accept Devaki's comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) corrects an error in the previous mail. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) withdraws concern. Sang-Jun thanks Atsushi (NTT Docomo) and provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) comments that the CR is really not needed, also it is wrong as it introduces dangerous technical misalignment with 23.502 procedure for AF influenced time sync activation. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Devaki (Nokia) and confirms it aligns with 23.502 procedure for AF influenced time sync activation. Devaki (Nokia) re-iterates that the CR doesn't align with 23.502 - current procedure does not allow AF to use both at the same time (as network rejects the request) while the CR proposes the opposite. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Devaki (Nokia), and explains that the CR aligns with 23.502. Devaki (Nokia) objects to the CR and its revisions as it changes the technical intention (unwarranted), ok with the CR if it takes the text from 502 (referred text). Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Devaki (Nokia). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2107418 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3177 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications regarding TSCTSF discovery and selection | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) does not see the need of this CR. Yuan Tao (CATT) comments. György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) replies Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 György (Ericsson) provides r02 Devaki (Nokia) shares the same view as NTT Docomo/Atsushi-San and Jari. We don't see the need for the CR (option 1 or option 2). György (Ericsson) responds to Devaki Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with György Devaki (Nokia) still believes that deployments are not prohibited from deploying just a single TSCTSF and configuring a single instance in the consumer NFs (= local configuration) (option 2 is already allowed in the spec) but why it should be restricted to just that is my question? György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) replies Devaki (Nokia) comments that we wish to postpone this CR and continue the discussion related to multiple TSCTSF instances versus option 2 offline (as ongoing with Qianghua already) until SA2#148E. György (Ericsson) fine to postpone and continue discussing offline. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107515 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3312 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update for Time Synchronization Information in PMIC and UMIC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108137 Revised to S2-2108137. | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) agrees with Devaki's proposal. In addition, we believe removal of the portDS.portState from PMIC for DS-TT ports is not needed. 7617 explains how it's used. Devaki (Nokia) proposes that this CR and 7130 should be merged, which one is used as the basis, leave it up to the authors to determine. Haiyang(Huawei) provides r01 as a merger. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR Haiyang(Huawei) provides r02. Saso (Intel) supports r02 and co-signs. Atsushi (NTT DOCOMO) supports r02 and co-signs. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108137 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3312R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update for Time Synchronization Information in PMIC and UMIC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107515r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107516 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3313 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on TSCTSF selection and residence time calculation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108138 Revised to S2-2108138. | Qianghua (Huawei) replies and provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies György (Ericsson) provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. As commented for the related paper, I believe option 2 does not require any specification, one can directly use it for deployment but there is no need to restrict the specific and enforce this restriction for all deployments. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108138 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3313R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on TSCTSF selection and residence time calculation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107516r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107517 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on the use of DS-TT port MAC address. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107518 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3107R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for TSC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105929 from S2#146E. Consider with S2-2107519. r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108139 Revised to S2-2108139. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Mirko (Huawei) responds Shabnam (Ericsson) cannot accept complete redone of the specification of TSN and TSC work for 2 releases, we are ok to include the TSC Assistance Container and any editorial changes can be made on the rapporteur CR. Devaki (Nokia) shares similar views as Shabnam (Ericsson). Also, definition of TSC assistance container, especially BAT semantics in the CR is technically incorrect both in r00 and r01. Mirko (Huawei) responds and provides r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and objects to r02 Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03 to limit the changes and not revamp the specifications, reverted change of egress port, objects to r00-r02 for reasons mentioned earlier. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r04 Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments that additionally changes to 'ingress' need to be reverted Mirko (Huawei) responds and provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) appreciates the effort and due to conflict with other CR and need to have some time to sort this out. So, prefer to endorse r05 for further evaluation/work towards next meeting. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r03 and r04 (r04 still contains ingress/egress changes) and objects to r05 but would be ok with r05 if the term 'independently' is reinstated and the SDAP layer references are removed for now Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to r00 and r05 as conflict with other CR (see comment) and need to be resolved, proposes to endorse or bring to CC#2 removing the overlapped changes as well as Qualcomm proposed updates to r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Mirko (Huawei) is ok with endorsing the CR to address the overlaps with other CRs and to fine-tune the wording regarding the two issues raised by Sebastian. | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108139 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3107R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for TSC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107518r05. Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107519 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0634R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for TSC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105930 from S2#146E. Consider with S2-2107518. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108140 Revised to S2-2108140. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and also asks for clarification on handling overlap with Nokia CR in 7303. The CR needs to be revised depending on the conclusion we reach. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. I also believe the 501/3 CRs are agreeable mainly as a package, since we are deleting essential functional description in 503 to move to 501, they must be approved together. Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments. Mirko (Huawei) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification Mirko (Huawei) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108140 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0634R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for TSC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107519r03. CC#2: Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107363 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3167 (Rel-17, 'F'): Addition of time synchronization service parameters | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shangai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | György (Ericsson) comments Devaki (Nokia) comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments to Gyorgy. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107615 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Initialization of PTP instances . | NTT DOCOMO, Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107616 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3321 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multiple TSCTSFs associated with a single UPF | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108141 Revised to S2-2108141. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) provides r02 mainly reformulation of text to reflect the intention better, cosigns this version. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) is fine with r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108141 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3321R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multiple TSCTSFs associated with a single UPF | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107616r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107617 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3322 (Rel-17, 'F'): Processing (g)PTP messages for domain numbers and while in Disabled state | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question for clarification Chunshan (Tencent) try to provide the clarification. Saso (Intel) provides r02 on top of r00 and co-signs. Replies to Chunshan (Tencent). Chunshan (Tencent) replies to Saso (Intel). Chunshan (Tencent) provides r03. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) suggests to take r02 as the outcome of this meeting. Chunshan (Tencent) suggests to take r03 as the outcome of this meeting. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r04. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comemnts. Saso (Intel) objects to r04; can live with r03. Chunshan (Tencent) agrees with Saso (Intel) that r04 is incorrect. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haiyang (Huawei) shows concern on r03 and seeks for clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) accepts r03 and r04. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments, Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Atsushi (NTT Docomo). Atsushi (NTT Docomo) responses to Chunshan (Tencent). zhendong (ZTE) respond to Atsushi. Haiyang (Huawei) also agrees to postpone this paper. Devaki (Nokia) can only accept original version or r02 from this meeting, objects to r01, r03, r04. Ok to continue the discussion. Saso (Intel) agrees to POSTPONE the document. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107660 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion and proposal on the EN on the priority in the AF session with required QoS procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments, prefers alt1, objects alt3 zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) this is DP, I think this should be noted (object for records) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2107661 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3208 (Rel-17, 'F'): Fix the EN on the priority in the AF session with required QoS procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to note the CR or merge into S2-2107418 zhendong (ZTE) prefer to keep it seperately. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. György (Ericsson) proposes to consider this document merged into 7132. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 but prefer to merge if S2-2107418 can be agreed. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) also proposes to merge this with 7132 (in which 7302 was merged and that handled priority as well) and progress along with 7132. György (Ericsson) proposes to consider this merged into 7132, as long as that document can be agreed. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107662 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3209 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the Time Synchronization exposure procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108131 | zhendong (ZTE) this CR is merged into S2-2107301. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2107663 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3210 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the Setting up and update AF session with required QoS procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108142 Revised to S2-2108142. | Devaki (Nokia) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108142 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3210R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the Setting up and update AF session with required QoS procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107663r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.5 | S2-2107664 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3330 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the time synchronization | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge the paper with 7617. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) objects to r00 - r01 as it deletes the NEF option (commented regarding this earlier). First change must be re-instated, also new Master/Slave must be replaced with Leader/Follower. zhendong (ZTE) repsond to devaki. Devaki (Nokia) replies. zhendong (ZTE) agree with devaki clarification and propose to further revise the CR. zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 to draft folder. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments that Primary / Secondary terms should be changed to Leader / Follower zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 and ask for cc#2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2107766 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3352 (Rel-17, 'F'): Addressing Rel-17 DS-TT backwards incompatibility for time synchronization | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108143 Revised to S2-2108143. | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2108143 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3352R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Addressing Rel-17 DS-TT backwards incompatibility for time synchronization | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107766r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture Phase 2 (ATSSS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107144 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0654 (Rel-17, 'F'): Extending MA PDU Session Control information in the PCC Rule | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107828 Revised to S2-2107828. | Susan (Huawei): Provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02 and comments. Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Dario (Qualcomm) comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) suggest changes for agreeing the CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107828 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0654R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Extending MA PDU Session Control information in the PCC Rule | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107144r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107145 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3247 (Rel-17, 'F'): Access performance measurements applicability to QoS Flows | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Huawei | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107829 Revised to S2-2107829. | Dario S. Tonesi (Qualcomm) asks clarifications. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107829 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3247R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Access performance measurements applicability to QoS Flows | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107145r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107146 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3248 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to UE assistance operation | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107830 Revised to S2-2107830. | Apostolis (Lenovo) provides comments and r01 Stefan (Ericsson) is OK with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107830 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3248R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to UE assistance operation | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107146r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107148 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3250 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on threshold condition | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107831 Revised to S2-2107831. | Myungjune (LGE) replies to Rainer (Nokia) and Apostolis (Lenovo). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Apostolis (Lenovo) prefers r02 but can live with r01. Rainer (Nokia) prefers r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107831 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3250R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on threshold condition | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107148r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107448 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3302 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on PMF protocol stack for non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107450 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3304 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Clarification on threshold values | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Apostolis (Lenovo) suggests alternative wording. Rainer (Nokia) replies. Dario (Qualcomm) supports Apostolis' wording ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) suggests to postpone Rainer (Nokia) agrees with Stefan (Ericsson) to postpone. Hualin(Huawei) suggest to bring this paper to CC#3 for the minor change. Hualin (Huawei) propose to agree the original version. Rainer (Nokia) proposes to postpone to next meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.6 | S2-2107483 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3110R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): PMF information transported via N4 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105941 from S2#146E. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107832 Revised to S2-2107832. | Susan (Huawei) is ok to r02. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r03 Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Susan (Huawei) is ok to r03. Rainer (Nokia) is also ok with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107832 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3110R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): PMF information transported via N4 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107483r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107484 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3013R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): PMF information transported via N4 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105942 from S2#146E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107833 Revised to S2-2107833. | Susan (Huawei) is ok with r01. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02. Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Susan (Huawei) is ok with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107833 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3013R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): PMF information transported via N4 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107484r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2107706 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3338 (Rel-17, 'F'): Change term 'default QoS Flow' to 'the QoS Flow associated with default QoS rule' in TS 23.501 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107834 Revised to S2-2107834. | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Mirko (Huawei) provides comments. Rainer (Nokia) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2107834 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3338R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Change term 'default QoS Flow' to 'the QoS Flow associated with default QoS rule' in TS 23.501 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107706r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | - | - | - | Support of Aerial Systems Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (ID_UAS) | - | - | Docs:=52 | - | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107059 | LS In | Information | Reply LS on UAS terminology alignment | SA WG1 (S1-213256) | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2107149 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0001 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment for Service operations to support UAS | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107963 | Jaewoo (LGE) OK to merge this into S2-2107441. Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to merge this with S2-2107441 due to overlaps. Either version is valid as basis, though perhaps 7441 is more complete. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2107684 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0028 (Rel-17, 'F'): UAS architecture figure update for IWK | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107956 Revised to S2-2107956. | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications and reserves to note the paper Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to the CR, there is no interaction between MME and SCEF defined. Runze (Huawei) provides r01. Runze (Huawei) cannot accept r01. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano. Guanzhou (InterDigital) points out Stefano(Qualcomm) had wrong names in the header in his previous comments Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Runze. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano and provides r02. Runze (Huawei) indicates to the chair the previous comment from Qualcomm using the wrong name. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Runze and provides R03. Runze (Huawei) is fine with R03. Shabnam (Ericsson) ok with r03, comments that the NOTE numbering seems not correct and can be fixed editorially by the CR author on the final version before upload. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107956 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0028R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UAS architecture figure update for IWK | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107684r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107150 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0002 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification and EN resolution for SMF Services | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Noted | Pallab (Nokia) comments. Tricci (OPPO) believes this CR is correct and it should be NOTED. Jaewoo (LGE) provides comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) shares the understanding of Tricci. Shabnam (Ericsson) I think the CR is correct removing unnecessary status transfer. Jaewoo (LGE) provides comment. Tricci (OPPO) responds to Jaewoo (LGE) question. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Jaewoo (LGE) proposes to approve r00. Guanzhou (InterDigital) objects the CR. Jaewoo (LGE) asks a question to Guanzhou (InterDigital). Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Jaewoo (LGE). Jaewoo (LGE) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital). Jaewoo (LGE) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) and OK to NOTE the CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2107152 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3132 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on SM subscription data to support UAS | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Pallab (Nokia) agrees with comments Stefano (Qualcomm) Stefano (Qualcomm) has questions for clarification Jaewoo (LGE) provides comments. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Jaewoo (LGE) Jaewoo (LGE) thanks Pallab (Nokia) for clarification and provides comment. Pallab (Nokia) thanks Jaewoo (LGE) for the questions and provides Nokia view Jaewoo (LGE) thanks Pallab (Nokia) for the comment and provides r01. Jaewoo (LGE) responds to Pallab (Nokia) and asks a question for clarification. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) proposes to POSTPONE Jaewoo (LGE) responds to Pallab (Nokia) and can agree to postpone this CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2107320 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3280 (Rel-17, 'F'): UAS NF selection based on the NEF capability | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107151 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0003 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications for UUAA-SM procedure | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107957 Revised to S2-2107957. | Jaewoo (LGE) provides comment and suggests merge the Third change of 7443 to 7151 Guanglei (Huawei) provides comments and suggests merge 7151 to 7443. Jaewoo (LGE) replies Stefano (Qualcomm) and. Stefano (Qualcomm) has questions for clarification Guanglei (Huawei) agrees to merge the third change of 7443 to 7152. Jaewoo (LGE) provides r01. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments some changes are not needed Jaewoo (LGE) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) and asks a question. Jaewoo (LGE) provides r02. Pallab (Nokia) comments and provides r03 Jaewoo (LGE) provides comment on r03. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Jaewoo (LGE) Jaewoo (LGE) provides responds to Pallab (Nokia). Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r05 Jaewoo (LGE) OK with r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) OK with r05 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107957 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0003R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications for UUAA-SM procedure | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107151r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107166 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0004 (Rel-17, 'F'): UUAA during default PDN connection at Attach | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107958 Revised to S2-2107958. | Pallab (Nokia) comments and provided r01 Pallab (Nokia) now providing the r01 link Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments. Pallab (Nokia) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) accepts Nokia explanation and r01 is ok with us. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107958 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0004R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UUAA during default PDN connection at Attach | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107166r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107322 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0009 (Rel-17, 'F'): UUAA-MM Procedure Updates | Samsung | Rel-17 | CC#2: r10 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2108173 Revised to S2-2108173. | Tricci (OPPO) would like to respond to both Samsung and Qualcomm. Furthermore, OPPO would like to propose to merge Nokia's S2-2107588 into Samsung's S2-2107322. Ashok (Samsung) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm) Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides R01. Ashok (Samsung) clarifies to Tricci (OPPO) Pallab (Nokia) comments. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Ashok (Samsung) clarifications and provides further feedback. Ashok (Samsung) responds to Tricci (OPPO) Tricci (OPPO) thanks Pallab (Nokia) clarifications and provides further feedback. Ashok (Samsung) provides comments. Tricci (OPPO) responds to Ashok (Samsung) and would like to ask for further clarifications. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Ashok (Samsung) and Tricci (OPPO). Tricci (OPPO) thanks Pallab (Nokia) for further clarifications and agrees with Ashok (Samsung)'s assessment. Ashok (Samsung) agrees with Tricci (OPPO) Tricci (OPPO) thanks Ashok (Samsung) responses and would like to further comment. Ashok (Samsung) provides r02 based on the agreed discussion Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and agrees with Stefano(Qualcomm). Ashok (Samsung) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) Tricci (OPPO) would like to respond to Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on the use of UCU Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Tricci. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Guanzhou (InterDigital) responses and provide further feedback. Ashok (Samsung) clarifies Guanzhou (InterDigital) and provides r03 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments and expresses concern on the proposed function change Ashok (Samsung) thanks Shabnam (Ericsson) for comments and provides r04 Pallab (Nokia) comments and provides r05 Ashok (Samsung) disagrees with Pallab (Nokia) explains the reason for it. Not Ok with r05 Ashok (Samsung) clarifies to Pallab (Nokia) Pallab (Nokia) responds to Ashok (Samsung). Tricci (OPPO) supports Ashok (Samsung) and proposes r06 to provide some updates on the possible UCU responses from the UE/UAV, and to clarify the proper references to the TS 23.502 and to become supporting company. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Nokia view Jaewoo (LGE) asks a question for previous comment. Ashok (Samsung) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) Ashok (Samsung) responds to Jaewoo (LGE) Pallab (Nokia) clarifies/corrects to Ashok (Samsung) on the response to Jaewoo (LGE) Ashok (Samsung) responds to Pallab (Nokia) Stefano (Qualcomm) responds and provides a provisional rev. 07 in case we get convinced of the need. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Stefano (Qualcomm) comments and provides r07. OPPO would like to share a few thoughts. Guanzhou (InterDigital) remains not convinced of the need of the CR. Tricci (OPPO) would like to respond to Guanzhou (InterDigital) question. Ashok (Samsung) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) question. Ashok (Samsung) thanks Stefano (Qualcomm) and Tricci (Oppo) for providing r07 and we are fine with it Shabnam (Ericsson) does not believe r07 text is really specification type, comments Ashok (Samsung) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) and request for a revision with suitable wordings Tricci (OPPO) thanks Shabnam (Ericsson) feedback and provides r08 to address Shabnam's comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Tricci (Oppo). Tricci (OPPO) apologizes to Guanzhou (InterDigital) for the mis-understanding but is still confused about the argument. Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this CR (& any related ones) until next meeting in an effort to find consensus offline, comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Ashok (Samsung) Ashok (Samsung) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) and request not to postpone Pallab (Nokia) also proposes to POSTPONE as there is no consensus on the topic Stefano (Qualcomm) we support postponing this to allow for more offline discussion to achieve a solid conclusion. Ashok (Samsung) provides r09 by removing the UCU changes for the Aerial subscription change and request to approve which had another two small change which was agreed during discussion Ashok (Samsung) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefano (Qualcomm) R09 is unreadable, please re-upload as R10. Chairs, this was most probably a file corruption, R09 was uploaded in time. Ashok (Samsung) provides r10 as r09 was corrupted. Jaewoo (LGE) provides comment on r10. Ashok (Samsung) responds Jaewoo (LGE) Jaewoo (LGE) responds Ashok (Samsung). Ashok (Samsung) clarifies to Jaewoo (LGE) Pallab (Nokia) confirms the understanding that UE does not need to know whether network performs UUAA-MM or UUAA-SM. If the UE is in possession of CAA-Level UAV ID, it shall always include it in 5GS registration and PDU Session establishment request. This has been agreed long time back. Do not see the need to review this again. Ashok (Samsung) provides r11 Jaewoo (LGE) is fine with r11. Pallab (Nokia) comments on r11. Also leaves the decision on chair and rapporteur if we can accept r11 as it is after revision deadline. Ashok (Samsung) clarifies to Pallab (Nokia) and explains the revision is with existing content (not addition of any new content). Just because r09 was corrupted which was provided before revision deadline, Tao (VC) and Stefano (rapporteur) agreed for new revision upload. Tricci (OPPO) supports to agree r11 given that it is an unforced error. Pallab (Nokia) points that r10 was provided for the issue with r09. I think r11 is a subsequent revision of r10. Again, I am not objecting and will leave the decision on chair and rapporteur. As it is a bit unfair to others if we accept revisions after deadline. Ashok (Samsung) explain that in past many instances are there where after deadline some revisions are accepted if agreed offline with concerned party and during CC ,Rapporteur and Chair ask for any objection on the latest revision. I do not have any problem if any company openly objects to it Shabnam (Ericsson) mentions that either we go for r10 which is not agreeable (I also believe the 'shall' are too strong) or we take it to CC#2 and provide changes we can accept compared to r10 which allows changing the 'shall' to 'may'. Ashok (Samsung ) comments and agree for CC#2 with changes which will be r10 + complete removal of 1st proposal Guanzhou (InterDigital) points out r10/r11 were both uploaded in the wrong folder. Would rather postpone this but is OK to bring it to CC#2. Stefano (Qualcomm): Ashok, for fairness, any revision after deadline (unless there was a technical upload error) are not OK. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Ashok (Samsung) and repeat we're OK to proceed r10 in CC#2 Ashok (Samsung) respect Stefano (Qualcomm)'s decision and not requesting for r11 approval. In #CC2 we can ask for r10+ removal of 1st proposal ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2108173 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0009R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UUAA-MM Procedure Updates | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107322r10 + changes. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107442 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0011 (Rel-17, 'D'): Clarify the implicit subscription during the UUAA procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107959 Revised to S2-2107959. | Guanglei (Huawei) replies and provides r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) asks why category 'D' and has other questions ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107959 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0011R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Clarify the implicit subscription during the UUAA procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107442r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107443 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0012 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on UUAA and C2 authorization failure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107960 Revised to S2-2107960. | Guanglei (Huawei) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) OK with r01. Objects to r00 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107960 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0012R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on UUAA and C2 authorization failure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107443r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107724 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0029 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network Initiated UUAA Revocation | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stefano. Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and reserves to note the paper Pallab (Nokia) feels that the proposed changes are not needed and the CR can be NOTED Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks all for the comments and explanations and proposes to note the CR. DongYeon (Samsung) replies to the comments. Pallab (Nokia) responds to DongYeon (Samsung) DongYeon (Samsung) accepts the comments from Nokia, and suggests to postpone this CR to only clarify when to remove UUAA context in next meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2107725 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Discussion on Network initiated UUAA Revocation . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107640 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0024 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on UUAA re-authentication and re-authorization procedure | InterDigital | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107961 Revised to S2-2107961. | Tricci (OPPO) can only accept the first change and rejects the second change for leveraging UCU to deliver the authorization message to UE. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Tricci (Oppo) comments Tricci (OPPO) thanks Guanzhou (InterDigital) for clarification and provides further feedback. Pallab (Nokia) shares the same view a Tricci (OPPO) Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Tricci (Oppo) and Pallab (Nokia) and provides r01. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab (Nokia). Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) comments on r01 and asks if the updates are necessary. Proposes not to approve r01 yet. Tricci (OPPO) has similar question as Pallab (Nokia) and prefer to provide response to USS to confirm UE receives the authorization info. Tao(VC) I do not see agreeable version on this thread yet. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab (Nokia) Tricci (Oppo) and Stefano (Qualcomm). Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to agree r01. Pallab (Nokia) is OK to approve r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107961 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0024R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on UUAA re-authentication and re-authorization procedure | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107640r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107167 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0005 (Rel-17, 'F'): USS Initiated procedures update | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Pallab (Nokia) provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) states the preference is to have the flows/procedures detail kept, but would like to hear others opinion as well. Comments on one issue below. Pallab (Nokia) has no strong preference on either approach and would be OK to go with the majority view as long as the procedure described are correct and aligned with 5GS procedure. Dimitris (Lenovo) states preference is to keep flows/detail procedures kept Stefano (Qualcomm): our preference is to keep flows/detail procedures ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) is OK to approve r00. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.7 | S2-2107168 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0006 (Rel-17, 'F'): C2 Authorization for EPS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107962, merging S2-2107561 Revised to S2-2107962. | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, which merges input from 7561. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107962 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0006R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): C2 Authorization for EPS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107168r01, merging S2-2107561. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107561 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0017 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on the procedure for C2 authorization in EPS | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107962 | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that this CR can be considered merged into revision of 7168. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2107652 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0025 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on C2 authorization procedure | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Postponed | Pallab (Nokia) feels that the corrections proposed in this CR are not needed and the CR can be NOTED Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab. Pallab (Nokia) provides reasons as requested by Guanzhou (InterDigital) Pallab (Nokia) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab (Nokia). Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab (Nokia) with additional comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo). Dimitris (Lenovo) provides additional comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dimitris (Lenovo) suggests to postpone this CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2107590 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0023 (Rel-17, 'F'): Revocation of C2 Connectivity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Guanzhou (InterDigital) thinks the clause is not needed and questions whether it's Cat B CR. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) proposes to approve the original CR Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to Note this. Pallab (Nokia) OK to NOTE the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2107564 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0018 (Rel-17, 'F'): USS-initiated C2 pairing policy configuration in EPS | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2107167 (Approved). Noted | Pallab (Nokia) proposes to merge this to 7167, as both the proposals are mostly aligned and we are already discussing the procedure in 7167 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dimitris (Lenovo) confirms 7564 is merged in 7167 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2107441 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0010 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification and Correction on AF and NEF authentication service | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2107963, merging S2-2107149 Revised to S2-2107963. | Tricci (OPPO) asks more fundamental questions regarding the naming convention for the services defined in 23.256 4.4.1.1 and 4.4.1.2. The naming of the services does NOT match the descriptions of the service. Jaewoo (LGE) provides r01. Guanglei (Huawei) replies Jaewoo (LGE) provides comment. Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to merge this with S2-2107149 due to overlaps. Either version is valid as basis, though perhaps 7149 is more complete. Guanglei (Huawei) agrees the naming of the services to have 'UAS'. Pallab (Nokia) provides r02 Pallab (Nokia) responds to Tricci (Oppo) Tricci (OPPO) responds to Pallab (Nokia) and Guanglei (Huawei) Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks a question for clarification. Guanglei (Huawei) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital). Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments. Guanglei (Huawei) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) and provides r03. Pallab (Nokia) provides r04 Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Pallab (Nokia) and think r04 is ok. Jaewoo (LGE) comments on r04 and provides r05. Pallab (Nokia) comments on r05 Jaewoo (LGE) replies Pallab (Nokia) and r04 is ok. Guanglei (Huawei) provides r06. Jaewoo (LGE) comments on r06. Jaewoo (LGE) provides r07. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Guanglei (Huawei) is ok with r07. Pallab (Nokia) OK with r07. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107963 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0010R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification and Correction on AF and NEF authentication service | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107441r07, merging S2-2107149. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107497 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0013 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on AMF and SMF addressing UAS NF/NEF | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107964 Revised to S2-2107964. | Stefano (Qualcomm) has questions and concerns Yi (China Mobile) replies to Stefano and provides r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) requests clarification on using USS address to discover a UAS NF/NEF Stefano (Qualcomm) provides R02. Cannot accept R01 and R00. Yi (China Mobile) ask question for clarification. Guanglei (Huawei) provides comments. Pallab (Nokia) comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) answers to Yi. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Yi (China Mobile) is fine with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107964 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0013R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on AMF and SMF addressing UAS NF/NEF | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107497r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107498 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0014 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on new CAA-level UAV ID allocation | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107499 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0015 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on UAV tracking mode | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107965 Revised to S2-2107965. | Pallab (Nokia) comments and raises concerns for mandating 3GPP to receive request with non 3GPP ID Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) echoes the previous concerns for rel. 17 and suggests to note the paper. Yi (China Mobile) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Pallab (Nokia) proposes to approve r01 Yi (China Mobile) will do the editorial change when uploading the document. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107965 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0015R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on UAV tracking mode | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107499r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107500 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0016 (Rel-17, 'F'): Association of CAA level UAV ID to 3GPP UAV ID in USS | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107966 Revised to S2-2107966. | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides R01 Guanglei (Huawei) shares the same view with Stefano(Qualcomm) and think r01 is acceptable Yi (China Mobile) is fine with r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107966 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0016R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Association of CAA level UAV ID to 3GPP UAV ID in USS | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107500r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107569 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0019 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction for UAV replacement in 5GS | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107968 | Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to merge this into S2-2107665. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dimitris (Lenovo) confirms 7569 is merged in 7665 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2107571 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0020 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure for UAV replacement in EPS | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107967 Revised to S2-2107967. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107967 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0020R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Procedure for UAV replacement in EPS | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107571r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107665 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0026 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction and simplification on UAV-C replacement procedure | InterDigital | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107968, merging S2-2107569 Revised to S2-2107968. | Guanglei (Huawei) provides r01 Dimitris (Lenovo) includes questions for clarification Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r02. Pallab (Nokia) provides r03. Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r03 Guanglei (Huawei) is fine with r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107968 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0026R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction and simplification on UAV-C replacement procedure | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107665r03, merging S2-2107569. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107588 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0021 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network triggered UE re-registration for aerial services when aerial subscription is enabled | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci (OPPO) agrees with Qualcomm that there is no need for new UAV Capability Indicator. OPPO suggests to merge this CR to Samsung's S2-2107322. Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and may suggest to note the CR. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) shares Stefano (Qualcomm)'s concerns. Stefano (Qualcomm) requests the paper to be noted based on the common concerns. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to POSTPONE the CR Stefano (Qualcomm) we support postponing this to allow for more offline discussion to achieve a solid conclusion. Dimitris (Lenovo) also supports postponing ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2107288 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0008 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up for List of Aerial UEs in a geographic area | OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107969 Revised to S2-2107969. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks a question for clarification. Tricci (OPPO) responds to Guanzhou (InterDigital) with clarification. Guanglei (Huawei) ask questions. Tricci (OPPO) responds to Guanglei (Huawei) question. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments Tricci (OPPO) thanks Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107969 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0008R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up for List of Aerial UEs in a geographic area | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107288r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107589 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0022 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107746 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0030 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS 23.256: various clarifications and corrections | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.501. Cover sheet needs correcting to 23.256. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107970 Revised to S2-2107970. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r01. Stefano (Faccin) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107970 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0030R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS 23.256: various clarifications and corrections | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107746r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107169 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0007 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.256 clean-up | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.7 | S2-2107666 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0027 (Rel-17, 'D'): Removing empty clause 5.2.9 | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Noted | Pallab (Nokia) proposes to NOTE this CR as S2-2107590 provides updates to the concerned clause i.e. 5.2.9 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2107747 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0031 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS 23.256: Rapporteur Editorial CR | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.501. Cover sheet needs correcting to 23.256. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107971 Revised to S2-2107971. | Jaewoo (LGE) provides r01. Jaewoo (LGE) provides r02. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Jaewoo (LGE) provides comments. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2107971 | CR | Approval | 23.256 CR0031R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS 23.256: Rapporteur Editorial CR | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107747r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | System enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (5G_ProSe) | - | - | Docs:=73 | - | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | LS for information | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107018 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on establishment/resume cause value and UAC on L2 SL Relay | CT WG1 (C1-214795) | Rel-17 | Noted | Fei (OPPO) proposes to note this incoming LS from CT1 since this incoming LS is for information and no action is required. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Relay discovery IDs | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2106991 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on discovery and relay (re)selection | RAN WG2 (R2-2104649) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105242 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107394. Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) this LS in can be noted. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107394 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on discovery and relay (re)selection | CATT | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2106991. r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2107972 Revised to S2-2107972. | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 by adding two questions to RAN2 raised during discussion. Fei (OPPO) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Fei (OPPO). Steve (Huawei) provides r02 Fei (OPPO) provides r03. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r04 with more clarifications and rewordings. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments on r04. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r05 correcting a typo. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06. Steve (Huawei) provides r07 Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r08. Steve (Huawei) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r09 with clean-up. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r09 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107972 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on discovery and relay (re)selection | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107394r09. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107424 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on non-serving PLMN IDs delivery | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Fei (OPPO) responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Zhang (Ericsson) ask questions Fei (OPPO) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT). Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comment Deng Qiang (CATT) think this LS can be marked as merged into S2-2107394r03. Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark this LS as merged or noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107392 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0020 (Rel-17, 'B'): Identifiers for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay discovery | CATT, ZTE, Intel | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107973 Revised to S2-2107973. | Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Zhang (Ericsson). Zhang (Ericsson) asks question Fei (OPPO) asks the question. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Lars (Sony) propose to remove the first change. Steve (Huawei) comments on RAN sharing - it's already supported. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments and provides r02. Fei (OPPO) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Mehrdad (Samsung). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107973 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0020R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Identifiers for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay discovery | CATT, ZTE, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107392r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107423 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | PLMN IDs delivery | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) it's a discussion paper, it should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107458 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on Relay TAI in the additional discovery message | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) it's a discussion paper, it should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107459 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0025 (Rel-17, 'F'): Relay TAI in addtional discovery message | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107974 | Wen (vivo) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT). Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments on SI forwarding. Wen (vivo) replies. Deng Qiang (CATT) indicates the 1st change has been merged into S2-2107391r01. Changhong (Intel) asks a question. Wen (vivo) replies to Changhong (Intel). Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to mark this CR merged into 2107391r01 Wen (vivo) replies and is ok to merge this paper into 7391 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2107391 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0019 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Relay Discovery Additional Information message | CATT, ZTE, Intel | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107974, merging S2-2107459 Revised to S2-2107974. | Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Zhang (Ericsson). Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Walter (Philips) provides comment Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged 1st change of S2-2107459. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Mehrdad (Samsung) asks a clarification on r01 Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for more clarification on r01 Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Mehrdad. Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung) and Zhang (Ericsson). Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Qualcomm. Fei (OPPO) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107974 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0019R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Relay Discovery Additional Information message | CATT, ZTE, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107391r01, merging S2-2107459. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | RAN dependency issues resolution | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107045 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on RAN dependency issues for 5G ProSe | RAN WG2 (R2-2109127) | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note the LS as the SA2 action does not require any reply LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107393 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0021 (Rel-17, 'B'): Remove ENs on RAN WG2 dependency issues | CATT, Intel, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107975, merging S2-2107172 and S2-2107173 Revised to S2-2107975. | Wen (vivo) comments and provides r02 Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged S2-2107172 and S2-2107173 into this CR. Zhang (Ericsson) propose to merge S2-2107172 and S2-2107173 into this CR and co-sign LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment and r03. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Qualcomm. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong. Fei (OPPO) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson, Qualcomm, CATT and OPPO and provides r06. Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT Xiaoyan Shi (interdigtial) agrees with Mehrdad to bring message size issue back in next meeting. R06 is fine with Interdigital. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) can live with r06. Zhang (Ericsson) can live with r06 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107975 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0021R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Remove ENs on RAN WG2 dependency issues | CATT, Intel, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107393r06, merging S2-2107172 and S2-2107173. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107172 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0006 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving EN about transmission of Application Layer discovery message | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107975 | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to mark this paper as merged into S2-2107393, as Zhang (Ericsson) also indicates in 7393 thread. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2107173 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0007 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding adaptation layer over PC5 for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107975 | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to mark this paper as merged into S2-2107393, as Zhang (Ericsson) also indicates in 7393 thread. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2107713 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0038 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to Groupcast mode 5G ProSe Direct Communication | Samsung, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) also proposes to merge the paper into S2-2107393. Zhang (Ericsson) proposes to merge the paper into S2-2107393 Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson and CATT Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) supports Samsung that 'the payload is sufficiently large to accommodate the discovery messages as metadata'. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) can we go with r00 or noted it Deng Qiang (CATT) postponed or noted should be fine. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK to mark this CR as POSTPONED. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Layer-3 Relay authorization | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107063 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay authentication and authorization | SA WG3 (S3-213128) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107309. Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) this LS in can be noted. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107309 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay authentication and authorization | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107063. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107976 Revised to S2-2107976. | Deng Qiang (CATT) ask question for clarification. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan and DengQiang. Steve (Huawei) it's a bit early to start this, let's wait for SA3 to get further. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Fei (OPPO) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) supports Q1) and Q2). Hannu (Nokia) proposes r01 to highlight the urgency of the questions. Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01. Steve (Huawei) comments Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) supports to attach CR S2-2107566 to the LS. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02 (with CR attached) and r03 (without CR) for further discussion. Fei (OPPO) indicates that r03 (without CR) is OK. Deng Qiang (CATT) prefers r03. Steve (Huawei) prefers r03 Zhang (Ericsson) prefers r03 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) object r03 and can live with r02 and r01. Steve (Huawei) could you suggest an update to the question. Hannu (Nokia) proposes r04. Steve (Huawei) r04 is fine for me Fei (OPPO) is ok with r04. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) can live with r04. Zhang (Ericsson) is fine with r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r04. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r04. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107976 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay authentication and authorization | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107309r04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107566 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0032 (Rel-17, 'B'): Security procedures for L3 relaying | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Interdigital Inc., LG Electronics, Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) also propose to postpone the CR, and wait for SA3 LS response to S2-2107309. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to postpone the CR, and wait for SA3 LS response to S2-2107309. Fei (OPPO) comments. Myungjune (LGE) provides r01 to use consistent wording. Zhang (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE the CR Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies to Hong and Deng qiang. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) includes questions for clarification Hannu (Nokia) comments and proposes to ask for feasibility of the solution documented in S2-2107566 from SA3. Steve (Huawei) it's a bit early to start this, let's wait for SA3 to get further. Jicheol (Samsung) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments and asks to postpone this CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) supports Jicheol in splitting the work to call flows in SA2 architecture work and SA3 security area (which is obviously up to SA3) Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone it. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | ProSe identifier | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107712 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0037 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to ProSe identifier definition | Samsung, LG Electronics, Apple | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107977 Revised to S2-2107977. | Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO and ZTE Judy (Ericsson) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Steve (Huawei) commetns Steve (Huawei) thanks for the clarification, seems like a nice clarification to have somewhere Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Qualcomm and Huawei and asks for further clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LGE. LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung). Steve (Huawei) comments Sudeep (Apple) comments. Changhong (Intel) comments and provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. Changhong (Intel) replies to Judy and disagrees with r03, proposes to use r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) prefers r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) prefers r02 but can live with r03 Judy (Ericsson) prefer r03 but can go with r02 if that's the majority view Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests we go with r02 as all seem OK with r02. Changhong (Intel) objects to r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107977 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0037R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to ProSe identifier definition | Samsung, LG Electronics, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107712r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107360 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0017 (Rel-17, 'F'): Change ProSe Service Type to ProSe Identifier | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Mobility restriction | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107525 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on ProSe Mobility Restrictions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Judy (Ericsson) propose to use this thread to discuss the principles to avoid duplicated comments in 7461, 7567, 7685 and 7722 to resolve the same EN. Fei (OPPO) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) also propose to use this thread to discuss the mobility restriction principles and provides Interdigital's view. Steve (Huawei) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Fei (OPPO) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification from LGE Judy (Ericsson) comments LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LGE and Ericsson. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO Steve (Huawei) comments on Relay's Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to start from S2-2107461 as the base for further revisions. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) asks clarification from InterDigital Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Mehrdad (Samsung) and comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to follow revisions in S2-2107461 thread. Steve (Huawei) As this is a discussion paper, it should be noted now. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107461 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0027 (Rel-17, 'F'): EN resolve for mobility restriction | vivo | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2107978, merging S2-2107567, S2-2107685 and S2-2107722 Revised to S2-2107978. | Laurent (Nokia): starts the discussion on the technical solution Wen (vivo) replies to Fei (OPPO). Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification and comments. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) provides comments. Wen (vivo) replies to Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital). Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed to take this CR as basis for revision, and merge S2-2107567, S2-2107685 and S2-2107722. Wen (vivo) provides r01 for further discussion. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02 and so-signs the CR. Judy (Ericsson) provide r03 Steve (Huawei) objects to r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Huawei and clarifies that this is FFS. Steve (Huawei) comments. Can live with r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) prefers r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) prefers r05/r07, can live with r04/r06 and comments LaeYoung (LGE) first comments r04 is from r02 with only cover page update while r05 is from r03 with only cover page update by Wen (vivo); then prefers r05/r07, but can live with r04/r06. Steve (Huawei) for the sake of progress, we can live with r07. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) can live with r07. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to take r07 as the way forward as nobody has objected to it. Mehrdad (Samsung) agrees with the view shared to go with r07. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107978 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0027R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): EN resolve for mobility restriction | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107461r07, merging S2-2107567, S2-2107685 and S2-2107722. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107567 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0033 (Rel-17, 'F'): Relay UE connectivity corrections | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107978 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed this CR be merged into S2-2107461.. Hannu (Nokia) accepts the proposal to merge this to S2-2107461. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2107685 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0034 (Rel-17, 'F'): Service Area Restriction on NW relay | Interdigital Inc | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107978 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed this CR be merged into S2-2107461.. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine to merge this CR into S2-2107461. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2107722 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0040 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to Mobility Restrictions for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107978 | Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed this CR be merged into S2-2107461.. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK that this CR be merged into S2-2107461. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | PC5 DRX | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107422 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0024 (Rel-17, 'B'): DRX support for direct communication | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to POSTPONE this CR and to focus on the LS drafted in S2-2107529 (LGE) in order to put proper description/questions and check the LS can be sent to RAN2. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports LGE position to postpone. Steve (Huawei) let's ask first then align (if needed, usual disclaimers apply etc.). postponing is fine. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) thinks that this CR can be postponed. Mehrdad (Samsung) also suggests to mark this CR as POSTPONED. Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark this postponed. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2107529 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on PC5 DRX for ProSe | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107979 Revised to S2-2107979. | Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, he wording may require some polishing up further. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Wen (vivo) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r05. Fei (OPPO) is ok with r03, r04 and r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r05 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107979 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on PC5 DRX for ProSe | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107529r05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Corrections to discovery | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107171 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0005 (Rel-17, 'F'): PC5 Discovery Model Selection | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107980 Revised to S2-2107980. | Fei (OPPO) comments. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Fei (OPPO) responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Lars (Sony) comments Fei (OPPO) comments r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) as a couple of questions for understanding Wen (vivo) comments Zhang (Ericsson) provides r04 Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and all revisions Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) also supports to remove all example. Zhang (Ericsson) provides r05 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is also fine with r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107980 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0005R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): PC5 Discovery Model Selection | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107171r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107359 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0016 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Discovery Request Procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107981 Revised to S2-2107981. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Fei (OPPO) comments on r01. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fei (OPPO) Hao Dong (ZTE) responds and provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107981 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0016R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Discovery Request Procedure | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107359r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107526 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on Naf_ProSe service and Nnef_ProSe service. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) it's a discussion paper, it should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107524 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3193 (Rel-17, 'F'): Service correction on 5G ProSe usage | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | WI Code should be 5G_ProSe. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107982 Revised to S2-2107982. | Steve (Huawei) provides r01, to correct the WI code. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107982 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3193R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Service correction on 5G ProSe usage | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107524r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107523 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0030 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on ProSe Direct Discovery with 5G DDNMF | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107983 Revised to S2-2107983. | Deng Qiang (CATT) also has concern on introduced NEF services in original version. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Guanglei (Huawei) replies. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Guanglei (Huawei) Guanglei (Huawei) responds to Judy (Ericsson). Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment on original version and r01. Guanglei (Huawei) provides r02 and replies to Mehrdad (Samsung) Judy (Ericsson) does not see the need to introduce NEF service for 5G DDNMF. Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Judy (Ericsson) and provides r03 Deng Qiang (CATT) has concerns on introduced NEF services. Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT) and asks for clarification Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Guanglei (Huawei). Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT) and asks for further clarification Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Guanglei (Huawei). Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Guanglei (Huawei) ask for Deng Qiang (CATT) and Hao Dong (ZTE) for further clarification Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Hannu (Nokia) responds to Zhang Fu. Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Zhang (Ericsson) Guanglei (Huawei) ask Hannu (Nokia) for clarification ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) this CR should be noted. Guanglei (Huawei) propose to accept r01 which does not touch the controversial part. Deng Qiang (CATT) can accept r01. Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r01 Hannu (Nokia) can agree the CR with the reduced scope in r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107983 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0030R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on ProSe Direct Discovery with 5G DDNMF | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107523r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107421 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0023 (Rel-17, 'F'): DDNMF stack | OPPO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107984 Revised to S2-2107984. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) question for clarification Fei (OPPO) responds to Steve (Huawei). Fei (OPPO) provides r02. Steve (Huawei) provides r03 Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r04 Fei (OPPO) is ok with r04. Steve (Huawei) thanks for the clarification. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107984 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0023R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): DDNMF stack | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107421r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Corrections to relay | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107390 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0018 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Layer-2 Relay selection | CATT, Intel | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107985 Revised to S2-2107985. | Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Fei (OPPO). Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged the 2nd and 3rd changes of S2-2107462. Steve (Huawei) asks a question Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Steve (Huawei) and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) thanks for the clarification, provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107985 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0018R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Layer-2 Relay selection | CATT, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107390r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107462 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0028 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous clarifications and corrections | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes the 2nd and 3rd changes merged into S2-2107390. Steve (Huawei) comments on overlap with S2-2107522 Wen (vivo) replies and provides r01 LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Wen (vivo) replies and provides r02. Wen (vivo) replies to Steve Steve (Huawei) provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with both r02 and r03. Wen (vivo) is also fine with both r02 and r03. Hong (Qualcomm) can only accept r02. Fei (OPPO) prefers r02 and can live with r03. Steve (Huawei) objects to r00, r01 and r02. Only r03 is acceptable. Wen (vivo) proposes go r03 first at this meeting excluding the controversial part. Hong (Qualcomm) objects to r03. Fei (OPPO) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Fei. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107522 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0029 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107986 Revised to S2-2107986. | Fei (OPPO) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Steve (Huawei) comments on the need, its needed for gNB operation. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks question on the indication for Remote UE authorization to gNB. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments Fei (OPPO) comments. Walter (Philips) provides comment. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Changhong (Intel) provides r02 by removing the forth change in the r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) also has concern on authorization info for L3 Remote UE. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) r02 should be ok. Changhong (Intel) can only accept r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107986 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0029R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107522r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107527 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0031 (Rel-17, 'F'): PDU Session release for L3 U2N Relay on authorisation revocation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107987 Revised to S2-2107987. | Judy (Ericsson) comments Fei (OPPO) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments Judy (Ericsson) responds and asks furthe Q Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Steve (Huawei) comments on AMF inspecting SM signalling and existing procedures. Judy (Ericsson) responds that AMF does not need to inspect SM signaling Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) shares same view with Steve. Fei (OPPO) commets and provides r01. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Fei (OPPO) is ok with r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) can live with r02 with the assumption that we clarify in the next meeting this is for PDU sessions exclusively used for relaying only. Chairman please kindly record this. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107987 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0031R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): PDU Session release for L3 U2N Relay on authorisation revocation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107527r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107153 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0001 (Rel-17, 'F'): EN resolution about U2N Relay reselection | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107154 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0002 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on IP address allocation for U2N Relay | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107988 Revised to S2-2107988. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) ask Q LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Fei (OPPO) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks question for clarification and comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) also supports to remove the example. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Fei (OPPO) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107988 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0002R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on IP address allocation for U2N Relay | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107154r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107325 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0013 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removing the EN of policy control for L3 U2N Relay | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Yali (OPPO) is fine with r01 LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. Steve (Huawei) asks a question or 2. Yali (OPPO) replies to Steve and provides r02 Steve (Huawei) comments Yali (OPPO) replies to Steve, ok to both r00 and r02 Steve (Huawei) thanks for the clarification, seems r00 is enough. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) also thinks that r00 can work. :) Judy (Ericsson) can live with r00 and comment Yali (OPPO) replies to Judy, and ok to agree r00 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.8 | S2-2107342 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0014 (Rel-17, 'F'): N3IWF connection via data network | Sony | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised to S2-2107989 Revised to S2-2107989. | Myungjune (LGE) asks question for clarification. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Lars (Sony) also think that the N6 should be remove from the architecture figure. Lars (Sony) responds to Myungjune's question. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) comments Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Lars (Sony) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Changhong(Intel) comments and provides r01. Lars (Sony) asks Xiaoyan for further clarification Lars (Sony) seek a r02 that show all changes suggested on top of r00. Lars (Sony) provides r02 on top of r00. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r03. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r03. Changhong (Intel) provides r04 and can't agree with r02 and r03. Myungjune (LGE) comments on r04. Lars (Sony) comments on r04. Lars (Sony) provides r05. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r05. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06, as r05 was provide by others already. Zhang (Ericsson) asks clarification Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Zhang. Lars (Sony) question on r06 architecture figure. Lars (Sony) asks question to Hong (Qualcomm) on r06. Myungjune (LGE) asks question on r06. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks question for clarification. Lars (Sony) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital). Lars (Sony) provides r07 Changhong (Intel) provides r08 with yellow highlighted changes. Myungjune (Sony) provides r09 Lars (Sony) responds to Changhong (Intel) and r08. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r08. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r10. Steve (Huawei) asks a question ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Lars (Sony) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Lars. Zhang (Ericsson) asks questions Hong (Qualcomm) comments and clarifies the r08 on the server is from another author. Lars (Sony) responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Lars (Sony) replies to Hong. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Myungjune. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Hong (Qualcomm). Lars (Sony) support that we either approve r07 or r10. Prefers r07. Zhang (Ericsson) prefers r07 Myungjune (LGE) prefers r07 Tao(VC) Let's check r07 agreeable or not Hong (Qualcomm) would only accept r10. Lars (Sony) responds and is ok to go with r10. Zhang (Ericsson) can go with r10 Myungjune (LGE) can live with r10 Hannu (Nokia) can live with r10 Changhong (Intel) supports Hong on accepting r10. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107989 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0014R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): N3IWF connection via data network | Sony | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107342r10. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107687 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0035 (Rel-17, 'F'): Relay Service for Public Network Integrated NPN | Interdigital Inc | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) comments and proposes to NOTE. Judy (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this paper and capture the interaction between NPN and ProSe in Rel-18 SID Fei (OPPO) comments. Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Steve (Huawei) comments on its not been studied Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies and provides r01 Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107324 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0012 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the PC5 QoS parameters for L3 U2N Relay | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107990 Revised to S2-2107990. | Yali (OPPO) replies to Zhang (Ericsson) Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Wen (vivo) ask questions: Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Yali (OPPO) replies to Hong and Mehrdad Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Yali. Yali (OPPO) provides r01. Yali (OPPO) provides r02 Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107990 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0012R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the PC5 QoS parameters for L3 U2N Relay | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107324r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107460 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0026 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on QoS handling for L3 relay | vivo | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107991 Revised to S2-2107991. | Yali (OPPO) comments Wen replies to Yali (OPPO) Yali (OPPO) replies to Wen Wen (vivo) replies to Yali (OPPO) Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Wen (vivo) replies and provides r01 Steve (Huawei) ask a question Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Wen (vivo) replies and provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Wen (vivo) replies. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Wen (vivo). Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r02. Steve (Huawei) comments Wen (vivo) replies and provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107991 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0026R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on QoS handling for L3 relay | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107460r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107688 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0036 (Rel-17, 'F'): User Info ID in Layer-2 link establishment with NW relay | Interdigital Inc | Rel-17 | Noted | Walter (Philips) comments Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r01 by merging a NOTE from S2-2107774. Walter (Philips) request clarification on r01 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r02 Walter (Philips) is fine with r02 Zhang (Ericsson) is fine with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) proposes to note Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) suggests to move forward with r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2107774 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0041 (Rel-17, 'F'): User Info ID clarifications | Philips International B.V. | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments Mehrdad (Samsung) comment Walter (Philips) responds to comments Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments Steve (Huawei) comments on the optionality of Discoverer Info and filtering Walter (Philips) responds to Zhang (Ericsson) Hao Dong (ZTE) comments Walter (Philips) reponds to Hao Dong (ZTE) and provides revision r02 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r03 Walter (Philips) is fine with moving the discussion about the NOTE in Change 5 to S2-2107688 thread Changhong (Intel) provides r04 Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) proposes to note ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Miscellaneous corrections | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107412 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0022 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mega Editorial CR on 5G ProSe | OPPO, Ericsson, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107721 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0039 (Rel-17, 'F'): Terminology correction | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107565 | CR | Approval | 23.303 CR0330 (Rel-17, 'F'): TS 23.303 corrections discovered when working on 5G ProSe | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) comments Hannu (Nokia) accepts Judy's comment, provides r01 and asks whether we can progress the CR under TEI17? Judy (Ericsson) comments that TEI17 is not on the agenda for this meeting and ask for chair's advice how to handle the paper. Hannu (Nokia) asks whether Judy wants to reject or to find a way to agree the CR? ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) if technical correct, we may use TEI 17 and check this in CC. Judy (Ericsson) supports Tao(VC)'s proposal to check in CC. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks that 'for CC#2' is appropriate than 'Agree r01?' as a marking. Hannu (Nokia) thanks to Judy and Tao for identifying a possible solution. Let's put this for CC#2 to check whether r01 with TEI17 WI code is acceptable. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2107155 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0003 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on scope | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107992 Revised to S2-2107992. | LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107992 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0003R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on scope | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107155r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107170 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0004 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to UE triggered Policy provisioning Procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.8 | S2-2107358 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0015 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Parameters Provided by ProSe Application Server | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107993 Revised to S2-2107993. | Fei (OPPO) comments on r01. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Judy (Ericsson) and Fei (OPPO). Fei (OPPO) is OK with r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) supports r01 Hao Dong (ZTE) thanks Mehrdad (Samsung) for support and will add Samsung as source company in the final version of this CR. Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2107993 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0015R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Parameters Provided by ProSe Application Server | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107358r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (5MBS) | - | - | Docs:=109 | - | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107037 | LS In | Action | LS on the MBS broadcast service continuity and MBS session identification | RAN WG2 (R2-2108914) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107200 and S2-2107545. Final response in S2-2108175 | Replied to | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107200 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on the MBS broadcast service continuity and MBS session identification | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107037. Merged into S2-2108175 | Robbie (Ericsson) confirms it has been merged into S2-2107545. LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to merge this document into S2-2107545. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107545 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply for supporting SAI | Huawei,HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107037. CC#2: r07 + changes agreed. Revised, merging S2-2107200, to S2-2108175. | Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01 to merge 7200 in Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 Robbie (Ericsson) provides r03 zhendong (ZTE) provides the r04. Thomas(Nokia) objects against r00, r01 and r03 Thomas (Nokia) provides the r05 and objects against r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== zhendong (ZTE) object r05. Thomas (Nokia) object r00, r01, r03, r05 Suggest either a late revision or postponing the LS Tao(VC) I did not see objection to r02. Can we go with r02 or work offline for an agreeable version? zhendong (ZTE) object r02. LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to work out an agreeable version and send the LS. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r06 in the draft folder. Thomas(Nokia) can accept r06 Robbie(Ericsson) provides r07 in the draft folder ==== Comments Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) provides r08 with removing all SIB-related description. | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108175 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on MBS broadcast service continuity and MBS session identification | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107545r07 + changes, merging S2-2107200. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107046 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on paging for multicast session activation notification | RAN WG2 (R2-2109177) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107738. Noted | Noted | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107738 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on paging for multicast session activation notification | ZTE | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107046. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107994 Revised to S2-2107994. | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107994 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on paging for multicast session activation notification | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107738r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107014 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG4: Reply LS on work split for MBSF and MBSTF definition | SA WG4 (S4-211292) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105374 from S2#146E. Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to postpone this LS. Robbie (Ericsson) asks LiMeng (Huawei). LiMeng (Huawei) is also fine with noting the LS in. Robbie (Ericsson) also support to note this LS in. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107080 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG3: LS on 5MBS preparation of stage 3 work split between SA4 and CT3 | CT WG3 (C3-214581) | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to mark this LS as noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107755 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Multicast paging with TMGI | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107995 Revised to S2-2107995. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Robbie (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS. The analysis should be submitted to SA3 who is responsible for such analysis. LiMeng (Huawei) considers it is beneficial to send the LS, and the content can be generalized a bit to resolve Robbie(Ericsson)'s concern. Miguel (Qualcomm) is ok with r02, explains why SA2 needs to provide an LS to SA3 LiMeng (Huawei) clarifies that r02 is from LiMeng (Huawei). Robbie (Ericsson) objects to previous revisions and provides r03. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r04 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Robbie (Ericsson) is fine with r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107995 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Multicast paging with TMGI | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107755r05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107756 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on MBS data forwarding | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107996 Revised to S2-2107996. | The requirements communicated in this LS depend on approval of the CR0049. However, given the content of this CR is not supported by RAN3 agreement, Paul (Ericsson) objects to this LS. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Paul (Ericsson) provides r03. zhendong (ZTE) provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Paul (Ericsson) objects to revisions 00, 01, 02 and 04. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response and prefer r04. Zhenhua (vivo) suggests to go with r04. TAO(VC) check whether R03 agreeable to everyone or not LiMeng (Huawei) asks whether we can further clarify the action part of the LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107996 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on MBS data forwarding | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107756r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107788 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on PCC parameters for 5MBS charging | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Judy (Ericsson) propose to note this LS. If companies believes there is charging impact, they can propose appropriate MBS WI in SA5-CH Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) propose to take the charging discussion in SA5 if needed and propose to NOTE this LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Discussion paper | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107198 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | MBS broadcast service continuity and MBS session identification. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Robbie (Ericsson) clarifies. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Thomas (Nokia) comments. Robbie (Ericsson) clarifies to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Robbie (Ericsson). Robbie (Ericsson) clarifies to Thomas (Nokia). zhendong (ZTE) is positive with SAI, and need more time to think the solution. Robbie (Ericsson) asks a question. zhendong (ZTE) provides the repsonse. Robbie (Ericsson) clarifies to zhendong (ZTE). Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Robbie (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) responses to Robbie (Ericsson). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Robbie (Ericsson) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107201 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Scalability and performance issue . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107202 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Policy Control for MBS Session . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107205 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Dynamic Policy Control for 5GC Individual MBS Traffic Delivery. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107570 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Handling of UE leaving from local multicast or location dependent multicast. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Mega CR | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107546 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0026 (Rel-17, 'F'): Micellaneous corrections | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson, ZTE, Tencent, CATT, vivo | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107997, merging S2-2107406 and S2-2107469 Revised to S2-2107997. | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) provides r03 to remove change in step 4 of 7.2.1.3 to avoid contradiction with 7490 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107997 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0026R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Micellaneous corrections | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson, ZTE, Tencent, CATT, vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107546r03, merging S2-2107406 and S2-2107469. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107191 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0002 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS Session Management vs Configuration | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107998 Revised to S2-2107998. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) does not agree r01 which introduces new inconsistency between MBS Session procedure and state model Thomas(Nokia) does not agree r00 and replies to Judy Judy (Ericsson) provide r02 Thomas (Nokia) accepts r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107998 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0002R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS Session Management vs Configuration | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107191r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107604 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0031 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial modification on terms, abbreviations, and EN related to UE aware of mapping information | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107999 Revised to S2-2107999. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) comments that some changes are not editorial (e.g. 6.6) and propose to merge such change to 7745 (ZTE), ask if the editorial part should be merged to mega CR 7546? Judy (Ericsson) provides r01, please ignore the previous comment regarding r01 which was not intended for this paper. Richard (BBC) points out that abbreviations in clause 3.2 should preferably be listed in alphabetical order. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2107999 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0031R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Editorial modification on terms, abbreviations, and EN related to UE aware of mapping information | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107604r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107711 | CR | Agreement | 23.247 CR0038 (Rel-17, 'F'): Replacement reference architecture figures | BBC | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108000 Revised to S2-2108000. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Richard (BBC) accepts the additional editor's note and the simplification to annex C proposed by Ericsson in r01. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r01 Judy (Ericsson) provide r02 removing the EN added in r01 to avoid dependency with other paper. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r02. Judy (Ericsson) asks Thomas (Nokia) to clarify which part of the update mandates the support of xMB and MB2. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy Judy (Ericsson) responds to Thomas (Nokia) LiMeng (Huawei) asks if we could add some clarification to resolve that. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy that he supports r00 Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r03. Richard (BBC) makes some suggestions to resolve the impasse between Nokia and Ericsson. Richard (BBC) responds and provides r04. Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r04 Thomas (Nokia) provides r05, objects against r01, r02, r03 and r04. Judy (Ericsson) provides r06 Thomas (Nokia) accepts r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Richard (BBC) accepts principle of r06 and proposes editorial polish. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Richard (BBC) Richard (BBC) responds to Judy (Ericsson) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108000 | CR | Agreement | 23.247 CR0038R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Replacement reference architecture figures | BBC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107711r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107405 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0015 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on functional entities | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108001 Revised to S2-2108001. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== Thomas(Nokia) comments that CR is containing wrong notion of shared delivery establishment by MB-SMF, not SMF. Suggest to raise the issue at the CC2 | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108001 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0015R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on functional entities | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107405r02. CC#2: Technically Eendorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107406 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0016 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on PCF and MB-PCF | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107997 | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to merge this document into the Mega CR (S2-2107546). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107469 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0020 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on control plane protocol stack | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107997 | Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge it into S2-2107546 LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to merge this document into the Mega CR (S2-2107546). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107081 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | [5MBS] Replacement reference point architecture figure | BBC | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | LiMeng (Huawei) asks whether this document will be marked as withdrawn. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Withdrawn |
| 8.9 | S2-2107082 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | [5MBS] Collaboration scenarios annex | BBC | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | LiMeng (Huawei) asks whether this document will be marked as withdrawn. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Withdrawn |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | MBS session management | - | - | Docs:=35 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107192 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0003 (Rel-17, 'F'): Scalability and performance issue | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) comments and suggest to note this CR Judy (Ericsson) responds that Thomas (Nokia) LiMeng (Huawei) comments and suggest to note this CR. Thomas (Nokia) responds to Judy (Ericsson) Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) correct a typo zhendong (ZTE) provides the proposal. LiMeng (Huawei) objects to this document. Thomas(Nokia) objects against the CR and replies to Zhendong (ZTE) zhendong (ZTE) agree with thomas. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107195 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0006 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast MBS Session: resolving ENs and cleanup | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r12 agreed. Revised to S2-2108002, merging S2-2107607 and S2-2107782 Revised to S2-2108002. | Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 and r03. R02 removes changes related to update procedures to enable that service area update remains in a separate clause. R03 combines all update procedures in one clause and merges contents of S2-2107782 Comments on preferred version are invited. Judy (Ericsson) comments provide r04 based on r03 Thomas Nokia replies to Judy Objects against r04 LiMeng (Huawei) comments on r04 and provides r05. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r06. Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r06 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r07 based on r06. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r08 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r09 Thomas (Nokia) provides r10 Zhenhua (vivo) ask questions to Thomas (Nokia) Thomas (Nokia) replies to Zhenhua (vivo) Thomas (Nokia) provides r11 zhendong (ZTE) provides r12. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108002 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0006R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast MBS Session: resolving ENs and cleanup | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107195r12, merging S2-2107607 and S2-2107782. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107607 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0034 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on MBS Session update procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108002 | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01. Judy (Ericsson) has concern on documenting the update for MBS service area and/or QoS in two separate clauses in this paper, and propose to take the update 7195 as basis Judy (Ericsson) comments on r01 that the new text for handover is not relevant in this clause. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaoyan (CATT) suggest to mark this CR as merged into S2-2107195. Judy (Ericsson) share Xiaoyan (CATT)'s view that this paper should be merged into 7195 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107782 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0052 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to Multicast session service area update procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108002 | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to merge 7.2.7 from 7607. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) has concern on documenting the update for MBS service are and/or QoS in two separate clauses in this paper, and propose to take the update 7195 as basis Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. Zhenhua (vivo) response to Judy (Ericsson) Thomas provides r03 to shift procedures to clause 7.2.4 This is what Judy suggested in the 7195 thread Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04 Thomas (Nokia) provides r05 and r06, asks to ignore r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaoyan (CATT) suggest to mark this CR as merged into S2-2107195. Judy (Ericsson) assumes this paper is merged into 7195 which covers the change in this paper.. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Judy. Zhenhua (vivo) suggest to technical endorse the CR. Judy (Ericsson) ask clarification for Zhenhua (vivo)'s suggestion of endorement, and responds to Thomas(Nokia). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107744 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0044 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on the MBS Broadcast session management | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108003 Revised to S2-2108003. | Judy (Ericsson) would like to check if this paper can be merged to other papers, e.g. the mega CR, 7781. zhendong (ZTE) respond. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01 to remove the overlapping part compared with S2-2107781. Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02 LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108003 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0044R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on the MBS Broadcast session management | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107744r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107781 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0051 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to MBS Broadcast Session Establishment | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108004 Revised to S2-2108004. | Robbie (Ericsson) objects to r00 and provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) can accept r01 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108004 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0051R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to MBS Broadcast Session Establishment | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107781r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107404 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0014 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast session leave and session release | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108005 Revised to S2-2108005. | LiMeng (Huawei) comments and provide r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108005 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0014R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast session leave and session release | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107404r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107204 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0008 (Rel-17, 'F'): Interworking with MBMS over E-UTRAN for broadcast service | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107452 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0017 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS session handling when the associated PDU session release | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Zhenhua (vivo). LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR because the proposed operation does not solve all cases and bring complexity. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides the revision r01. Judy (Ericsson) comments that the proposal changes the basic handling of PDU Session release. LaeYoung (LGE) has same view with Judy (Ericsson) and provides comments. Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Judy(Ericsson) Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). Zhenhua (vivo) shares the view from LaeYoung (LG) and Judy (Ericsson) LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Youngkyo(Samsung) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR. Youngkyo(Samsung) can not be convinced by the rationale from LaeYoung(LGE) and it is necessary for public safety user's experience. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Youngkyo (Samsung). Youngkyo(Samsung) replies and provide the revision r02. Zhenhua (vivo) propose to NOTE this CR. Thomas (Nokia) supports to NOTE this CR. Youngkyo(Samsung) can not accept rationale from Zhenhua (vivo) since it is not an implementation issue apparently. Youngkyo(Samsung) answers to the questions. Zhenhua (vivo) replies Judy (Ericsson) comments that the issue may exist but the proposal does not address the issue in systematic way thus propose to NOTE the paper. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107402 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0012 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast session join and session establishment | CATT | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108006, merging S2-2107549 and S2-2107751 Revised to S2-2108006. | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. Miguel (Qualcomm) ok with r03 and asks to please add Qualcomm Inc. as cosigning company at next revision or final upload. Thomas(Nokia) provides r04 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r05. Thomas (Nokia) provides r06. Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r06. Thomas (Nokia) replies that he is also fine with the proposed way forward of Xiaoyan (CATT) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108006 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0012R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Multicast session join and session establishment | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107402r05, merging S2-2107549, merging S2-2107549 and S2-2107751. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107549 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0028 (Rel-17, 'F'): On the issue of user plane activation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108006 | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge this document into the S2-2107402. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107551 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0029 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates on cases that SMF rejects UE join request | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108007 Revised to S2-2108007. | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108007 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0029R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates on cases that SMF rejects UE join request | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107551r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107605 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0032 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on session join and shared tunnel establishment related procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108008 Revised to S2-2108008. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01. Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02 to merge the updates in clause 7.2.1.4 in S2-2107195 in. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108008 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0032R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on session join and shared tunnel establishment related procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107605r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107606 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0033 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on session leave and shared tunnel release related procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108009 Revised to S2-2108009. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to merge modifications in clause 7.2.2.2 of S2-2107404 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 Zhenhua (vivo) comments on r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Thomas (Nokia) replies to Zhenhua (vivo) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108009 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0033R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on session leave and shared tunnel release related procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107606r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107741 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0041 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to the Multicast session join and session establishment, and removing procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108010 Revised to S2-2108010. | zhendong (ZTE) provides r01. Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02 to merge clause 7.2.1.3 in S2-2107195 in. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108010 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0041R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to the Multicast session join and session establishment, and removing procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107741r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107751 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0046 (Rel-17, 'C'): Multicast session join alignment with CT WG1 | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108006 | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge this document into the S2-2107402. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107475 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0022 (Rel-17, 'F'): Leftover issue for MBS session activation and deactivation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108011, merging S2-2107610 Revised to S2-2108011. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01 to merge the suggestion from 7610. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. Judy (Ericsson) provide r04 Fenqin (Huawei) provide r05 Fenqin (Huawei) provide r06 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108011 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0022R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Leftover issue for MBS session activation and deactivation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107475r06, merging S2-2107610. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107477 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3188 (Rel-17, 'F'): Service operation for MBS session activation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108012 Revised to S2-2108012. | Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108012 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3188R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Service operation for MBS session activation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107477r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107479 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0024 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on MBS Session activation procedure | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) has concern on the proposal to delay per UE paging Youngkyo(Samsung) provides replies to Judy(Ericsson). Judy (Ericsson) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) does not think the proposal can resolve the issue of individual delivery due to increased number of pagings thus propose to NOTE this paper, explained Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Judy (Ericsson) that the proposal aims to mitigate the problem than re-solve it completely. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107610 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0037 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on activation/deactivation procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108011 | Fenqin (Huawei) propose to merge this paper to 7475 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107743 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0043 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the MBS service actication/deactivation/update and related service operation | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108013 Revised to S2-2108013. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108013 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0043R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the MBS service actication/deactivation/update and related service operation | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107743r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107752 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0047 (Rel-17, 'C'): Alignment with RAN WG2 for Multicast paging in service activation | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) comments against r01. Robbie (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this CR to wait the feedback from RAN3. zhendong (ZTE) provides the way forward. Robbie (Ericsson) asks Zhendong (ZTE). zhendong (ZTE) responds to robbie(ericsson). Robbie (Ericsson) responds to Zhendong (ZTE). Miguel (Qualcomm) asks question to LiMeng for r01 (still prefers r00 for now), and responds to Robbie LiMeng (Huawei) clarifies and provides r02. Miguel (Qualcomm) not quite clear what the issue with r00 was but can live with r02 Robbie (Ericsson) insists to postpone this paper and wait for RAN3 feedback ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | S2-2107753 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0048 (Rel-17, 'F'): Preventing attacks if paging with TMGI | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed | Thomas (Nokia) proposes to postpone the CR Miguel (Qualcomm) author ok to postpone CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Local MBS | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107453 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0018 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handover procedure with limited area MBS session | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108014 | Fenqin (Huawei) propose to merge this paper into 7474 . Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge this paper into 7474 . ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107573 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0030 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on UE leaving from local multicast or location dependent multicast | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108014 | Fenqin (Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 7474. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine to merge this paper into 7474. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107609 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0036 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add new clauses for local MBS considering activation and idle/inactive mobility | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108014 | Fenqin (Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 7474. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107785 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0053 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections for Local MBS service and Location dependent MBS service | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108014 | Judy (Ericsson) comments that this paper (7785) has overlapping with 7474 and propose to merge the overlapping part in clause 7.2.4 into 7474 Thomas (Nokia) agrees to to merge the contribution into 7474 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107474 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0021 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of the local MBS service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r18 agreed. Revised to S2-2108014, merging S2-2107453, S2-2107573, S2-2107609 and S2-2107785 Revised to S2-2108014. | Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03 based on r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. Thomas (Nokia) provides r06 to merge the contents of S2-2107785 into this CR Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r07. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r08. Judy (Ericsson) provides r09 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r10. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) and ask a question Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r12. Thomas (Nokia) provides r13. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r14. Thomas (Nokia) provides r15 and r16, asks to ignore r15 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r17. zhendong (ZTE) provides r18. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108014 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0021R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of the local MBS service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107474r18, merging S2-2107453, S2-2107573, S2-2107609 and S2-2107785. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Intra system mobility | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107369 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0011 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Xn-based Mobility Procedure | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108015 | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge this document into the S2-2107742. Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge this into 7608. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107608 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0035 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on handover procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108015, merging S2-2107742 and S2-2107369 Revised to S2-2108015. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to merge 7369 into this paper, and removes clauses 7.2.4.2.3 and 7.2.4.3.3, which are merged into 7474. Fenqin (Huawei ) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. Fenqin (Huawei ) provides r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r05. Paul (Ericsson) provides r06. zhendong (ZTE) provides r07. Fenqin (Huawei ) provides r08. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Paul (Ericsson) accepts r06 and objects to all other revisions. zhendong (ZTE) ask the technical clarification on the r07. Paul (Ericsson) replies and provides clarification. zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarifcation. Tao(VC) I check r06 for now unless r07 clarified as agreeable. Fenqin (Huawei) support r08. zhendong (ZTE) support r08 and provides r10. Tao(VC) check whether compromise on some version. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108015 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0035R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on handover procedures | Vivo Mobile Communications Co. LTD | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107608r06, merging S2-2107742, merging S2-2107742 and S2-2107369. CC#2: Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107742 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0042 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modification on the mobility proceudre | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108015 | Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this CR. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01. Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02. Zhenhua (vivo) comments on r02. Paul (Ericsson) provides r03. zhendong (ZTE) this CR is merged to 7608. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107754 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0049 (Rel-17, 'B'): Data Forwarding during mobility | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108016 | Paul (Ericsson ) replies that no contribution providing the e2e solution has been submitted and that based on common understanding, SA2 will align with RAN3 once RAN3 progressed that topic. Fenqin (Huawei) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to merge this paper to 7476 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107476 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0023 (Rel-17, 'F'): Lossless handover for MBS session | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108016, merging S2-2107754 Revised to S2-2108016. | Paul (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. Paul (Ericsson) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Paul (Ericsson) can accept r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108016 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0023R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Lossless handover for MBS session | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107476r01, merging S2-2107754. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | MBS PCC | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107745 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0045 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the Qos handling and Policy control in the clause 6 | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108017 Revised to S2-2108017. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108017 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0045R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the Qos handling and Policy control in the clause 6 | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107745r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107776 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0666 (Rel-17, 'F'): PCC impacts of 5MBS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Judy (Ericsson) comments that the proposal is incomplete if associated QoS Flow setup should involve PCF (not decided yet). DP 7205 includes a more complete proposal. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) does not agree to this CR due to incomplete solution ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107780 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0050 (Rel-17, 'F'): PCC related MBS corrections | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) provides comments Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) propose to postpone/note this CR, explained. Thomas(Nokia) comments that there were also many unrelated changes that Judy did not comment against at all We could try to approve those or otherwise will need to postpone. Also comments that ample explanation for UDR additions was provided Judy (Ericsson) provide comments on the related changes. The only change that is acceptable is 'Explicitly signalled QoS Characteristics'. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | S2-2107193 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0004 (Rel-17, 'F'): Policy Control for MBS Session | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) suggest to note this CR Judy (Ericsson) response that Thomas (Nokia)'s main argument shows a complete misunderstanding of this CR thus the proposal to note the CR lacks technical basis, explained. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments and propose to keep existing procedure. Judy (Ericsson) ask Q to zhendong (ZTE) zhendong (ZTE) responds to judy(ericsson). Thomas (Nokia)'s replies that rather the CR lacks technical basis, as explained in the previous email. Judy (Ericsson) comment that Thomas (Nokia) seems to simply ignore the justifications in DP 7202. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy (Ericsson) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2107739 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0039 (Rel-17, 'F'): Calrification on the initial MBS session configuration and update | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) comments this paper depends on discussion of MBS PCC. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) does not agree to this CR, explained ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | S2-2107740 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0040 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update to the Removal of MBS session configuration with PCC and related service operation. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | Judy (Ericsson) comments that this paper is related to MBS PCC discussion in 7193 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) propose to postpone this paper. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | UE authorization | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107194 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0005 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of MBS subscription data | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108019 | Youngkyo(Samsung) proposes to merge this paper into 7490. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) confirms that this paper is merged into 7490 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107203 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3140 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of MBS subscription data | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108018 Revised to S2-2108018. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02 Judy (Ericsson) comments that LiMeng (Huawei) hasn't provided r02 for this paper. Fenqin (Huawei) responds Judy (Ericsson) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108018 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3140R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of MBS subscription data | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107203r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107403 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0013 (Rel-17, 'F'): Subscription to multicast services | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108019 | Judy (Ericsson) comments and propose to use 7490 or 7194 as base tdoc for further update. Youngkyo(Samsung) proposes to merge this paper into 7490. Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with using S2-2107490 for further discussion and merging relevant CRs (including this CR) to S2-2107490. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2107490 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0025 (Rel-17, 'F'): When UE joining UE authorization for the multicast MBS session | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2108019, merging S2-2107194 and S2-2107403 Revised to S2-2108019. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 merging 7194 into this paper. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r03. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05. Thomas (Nokia) provides r06. Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r05 and r06. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r07. Thomas (Nokia) comments that S2-2107402r06 now contains the missing parts and asks Xiaoyan (CATT) to reconsider objection Judy (Ericsson) shares Xiaoyan's view to keep authorization aspect in this paper. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108019 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0025R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): When UE joining UE authorization for the multicast MBS session | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107490r07, merging S2-2107194 and S2-2107403. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | UP management | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107547 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0027 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on User Plane Management | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108020 Revised to S2-2108020. | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. LiMeng (Huawei) replies and provides r01. Judy (Ericsson) provide r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108020 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0027R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on User Plane Management | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107547r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | NF services | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107196 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3092R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add NF services for 5G MBS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105819 from S2#146E. Revised to S2-2108021, merging S2-2107777 | Thomas (Nokia) comments that this CR is incomplete and suggest to consider the CR merged into the complete CR S2-2107777 Judy (Ericsson) does not agree with the proposal to merge 7196 to 7777 and comment that 7196 does what the title indicates thus Nokia comment 'CR is incomplete' is unfair. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) ask can we go with r00? Thomas (Nokia) object against r00, suggest bringing issue to CC Judy (Ericsson): Thomas (Nokia)'s objection lacks of technical basis. The update in this paper is according to the CR title. If Nokia believes there is documentation issue whether to update NF description in 23.501 for MBS, please use Nokia paper 7777 for CC. After discussions in CC1b Thomas accept r00 and asks that Nokia is added as supporting company Judy (Ericsson) thanks Thomas (Nokia) for support. Tao(VC), can I get a new tdoc to add Nokia in the co-source? ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108021 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3092R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add NF services for 5G MBS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107196, merging S2-2107777. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107457 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0019 (Rel-17, 'F'): NRF service operation for broadcast service | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108022 Revised to S2-2108022. | Youngkyo(Samsung) provide r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108022 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0019R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): NRF service operation for broadcast service | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107457r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107492 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3192 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NRF service operations for MBS | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108023 Revised to S2-2108023. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Fenqin (Huawei ) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia ) suggests to postpone this CR Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Thomas (Nokia ) and provide r03 Thomas (Nokia ) provides r04 and objects to all previous revisions including r00 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Youngkyo(Samsung) questions to Thomas (Nokia ). Thomas (Nokia ) replies to Youngkyo(Samsung) Youngkyo(Samsung) provides further questions and a compromise proposal. Thomas(Nokia) replies Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Thomas(Nokia) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2108023 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3192R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NRF service operations for MBS | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107492r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107777 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3353 (Rel-17, 'F'): Documentation of NF services for 5G MBS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108021 | Judy (Ericsson) proposes to keep only the NF function description in '6.2.6.2 NF profile' in this paper and merge the rest to 7196 Thomas (Nokia) proposes to do the merge the other way round as the present CR is complete ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) ask other interested people's view whether we go with 7777 or 7196 Judy (Ericsson) does not agree with this paper due to change in 6.2.6.2, and propose to approve 7196 Thomas(Nokia) agrees to merge this paper to 7196 Suggest to postpone NF profile extensions ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Inter system mobility | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107156 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0001 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on interworking with EPS | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Document exceeding quota | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107197 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0007 (Rel-17, 'F'): Introducing MBS SAI and updating MBS service area | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Robbie (Ericsson) clarifies and suggest to move the discussion to S2-2107198. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | - |
| 8.9 | S2-2107199 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3139 (Rel-17, 'F'): Introducing MBS SAI and updating MBS service area | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107206 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3055R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS Packet detection and forwarding | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2105649 from S2#146E. Not Handled | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107207 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0009 (Rel-17, 'F'): Dynamic Policy Control for 5GC Individual MBS Traffic Delivery | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2107208 | CR | Approval | 23.247 CR0010 (Rel-17, 'F'): Local MBS service and Location dependent MBS service | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Not Handled | - | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | System enablers for multi-USIM devices (MUSIM) | - | - | Docs:=33 | - | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107010 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on NAS-based busy indication | RAN WG2 (R2-2108855) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105370 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107021 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on NAS-based busy indication | CT WG1 (C1-214917) | Rel-17 | Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2106996 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on UE assistance information for paging collision avoidance | RAN WG2 (R2-2106517) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105266 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107096. Final response in S2-2108144 | Replied to | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107096 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on UE assistance information for paging collision avoidance | vivo | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2106996. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108144 Revised to S2-2108144. | Steve (Huawei) closing the loop is good, does not quite tell the whole story yet, updates required to the LS. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Steve's comments Saso (Intel) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) is fine to not send the LS. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with either no LS or r01. xiaowan (vivo) is fine with r01 and clarifies the LS reply is needed since there is SA2 action in LS in. alessio(Nokia believes we need not this LS. if we do send it (and I let anyone interested to provide a revision along these lines) we need to reference the Cr in sA2 under discussion at this meeting also. but this LS has no RAN impact so really I do not see a need to send it. xiaowan (vivo) reply to Alessio(Nokia) that RAN2 expect SA2 conclusion even if no AI is agreed. Since they are deciding whether close the discussion loop and stop update 38304 or not. R02 is provided as requested. alessio(nokia) can live with this LS but be sure to include the right CR that gets agreed as attachemnt ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108144 | LS OUT | Approval | LS reply on UE assistance information for paging collision avoidance | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107096r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | Maintenance CRs | - | - | Docs:=28 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107085 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3123 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM and CIoT in 5GS | Intel, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Jihoon (ETRI) indicates the tdoc number is wrong in the title. Jianning (Xiaomi) correct the title to 7085, and ok with this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107086 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3235 (Rel-17, 'F'): Enabling of paging reception for 5GS | Intel, Sony, Ericsson, Apple | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108145 Revised to S2-2108145. | xiaowan (vivo) provides r01 Saso (Intel) is OK with r01 alessio(Nokia) asks a question do we need the capability indication since we use standard RR? Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio Myungjune (LGE) replies to Saso (Intel) and Alessio (Nokia) alessio(Nokia) asks what is an empty RR Lars (Sony) agree with Myungjune (LGE) Steve (Huawei) comments Saso (Intel) comments alessio(Nokia) cleans this CR up and also clarifies the text a bit... it is important to say there is no specific indication in this RR, right? Saso (intel) is OK with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Lars (Sony) is OK with r02 Qian (Ericsson) is also OK with either r02 or r01 Xiaowan(vivo) is OK with r02 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108145 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3235R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Enabling of paging reception for 5GS | Intel, Sony, Ericsson, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107086r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107101 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3658 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM capabilities in Emergency Attach | Intel, Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Saso (Intel) provides r01. Xiaowan(vivo) objects to this CR and comments Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan(vivo) Qian (Ericsson) comments and supports r01 Lalith(Samsung) comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith(Samsung). Lalith(Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel) Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning. Saso (Intel) proposes to agree r01 based on the discussion on the 7103 thread ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Krisztian (Apple) supports r01. Xiaowan(vivo) object r00 and r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2107102 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3237 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM capabilities in Emergency Registration | Apple, Intel | Rel-17 | Consider with S2-2107103. Noted | xiaowan (vivo) objects to the CR Saso (Intel) proposes to agree the CR based on the discussion on the 7103 thread ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Krisztian (Apple) supports to agree original version. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2107103 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3124 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM capabilities in Emergency Registration | Intel, Apple | Rel-17 | Consider with S2-2107102. Postponed | Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Saso (Intel) provides r01. Lars (Sony) comments. Xiaowan(vivo) objects to this CR and comments Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan(vivo) Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Saso (Intel) Qian (Ericsson) comments and supports r01 xiaowan (vivo) seek clarification for r02 Saso (intel) replies to xiaowan (vivo) Xiaowan(vivo)replies to Saso (intel) Saso (intel) objects r02; replies to xiaowan (vivo) xiaowan (vivo) comment r01 and seek clarification for Saso (intel)'s comment Myungjune (LGE) replies to Xiaowan (vivo) Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Xiaowan (vivo). Jianning (Xiaomi) provide question for clarification Myungjune (LGE) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi). Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Saso (Intel) replies to xiaowan (vivo); proposes to agree r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Myungjune (LGE) support r01 Krisztian (Apple) supports r01. Xiaowan(vivo) object r00 and r01 Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan(vivo); proposes to mark the document POSTPONED because the issue needs to be resolved one way or another Jianning (Xiaomi) provides views. Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107210 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3659 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of MUSIM mode | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107211 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3141 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of MUSIM mode | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107219 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3660 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on paging restrictions | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) asks a question Myungjune (LGE) replies to Qian (Ericsson) Lalith(Samsung) seeks clarification. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lalith(Samsung). Saso Intel) comments Steve (Huawei) comments Jianning (Xiaomi) shares the view with Steve (Huawei) Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Lalith(Samsung) is fine with r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments Jianning (Xiaomi) proposes r02 by considering the part from 7719 Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Krisztian (Apple) suggests to agree r03. Lalith(Samsung) can accept only r01. Objects r00, r02, r03 and r04. Myungjune (LGE) proposes to agree r01 Jianning (Xiaomi) replies Lalith (Samsung) and Myungjue (LGE) Lalith (Samsung) replies Steve (Huawei) comments on reachability Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Lalith (Samsung) can accept only r01. Objects r00, r02, r03 and r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Steve (Huawei) Jianning (Xiaomi) shares the view with Steve (Huawei) and replies to Juan(Qualcomm) and Lalith (Samsung) Lalith(Samsung) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Saso (Intel) proposes to approve r01 Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r01 Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Saso(Intel) and Lalith(Samsung) Jianning (Xiaomi) ask question on r01 Myungjune (LGE) replies to Jianning Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Jianning (xiaomi) Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Myungjune (LGE) and Lalith (Samsung) Alessio(nokia) asks whether a Cr is really needed Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Juan (Qualcomm) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Myungjune (replies) to Alessio (Nokia) Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) that the CR is needed because it clarifies for cases b, c and d that paging can be triggered by the C-plane signalling associated with these (but not with other) PDU Sessions. Jianning (Xiaomi) replie to Saso (Intel), Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Jianning (Xiaomi) cannot accept r00 and r01, since new NOTE 3 brings confusing and not clear. Propose to postpone. Jianning (Xiaomi) propose to postpone this CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107220 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3258 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on paging restrictions | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) asks a question Myungjune (LGE) replies to Qian (Ericsson) Lalith(Samsung) seeks clarification. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lalith(Samsung). Saso Intel) comments Lalith(Samsung) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Myungjune (LGE) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) and provides r01. Lalith(Samsung) is fine with r01. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Jianning (Xiaomi) proposes r02 by considering the part from 7718 Saso (Intel) prefers r01 Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Myungjune (LGE) asks question on r04. Krisztian (Apple) suggests to agree r03. Lalith(Samsung) can accept only r01. Objects r00, r02, r03 and r04. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Myungjune(LGE) Myungjune(LGE) proposes to agree r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) only accept r01, object r02, r03 and r04. Saso (Intel) proposes to approve r01 Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r01 Jianning (Xiaomi) comment on r01 alessio(Nokia) we should postpone this or take a single approach in CC#2. the main thing we need to understand is that a well understood normative behaviourt is taken that allows the Ue and network to know exactly what happens when a request is accepted. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio alessio (Nokia) further discusses Myungjune (LGE) clarifies r01 Jianning (Xiaomi) cannot accept r00 and r01, since new NOTE 3 brings confusing and not clear. Propose to postpone. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107373 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3229R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Deleting PRs in non allowed area | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of (Postponed) S2-2106477 from S2#146E. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108146, merging S2-2107720 Revised to S2-2108146. | Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Jianning (Xiaomi) proposes to merge the 07720 into this paper, and provide r01 Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Jianning (Xiaomi) Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Lalith(Samsung) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lalith(Samsung) and Jianning (Xiaomi) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Steve (Huawei) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108146 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3229R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Deleting PRs in non allowed area | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107373r01, merging S2-2107720. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107378 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3170 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up about paging cause support indication in N2 message | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108147 Revised to S2-2108147. | Lars (Sony) comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Lalith(Samsung) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01. Lars (Sony) provides r02. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Lars (Sony) responds to Jianning (Xiaomi) Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Lars (Sony) xiaowan (vivo) comments r01 and r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to xiaowan (vivo) Jianning (Xiaomi) is ok with r01 to remove the duplicated text Lars (Sony) comments on pushing the decision to RAN3 alessio(Nokia) provides r03 Jianning (Xiaomi) comment on r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) agrees with Lars. However we should use the right name 'Core Network Assistance Information for RRC INACTIVE' Lars (Sony) responds to Alessio. True that stage 3 uses 'Core Network Assistance Information for RRC INACTIVE' but we in SA2 uses 'RRC Inactive Assistance Information' in both 23.501 and 23.502. Lars (Sony) is ok with r03. xiaowan (vivo) is OK with r01, object r02, r03 Lars (Sony) responds to xiaowan (vivo) Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Lars (Sony), propose go r01 Qian (Ericsson) comments and ok to go with r01 Lars (Sony) is ok to go with r01 alessio(nokia) is ok to go with r01but please clean up the CR well before submission ?? ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108147 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3170R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clean up about paging cause support indication in N2 message | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107378r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107381 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3094R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM support for SNPN access mode | Qualcomm Incorporated, Samsung, Intel, MediaTek Inc, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Charter Communications, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105824 from S2#146E. r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2108148 Revised to S2-2108148. | Xiaowan(vivo) comments and provides r01 Saso (Intel) objects r01. Seeks clarification xiaowan (vivo) replies Saso (Intel) replies to xiaowan (vivo) Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to Qian (Ericsson) about r02. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to xiaowan (vivo) and provides r03. xiaowan (vivo) provides r04 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r05. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) provides r06. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r07. Saso (Intel) comments on r07. Qian (Ericsson) responds. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes Jianning to provide technical concern Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Juan (Qaulcomm) Saso (Intel) is also OK with r07. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is also OK with r07. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) can live with r07 and comments. Xiaowan(vivo) can live with r07 with removal of 'The UE should use the same PEI value for a network subscription if possible.'; otherwise, we disagree it. Ouyang(Huawei) is not OK with r07, support to remove the following text in this meeting and discuss in next meeting. 'The UE should use the same PEI value for a network subscription if possible'. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides a r08 in to draft folder to remove the controversial sentence. Qian (Ericsson) responds and says ok to go with proposed r08. alessio(Nokia) ok to go with proposed r08. Saso (Intel) flags r08 for CC#2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108148 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3094R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): MUSIM support for SNPN access mode | Qualcomm Incorporated, Samsung, Intel, MediaTek Inc, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Charter Communications, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107381r07. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107382 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3171 (Rel-17, 'F'): NAS Paging reject clarification | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Lars (Sony) comments. Steve (Huawei) questions whether this CR is correct (spoiler - it's not). Saso (Intel) also thinks the CR is not needed. Propose to NOTE. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) also proposes to NOTE the CR. Myungjune (LGE) also proposes to NOTE the CR. Lalith(Samsung) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm), Saso (Intel), Steve (Huawei), Myungjune (LGE) and Lars (Sony) Lars (Sony) comment on r01 Saso (Intel) comments on r01 Steve (Huawei) objects to r00 and r01. Lalith(Samsung) Ok to NOTE. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2107686 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3664 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Paging restrictions handling | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, MediaTek Inc, Samsung, Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108150 Revised to S2-2108150. | Yang (OPPO) comments Steve (Huawei) suggests clarifying it is YES/NO to ALL and the result of saying NO. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01. Yang (OPPO) replies and provide a draft. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Yang (OPPO) Steve (Huawei) provides r02 Krisztian (Apple) asks a question on r02 Lalith(Samsung) provides r03 Saso (Intel) provides r04 alessio(Nokia) OK with r04 Steve (Huawei) is ok with r04 Yang (OPPO) comments to the r04 Jianning (Xiaomi) comments Saso (Intel) replies to Yang (OPPO); proposes to agree r04 Steve (Huawei) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Krisztian (Apple) supports to agree r04. Lalith(Samsung) is fine with r04 Qian (Ericsson) provides some comments Lalith(Samsung) comments Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments Yang (OPPO) is fine to agree r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108150 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3664R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Paging restrictions handling | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, MediaTek Inc, Samsung, Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107686r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107689 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3334 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Paging restrictions handling | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, Mediatek Inc., Samsung, Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108151 Revised to S2-2108151. | Steve (Huawei) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108151 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3334R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Paging restrictions handling | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, Mediatek Inc., Samsung, Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107689r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107696 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3335 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Connection Release and Paging Restriction during a Mobility Registration Update in a TA outside the current Registration Area | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108152 Revised to S2-2108152. | Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Lalith(Samsung) provides r01. Saso (Intel) points that the changes in r01 are done without change tracking. Lalith(Samsung) provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) ok with r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Jianning (Xiaomi) ok with r02 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108152 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3335R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Connection Release and Paging Restriction during a Mobility Registration Update in a TA outside the current Registration Area | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107696r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.10 | S2-2107718 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3343 (Rel-17, 'F'): Exception of Paging Restriction for important system signalling | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Lalith(Samsung) comments Saso (Intel) proposes to consider this CR MERGED in 7220 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to go with 7220 Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Juan (Qualcomm) Lalith(Samsung) shares same view as Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and proposes to merge with 7220. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Lalith(Samsung) and Juan (Qualcomm) alessio(nokia) also proposes to merge with 7220. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Lalith(Samsung) objects to all revisions but OK mark merged with 7220. (as part of this proposal is merged). ==== Comments Deadline ==== Jianning (Xiaomi) propose to postpone this CR | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107719 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3666 (Rel-17, 'F'): Exception of Paging Restriction for important system signalling | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Lalith(Samsung) comments Saso (Intel) proposes to consider this CR MERGED in 7219 Steve (Huawei) comments Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Saso (Intel), Lalith(Samsung) and Qian (Ericsson), provide r01 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to go with 7219. Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Juan (Qualcomm) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Curt (Charter) comments xiaowan (vivo) provides comments Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Curt(Charter) and Xiaowan(vivo) alessio(nokia) also proposes to merge with 7219 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Lalith(Samsung) objects to all revisions but OK mark merged with 7219. (as part of this proposal is merged). Jianning (Xiaomi) propose to postpone this CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2107720 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3344 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Paging Restriction on Non-Allowed Aare | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108146 | Myungjune (LGE) proposes to discuss in S2-2107373 thread and consider this CR is merged into S2-2107373. Jianning (Xiaomi) is ok to merge into 7373. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2107690 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3665 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Connection Release and Paging Restriction during a mobility TAU in a TA outside the current Registration Area | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108153 Revised to S2-2108153. | Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment Saso (Intel) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Saso (Intel) Steve (Huawei) comments Saso (intel) confirms Steve's (Huawei) understanding that MUSIM feature support might not be homogeneous Jianning (Xiaomi) provide r01 based on the discussion. Saso (Intel) provides r02. Steve (Huawei) thanks for the clarification Saso (Intel) replies to Steve. Jianning (Xiaomi) is ok with r02 Alessio(nokia) provides r03 Lalith(Samsung) provides r04 Steve (Huawei) provides r05 Alessio(nokia) thanks Lalith Samsung for r04 which is OK. Jianning (Xiaomi) ok with r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2108153 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3665R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): On Connection Release and Paging Restriction during a mobility TAU in a TA outside the current Registration Area | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107690r05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G (5GSAT_ARCH) | - | - | Docs:=31 | - | |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Other LSs | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2106997 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on PDB for new 5QI | RAN WG2 (R2-2106533) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105268 from S2#146E. Noted | Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS, since it was handled at SA2#146E ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2107025 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: LS on extended NAS supervision timers at satellite access | CT WG1 (C1-215074) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | UE location aspects in NTN LSs | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107048 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on UE location aspects in NTN | RAN WG2 (R2-2109216) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107049 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on UE location aspects in NTN | RAN WG2 (R2-2109217) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107750 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on UE location aspects in NTN | Intel | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107049. Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Saso (Intel) is ok with r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Yuxin (Xiaomi) proposes to use r00 DongYeon (Samsung) supports Qualcomm's comment. Yuxin (Xiaomi) agrees with Stephen and DongYeon this LS out is not needed ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees with DongYeon (Samsung) and proposes not to send the LS at all Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also proposes to NOTE the draft LS Saso (Intel) comments DongYeon (Samsung) proposes to NOTE, and not to send this LS. jean yves (Thales) propose to note/postpone the LS ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2107002 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on UE location aspects in NTN | SA WG3 (S3-212306) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105295 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107076 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG1: Reply LS on PDB for new 5QI | RAN WG1 (R1-2106331) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105264 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Multiple TACs per PLMN | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107015 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Response LS on Multiple TACs per PLMN | RAN WG2 (R2-2108888) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105375 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2106993 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS reply on multiple TACs per PLMN | CT WG1 (C1-213965) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105251 from S2#146E. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107232 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | TA handling with satellite access. | Ericsson | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Wanqiang (Huawei) provides comments and proposes to first agree on the principles to resolve the multiple TACs issue for R17. Hucheng (CATT) support Wanqiang (Huawei) to discuss the principles first, and provide comments. Stefan (Ericsson) provides replies to Stephen Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Wanqiang Hannu (Nokia) comments that the selected TAC should remain consistent between the UE and the AMF. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies. Jean Yves (Thales) comments and asks questions. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides replies to Stefan Hucheng (CATT) investigates the issues to support multiple TACs per cell on the network side and thinks the solution for soft TAC can be defined easily based on the answers of those issues. Stefan (Ericsson) provides question to Hucheng Hucheng (CATT) replies to Stefan (Ericsson). Stephen (Qualcomm) provides further replies to Stefan (Ericsson) Jingran(OPPO) comments on how to handle the ULI, SAs and FAs issues. Jingran (OPPO) replies to Jean Yves (Thales) Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and proposes to use 7619/7620 to move forward Stefan (Ericsson) provides additional replies to Stephen Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the CRs as we have outstanding LSs and open issues Yuxin (Xiaomi) comment Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Wanqiang Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Yuxin Hucheng (CATT) prefers to agree what we can agree in this meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) comments that some parts are already in 23.501 and the rest we should postpone Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to some of the previous comments Stephen (Qualcomm) provides more replies to Stefan (Ericsson) Yuxin (Xiaomi) responds to Jean Yves Wanqiang (Huawei) ok to postpone the related CRs ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107233 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3262 (Rel-17, 'F'): TA handling in satellite access | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) has concerns on this approach and proposes to agree first on whether one or multiple TAC is reported to the AMF. Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that the principles need to agreed first, and also LS feedback from other groups is needed. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) assumes (proposes) that the CR will be noted or postponed Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to mark as postponed, inline with other CRs on the same topic. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2107503 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on Mobility Registration Update when broadcasting more than one TACs. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Jean Yves (Thales) comments and asks questions. Yuxin (Xiaomi)replies to Jean Yves. Stefan (Ericsson) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2107779 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Resolution of Tracking Area Indication in the NGAP ULI for Moving Cells | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Hannu (Nokia) comments and asks a question. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Hannu (Nokia) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2107618 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on Supporting Multiple TACs for Satellite Access. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Jean Yves (Thales) comments and asks questions. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies. Stefan (Ericsson) comments jean yves (Thales) agrees with Stefan comments Hucheng (CATT) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2107619 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3323 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support multiple TACs for Satellite access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) has concerns on this approach and proposes to agree first on whether one or multiple TAC is reported to the AMF. Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that the principles need to agreed first, and also LS feedback from other groups is needed. Proposes to postpone CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) also proposes postponement Wanqiang (Huawei) OK to postpone the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2107620 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3197 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support multiple TACs for Satellite access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) has concerns on this approach and proposes to agree first on whether one or multiple TAC is reported to the AMF. Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that the principles need to be agreed first, and also LS feedback from other groups is needed. Proposes to postpone CR. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees with postponement to start afresh in November with more agreed principles Wanqiang (Huawei) OK to postpone the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2107345 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3288 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Tracking Area configuration in case of satellite access | Rakuten Mobile, Inc | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Relja (TNO) proposes to merge S2-2107345 into S2-2107578. Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) withdraw the CR and continue the discussion in AI#8.27 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Withdrawn |
| 8.11 | S2-2107446 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3301 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support of selecting a single TAI | CATT | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that the CR does not make any sense Hucheng (CATT) replies to the comment and proposes to further discuss how UE selects a suitable TAC. jean yves (thales) comments. Hucheng (CATT) replies to the comment. Hucheng (CATT) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) cannot agree the r00 or r01 and suggests postponement Yuxin (Xiaomi) suggests to postpone this CR Hucheng (CATT) is OK to postpone the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Location verification handling | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107230 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3030R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE location verification handling | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105528 from S2#146E. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107835 Revised to S2-2107835. | Jingran (OPPO) provides r01. Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to consider merging S2-2107230 and S2-2107333 Hannu (Nokia) supports the proposal to merge S2-2107230 and S2-2107333 and proposes to use S2-2107230 as the basis for further work. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Jingran and provides r02. Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Jean Yves and Shabnam Jingran (OPPO) replies to Hannu. Yuxin (Xiaomi) provides r03. Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that sequential location avoids complication and corner cases Jean Yves (Thales) comments on single or multiple MCC Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that the r04 is acceptable Yuxin (Xiaomi) supports r04 as final version Jean Yves (Thales) supports also r04 Hannu (Nokia) can live with r04 for now but expects that SA2 can make it more accurate when the decision on the MCC is done? ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2107835 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3030R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE location verification handling | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107230r04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107231 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2930R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE location verification handling | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105529 from S2#146E. Approved | Yuxin (Xiaomi) agrees to this CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.11 | S2-2107366 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3291 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Verification of UE Location | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that the changes do not seem needed and are redundant given the CR in S2-2107230 Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Stephen's comments and cannot agree with the CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107333 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3284 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.501 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107836 Revised to S2-2107836. | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2107230. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01, but also ok to merge into 7230 Yuxin (Xiaomi) agree to further discuss based on r01 jean yves (Thales) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) was under the assumption that this CR would be merged and proposes to POSTPONE as it's too late to revise it now. Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Hannu (Nokia) Hannu (Nokia) withdraws his opposition against this document based on explanation given by Yuxin. Reference from the new note in TS 23.501 to 23.503 clause 6.1.3.5 should be added, though. Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Hannu. Hannu (Nokia) accepts the offer to agree what we have got now and to clean up in next SA2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2107836 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3284R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.501 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107333r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107334 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3161 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.502 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107837 Revised to S2-2107837. | Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to consider merging S2-2107231 and S2-2107334 Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Hannu (Nokia) points out that the revised CR does not match the title. Hannu (Nokia) supports merging and proposes to merge 7334 to 7231. Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Stefan, Jean Yves Yuxin (Xiaomi) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) can agree r01 but not the original version ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2107837 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3161R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.502 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107334r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107335 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0659 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.503 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107838 Revised to S2-2107838. | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 Yuxin (Xiaomi) is fine with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2107838 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0659R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Editorial correction in TS 23.503 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107335r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107361 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3290 (Rel-17, 'D'): Clarification on RTD and Terminology Alignment | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107839 Revised to S2-2107839. | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2107839 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3290R1 (Rel-17, 'D'): Clarification on RTD and Terminology Alignment | Tencent, Tencent Cloud | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107361r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.11 | S2-2107568 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3318 (Rel-17, 'F'): Limited service PLMN selection for emergency | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Yuxin (Xiaomi) asks one question Hannu (Nokia) replies to Yuxin Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Hannu Hannu (Nokia) replies to Yuxin. Yuxin (Xiaomi) replies to Hannu and agrees to this CR. Hannu (Nokia) thanks Yuxin for support and promises to bring the corresponding network enforcement text for the next time. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services - Phase 2 (eV2XARC_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107043 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on Tx Profile | RAN WG2 (R2-2108995) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107218, S2-2107308 and S2-2107428. Final response in S2-2107840 | Replied to | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107218 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Tx Profile | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107043. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107840, merging S2-2107308 and S2-2107428 Revised to S2-2107840. | Ouyang(Huawei) comments LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answers to Ouyang (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2107840 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Tx Profile | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107218r02, merging S2-2107308 and S2-2107428. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107308 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Relay LS on Tx Profile | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107043. Merged into S2-2107840 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this LS to 7218 (LGE). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to get this LS noted or merged to 7218 (LGE). Hong (Qualcomm) is fine to merge. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.12 | S2-2107428 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Tx Profile | OPPO | Response to S2-2107043. Merged into S2-2107840 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this LS to 7218 (LGE). Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark it as merged or noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107216 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | NR Tx Profile related to PC5 DRX. | LG Electronics, Deutsche Telekom, ZTE, Tencent, vivo, Intel, CATT, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107217 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0165 (Rel-17, 'B'): NR Tx Profile | LG Electronics, Deutsche Telekom, ZTE, Tencent, vivo, Intel, CATT, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107841, merging S2-2107307 and S2-2107426 Revised to S2-2107841. | Ouyang(Huawei) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Ouyang (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answers. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02 and answers. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r04. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). Fei (OPPO) provides r05. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r05. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06. Ouyang(Huawei) comments on QC's note from r03-r06.. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Ouyang. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hong. LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2107841 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0165R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): NR Tx Profile | LG Electronics, Deutsche Telekom, ZTE, Tencent, vivo, Intel, CATT, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107217r06, merging S2-2107307 and S2-2107426. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107306 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Support of Tx Profile for SL DRX operation. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.12 | S2-2107307 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0166 (Rel-17, 'B'): Tx Profile support for NR PC5 | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107841 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this CR to 7217 (LGE et al). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) is fine to merge. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.12 | S2-2107426 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0167 (Rel-17, 'B'): Tx profile for V2X | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107841 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this CR to 7217 (LGE et al). Fei (OPPO) is ok to mark this CR as merged. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.12 | S2-2107552 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0168 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of ProSe communication path selection between PC5 and Uu reference points into eV2X | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR because this CR is out of scope of this WI. Ouyang(Huawei) replies. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) has same view with Hong (Qualcomm) and provides comment. LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). Fei (OPPO) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) shares same view as others, except Huawei/Hisilicon, and this is a Cat B CR for V2X which is not allowed/in scope. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.13 | - | - | - | 5G System Enhancement for Advanced Interactive Services (5G_AIS) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | Enhancement to the 5GC LoCation Services-Phase 2 (5G_eLCS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=25 | - | |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | Storage of UE positioning capabilities | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107042 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Response LS on storage of UE Positioning Capabilities | RAN WG2 (R2-2108960) | Rel-17 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS in. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107434 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0198 (Rel-17, 'F'): Delete FFS related to UE Positioning Capability | CATT | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2107784 (Approved). Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to merge 7434 into 7784. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107784 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0201 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of Editor's Note concerning storage of UE Positioning Capabilities | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107748 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0200 (Rel-17, 'F'): Store UE positioning capability in failed case | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107842 Revised to S2-2107842. | Åke (Ericsson) Claims CR not needed as justification is incorrect Cai Simon (Nokia) clarifies to Åke (Ericsson) Åke (Ericsson) Respond to clarification from Cai Cai Simon (Nokia) further clarifies to Åke (Ericsson) Yunjing(CATT) provides comments. Åke (Ericsson) Support CATT proposal to leave to stage-3 Cai Simon (Nokia) provides r01 based on comments from Åke (Ericsson) and Yunjing(CATT) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Yunjing (CATT) accepts r01. Åke (Ericsson) accepts r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.14 | S2-2107842 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0200R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Store UE positioning capability in failed case | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107748r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | PRUs for positioning enhancement | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.14 | S2-2106995 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG1: LS on Positioning Reference Units (PRUs) for enhancing positioning performance | RAN WG1 (R1-2106326) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105263 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107682. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107055 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on Positioning Reference Units | RAN WG3 (R3-214457) | Rel-17 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS in. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107682 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on PRU | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2106995. Postponed | Yunjing (CATT) provides r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that neither r00 nor r01 are acceptable Runze (Huawei) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm). Runze (Huawei ) is ok with r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) cannot agree r00 or r01 Yunjing (CATT) is ok to wait for RAN progress ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | Determination of location estimates | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107036 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG1: Reply LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | RAN WG1 (R1-2108509) | Rel-17 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107051 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | RAN WG3 (R3-214312) | Rel-17 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107040 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | RAN WG2 (R2-2108957) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107126, S2-2107437 and S2-2107783. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107126 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107040. Postponed | Åke (Ericsson) provide r01 Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the r01 Åke (Ericsson) Respond to comment on r01 from Qualcomm Yunjing (CATT) provides comments. Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to comments from Åke (Ericsson) Åke (Ericsson) Responds to Qualcomm Åke (Ericsson) Provides r02 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03 Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r04 Cai Simon (Nokia) supports r02 and r03, object to r04 Åke (Ericsson) Provides r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Cai Simon (Nokia) objects r05 since it is not from SA2 perspective Cai Simon (Nokia) provide r06 draft Stephen (Qualcomm) can only agree r04 and no other revs. Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Cai (Nokia) Cai Simon (Nokia) still supports r02/r03 and clarifies ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | S2-2107437 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | CATT | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107040. Postponed | Runze (Huawei) also proposes to take 7126 as the baseline. Yunjing (CATT) proposes to take 7126 as the baseline of the LS reply and merge 7437 into 7126. Åke (Ericsson) propose merge to S2-2107126 Yunjing(CATT) is fine to merge to S2-2107126 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) is fine with merger to S2-2107126 (if that gets approved) but cannot agree S2-2107437 by itself ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | S2-2107783 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response to Reply LS on determination of location estimates in local co-ordinates | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107040. Postponed | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to merge 7783 into 7126. Åke (Ericsson) propose merge to S2-2107126 Andy (Samsung, VC): The AI is wrong in the subject line. Stephen (Qualcomm) comments Åke (Ericsson) (re)propose merge to S2-2107126r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees merger to S2-2107126 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | S2-2107789 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0202 (Rel-17, 'F'): Identification of Position Methods not able to support Local Coordinates | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107843, merging S2-2107127 and S2-2107433 Revised to S2-2107843. | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to take 7433 as the baseline to remove the EN related to local co-ordinates and merge 7789 into 7433. Stephen (Qualcomm) proposes 7789 as baseline and explains why Åke (Ericsson) Supports using 7789 as baseline Yunjing (CATT) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm) Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Yunjing (CATT) and clarifies TS 23.032 Yunjing (CATT) is fine to use 7789 as baseline and provides r01. Runze (Huawei) supports r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) can also agree r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.14 | S2-2107843 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0202R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Identification of Position Methods not able to support Local Coordinates | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107789r01, merging S2-2107127 and S2-2107433. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107127 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0195 (Rel-17, 'F'): Remove Editors note on Local Co-ordinates | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107843 | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to take 7433 as the baseline to remove the EN related to local co-ordinates and merge 7127 into 7433. Åke (Ericsson) accept using S2-2107789 as baseline Yunjing (CATT) is fine to use S2-2107789 as baseline ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.14 | S2-2107433 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0197 (Rel-17, 'F'): Delete FFS related to local co-ordinates | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107843 | Stephen (Qualcomm) assumes this is now merged into S2-2107789 Yunjing(CATT) is fine to merge this CR into S2-2107789 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | Scheduled location time | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107041 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS to SA WG2 on scheduled location time | RAN WG2 (R2-2108958) | Rel-17 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS in. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2106994 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG1: Reply LS to SA WG2 on Scheduling Location in Advance | RAN WG1 (R1-2106312) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105262 from S2#146E. Noted | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS in. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.14 | S2-2107787 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0151R4 (Rel-17, 'B'): Addition of a Scheduled Location Time | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2102047 from S2#143E, (Postponed) S2-2104772 from S2#145E. Postponed | Cai Simon (Nokia) claims QoS in CR not consistent to stage 1 and not needed Yunjing (CATT) provides comments Stephen (Qualcomm) provides an r01 and responds to comments Åke (Ericsson) provides r02 Runze (Huawei) provides r03 Stephen (Qualcomm) provides an r04 Yunjing (CATT) asks questions for clarification. Runze (Huawei) provides r05. Runze (Huawei) replies to Yunjing (CATT) Yunjing (CATT) replies to Runze (Huawei). Runze (Huawei) thanks Yunjing (CATT). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Runze Stephen (Qualcomm) can agree the r00, r01, r02 and, as lowest priority, the r04. We cannot agree the r03 or r05. Runze (Huawei ) suggests to postpone the paper. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | S2-2107435 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3180 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add the Scheduled Location Time | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107681 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0199 (Rel-17, 'B'): Addition of a Scheduled Location Time | Huawei | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stephen (Qualcomm) comments and suggests to use S2-2107787 as a baseline ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) clarifies that merger into S2-2107787 is fine but S2-2107681 is not acceptable by itself Runze (Huawei) conditionally agrees to merge 7681 into 7787. The condition is r05 of 7787 is agreed. Otherwise both papers should be postponed. Runze (Huawei) requests to postpone the paper. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.14 | - | - | - | Other | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.14 | S2-2107432 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0196 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add timestamp of location estimate | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107844 Revised to S2-2107844. | Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on addition of a timestamp Runze (Huawei) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm). Yunjing (CATT) provides r01. Runze (Huawei) is ok with r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) is also okay with r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.14 | S2-2107844 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0196R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add timestamp of location estimate | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107432r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.15 | - | - | - | Multimedia Priority Service (MPS) Phase 2 (MPS2) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.16 | - | - | - | Dynamic management of group-based event monitoring (TEI17_GEM) | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.16 | S2-2107413 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3175 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates for service parameters regarding addition of UEs for group based event subscription | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107845 Revised to S2-2107845. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.16 | S2-2107845 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3175R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates for service parameters regarding addition of UEs for group based event subscription | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107413r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.16 | S2-2107414 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0484 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates for service parameters regarding addition of UEs for group based event subscription | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.17 | - | - | - | N7/N40 Interfaces Enhancements to Support GERAN and UTRAN (TEI17_NIESGU) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.18 | - | - | - | System enhancement for Redundant PDU Session (TEI17_SE_RPS) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.19 | - | - | - | IMS Optimization for HSS Group ID in an SBA environment (TEI17_IMSGID) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.19 | S2-2107319 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1248 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction in HSSGID procedures | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107846 Revised to S2-2107846. | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01. Ashok (Samsung) replies to Leo (Deutsche Telekom) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.19 | S2-2107846 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1248R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction in HSSGID procedures | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107319r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.20 | - | - | - | Support for Signed Attestation for Priority and Emergency Sessions (TEI17_SAPES) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.21 | - | - | - | Dynamically Changing AM Policies in the 5GC (TEI17_DCAMP) | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107029 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS on DCAMP related issues | CT WG3 (C3-214425) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107107 and S2-2107480. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107107 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS reply on DCAMP related issues | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107029. Postponed | Belen (Ericsson) asks to postpone this LS reply. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.21 | S2-2107480 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on DCAMP related issues | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107029. Postponed | Belen (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107107 Susan (Huawei) proposes to discuss the CR first and then decide to use which one as basis for the LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Belen (Ericsson) asks to postpone this LS reply. Susan (Huawei) is ok to postpone this LS reply. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.21 | S2-2107104 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3125 (Rel-17, 'F'): Use of the Application Identifier in the AF influence on AM policies procedure | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107105 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0650 (Rel-17, 'F'): Reporting the outcome of the AM Policy request fron the AF | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107106 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0651 (Rel-17, 'F'): Access and Mobility related Policy Authorization for a UE | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107214 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3142 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to procedure for AF influence on AM policies | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107215 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0655 (Rel-17, 'F'): Consistent usage of the term service area coverage throughout the TS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107267 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0657 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on 'geographic zone' | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.21 | S2-2107481 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3189 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to AF-triggered change of AM policies | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) provides r01, replies to Huawei and objects to the initial version. Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and cannot accept r01. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Susan comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Susan. Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept r02, replies to Susan. Pallab (Nokia) comments. Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04 replies to Susan ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and is ok with r04. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to POSTPONE the CR Belen (Ericsson) is okay to postpone Susan (Huawei) replies to Pallab (Nokia) and is ok to postpone the CR ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.21 | S2-2107482 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0662 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to AF-triggered change of AM policies | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108024 Revised to S2-2108024. | Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) provies r01, objets to the initial revisions and comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.21 | S2-2108024 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0662R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to AF-triggered change of AM policies | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107482r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.22 | - | - | - | IP address pool information from UDM (TEI17_IPU) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.23 | - | - | - | Same PCF selection for AMF and SMF (TEI17-SPSFAS) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.24 | - | - | - | Support of different slices over different Non-3GPP access (TEI17_N3SLICE) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | Minimization of Service Interruption (MINT) | - | - | Docs:=30 | - | |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107005 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG SA: Reply LS on the conclusion of FS_MINT-CT | TSG SA (SP-210581) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105307 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107157. Final response in S2-2108172 | Replied to | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107157 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on MINT functionality for Disaster Roaming | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107005. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108172 Revised to S2-2108172. | Qian (Ericsson) asks questions and provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook provides r02 in draft folder. Lalith(Samsung) is not OK with r01, because it is incomplete. Proposes this be discussed in CC#1b. OK with draft r02 shared in drafts folder. Qian (Ericsson) is ok with the proposed r02 in the DRAFTS folder. Haiyang (Huawei) is also ok with the proposed r02, which follows the discussion in other CR threads. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2108172 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on MINT functionality for Disaster Roaming | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107157r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.25 | S2-2106992 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on the final conclusion of FS_MINT-CT | CT WG1 (C1-213908) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105249 from S2#146E.CC#2: This LS was noted. | Noted | |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | Authentication, subscription | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107158 | DISCUSSION | Information | Authentication & Subscription info checking for Disaster Roaming service | LG Electronics, KT Corp., LG Uplus, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107159 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3251 (Rel-17, 'B'): Authentication and Subscription information checking for Disaster Roaming service | LG Electronics, KT Corp., LG Uplus, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2107847, merging S2-2107464 Revised to S2-2107847. | Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r02. Haris(Qualcomm) cannot agree to standardise both options, we suggest to only specify the signalling based option Haiyang (Huawei) thinks configuration based solution (e.g. from vivo) is better, and suggests to first check with SA3 if needed Haris(Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Lalith(Samsung) seeks clarification Wen(vivo) comments and provides some clarifications Hyunsook (LGE) provide a comment. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Hyunsook (LGE) reply to Haris (QC). Wen (vivo) comments and provides some thinking. Haiyang (Huawei) comments Hyunsook (LGE) provides the options for the way forward. Haris(Qualcomm) comments and provides r03 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r04. Lalith(Samsung) comments on r04. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r05. Wen (vivo) also can accept r05. Lalith(Samsung) ok with r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107847 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3251R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Authentication and Subscription information checking for Disaster Roaming service | LG Electronics, KT Corp., LG Uplus, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107159r05, merging S2-2107464. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107160 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3133 (Rel-17, 'B'): Authentication and Subscription information checking for Disaster Roaming service | LG Electronics, KT Corp., LG Uplus, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | Postponed | Wen (vivo) provides r02. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides r03. Haris(Qualcomm) cannot agree to standardise both options, we suggest to only specify the signalling based option Lalith(Samsung) seeks clarification Haiyang (Huawei) suggest to postpone the 502 CR. Haris(Qualcomm) agrees with Haiyang to postpone this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) can agree to postpone it. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.25 | S2-2107252 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3264 (Rel-17, 'C'): MINT updates | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2107848 Revised to S2-2107848. | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to merge it into 7159. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. Hyunsook (LGE) cannot agree the part on 'Disaster Roaming service indication to SMF/NF' in r01. Wen (vivo) have concerns on the 5G capability 'Minimization of service interruption in Disaster Condition'. Lalith(Samsung) provides comments. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Lalith (Samsung), Wen(Vivo) and Hyunsook (LGE). Wen (vivo) replies to Qian. Qian (Ericsson) asks further questions. Wen (vivo) replies to Qian (Ericsson). Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Lalith(Samsung) agrees with Hyunsook (LGE) Lalith(Samsung) comments. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02. Wen (vivo) comments, replies to Lalith(Samsung) and provides r03. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r04. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r05. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r06. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r06. Wen (vivo) is also fine with r06. Lalith (Samsung) is also fine with r06. Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r06. Alessio(Nokia) comments that r06 is ok BUT before upload needs substantial cleanup as it strikes out important clauses of the spec which must not be removed by accident (I make this comment to be on safe side) Qian (Ericsson) responds and thanks for the reminder ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107848 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3264R1 (Rel-17, 'C'): MINT updates | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107252r06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107253 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3146 (Rel-17, 'C'): Registration procedure improvement for MINT | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to merge it into 7160. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r01. Lalith(Samsung) comments on r01 Wen(vivo) comments on r01 Qian (Ericsson) responds to Wen (vivo) and Lalith (Samsung). Lalith(Samsung) provides comments Wen(vivo) comments and provides r02 Lalith(Samsung) provides r03 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r04 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r05 Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Haris(Qualcomm) asks question for clarification Hyunsook (LGE) responses to Haris (QC) Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Haiyang (Huawei) thinks Haris has a point and suggests to also postpone this CR Haris(Qualcomm) comments that is ok to go ahead with r05 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== To keep the consistency and neutral signal to CT1 about on-going CT1 discussion issue, Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to postpone it. Lalith(Samsung) proposes to agree r05. Alessio(Nokia) can live with r05 but please cleanup as it strikes out an important clause ?? Because there is still no conclusion in CT1 yet, Hyunsook (LGE) suggests to postpone it. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.25 | S2-2107463 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on disaster roaming | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107464 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3305 (Rel-17, 'B'): No need DC indication from AMF during DC roaming registration | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107847 | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to merge it into 7159. Lalith(Samsung) supports this paper but OK to discuss in 7159. Haiyang (Huawei) shares similar view with Lalith (Samsung) Wen (vivo) is ok to merge this paper into 7159 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.25 | S2-2107465 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3183 (Rel-17, 'B'): EN resolve of how AUSF executes authentication | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107160 (Postponed) | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to merge it into 7160. Lalith(Samsung) supports this paper but OK to discuss in 7160. Haiyang (Huawei) shares similar view with Lalith (Samsung) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wen (vivo) : this paper can be marked as merging into 7160 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.25 | S2-2107466 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3184 (Rel-17, 'B'): EN resolve of how UDM provides subscription data | vivo | Rel-17 | Confirm CR Number - CR states -3184! Postponed | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to merge it into 7160. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wen (vivo) : this paper can be marked as merging into 7160 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | Session Management | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107162 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3134 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Disaster Roaming registration | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Saad (Interdigital) provides a comment Hyunsook (LGE) asks the suggested text to Interdigital. Saad (Interdigital) asks to clarify the scenario Hyunsook (LGE) response to Saad (Interdigital) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) thinks we can approve r00 in this meeting. Saad (IDCC) is Ok with approving r00 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Agreed |
| 8.25 | S2-2107254 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3147 (Rel-17, 'C'): Session procedure improvement for MINT | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Hyunsook (LGE) doesn't prefer to extend the indication for the session management at this stage. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Hyunsook (LGE). Haiyang(Huawei) also think the indication for the session management is not necessary, and suggests to also check with SA3 if an LS on this is required. Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to note it in this meeting. Haiyang(Huawei) agrees to note this paper. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | Deregistration | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107467 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3306 (Rel-17, 'B'): Deregistration after disaster condition is no longer applicable | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107160 (Postponed) | Lalith(Samsung) comments Hyunsook (LGE) agrees with Samsung's comment. Qian (Ericsson) supports the view from LGE and Samsung. Wen (vivo) is ok to postpone. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.25 | S2-2107514 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3311 (Rel-17, 'B'): Deregistration for UE not eligible for disaster roaming service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107849 Revised to S2-2107849. | Qian (Ericsson) comments and proposes to postpone the paper Hyunsook (LGE) also supports to postpone it. Haiyang(Huawei) clarifies this paper is not touching the exact procedures. Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Lalith(Samsung) shares view with Haiyang(Huawei) Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01 Haiyang(Huawei) provides r02 as an alt. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) prefers r03. Haiyang(Huawei) is OK with r03. Qian (Ericsson) comments. Hyunsook (LGE) comments. Haris(Qualcomm) accepts only r03 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107849 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3311R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Deregistration for UE not eligible for disaster roaming service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107514r03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | - | - | - | General/other | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107344 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3287 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MINT | Rakuten Mobile, Inc | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107850 Revised to S2-2107850. | Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) is fine with r01 Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) responds to the clarification Hyunsook (LGE) asks for the clarification. Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) answers to the clarification Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02. Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) is fine with r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r02. Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107850 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3287R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MINT | Rakuten Mobile, Inc | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107344r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107398 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3294 (Rel-18, 'F'): Applicability of states of non-3GPPA and clarifications. | Samsung | Rel-18 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107851 Revised to S2-2107851. | Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR Saad (Interdigital) provides r01 Lalith(Samsung) comments replies to Haris(Qualcomm) Lalith(Samsung) comments on r01 Lalith(Samsung) provides r02 Saad(Interdigital) is fine with the initial wording ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107851 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3294R1 (Rel-18, 'F'): Applicability of states of non-3GPPA and clarifications. | Samsung | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107398r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107411 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3174 (Rel-17, 'F'): MINT and EPC interworking. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107852 Revised to S2-2107852. | Haris(Qualcomm) comments Hyunsook (LGE) agrees to Haris(Qualcomm)'s comment Lalith(Samsung) replies to Hyunsook (LGE) and Haris(Qualcomm) and provides r01 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02. Lalith(Samsung) ok with r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.25 | S2-2107852 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3174R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): MINT and EPC interworking. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107411r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107420 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on AMF determination of PLMN with disaster condition. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107425 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3298 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF determination of PLMN with disaster condition | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Hyunsook (LGE) thinks the information on disaster PLMN will be configured via OAM when the disaster condition occurs, so we have no issue. Qian (Ericsson) comments that UE shall determine the registered/selected PLMN is having disaster condition first before asking for the disaster roaming service in the forbidden PLMNs. Lalith(Samsung) replies to Qian (Ericsson) comments Lalith(Samsung) replies to Hyunsook (LGE) Hyunsook (LGE) has a comment. Qian (Ericsson) provides response to Lalith (Samsung) Lalith (Samsung) provides r01 Hyunsook (LGE) comments on r01 Lalith (Samsung) provides r02 Haris(Qualcomm) comments that the CR is unecessary since we don't need EN as proposed in r02 Lalith(Samsung) replies to Haris(Qualcomm) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this CR as it seems also that other CR adds the possibility the AMF configures the UE with the list... and anyhow if CT1 decides something in a contribution driven manner we can align. Lalith(Samsung) replies to Alessio(Nokia) insist on agreeing the CR Haris(Qualcomm) cannot (still) understand the problem ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.25 | S2-2107161 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3252 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Disaster Roaming service | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.25 | S2-2107531 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3315 (Rel-17, 'C'): Closing Editor's Notes for MINT | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to postpone it. Haris(Qualcomm) comments and agrees with LGE and Samsung to postpone the CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.26 | - | - | - | Architecture Enhancement for NR Reduced Capability Devices (ARCH_NR_REDCAP) | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107023 | LS In | Information | Reply LS on lower bound for eDRX cycle length | CT WG1 (C1-214961) | Rel-17 | Noted | Miguel (Qualcomm) proposes this incoming LS to be NOTED. Alignment was done at SA2#146E and no need to reply to CT1 LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.26 | S2-2106998 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on lower bound for eDRX cycle length | RAN WG2 (R2-2106537) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105269 from S2#146E. Noted | Miguel (Qualcomm) proposes this incoming LS to be NOTED. Alignment was done at SA2#146E and no need to reply. Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Miguel to note the LS. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.26 | S2-2107255 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on introducing NR RedCap Indication | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107853 Revised to S2-2107853. | Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02 and explains changes. Also please disregard r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r02. Hannu (Nokia) prefers r02. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.26 | S2-2107853 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on introducing NR RedCap Indication | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107255r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107256 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3265 (Rel-17, 'C'): NR RedCap Indication during IRAT handover procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107257 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3148 (Rel-17, 'F'): Introduction of NR RedCap Indication in UE context | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2107854 Revised to S2-2107854. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) withdraws his latest comment on 7257 as it was intended on different document. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.26 | S2-2107854 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3148R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Introduction of NR RedCap Indication in UE context | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107257r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107554 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3316 (Rel-17, 'B'): EDRX enhancement for 10.24s cycle for RedCap | China Mobile | Rel-17 | CC#2: This was postponed. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r02. Miguel (Qualcomm) questions the proposed solution Hannu (Nokia) seconds the questions from Miguel? Aihua(CMCC) replies and provides r03. Chris (Vodafone) provides r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) provides r05 in draft folder. Hannu (Nokia) can live with r04 but prefers r05 even though it's a late revision Wanqiang (Huawei) provides r06 in draft folder. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.26 | S2-2107625 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3324 (Rel-17, 'B'): Capabilities for NR RedCap UE | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2107855 Revised to S2-2107855. | Qian (Ericsson) asks a question Miguel (Qualcomm) questions the proposed way forward for handling the limit of 8 DRBs. Hannu (Nokia) supports considering Miguel's Option 2 but provides r01 for terminology consistency. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02, removing 8 DRB text Steve (Huawei) is ok with r02 Chris (Vodafone) comments that clean CR should not delete 5.6.1 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 where clause 5.6.1 is intended to be removed from the CR and not deleted from the TS! Miguel (Qualcomm) confirms r02 intention is to remove from CR all changes to clause 5.6.1. (and not to remove the section from TS). Steve (Huawei) that was our understand too, we will drop clause 5.6.1 from the CR (not the TS!) in clean-up. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.26 | S2-2107855 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3324R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Capabilities for NR RedCap UE | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107625r02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107626 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3198 (Rel-17, 'B'): UP resources establishment for NR RedCap UE | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Miguel (Qualcomm) questions the proposed way forward for handling the limit of 8 DRBs. Miguel (Qualcomm) proposes to note this CR. Steve (Huawei) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) it's fine to note. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.26 | S2-2107729 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3346 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on Paging for extended idle mode DRX in E-UTRA and NR connected to 5GC | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.26 | S2-2107757 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3349 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of Access Restriction for RedCap | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | - | - | - | Architecture support for NB-IoT/eMTC Non-Terrestrial Networks in EPS (IoT_SAT_ARCH_EPS) | - | - | Docs:=23 | - | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107017 | LS In | Action | LS on EPS support for IoT NTN in Rel-17 | TSG RAN (RP-212617) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107543, S2-2107576 and S2-2107732. Postponed | Guillaume (MediaTek) opens the discussion. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Guillaume (MediaTek) comments Chris (Vodafone) comments Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Sherry (Xiaomi) provides comments and questions Hannu (Nokia) is reluctant to make implementation changes if Rel-18 will include more requirements. Timer configuration update without implementation change would be acceptable. Chris (Vodafone) replies to Ericson, Xiaomi and Nokia Stefan (Ericsson) provides replies to Chris Chris (Vodafone) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) Chris (Vodafone) provides specification extracts to show that HLCOM can work as described in the CR in S2-2107723 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Tao(VC) check in this thread on the way forward between LS OUT 7543/7577, which to go with Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Tao Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Tao (again) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.27 | S2-2107047 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on supporting discontinuous coverage in IoT NTN | RAN WG2 (R2-2109213) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107732. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107543 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on EPS support for IoT NTN in Rel-17 | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107017. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107576 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on EPS support for IoT NTN in Rel-17 | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107017. CC#2: r01 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2108176. | Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r01 in the Drafts folder. Relja (TNO) supports r01. Hannu (Nokia) supports r01 and considers late revision justified as it reflects the discussions during the meeting. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.27 | S2-2108176 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on EPS support for IoT NTN in Rel-17 | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107576r01 + changes. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107732 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on LS on EPS support for IoT NTN in Rel-17 & LS on supporting discontinuous coverage in IoT NTN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107017 and S2-2107047. Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107444 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3661 (Rel-17, 'B'): Handover enhancement for IoT NTN in EPS | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2108027 | Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to merge in S2-2107737 Jingran(OPPO) agree to merge this CR in S2-2107737 but S2-2107737 need some clarification. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.27 | S2-2107445 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0485 (Rel-17, 'B'): Clarify MBMS is not supported in IoT NTN in EPS | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris(Qualcomm) comments that this restriction is probably better captured in TS 23.246 Jingran(OPPO) replies to Haris and provides r01. Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r01 Sherry(Xiaomi) comments. Jingran(OPPO) replies to Sherry(Xiaomi) and Haris(Qualcomm) and provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) objects to all revisions ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.27 | S2-2107534 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3662 (Rel-17, 'B'): LTE-M NTN identification | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) the CR brings changes not needed compared to LTE-M differentiation in terrestrial access. Dongeun (Samsuing) has same view with Huawei. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Chris (Vodafone) responds to Haris Sherry (Xiaomi) comments Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) comments Steve (Huawei) This CR should be noted. Haris(Qualcomm) comments that the statement from Stephen (Huawei) is incorrect Chris (Vodafone) replies to Qualcomm Haris(Qualcomm) comments that the indication is conveyed to MME in Initial UE Message Steve (Huawei) comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) objects to all revisions. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.27 | S2-2107577 | DISCUSSION | Decision | EPS IoT NTN: discussion on RAN LS (S2-2107017/RP-212617). | MediaTek Inc., Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107578 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3663 (Rel-17, 'B'): Introduction of Satellite support for Cellular IoT | MediaTek Inc., Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2108025 Revised to S2-2108025. | Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01 Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Haris (Qualcomm) Steve (Huawei) a few questions for clarification Haris(Qualcomm) responds to Guillaume Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) answers. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) responds to Haris. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r02 Wanqiang (Huawei) comments the WB-E-UTRAN NTN part. Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments on should to shall Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Aoken (Rakuten Mobile) Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r03 and replies to Sherry (Xiaomi) Haris(Qualcomm) asks Wanqiang to check the status of the 36.300 CR with his RAN2 colleagues Haris(Qualcomm) comments that clause 4.x.2 needs to be considered also together with S2-2107534 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r04. Wanqiang (Huawei) is ok with the WB-E-UTRAN NTN part. Steve (Huawei) Supports the CR and wishes to cosign. Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Stefan and provides r05 Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Steve (Huawei). Haris(Qualcomm) provides r06 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r07 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) supports r07. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.27 | S2-2108025 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3663R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Introduction of Satellite support for Cellular IoT | MediaTek Inc., Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107578r07. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107579 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0486 (Rel-17, 'B'): Introduction of Satellite support for Cellular IoT | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.401!. Confirm Spec version used - CR states 17.2.0! Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes that the CR is to be postponed to wait for the high level decision on discontinuous coverage (mainly which release should address it). Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note 7579 or merge it in 7723. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees with postponement ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.27 | S2-2107622 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on system impact of discontinuous coverage in IoT NTN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01 Chris (Vodafone) comments that r01 is not needed but provides r02 to further clarify. Chris (Vodafone) comments that his and Haris' comments addressed 7737 not 7622. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.27 | S2-2107623 | CR | Approval | 23.271 CR0436 (Rel-17, 'B'): LCS enhancement for IoT NTN in EPS | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108026 Revised to S2-2108026. | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wanqiang (Huawei) ok with r01 Stefan (Ericsson) ok with r01 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.27 | S2-2108026 | CR | Approval | 23.271 CR0436R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): LCS enhancement for IoT NTN in EPS | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107623r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107624 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0487 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support IoT NTN in EPS | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107723 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3667 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support for IoT NTN with discontinuous coverage | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 to clarify the cover page text. Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the CR Chris (Vodafone) asks Haris(Qualcomm) to respond to the technical aspects. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r02 Haris(Qualcomm) re-iterates his objection to all revisions Chris (Vodafone) replies to Qualcomm Chris (Vodafone) provides r03 Wanqiang (Huawei) comments rushing a temporary solution/depending on too many implementations is really not a good approach. Chris replies to Huawei. Actually this Q&A/debate seems to show that this may well be a good long term solution. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Thierry (Novamint) supports r03 as we believe it is a good proposal aiming at a simple solution Haris(Qualcomm) objects to any revision Wanqiang(Huawei) proposes to postpone Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) supports r03 Hannu (Nokia) supports r03 of this CR. Chris (Vodafone) provides technical answers to respond to Qualcomm's objection to the CR. Wanqiang (Huawei) feedback to Chris Chris (Vodafone) replies to Huawei > Chris (Vodafone) replies to Huawei > Relja (TNO) support r03 and provides some comments. Ramon Ferrus (Sateliot) support r03 and provides some comments. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.27 | S2-2107737 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3668 (Rel-17, 'C'): IoT NTN: Ensure use of MME in the country where UE is located | Vodafone | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108027, merging S2-2107444 Revised to S2-2108027. | Chris (Vodafone) comments that r01 is not needed but provides r02 to further clarify. Hannu (Nokia) comments that r01 is not wrong, but prefers either the original version or r02. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Chris (Vodafone) replies to Xiaomi. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.27 | S2-2108027 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3668R1 (Rel-17, 'C'): IoT NTN: Ensure use of MME in the country where UE is located | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107737r02, merging S2-2107444. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107621 | CR | Approval | 23.203 CR1136 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support policy and QoS control for satellite access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108028 Revised to S2-2108028. | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) is ok with r01 for this meeting but some more change is needed Wanqiang (Huawei) is ok with r01. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.27 | S2-2108028 | CR | Approval | 23.203 CR1136R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support policy and QoS control for satellite access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107621r01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.27 | S2-2107580 | WID REVISED | Approval | Revised WID on IoT_SAT_ARCH_EPS | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Postponed | Guillaume (MediaTeK Inc.) provides r01 Haris(Qualcomm) comments that the completion date has to be pushed by at least 1Q Hannu (Nokia) can't agree with r01. The initial version is fine. Sherry (Xiaomi) agrees with Hannu (Nokia) to not include discontinuous coverage in the WID. Guillaume provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) can't agree r02 either. The initial version is still fine. Stefan (Ericsson) suggests to consider r01 and an exception instead of changing WID timeline Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Hannu Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Stefan Hannu (Nokia) answers to Guillaume Wanqiang (Huawei) replies to Hannu Hannu (Nokia) asks whether we should then postpone also the WID update until we know what we are doing? Hannu (Nokia) replies to Guillaume Haris(Qualcomm) suggests to follow the WPs Thierry (Novamint) supports r01 or r02 as we believe there are some low hanging fruits and simple solutions that can be addressed in R17 in order to provide basic support for discontinuous coverage (as illustrated by the CR from Vodafone) ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | Rel-17 CAT B/C alignment CR(s) due to the work led by other 3GPP Working Groups | - | - | Docs:=53 | - | |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | UE Power Saving (NR_UE_pow_sav_enh) | - | - | Docs:=19 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107050 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG3: LS on RAN3 work associated with UE Power Saving | RAN WG3 (R3-214281) | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this LS as it is CC'd to SA2 with no action to us. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2106999 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on Paging Subgrouping | RAN WG2 (R2-2106552) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2105272 from S2#146E. Response drafted in S2-2107582. Final response in S2-2107856 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107582 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Paging Subgrouping | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2106999. Merged into S2-2107856 | Steve (Huawei) as per CC#1, this LS should is merged with S2-2107627 or noted, as 7627 is the one we worked in. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107768 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion related to incoming LS on Paging Early Indication (S2-2106999) | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) it's a discussion paper, it should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2107038 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on UE Power Saving | RAN WG2 (R2-2108917) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107627. Final response in S2-2107856 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107627 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on UE Power Saving | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107038. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2107856, merging S2-2107582 Revised to S2-2107856. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r03 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r03. Re-send to corrected the wrong AI in the subject as well now. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) prefers the latest version in r03. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.): r03 is ok Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107856 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on UE Power Saving | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107627r03, merging S2-2107582. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107628 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3325 (Rel-17, 'B'): Paging Subgrouping Assistance for UE Power Saving | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107857 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107629 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3199 (Rel-17, 'B'): Paging Subgrouping for UE Power Saving | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107858 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107258 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3266 (Rel-17, 'B'): Paging subgroup support for power saving | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107857 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107259 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3149 (Rel-17, 'B'): Paging subgroup support for power saving | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107858 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107583 | DISCUSSION | Decision | Support for Paging Early Indication (PEI). | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107584 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3319 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support for Paging Early Indication | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | r17 agreed. Revised to S2-2107857, merging S2-2107258, S2-2107628 and S2-2107758 Revised to S2-2107857. | Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) opens the discussion and provides r01. As per CC#1 this thread addresses: 7584, 7628, 7758 Chris (Vodafone) requests that this CR also addresses the issues raised in the discussion document in S2-2107768 (e.g. behaviour consistent across all AMFs, etc) Steve (Huawei) comments Miguel (Qualcomm) provides multiple comments and r02. Chris (Vodafone) provides comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to the comments and provides r03. Hannu (Nokia) shares r04. Hannu (Nokia) provides r05 after having compared the terminology with the one used in S2-2107760. Steve (Huawei) comments, provides r06. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r07 Tricci (OPPO) thanks Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) to clean up the revisions and would like to propose further clarifications in r08. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r09. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) for your kind acceptance of my request and agrees with r09. Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r10. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r11. Qian (Ericsson) comments and is ok with r11. Sudeep (Apple) indicates support for revision r11. Hannu (Nokia) provides r12 proposing to leave the UE PEIPS Assistance Information TBD together with RAN2. Chris (Vodafone) provides r13. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides comments on r13, especially on removing UE support to RAN indication Chris (Vodafone) replies to Qualcomm Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r14 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r14 Miguel (Qualcomm) clarifies r14 is from Mediatek Guillaume (MediaTek): indicates r14 was already provided :) Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r15 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r16 Steve (Huawei) r16 looks good Miguel (Qualcomm) also ok with r16 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r17 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) thanks everybody for good work and proposes to agree r17. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r17. Qian (Ericsson) is also ok with r17. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107857 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3319R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support for Paging Early Indication | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107584r17, merging S2-2107258, S2-2107628 and S2-2107758. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107585 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3195 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support for Paging Early Indication | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107858 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107758 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3350 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of Paging subgrouping | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107857 | Merged | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107760 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3216 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of Paging subgrouping | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.501. Cover sheet needs correcting to 23.502. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107858, merging S2-2107259, S2-2107585 and S2-2107629 Revised to S2-2107858. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 in attempt to align 23.502 text with S2-2107584. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Qian (Ericsson) provides r03. Tricci (OPPO) asks Qian (Ericsson) to clarify why r03 is considered as the alignment with 7584r10 as there are still references, e.g. UE PEIPS Assistance Information, which have been removed from 7584r10 but not in 7760. OPPO cannot accept any version of 7760 as it is. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Tricci (OPPO) Sudeep (Apple) support r03. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Qian (Ericsson) response and keeps the same position not to accept any revision of this CR. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Tricci (OPPO) with further clarification Hannu (Nokia) shares the view of Tricci and provides r04 to align with S2-2107584r12. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to try to agree baseline versions of 7584 and 7760 in this meeting rather than postponing the whole CRs. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Hannu (Nokia) to provide r04 and OPPO supports r04. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Hannu (Nokia) again to propose the latest revisions on both 7584 and 7760 and OPPO supports both latest versions r12 and r04 respectively. Steve (Huawei) provides r05 for paging in CIoT and cosigns. Miguel (Qualcomm) ok with r04, has question on r05 for Steve, will add Apple as cosigner in final version Steve (Huawei) good thought, let's stick with r04. Chris (Vodafone) comments that we will need to add UE Capability Update allocation of the subgroup in a future meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) supports the recommendation from the others to agree r04 even though it is not the latest revision. Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) supports r04 Qian (Ericsson) supports also r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107858 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3216R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of Paging subgrouping | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107760r04, merging S2-2107259, S2-2107585 and S2-2107629. Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107778 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | NAS Signaling for IDLE/INACTIVE UE Paging Subgrouping for enhanced UE Power Saving | Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) it's a discussion paper, it should be noted. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | NSWO architecture (FS_NSWO_5G) | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107064 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on proposed NSWO architecture | SA WG3 (S3-213174) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107099, S2-2107502 and S2-2107642. Final response in S2-2107859 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107749 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | On the LS reply to SA WG3 LS on NSWO architecture (FS_NSWO_5G; S2-2107064) | Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the document and concentrate on 7502 Saso (Intel): OK to note ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2107099 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on proposed NSWO architecture | Intel | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107064. Merged into S2-2107859 | Laurent (Nokia): I suggest we take S2-2107502 Saso (Intel): OK to merge in 7502 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107502 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on proposed NSWO architecture | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107064. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107859, merging S2-2107099 and S2-2107642 Revised to S2-2107859. | Laurent (Nokia): I suggest we take S2-2107502 Stefan (Ericsson) also thinks that 7502 can be used as basis for discussion. And provides r02. Saso (Intel) provides r03. Hualin(Huawei) comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Hualin (Huawei). Haris(Qualcomm) provides r04 Saso (Intel) provides r05. Farooq (AT&T) provide r06 with some cleanup text. Hualin(Huawei) provide r07. Stefan (Ericsson) cannot accept r07, proposes to use r06 Saso (Intel) objects to r07 Hualin(Huawei) objects to r06 and propose to take r04 as compromise way ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to R02, R03. Saso (Intel) can live with r04; prefers r06. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107859 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on proposed NSWO architecture | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107502r04, merging S2-2107099 and S2-2107642. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107642 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on proposed NSWO architecture | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107064. Merged into S2-2107859 | Laurent (Nokia): I suggest we take S2-2107502 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | Security of AMF re-allocation (FS_AMFREAL_SEC) | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107061 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | SA WG3 (S3-213035) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107091, S2-2107261, S2-2107470 and S2-2107631. Final response in S2-2107860 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107091 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107061. Merged into S2-2107860 | Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes to merge this LS into 7470 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107261 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107061. Merged into S2-2107860 | Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes to merge this LS into 7470 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107331 | LS OUT | Agreement | [DRAFT] LS Response to S2-2107061 | NEC Corporation | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107860 | Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes to merge this LS into 7470 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107332 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3160 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSAC procedure when multiple APNs associated with same S-NSSAI | NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107865 | Qian (Ericsson) propose to merge this into 7260 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107471 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3186 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of the Registration Request message in AMF reallocation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107865 | Qian (Ericsson) propose to merge this into 7260 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107260 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3150 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on rerouted Registration Request message | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Should not use a FS WI for a TS update. r10 endorsed. Revised to S2-2107865, merging S2-2107332 and S2-2107471 | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r02 to correct the related WIs Jinguo(ZTE) comments on r02 Qian (Ericsson) responds to Jinguo (ZTE) Alessio ( Nokia ) proposes a way forward Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes a r03 Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r04. Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to go with r03. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei). Fenqin (Huawei) provides r05. alessio(Nokia) cannot accept agreeing any CR at this meeting, but we could technical endorse .... provides r06 Genadi (Lenovo) comments. Qian (Ericsson) comments and share the view from Genadi (Lenovo) and provide r07. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r07. Genadi (Lenovo) agrees with r07 provided by Qian (Ericsson). My r07 was not uploaded correctly and there is no need to upload it any more. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r08. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Kundan(NEC)is fine with revision 8. Qian(Ericsson)comments and provides r09. We can endorse the r09. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r10. Alessio(nokia) can only agree to technically endorse r10, not to agree to it. the CR we send to SA should take the SA3 final decision on this into account. Kundan(NEC) also supports to endorse the r10 and agree after receiving feedback from the SA3. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qian (Ericsson) also supports to endorse r10. Alessio(Nokia) supports to endorse r10. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107865 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3150R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on rerouted Registration Request message | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107260r10, merging S2-2107332 and S2-2107471. Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107470 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | Huawei,HiSilicon | Response to S2-2107061. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2107860, merging S2-2107091, S2-2107261, S2-2107331 and S2-2107631 Revised to S2-2107860. | Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes a r01 Alessio(Nokia) proposes a r02 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r03 Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes a r04 Qian ( Ericsson) is ok with r04 Genadi (Lenovo) is fine with r04. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== alessio(Nokia) is fine with r04. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107860 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Response on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | SA WG2 | - | Revision of S2-2107470r04, merging S2-2107091, S2-2107261, S2-2107331 and S2-2107631. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107631 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response to LS on full registration request message to be rerouted via RAN | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107061. Merged into S2-2107860 | Fenqin ( Huawei ) proposes to merge this LS into 7470 Alessio(Nokia) ok ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | SBA for GBA (GBA_5G) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107066 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on SBA for GBA | SA WG3 (S3-213215) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2107263. Final response in S2-2107793 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107263 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to LS on SBA for GBA | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107066. Revised to S2-2107793. | Revised | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107793 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS to LS on SBA for GBA | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107263. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107262 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3267 (Rel-17, 'F'): GBA reference points | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | UPIP (UPIP_SEC_LTE) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107650 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3327 (Rel-17, 'F'): EPS User Plane Integrity Protection corrections for Service Request and mixed eNB UPIP support; etc in TS 23.501. | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107651 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3205 (Rel-17, 'F'): EPS User Plane Integrity Protection corrections for Service Request and mixed eNB UPIP support; etc in TS 23.502. | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Approved | Agreed | |
| 8.28 | - | - | - | NSAC / NSSAA | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107039 | LS In | Action | LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | RAN WG2 (R2-2108928) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted in S2-2107272, S2-2107507, S2-2107555, S2-2107638 and S2-2107734. Final response in S2-2107861 | Replied to | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107272 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107039. r11 agreed. Revised to S2-2107861, merging S2-2107507, S2-2107555, S2-2107638 and S2-2107734 Revised to S2-2107861. | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Dan (China Mobile) provide r02. The r01 I think is updated by Ericsson experts and in revision box Haiyang (Huawei) provides r03 Alessio(Nokia) cannot accept using this type of LS as a response (i.e object) for the reasons explained. we would like to sue lenovo's as a basis. Mike (Convida Wireless) provides r04 alessio(Nokia) proposes to mark S2-2107272 merged into S2-2107734 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r05 Dan (China Mobile) provides r06 with simplifying the questions for RAN Tricci (OPPO) thanks everyone to provide the prior versions and proposes r07 for editorial suggestions. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r08 Tricci (OPPO) thanks Peter Hedman (Ericsson) for clarifications and provides r08. OPPO is okay with r08. Dan (China Mobile) provides r09 Genadi (Lenovo) provides r10. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r11. alessio(nokia) agrees with Stefano and also does not agree to include any attachment to this LS as we have no time to continue discussing a CR (which is too baseless at this meeting to include!) provides r12. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r13 based on r12. Dan(China Mobile) would like to check with Alessio, whether the version for r12 is correct or not ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dan(China Mobile) provide r14 in draft folder Stefano (Qualcomm) cannot accept R12 and R13 because based on R10, not R11. Cannot accept R14 (post deadline). R11 is fine. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r11 (as only revision so far without objections) Dan (China Mobile) ok with r11 alessio (nokia) can live with r11 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 8.28 | S2-2107861 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107272r11, merging S2-2107507, S2-2107555, S2-2107638 and S2-2107734. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.28 | S2-2107507 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107039. Merged into S2-2107861 | Alessio(Nokia) COMMENTS on this LS Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 and use that as basis Haiyang (Huawei) is OK to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 and use that as basis for the discussion alessio(Nokia) prefers to use lenovo's reply LS in S2-2107734 as basis ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107555 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107039. Merged into S2-2107861 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 and use that as basis ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107638 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response to LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107039. Merged into S2-2107861 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 and use that as basis Alessio(nokia) can only accept the LS by LENOVO or our LS as basis. Dan(China Mobile) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) propose to mark the LS as merged into 07272 and questioning the non-technical resistance to use other LS out ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107734 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response to LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2107039. Merged into S2-2107861 | Alessio(Nokia) COMMENTS on this LS Genadi (Lenovo) provides further comments before providing a revision. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as merged into S2-2107272 and use that as basis alessio(nokia) indeed we need to ask them whether RACH grouping should be configured by NAS or not, and whether the granularity of the slice groups for RACH and cell reselection are per cell, TA or PLMN, and finally whether the groups are same or different for RACH and cell reselection. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments that questions asked to be added are in principle already part of LS out in 07272 Genadi (Lenovo) is fine to mark S2-2107734 merged into S2-2107272. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Merged |
| 8.28 | S2-2107287 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3272 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of slice priority and slice group information for cell (re)selection | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2107556 (Noted) | Dan (China Mobile) reply to Mike(Convida Wireless), Mike (Convida Wireless) expresses concerns about the CR and provides r01. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments. Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this CR Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments. Dan(China Mobile) reply Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Alessio(Nokia) as already stated we can support studying the topic in rel-18 but defining a slice priority scheme in rel-17 is not feasible. the CR by Ericsson is not agreeable. nor any other CR at this meeting. Serge (T-Mobile USA) also has concerns and objects to this CR. Dan (China Mobile) would like to merge this paper to 2107556, and let's use that one for further update. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2107535 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3194 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of slice priority and slice group information for cell (re)selection | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Mike (Convida Wireless) expresses concerns about the CR. Dan (China Mobile) reply Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this CR also ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2107508 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on Slice Group and slice priority. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and do not agree on the analysis ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 8.28 | S2-2107556 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3317 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling slice priority and slice groups for RRM purposes | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) comments on this paper Mike (Convida Wireless) expresses concerns about part of the CR and provides r01. Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note the CR Alessio(Nokia) concurs a deterministic behaviour could be preferable but to achieve that we believe we need to study this in rel-18 as part of the improved UE control by network operators. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and objects to r01 alessio(Nokia) can only agree a simple LS response at this meeting and no CRs. Objects to any revision of this CR. we need to know more form RAN2. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 to remove all the priority related description Mike (Convida Wireless) comments Stefano (Qualcomm) cannot accept any revision of any CRs or WIDs with solutions to this problem at this meeting. Dan (China Mobile) suggest we can create an initial version in this meeting Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 alessio(Nokia) reconfirms objection to approving any revision of this CR ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) would prefer to agree a revison (e.g. r03) as technically endorsed (as basis for further work) alessio(Nokia) is not as pessimistic as Peter. there is no need to endorse a CR that is for now not well grounded on stable requirements. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9 | - | - | - | Project Planning and Management | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | New and Revised Work Items, TS/TR Cover sheets, Exception Sheets | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 9.1.1 | - | - | - | Rel-17 new and revised Work Items | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 9.1.1 | S2-2107273 | WID NEW | Approval | New WID on 5G Architecture Enhancements for RAN Slicing for NR | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) provides r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 and comments Alessio(Nokia) objects to this WID at this meeting Mike (Convida Wireless) objects to r02 and provides r03 Dan (China Mobile) provides r04 Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan (China Mobile) to provide the update and proposes r05 for more neutral language for bullet one for the UE. Dan (China Mobile) reply and provide r06 Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan (China Mobile) for the prompt update and would like to r07 to clarify the merge bullet. Dan(China Mobile) provide r08 Tricci (OPPO) asks Dan(China Mobile) for further clarification before the next revision. Dan (China Mobile) answer to Tricci. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan (China Mobile) for the clarifications and proposes new wordings. Dan (China Mobile) reply r05 is Ok for me Tricci (OPPO) asks Dan (China Mobile) to clarify 'how' the UE to obtain the info and can't accept any version at this point. Alessio(Nokia) reconfirms objection to any WID approval at this meeting. Dan(China Mobile) reply Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan(China Mobile) reply and asks for further clarifications. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan (China Mobile) for your kind response and OPPO can only accept r07. Dan (China Mobile) think r07 also OK. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Dan (China Mobile) to accept r07. Stefano (Qualcomm) supports Nokia and does not see the need for such detailed discussion and objects to any revisions of this WID at this meeting. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.2 | - | - | - | TS/TR Cover sheets | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 9.1.3 | - | - | - | Rel-18 new Study Items/Work Items proposal [no TEI18 mini WIDs] | - | - | Docs:=83 | - | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107572 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 3. | China Mobile, vivo | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106808 from S2#146E. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108169 Revised to S2-2108169. | David (Samsung) provides comments on the SID Belen (Ericsson) provides comments to SID. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to SID LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) provides comment. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments and clarification on AI based positioning. David (Samsung) replies to Huawei Xiaobo(vivo) replies to David(Samsung) LaeYoung (LGE) objects to include PC5/Sidelink aspect in the SID. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to objective 4.2. This is already proposed in eLCS study, there is no point in having it twice in SA2. eLCS study coordinating with eNA phase 3 is enough, in our view. David (Samsung) kindly asks rapporteurs to provide a revision matching their comments Iskren (NEC) supports the KI#2.1: NWDAF-assisted application detection study in Rel-18 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests that objectives in the SID are not listed as KIs already. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to some questions from Ericsson on eNA phase 3 SID. Xiaobo(vivo) reply to David (Samsung) Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides comments Belen (Ericsson) thanks for the explanation and provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy enhancement. Xiaobo (vilvo) propose to take out WiFi from KI#3.2 to address the comment from Belen(Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) is okay with Xiaobo proposal David (Samsung) comments Belen (Ericsson) comments Samsung proposal Yannick (Nokia): Nokia cannot accept WT#5 deployment. Aihua(CMCC) provides comments on Yannick's reply. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) provides further comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides reference to previous discussion on the topic in 2021, and asks for the corresponding objective to be kept in eNA Phase 3 SID. Xiaobo(vivo) reply to Ulises Olvera (Interdigital Inc.) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments on KI#4.7. Aihua(CMCC) reply to Ulises Olvera (Interdigital Inc.) on KI#4.1. Ming(CATT): replay to Nokia, and propose wording on objective 4.2. David (Samsung) replies to Qualcomm. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia maintains objection to eNA phase 3 objective 4.2. Aihua(CMCC) provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Aihua(CMCC) disagree with Yannick's reply. Ming (CATT): clarify the work-spilt between LCS and eNA, and ask Nokia to remove the objection to eNA phase 3 objective 4.2. Xiaobo(vivo) replies to Yannick (Nokia). Xiaobo(vivo) ask Yannick (Nokia) to provide clarification on KI#3.7. Aihua(CMCC) generally agrees with Ming. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Aihua (CMCC). Aihua(CMCC) disagree with Yannick's reply on WT3.5. Wang Yuan (Huawei) supports to reserve a place for AI based positioning in eNA_ph3, i.e., to keep WT 4.2 as an objective Belen (Ericsson) provides some comments. Belen (Ericsson) asks again what objectives may have RAN impacts, please explain Aihua(CMCC) asks clarification on WT#3.1 to Yannick(Nokia), please explain. Xiaobo replies to Belen (Ericsson) and rephrase WT#3.9 to address Belen's comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02 and requests for further changes to the eNA phase 3 SID. We repeat our objection to WT#4.2. David (Samsung) proposes a way forward for WT4.2/WT4.3. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) also supports David's comments. Wang Yuan provides clarification and supports on WT 3.9 and also provides the 5GAA reference. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides clarification and supports on KI#3.2 Yang (OPPO) comments. Aihua(CMCC) asks Belen (Ericsson) for clarification on the previous comment. Xiaobo(vivo) can live with the David's proposal as compromise to make progress. Xiaob0(vivo) responds to Yang (OPPO) comments. Ming (CATT) is fine with David (Samsung) proposal on the way forward for WT4.2/WT4.3. Aihua(CMCC) provides r04 for reference in the drafts folder. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to r02. We should solve the split of work between eLCS and eNA study. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Xiaobo (vivo) would like to make progress this meeting at least technical endorse and can live with proposal from Yannick to solve the split of work between eLCS and eNA study. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Aihua comments on FL in SA5 Belen (Ericsson) asks Xiaobo to list the few controversial issues to be discussed at CC#2 Xiaobo (vivo) list the few controversial issues to be discussed at CC#2 per request from Belen(Ericsson) and propose to provide r04-delta for quick handling in CC#2 Zhuoyi (China Telecom) agrees to remove WT#3.2 at this meeting and will provide a DP for detail justification on that at next meeting. Aihua (CMCC) replies and provide the draft version for r04-delta. | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108169 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 3. | China Mobile, vivo | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107572r04. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107083 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Enhancement to the 5GC LoCation Services Phase 3. | CATT, Huawei | Rel-18 | Revision of (noted) SID SP-211123. CC#2: r02 endorsed. Revised to S2-2108170 Revised to S2-2108170. | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides a revised draft Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides a revised draft Runze (Huawei) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm). Runze (Huawei) provides a draft. David (Samsung) would like to support the SID, provides a comment. Cai Simon (Nokia) provides revision based on Runze (Huawei)'s version Runze (Huawei) agrees the version from Nokia. Runze (Huawei) can accept the this version. Ming (CATT) provides r01 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stephen (Qualcomm) cannot agree r00 or r01 Cai Simon (Nokia) clarifies to Stephen (Qualcomm) Runze (Huawei) supports r01. Cai Simon (Nokia) supports r01 Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides a revision to r01 to the draft folder. Cai Simon (Nokia) supports r01, objects S2-2107083r01_Mi.doc Åke (Ericsson) object to r01 and accept r00 Cai Simon (Nokia) accepts r00 as well Sherry (Xiaomi) replies, and can also accept r00. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) object to r00 and accepts r01 Ming (CATT) response to comments and provides r01-CATT in the draft folder. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) comments on the proposal. Ming (CATT) answers to Leo and provides correct version, r01-CATT-V2. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108170 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Enhancement to the 5GC LoCation Services Phase 3. | CATT, Huawei | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107083r02. Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107084 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Passive Internet of Things (Passive IoT) for 5G Advanced | China Mobile, Spreadtrum Communications, Huawei, HiSilicon, China Telecom, China Unicom, CATT, Tencent, vivo, Quanray, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-18 | Revision of (noted) SID SP-211125. Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Miguel (Qualcomm) maintains all the serious concerns from SA2#146E, proposes to not proceed with this SA2 Rel-18 SID in favour of Rel-19 study in SA1. Chunhui (Spreadtrum) replies the comments from Qian (Ericsson) and Miguel (Qualcomm), and provides the revision(r01). Hannu (Nokia) shares Miguel's view and can't agree any version. Hualin(Huawei) think the study is good and support the SID. Hannu (Nokia) comments that the service requirements are missing in SA1 Rel-18 specifications and consequently SA2 study is not justified. Chunhui(Spreadtrum) replies Hannu (Nokia)'s comments and suggests to proceed with Passive IoT SID in Rel-18. Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Chunhui, still has concerns with proceeding with no clear SA1 requirements. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Chunhui(Spreadtrum) responds to Miguel (Qualcomm)'s comments and strongly suggests to proceed with Passive IoT SID in Rel-18. Aihua(CMCC) agrees with Chunhui(Spreadtrum) and suggests to have Passive IoT SID in R18. Hannu (Nokia) responds to Aihua and Chunhui Chris (Vodafone) says that we a supporting company and we would like some work in R18 Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees with Chairman notes to note/postpone this SID. If needed, Qualcomm objects to this SA2 SID with no clear SA1 requirements. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Chunhui(Spreadtrum) provides the information about Passive IoT discussion in RAN. | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107092 | SID NEW | Approval | Study of Further Architecture Enhancement for UAV and UAM | QUALCOMM, Verizon, AT&T, InterDigital, FirstNet, Futurewei, CMCC, Oppo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, T-Mobile, Panasonic, SK Telecom | Rel-18 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108154 Revised to S2-2108154. | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to include objective WT#2.4. Support of simultaneous connectivity to multiple PLMNs into the study. Runze (Huawei) provides concern on WT#2.1 and WT#2.2 Runze (Huawei) supports Dieter (Deutsche Telekom), and objects to include objective WT#2.4. Support of simultaneous connectivity to multiple PLMNs into the study. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on WT#2.2. Stefano (Qualcomm) addresses concerns on WT#2.1 and WT#2.2 and provides R01. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides R02 to address the comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides a draft update. Chunhui(Spreadtrum) supports Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) and Runze (Huawei) to object to include objective WT#2.4 into the study, and proposes to not proceed with this SA2 Rel-18 SID in favour of Rel-19 study in SA1. Runze (Huawei) provides a draft revision to the SID. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) responds to Qualcomm and maintains the objection to WT2.4. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides an additional revision and responds. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Chunhui (Spreadtrum) would like to withdraw the previous objection since WT#2.4(Multi-PLMN) has been removed in R03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108154 | SID NEW | Approval | Study of Further Architecture Enhancement for UAV and UAM | QUALCOMM, Verizon, AT&T, InterDigital, FirstNet, Futurewei, CMCC, Oppo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, T-Mobile, Panasonic, SK Telecom | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107092r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107100 | SID NEW | Approval | New Study on Service-based interface between NG-RAN and 5GC | Intel, Qualcomm Incorporated, Deutsche Telekom, Verizon UK Ltd., AT&T, Microsoft, Orange, Cisco, InterDigital | Rel-18 | Revision of (noted) SP-211025. Postponed | Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and questions the value of the study. Laurent (Nokia): Comments questioning the value of the study. Saso (Intel) replies to Wanqiang and Laurent. Florin (Broadcom) asks for clarifications and provides comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports comments already provided by others, add some more comments. Jinguo (ZTE) supports comments already provided by others. Saso (Intel) provides r01; replies to Florin, Shabnam, Jinguo. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc Saso (Intel) points out that Nokia's objection is not based on technical arguments. If Nokia has no interest in this proposal they can choose to not support it during the prioritization exercise, but there is no technical reason for the objection. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects approval of this SI & revision, we don't see the justification and objectives relate to each other and we do not see any stage 1 requirements for this work. Saso (Intel) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson) that this study is triggered from SA2 and does not require specific stage-1 requirements. Provides examples with other approved SBI-related studies (FS_eSBA; SP-180231) (FS_SB_SMS ; SP-190184 - with Ericsson as rapporteur!!) that were triggered by SA2 and do not rely on specific stage-1 requirements. The SBI itself has no stage-1 requirements in TS 22.261 and was defined by SA2 as part of stage-2 work. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107129 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on Interworking of Non-3GPP Multicast and Broadcast Networks with 3GPP 5G System | Saankhya Labs | Rel-18 | Postponed | Thomas (Nokia) comments that the objectives need to be clarified Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that objectives are unclear Wanqiang (Huawei) comments that the current objectives are too wide. Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees with concerns that the objectives are too wide. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with the ChairNotes' proposal to note/postpone Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees with Chairman proposal to note/postpone Anindya Saha (SaankhyaLabs) responds to comments Thomas (Nokia) replies to Anindya Saha ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107137 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Extensions to the TSC Framework to support DetNet | Ericsson | Rel-18 | CC#2: r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2108178. | Devaki (Nokia) provides Nokia proposed revision in the DRAFTS folder. Ideally, we prefer to merge this with 7297, would like to hear other companies views on this. György (Ericsson) responds and provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) still wonders the value of studying objective #1 if there is no normative work expected. Either allocate TUs for normative work or remove the objective. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) ok for the SID to progress (although prefer to merge with 7297) but object to WT#1 in its current form - we insists the need for reserving normative TU(s) for WT#1 or remove WT#1. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides rev03 in the drafts folder. Devaki (Nokia) comments. György (Ericsson) provides rev04 in the drafts folder. Devaki (Nokia) fine with r04. György (Ericsson) provides rev05 in the drafts (cleanup only). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108178 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Extensions to the TSC Framework to support DetNet | Ericsson | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107137r05. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107180 | DISCUSSION | Information | Time Critical Communication: Latency Critical High-Rate Adaptive services & Low Latency Low Loss Scalable Throughput (L4S). | Ericsson | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107181 | WID NEW | Approval | New WID on Use of L4S in 5GS | Ericsson | Rel-18 | Is this TEI18 ? Postponed | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to update the WID to include EPS. Paul (Ericsson) provides r02. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks question for clarification. Curt (Charter) supports r02. Krisztian (Apple) supports r02 and suggests not to include EPS in the scope in R18. Frank (Telstra) also supports r02. Stephen (BT) supports r02. Hui(Huawei) comments to the WID. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Hui(Huawei) objects this WID and suggest to study L4S and other potential solutions in related SIDs. Chris (Vodafone) comments that VPLMN-EPS seems to be naturally included, so perhaps clarify r02 at the next meeting? Paul (Ericsson) replies. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) comments maybe Huawei remembers this has been discussed first in Rel-17 as well but was little late to include in AIS scope and as clarified scope of XR explained by Dan in the other thread, we see that L4S can progress independently within its well defined scope. Devaki (Nokia) also prefers that L4S remains well scoped and as a standalone WID for 5GS only. Hui(Huawei) proposes to postpone this WID proposal to next meeting. | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107187 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhanced support of Non-Public Networks phase 2 | Ericsson, Futurewei, Convida Wireless, Charter, China Unicom, ETRI, Cisco, China Mobile, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Qualcomm, ZTE, Philips, Intel, Matrixx, SHARP, InterDigital, LG Electronics, NEC, Samsung, OPPO, T-Mobile USA | Rel-18 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108179. | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides comments and asks question for clarification. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) disagrees with the addition of 'or via both simultaneously.' to objective 5. B Hualin(Huawei) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides replies and r01 Rainer (Nokia) replies to Peter (Ericsson). Patrice (Huawei) prefers WT1 to not point to a specific solution. Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to add a Note for PALS requirements. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides proposed wording Hualin(Huawei) provide additional comments. Hualin(Huawei) reply to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Chia-Lin (Mediatek) suggest to remove bullet 6 Chia-Lin (Mediatek) please ignore the previous comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and suggest explicit statement of excluded requirements Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments on the proposed changes to bullet 6 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Patrice (Huawei) replies, objects any version that includes the solution 'equivalent SNPNs' as part of WT1, that means at least r00-r02. Ming (CATT) comments on bullet 6. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggests to agree r02+a NOTE for objective 1 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) still has concerns with both objectives in 4 and propose to remove them. Patrice (Huawei) does not want to see a solution-driven objective, and maintain the current position. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Dieter Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Patrice Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides proposal for change to objective 4 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides possible rewording of objective 1 Patrice (Huawei) thanks Peter (Ericsson) for his proposal, which he accepts. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides draft r03 in draft folder based on discussions Patrice (Huawei) is OK with draft r03 shared below by Peter (Ericsson). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108179 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhanced support of Non-Public Networks phase 2 | Ericsson, Futurewei, Convida Wireless, Charter, China Unicom, ETRI, Cisco, China Mobile, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Qualcomm, ZTE, Philips, Intel, Matrixx, SHARP, InterDigital, LG Electronics, NEC, Samsung, OPPO, T-Mobile USA | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107187r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107213 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on NWDAF assisted URSP. | China Telecom | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107225 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Study on enhancement of 5G AM Policy | China Telecom Corporation Ltd., CATT, China Mobile, China Unicom, Ericsson, Huawei, Intel, Oracle, Tencent, vivo, ZTE | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106799 from S2#146E. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108155 Revised to S2-2108155. | Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification. Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification. Resending with correct subject line Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies to Nokia and provide r01. Pallab (Nokia) raises concern with r01 and comments Belen (Ericsson) provides comments. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies to Ericsson. Belen (Ericsson) objects to the initial version, r01 and provides a proposal in draft folder Uri (Oracle) responds to Pallab's comment on objective 3. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides r02 based on Ericsson's draft. Pallab (Nokia) objects to all the revisions as our concern with objective #1 is not addressed. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides r03. Pallab (Nokia) thanks Zhuoyi (China Telecom) for r03 and is OK to approve it. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108155 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Study on enhancement of 5G AM Policy | China Telecom Corporation Ltd., CATT, China Mobile, China Unicom, Ericsson, Huawei, Intel, Oracle, Tencent, vivo, ZTE | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107225r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107249 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Ericsson comments on the Rel-18 Edge Computing study objectives | Ericsson | Rel-18 | Noted | Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments Patrice (Huawei) agrees that this discussion paper can be noted. Magnus (Ericsson) is fine with noting the discussion paper and continue the discussion the study item. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107251 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhanced support of NR RedCap with long eDRX for RRC INACTIVE State | Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom, Verizon, Xiaomi, Sony, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, MediaTek, AT&T, Apple | Rel-18 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108174 Revised to S2-2108174. | Miguel (Qualcomm) cannot accept r00 and provides r01 for which Qualcomm is added as supporting company Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and probably TEI is a good format to organize the work? Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r02 Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Miguel (Qualcomm) not ok with r02 sorry Qian (Ericsson) responds to Saso (Intel) Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Wanqiang (Huawei) ask to take this issue to CC#2 regarding how to manage the work: SID, WID or TEI. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108174 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhanced support of NR RedCap with long eDRX for RRC INACTIVE State | Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom, Verizon, Xiaomi, Sony, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, MediaTek, AT&T, Apple | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107251r01. CC#2: Postponed | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107270 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on architecture enhancement for XR and media services | China Mobile, Huawei, Hisilicon, Tencent, Xiaomi | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106810 from S2#146E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108156 Revised to S2-2108156. | Dan (China Mobile) provide r01 Dan (China Mobile) provide r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) comments on potential overlap with SI on Timing Resiliency and TSC enhancements (7297). Dan (China Mobile) reply ==== Comments Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) replies that there is no issue with overlap/conflict, agree with Dan (China Mobile). Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Dan and Devaki for their clarification, hope we are consistent as same approach can be taken for the relationship with L4S scope which is also independent from XR study as I read the explanation. | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108156 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on architecture enhancement for XR and media services | China Mobile, Huawei, Hisilicon, Tencent, Xiaomi | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107270r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107271 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on UPF enhancement for control and SBA | China Mobile, AT&T, Vodafone, CATT, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, SK Telecom, Sandvine, Matrixx | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106811 from S2#146E. r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2108157 Revised to S2-2108157. | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Dan (China Mobile) provides r02 Fenqin (Huawei): provides an updated version Dan(China Mobile) provide r03 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision uploaded to DRAFTS Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Dan (China Mobile) provides response and provide r04 Dan (China Mobile) reply Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides another draft revision Stefan (Ericsson) repeats question Dan (China Mobile) reply and provide r05 Fenqin (Huawei) comments Dan (China Mobile) comments Dan (China Mobile) provide r07 Laurent (Nokia): Comments Dan (China Mobile): Comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects R00, R02, R04, R05, R06(non existent). I think R07 can proceed with WT2 TU upgraded to 2.5 TU of study and 1.5 TU Of normative Dan (China Mobile) OK for R07 with updating TU proposed by Laurent(WT#2 2.5 for Study phase and 1.5 for normative phase), we can do this in CC#1b Dan (China Mobile) request this for CC#1b or CC#2 for updating the TU Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that TUs should be increased. Dan (China Mobile) provide r08 with update the TU in draft folder. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108157 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on UPF enhancement for control and SBA | China Mobile, AT&T, Vodafone, CATT, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, SK Telecom, Sandvine, Matrixx | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107271r07. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107281 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 3 | ZTE, LG Electronics, Samsung, Alibaba, Apple, AT&T, CATT, China Telecom, China Unicom, Convida Wireless LLC, Ericsson, Intel, InterDigital , KDDI, Lenovo, Matrixx, MITRE, Motorola Mobility, NEC , Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell , NTT Docomo, OPPO, Orange, Qual | Postponed | Peter (Ericsson) provides comments Patrice (Huawei) comments (objects to r00), provides a draft update. Jinguo(ZTE) response and provide r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments Gerry (Verizon) provide comments (objects to HW SID document draft provided) Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02 alessio (Nokia) comments and provides a draft in drafts folder Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggestions. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r03 alessio(Nokia) comments on r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dongeun (Samsung) provides comments. Jinguo (ZTE) provides r04 in draft folder George (Ericsson) comments. The SID needs more work. We can use r04 as basis. For example one of the changes we want is to replace what U have now I objective 13 with 13. Study whether and how to enhance support of networks with multiple NSACFs covering different Service Areas. This is juts one example Patrice (Huawei) thanks Jinguo for the effort. The SID is rapidly converging, however there are still a number of issues (for formality: r00~r04 cannot be agreed) Stefano (Qualcomm) indicates the SID requires more work and cannot agree to any revisions to be approved. Kundan (NEC) objects to r2/r3. We don't support any version which removes study on disjoint network which was approved by SA1. Patrice (Huawei) provides to Alessio (Nokia) the rationale for objecting to the current version of objective 5, besides all the technical comments made so far. I am still waiting for an actual rational justification. NEC(Kundan) objects to r2/r3/r4 as they don't capture SA1 requirement on disjoint slice (bullet 2 of the objective). Patrice (Huawei) requests that companies pushing for some objectives that have been controversial provide in next meeting discussion papers highlighting why this work is necessary (including SA1 requirements, and how these SA1 requirements are not fulfilled by the current specification). Alessio(nokia) asks this SID to be for CC#2 Patrice (Huawei) objects all revisions including the original version. Good progress was made, progress still needs to be made. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107289 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on 5G System Support for AI/ML-based Services | OPPO, Samsung | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106797 from S2#146E. r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108158 Revised to S2-2108158. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments and requests for a revision. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Yannick (Nokia) for your detailed comments and would like to provide feedback inline below. Also r02 is uploaded to reflect the incorporation of some of the comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia clarifies that r01 was provided by Tricci (OPPO), not r02. Also provides follow-up clarifications since Nokia comments may have been misunderstood. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Yannick (Nokia) for your further clarification. The actual r02 was uploaded to reflect the incorporation of some of the comments. Tricci (OPPO) forgot to mention that the previous email also included some further responses inline to Yannick (Nokia). Please check. Thanks. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia thanks Rapporteurs for the revision. Nokia would like to suggest few additional changes to the SID as per version in drafts folder. Aihua(CMCC) provides comment. Chia-Lin (Mediatek) comments and suggests to delete some text as captured below David (Samsung) provides r03 and replies to comments from CMCC and Mediatek Paul (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. Aihua(CMCC) requests for further clarification. Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments on r03. David (Samsung) replies to Ericsson Paul (Ericsson) replies. David (Samsung) provides r04 and replies to latest comments Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to David (Samsung) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Amanda ( Futurewei ) asks question for clarification. Xiaobo (vivo) provides comments to David (Samsung) Tricci (OPPO) thanks Amanda ( Futurewei ) comments and provides feedback inline below. Tricci (OPPO) thanks Xiaobo (vivo) comments and provided feedback in line below. David (Samsung) replies to comments from CMCC and Huawei David (Samsung) makes a proposal to Nokia based on the comment from Huawei David (Samsung) provides r05 in the drafts folder Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r03, but do not accept the change in r04. David (Samsung) provides r06 in the drafts folder ==== Comments Deadline ==== Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to David (Samsung). | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108158 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on 5G System Support for AI/ML-based Services | OPPO, Samsung | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107289r06. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107291 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhancement of 5G UE Policy | Intel Belgium SA/NV | CC#2: r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2108159 Revised to S2-2108159. | Pallab (Nokia) comments and requests for clarification on objective #4 Yang (OPPO) object to remove #4 and concern if it is a constructive way to show concern even without checking existing TS Yang (OPPO) provides response and r01 Mike (Convida Wireless) supports objective #4 and provides a revision in the drafts folder. Changhong (Intel) provides r02 with rephrasing objective #4 and adding Orange as supporting company. Antoine (Orange) confirms Orange support of this SI and opposition to remove objective #4. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to rephrase the objective #4. Also requests to review the TU estimation and update with more realistic figure. Belen (Ericsson) provides a revision in draft folder. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides an additional revision using Ericsson revision as basis Pallab (Nokia) provides a revision in drafts folder. Changhong (Intel) replies to Pallab. Pallab (Nokia) thanks Changhong (Intel) for response and comments further Changhong (Intel) provides r03. Yang (OPPO) provides a comment. Belen (Ericsson) comments on r03 to state that comments are not addressed. Pallab (Nokia) objects to all revisions and proposes a revision in the drafts folder. Belen (Ericsson) asks Nokia why to limit the scope of the study Pallab (Nokia) responds to Belen (Ericsson) Changhong (Intel) provides r04 based on the comments received. Susana (Vodafone) prefers the formulation of objective #4 in version r03 sent by ChangHong Pallab (Nokia) comments on r04. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Pallab (Nokia). Pallab (Nokia) responds to Hong (Qualcomm) Yang (OPPO) share a similar view with Nokia's comment Antoine (Orange): supports r03, cannot accept r04 and does not understand why Nokia wants to restrict objective #4 . Pallab (Nokia) replies to Antoine (Orange) Sherry (Xiaomi) provides a revision on top of r03 in the draft folder. Changhong (Intel) provides r05 based on the discussion. Changhong (Intel) replies to Sherry. Antoine (Orange) cannot accept r05 either; replies to Pallab. Pallab (Nokia) replies to Antoine (Orange) and requests for clarification Antoine (Orange) replies to Pallab. Changhong (Intel) provides r06 to make Antoine happy. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Antoine (Orange) is not happy with r06; replies to Pallab. Belen (Ericsson) does not agree with the content of r06 Changhong (Intel) replies to Belen and provides two revisions based on r06 in the draft folder. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to go with r05. Objects to all other revisions. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Intel Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Belen (Ericsson) proposal Belen (Ericsson) objects to all revisions so far, sent a proposal to try to reach consensus Changhong (Intel) is fine with Belen (Ericsson) proposal. Antoine (Orange) objects to r04, r05 and r06; can accept Belen's proposal. Changhong (Intel) provided a v3 in the draft folder based on Belen's proposal. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Changhong (Intel). Changhong (Intel) provided a v4 in the draft folder to make everybody feel comfortable. Changhong (Intel) asks Chairman to put it to CC#2 agenda. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Changhong (Intel) provided a v5 in the draft folder based on the compromise offline. | Revised | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108159 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on enhancement of 5G UE Policy | Intel Belgium SA/NV | - | Revision of S2-2107291r07. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107292 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on System Enabler for Service Function Chaining | Intel | Rel-18 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2108160 Revised to S2-2108160. | Laurent (Nokia): asks questions and provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions and uploads a revision to DRAFTS folder Laurent (Nokia): Comments that he agrees with stefan's questions and updates Fenqin (Huawei): comments Ellen (Intel) provides feedback and r02 in revision folder Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision proposal Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports Stefan's comment on ME impacts Ellen (Intel) provides r03 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Ellen (Intel) provides feedbacks to Ericsson and Nokia Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version but R01 (but R01 was provided by me and may not be valid?). I am open to finding an agreeable text but suggests it starts from R01 with the change below Ellen (Intel) replies to Laurent and provides r05 [here Ellen (Intel) provided r06 [here ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108160 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on System Enabler for Service Function Chaining | Intel | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107292r06. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107297 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on 5G Timing Resiliency and TSC enhancements | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Verizon, AT&T, Sennheiser, Huawei, HiSilicon, Matrixx, ZTE, China Unicom, Vivo, NTT Docomo, ETRI, Xiaomi, Orange, China Mobile, KDDI, Tencent, T-Mobile USA, Interdigital, Samsung, CATT, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, Denso, BMWi, | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106798 from S2#146E. CC#2: r06 endorsed. Revised to S2-2108161 Revised to S2-2108161. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00 and provides a draft revision Haiyang(Huawei) responds and seeks for some clarification based on the draft revision Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies György (Ericsson) replies Devaki (Nokia) comments that the draft revision proposes to remove a key objective regarding notification of failure, consistent mitigation actions by assuming a certain solution without any study in 3GPP (any WG). Devaki (Nokia) provides r01, answering comments inline, incorporating draft version. György (Ericsson) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments on WT#1 and provides alternative text proposal in the email directly Devaki (Nokia) provides r03, based on Gyorgy's and Shabnam's revision proposals. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) replies to Gyorgy's comment on WT#4. Haiyang (Huawei) replies to comment on WT#3. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04, re-instating the statement regarding 'gaps' back to WT#3. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. György (Ericsson) responds to Devaki on WT#3. Haiyang (Huawei) replies to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r01-r04 and provides another draft revision György (Ericsson) provides another draft revision. György (Ericsson) responds to DoCoMo. Haiyang (Huawei) further replies to Ericsson. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) is ok to go forward with r05, but may have some terminology cleanup further at the next meeting, specially on WT#1, has question on dependency with XR study Devaki (Nokia) clarifies the dependency with XR study: this SID WT4.x are very specific, same with XR study WT3.x - they are complimentary, not overlapping nor conflicting. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05 with the following two (editorial) fixes on top of r05: (1) move/add the word 'network' behind '5GS' in the two sub-bullets of WT#1.1 (resulting in '5GS network timing synchronization status') and (2) replace '5G timing service' by '5G time synchronization service' in WT#1.3 Devaki (Nokia) is fine with Qualcomm suggested (editorial) fixes on top of r05. Devaki (Nokia) uploaded r06 in CC#2 folder - Qualcomm suggested (editorial) fixes on top of r05. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) uploaded r07 in CC#2 folder - Qualcomm suggested (editorial) fixes on top of r05. | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108161 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on 5G Timing Resiliency and TSC enhancements | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Verizon, AT&T, Sennheiser, Huawei, HiSilicon, Matrixx, ZTE, China Unicom, Vivo, NTT Docomo, ETRI, Xiaomi, Orange, China Mobile, KDDI, Tencent, T-Mobile USA, Interdigital, Samsung, CATT, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, Denso, BMWi, | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107297r06. CC#2: Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107310 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study of Architecture Enhancement for Vehicle Mounted Relays. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Sony, InterDigital Inc. AT&T, Verizon UK Ltd, ZTE Corporation, Telstra, vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, Volkswagen AG, Philips International B.V., Xiaomi, SyncTechno Inc., FirstNet, Lenovo/Motorola Mobility, LG Electronics, Rakuten | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106814 from S2#146E. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): asks questions and suggests some revisions in Draft Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Wanqiang. Chunhui (Spreadtrum) maintains all the serious concerns from SA2#146E, proposes to not proceed with this SA2 Rel-18 SID in favour of RAN starting the related work firstly. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies to Hong. Laurent (Nokia): Comments Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01_Ericsson version in the Drafts folder. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Wanqiang (Huawei): the concern remains and proposes to note. Further clarification of the scope is needed. Wanqiang (Huawei) object any version as lack of clear SA2 scope and big overlap with RAN. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107346 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study of Enhanced System enablers for Multi-USIM | Sony, Convida Wireless, NEC, Samsung, Interdigital | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105997 from S2#146E. Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Ouyang(Huawei) comments Lars (Sony provides r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to the study. Lars (Sony) responds to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) to clarify that reason for objection is not correct Steve (Huawei) objects to all revisions. Lars (Sony) responds to Steve (Huawei) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) objects the SID. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107376 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID about AF control of 5GC groups | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-18 | Postponed | Hyunsook (LGE) supports the previous comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) also proposes to merge S2-2107376 into S2-2107419. Heng (China Telecom) supports the merge propose Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2107376 into S2-2107419 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments/questions. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) explains more on the reasons that the SID needs to be merged into FS_GMEC (S2-2107419) Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports to keep this SID separate from what is proposed in 7419 and comments on WT4 Qianghua (Huawei) still insists to merge this into GMEC in S2-2107419 considering the previous overall analysis. Besides these, WT#4 is already supported in Rel-16. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Rainer (Nokia) replies to Qianghua (Huawei). Rainer (Nokia) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) WT#4 is not needed and since your objectives rely on enhancements of 5G VN mechanism. so it is rational to ask this SID merge into GMEC S2-2107419 Chunhui (Spreadtrum) supports to merge S2-2107376 into GMEC S2-2107419, and cannot agree any version of S2-2107376. Stefan (Ericsson) supports keeping this SID separate, and cannot see reason for mixing it up with 5G VN Sebastian (Qualcomm) has the same view as Ericsson ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) cannot agree any revision of this SID, as explained WT#4 is already possible today, we don't see any issues need to be study, and the target for generation is still unclear in any revision of this SID. More importantly, this SID as well as the intention is already covered in GMEC, with a more specific study scope, and this SID closely rely on 5G VN mechanism, it is rational to merge this into GMEC SID Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments that discussions about merging / not merging can be sorted out in SA but are not really a valid reason for objecting to a SID in our view Sang-Jun (Samsung) has the same view as Huawei. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107379 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on 5G support for Femto | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions and comments Marco (Huawei) provides questions Rainer (Nokia) replies to Stefan (Ericsson). Rainer (Nokia) replies. Marco (Huawei) provide comments . Marco (Huawei) comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments Rainer (Nokia) replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Chunhui (Spreadtrum) provide comments and cannot agree any version of this SID. Huan (vivo) comments Marco (Huawei) objects the SID since it introduces a specific features for a not existing entity. First it is needed to define the architectures and all required generic functionalities. In addition the dependency on RAN needs to be stated. Stefan (Ericsson) also objects to this SID as it assumes a non-defined entity that seems to fall in RAN scope. Rainer (Nokia) replies and provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Marco (Huawei) prefer to postpone. Revision if proposed in draft folder. The RAN dependency in WT 1 shall be changed to 'yes'. Stefan (Ericsson) maintains objection ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107383 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Study on Seamless UE context recovery | Samsung, NEC, CableLabs, Cisco, InterDigital Inc | Rel-18 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): Comments (concerns with the SID) Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Haris(Qualcomm) provides comments and suggested revision in DRAFTS Fenqin (Huawei): Comments Lalith(Samsung) provides r02 Lalith(Samsung) replies to Qian (Ericsson) and Fenqin (Huawei) Lalith(Samsung) replise to Laurent (Nokia) Lalith(Samsung) provides r03 Lalith(Samsung) provides r04 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version. R04 is going into a good direction Lalith(Samsung) proposes to discuss this on CC#2 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107384 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Motivation for Seamless UE context recovery | Samsung | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107396 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Proximity based Services in 5GS - Phase 2 | CATT, OPPO | CC#2: r03 endorsed. Revised to S2-2108162 Revised to S2-2108162. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r00-Ericsson in draft folder Fei (OPPO) responds to Judy (Ericsson) Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fei (OPPO) Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Judy (Ericsson). Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Walter (Philips) provides r00-Philips in draft folder James (AT&T) provides comments that we prefer to have PC5 DRX included as a top level task; also we do not see a reason to have NPN in this SID. Deng Qiang (CATT) thanks all the comments and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments on r01. Fei (OPPO) responds to Walter (Philips) Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02 with reworded NOTE 3. Jarmo Wilkens (KPN) asks clarification on #WT11 Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Jarmo Wilkens (KPN). Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Zhang (Ericsson). Deng Qiang (CATT) replies to Zhang (Ericsson). Zhang (Ericsson) responds to Qiang (CATT) Zhang (Ericsson) propose to postpone this SID Deng Qiang (CATT) further clarifies to Zhang (Ericsson), and surprised of postponed, and seek for guidance from chair. Fei (OPPO) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides revision in draft folder. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides v2 by adding more companies in draft folder. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to discuss in CC#2 if Zhang (Ericsson) insists on changing the TU for WT#9. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02V2 | Revised | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108162 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Proximity based Services in 5GS - Phase 2 | CATT, OPPO | - | Revision of S2-2107396r03. Technically Endorsed | Endorsed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107419 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on generic group management, exposure and communication enhancements | Huawei, China Mobile, China Telecom, China Unicom, Samsung, Juniper | Rel-18 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108163 Revised to S2-2108163. | Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Rainer (Nokia) provides comments, proposes to remove WT1 related objectives from 7419 and merged with 7376. Marco (Huawei) answers to Tugce (NTT DOCOMO). Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Rainer (Nokia) comments. Marco (Huawei) provides answer to Stefan Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00 and provides a draft revision as a way forward xiaowan (vivo) seeks clarification for impact on ME Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Rainer (Nokia). Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses Chunhui (Spreadtrum) requests to add Spreadtrum as supporting company of this SID. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) object to r01 and provides another draft revision Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Rainer (Nokia) agrees with Ericsson and Qualcomm to merge WT#1 into 7376. Rainer (Nokia) proposes to postpone 7419. Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to postone this SID to sort out overlap for group management and address unresolved comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the SID because 0.5 TUs for WT#2.1 and WT#3 is too low in our view; if the TUs for both are increased to 1 we would be ok. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 in draft folder and proposes to continue this SID. 1: 5Ggroups SID scope/intention is well covered in this SID, and it relies on 5G VN related mechanism, it is rational to take GMEC as baseline. 2: group management/group communication are closely related, they are studied together since Rel-16 Vertical_LAN, they are studied together. 3: adjust TU as Sebastian suggested 4: Adjust WT#5 to make it clear to avoid the misunderstanding from Stefan Rainer (Nokia) replies. Stefan (Ericsson) reiterates concerns with some WTs, and again proposes to postpone this SID to resolve the concerns and have common handling with the other group mgmt SID Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 in the draft folder and asks for technical reasons for your postpone proposal ==== Comments Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) clarifies to Qianghua, and also refers to already provided comments | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108163 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on generic group management, exposure and communication enhancements | Huawei, China Mobile, China Telecom, China Unicom, Samsung, Juniper | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107419r04. CC#2: Postponed | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107429 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Support of Satellite Backhauling in 5GS. | CATT | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106073 from S2#146E. Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Haris(Qualcomm) provides comments Hucheng (CATT) replies to the comments and questions from Stefan (Ericsson) Hucheng (CATT) replies to Haris(Qualcomm). Hucheng (CATT) provides r01 to reflect the comments. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this SID due to several unresolved comments Wanqiang (Huawei) support r01 Stefan (Ericsson) objects to approval of this SID, and comments that Wanqiang's comments show that more work is needed Hucheng (CATT) responds to Stefan (Ericsson) and provides a revision r02 into the draft folder ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107451 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on 5GC enhancement for satellite access Phase 2 | THALES, XIAOMI, NOVAMINT | Rel-18 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2108164 Revised to S2-2108164. | Haris(Qualcomm) provides revision in DRAFTS Stefan (Ericsson) provides a revision in DRAFTS, on top of Haris' version Wanqiang (Huawei) provides update in DRAFTS folder Sherry (Xiaomi) provides 2 revisions on top of HW's revision in DRAFTS folder. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r01 and r02. Jean Yves (Thales) provides r03 and asks question - clarification to Haris Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Jean Yves (Thales) provides r04 to answer Stefan request Haris(Qualcomm) comments Jean Yves(Thales) responds to Haris: your concern is addressed in r04 (+PEP) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Jean Yves (Thales) Haris, your concern is already addressed in r04 posted before. Hucheng (CATT) supports r04 provided by Jean Yves (Thales) . DongYeon (Samsung) asks clarification what does 'NTN-GW' mean in the justification in r04. Stefan (Ericsson) comments that the solution related text in justification should be removed Jean Yves (Thales) responds to DongYeon Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Stefan and asks question Relja (TNO) supports r04 and responds to Stefan/Jean-Yves and all. Ramon Ferrus (Sateliot) supports r04 and comments on previous Jean-Yves (Thales) answer Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Relja and Jean-Yves Thierry (Novamint) supports r04 Thierry (Novamint) supports r04 ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108164 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on 5GC enhancement for satellite access Phase 2 | THALES, XIAOMI, NOVAMINT | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107451r04. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107454 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | DP Study on 5GC enhancement for satellite access Phase 2 | THALES, XIAOMI, NOVAMINT | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107455 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on interworking with transport networks in SID proposal on Study on 5G Timing Resiliency and TSC enhancements | NTT DOCOMO INC. | Rel-18 | Noted | György (Ericsson) comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) replies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107494 | SID REVISED | Approval | Study on system architecture for next generation real time communication services | China Mobile, China Unicom, Huawei, Hisilicon, ZTE, CATT, Vivo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106816 from S2#146E. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2108165 Revised to S2-2108165. | Haris(Qualcomm) asks question for clarification Yi (China Mobile) replies and provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Thomas (Nokia) provides a comment Yi (China Mobile) replies to Thomas. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Yi (China Mobile) provides draft r02. | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108165 | SID REVISED | Approval | Study on system architecture for next generation real time communication services | China Mobile, China Unicom, Huawei, Hisilicon, ZTE, CATT, Vivo, Deutsche Telekom, T-Mobile USA, Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107494r01. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107532 | SID NEW | Approval | New Study on Enhancement of Support for Separation and Isolation of NF and Data in 5GC | China Telecommunications | Rel-18 | Postponed | Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification, comments. Rainer (Nokia) responds and provide r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments Rainer (Nokia) provides further comments. Saso (Intel) comments. Yubing(China Telecom) replies to Peter(Ericsson), Rainer(Nokia), Saso(Intel), and provide r02 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Rainer (Nokia) proposes to postpone this SID and further work on clarification of the scope. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107550 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Rel-18 MBS | Huawei,HiSilicon | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106805 from S2#146E. Postponed | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Robbie (Ericsson) asks questions on r00 and disagree with Thomas to remove WT#2. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Robbie (Ericsson) for WT#3.2. Robbie (Ericsson) asks Zhenhua (vivo) for WT#3.2. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides comments, has concerns with WT 1.2, WT 1.3 and WT 1.1 for RRC IDLE LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02 to address the comments. Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02-Ericsson in DRAFTS folder. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Robbie (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the SID and continue the discussion in next meeting. The comments provided in r02-Ericsson haven't been taken into account. Robbie (Ericsson) supports this work but objects to all revisions at this meeting and proposes to continue working until next meeting, ok to endorse the revision in Drafts folder (S2-2107550r02-Ericsson) as basis for further revision. Miguel (Qualcomm) objects to WT#1.2 and WT#1.3 LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Robbie (Ericsson). ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107558 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on NWDAF-assisted application detection. | China Mobile | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia do not see benefit to study NWDAF based application detection when this can already be done by DPI. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Belen(Ericsson) and provide r01. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaobo(vivo) support NWDAF-assisted application detection for HTTPS based application service. Iskren (NEC) also supports NWDAF-assisted application detection study. Wang Yuan (Huawei) also supports to study NWDAF-assisted application detection in eNA_ph3. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107559 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | The Discussion on the motivation of Passive IoT | China Mobile | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107562 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on integration of network and computing power in 5GS | China Telecomunication Corp. | Revision of (Noted) S2-2105978 from S2#146E. Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): Comments (concerns with the SID) Yifan (China Telecom) replies to Laurent. Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the approval of this SID Saso (Intel) proposes to consider this study for a future release Shabnam (Ericsson) shares same views already expressed and does not believe this work is within scope of SA2, nor is it clear how it relates to SA2 work. Yifan (China Telecom) replies to Haris, Saso and Shabnam. Yifan (China Telecom) provides further clarifications. Yifan (China Telecom) provides r01. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Haris(Qualcomm) objects to any revision of this SID since there are no SA1 requirements Yifan (China Telecom) replies to Haris. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc Shabnam (Ericsson) in addition to already given reason, Ericsson objects to all version of the SI, the justification and scope are not within SA2, requirements are not defined in 3GPP. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107563 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion paper on Network & Computing Power integration | China Telecomunication Corp. | Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107575 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | DP on motivation for studying 5GC network function coordination in Release 18. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Noted | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to this proposal. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia expresses some concerns with the proposal as currently formulated. Wang Yuan (Huawei) also has concerns with the proposal. Belen (Ericsson) raises concerns about this proposal. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107601 | DISCUSSION | Information | Sensing in 5G and Trial for Respiration Monitoring | vivo | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107602 | DISCUSSION | Information | AI based positioning in R18 eNA Ph3 | vivo | Rel-18 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.. Belen (Ericsson) provides comments. David (Samsung) agrees with Qualcomm and Ericsson. Xiaobo(vivo) reply to David (Samsung)/Belen(Ericsson)/Juan(Qualcomm) and agree that a model in LMF needs to be discussed in eLCS but coordination between eLCS and eNA is needed e.g. data collection for LCS model should be studied dependent on eLCS requirement Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaobo (vivo) Xiaobo(vivo) reply to Juan(Qualcomm) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments to Xiaobo (vivo) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Cai Simon (Nokia) believes LCS group should lead Xiaobo(vivo) reply to Cai Simon (Nokia) and agree that LCS group should lead the discussion but close coordination is needed between LCS and eNA. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107603 | DISCUSSION | Information | Discussion on predictive QoS enhancement in FS_eNA_Ph3. | vivo, China Mobile | Rel-18 | Noted | Antoine (Orange) supports this proposal. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Yang (OPPO) provides comment and suggest to justify it considering the comments for a more constructive way. Vivian (vivo) replys comments from LaeYoung(LGE) and Yang(OPPO) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) rpovides comments Vivian (vivo) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Wang Yuan (Huawei) supports to study predictive QoS enhancement, in particular finer granularity of QoS prediction. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on the finer granularity of QoS predictions. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Ernst (Volkswagen AG): Volkswagen AG supports the proposals in S2-2107603. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107611 | DISCUSSION | Information | Discussion on Personal IoT Network architecture | vivo | Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107612 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Personal IoT Network architecture | vivo, CATT, China Telecom, Convida Wireless, InterDigital, KPN, OPPO, Philips, Spreadtrum Communications, T-Mobile USA, Tencent | Postponed | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to copy TU estimates from DP (S2-2107611) to this SID document. Laurent (Nokia): asks questions Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Zhenhua (vivo) replies and provides r02. Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Walter (Philips) provides comment Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03 Laurent (Nokia): Comments Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04. Hualin(Huawei) provide r05 in the draft. Mike (Convida Wireless) comments Zhenhua (vivo) provide r06. Mike (Convida Wireless) questions why WT#5 was removed in r06 Walter Dees (Philips) comment on r06 Hualin(Huawei) provide feedback to Walter Dees (Philips) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Walter Dees (Philips) responds to Hualin (Huawei) Amanda ( Futurewei ) provides view on the issues raised by Philips and Huawei Hualin(Huawei) reply to Walter Dees (Philips). Zhenhua (vivo) provides r07 in draft folder. Walter (Philips) comments on r07 Laurent (Nokia): objects to R00 to R05 and to R07; R06 would need some changes so I 'object to it' but I suggest to endorse it for future work Mike (Convida Wireless) expresses support for WT#5, points out that it is clearly supported by an SA1 requirement and technically correct. If companies want to de-prioritize it, that can be addressed at plenary. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r08 in draft folder only for working out a mostly agreeable version for next meeting. Mike (Convida Wireless) provides r08-Convida in the drafts folder which reinstates WT#5 since there are no technical objections for WT#5. Stefan (Ericsson) also support to 'endorse' or 'postpone' for further work Hong (Qualcomm) prefers postpone. Hualin(Huawei) disagree postpone and propose to endorse r06 or r07. But R08 and other revisions are not acceptable. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Amanda ( Futurewei ) asks to add Futurewei as supporting and co-source company and prefers to endorse r08 instead of r06. Also, responses to Qualcomm on WT#2.3. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r09 in draft folder try to resolve concerns, and ask for endorse the SID instead of 'postpone' it. | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107613 | DISCUSSION | Information | Discussion on UE Aggregation for Industry with Multi-connectivity | vivo | Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107614 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on UE Aggregation for Industry with Multi-connectivity | vivo, China Telecom, China Unicom, CATT, Spreadtrum Communications | Postponed | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to copy TU estimates from DP (S2-2107613) to this SID document. Devaki (Nokia) provides DRAFT revision proposal by Nokia in the DRAFTS folder. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r02 Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Saso (Intel) comments Florin (Broadcom) comments and requests clarifications. Zhenhua (vivo) replies and provides r03. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Florin (Broadcom) objects to r03 and all previous versions and provides motivation for the objection. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Florin (Broadcom) and kindly ask for more consideration. Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to postpone Devaki (Nokia) supportive to progress the SID objectives, ok to postpone. Qian (Ericsson) propose also to postpone the SID. Saso (Intel) objects to all revisions. ==== Comments Deadline ==== Florin (Broadcom) withdraws his objection and proposes the SI to be postponed for the next meeting. | Postponed | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107635 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Access Traffic Steering, Switching and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture; Phase 3 | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, ZTE, Broadcom, Apple, Alibaba, Tencent, China Mobile, Convida Wireless, Deutsche Telekom, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung, Interdigital, Matrixx, Cisco Systems, Charter Communications, CableLabs, Comcast, CATT, Intelsat, Viv | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106800 from S2#146E. Postponed | Susan (Huawei) provides a revision. Apostolis (Lenovo) requests clarifications about the changes proposed by Huawei. Marco (Huawei) provide background on Why concern for objectives #5. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports the addition of the objective on ATSSS EPC interworking via ePDG. Susan (Huawei) replies to Apostolis (Lenovo) on objectives #5. Rainer (Nokia) replies. Curt (Charter) replies. Dario (Qualcomm) supports Nokia's and Charter's views. Apostolis (Lenovo) comments on Stefan's (Ericsson) questions. We object to (WT 5) the studying of features requiring a UE to have more than 1 connection using the same RAT type simultaneously (e.g. 2x3GPP or 2xN3GPP) and to the studying of 3 access type simultaneously in several separated SIDs without having first addressed it as a general feature. If this is not studied as a general features, then there is a high risk if fragmentation of the functionalities leading to a contrasting and incompatible solutions. Curt (Charter) comments on Marco's objection. Florin (Broadcom) replies to Marco (Huawei)'s objection. Florin (Broadcom) supports Dario (Qualcomm)'s views. Rainer (Nokia) comments. Omkar (CableLabs) supports Charter/Nokia/Qualcomm/Broadcom views and responds to Stefan (Ericsson) on 5.2 Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) on WT#2, and objects to the texts in the original version for WT#2. Aditya (Comcast) supports Charter/CableLabs/Nokia/Qualcomm/Broadcom views/ Furthermore, Comcast is also of the view that 5.2 is to be viewed differently than 5.1. Jishnu Aravindakshan (Tejas Networks) supports CableLabs/Charter/ Qualcomm/Broadcom views. Apostolis (Lenovo) proposed changes to WT#2.1. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Marco (Huawei) about the multiple simultaneous registrations. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks Omkar (CableLabs) to provide clarifications. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01. DongYeon(Samsung) supports Charter/Nokia?Qualcomm/Broadcom/CableLabs views on 5.2. Marco (Huawei) further comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) expresses concerns with WT5.2 and proposes to remove it. Chia-Lin (Mediatek) suggest to remove some text captured below Omkar (CableLabs) provides clarifications and responds to Apostolis (Lenovo) Olesen (Intelsat) supports objective 5, in particular 5.2, as we believe it is very well aligned with the intent of the ATSSS scope. Marco( Huawei) asks clarification to Olesen (Intelsat) Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r02. Susan (Huawei) replies to Apostolis (Lenovo). Jean Yves (Thales) supports also objective 5, in particular 5.2, as enabler for NTN use cases and same reasons as Olesen (Intelsat). ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Omkar (CableLabs) proposes to remove the NOTE 1 for 5.2 in r02. Aditya (Comcast) supports CableLabs view on the note for topic 5.2 Apostolis (Lenovo) asks clarifications from Marco (Huawei). Marco (Huawei) answers to Apostolis (Lenovo) Curt (Charter) - to Marco (Huawei), this is not helping to make progress. Pranav (IIT Bombay) supports CableLabs/Nokia/Qualcomm/Broadcom views on 5.2 Anindya (SaankhyaLabs) supports CableLabs/Nokia/Qualcomm/Broadcom views on 5.2 ==== Comments Deadline ==== Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Apostolis and Curt | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107636 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on 5G Architecture enhancements for Harmonized Communication and Sensing service | Huawei, HiSilicon, vivo, CAICT, China Unicom, China Mobile, China Telecom, CATT, ZTE, OPPO, ROBERT BOSCH GmbH, NTT DOCOMO, TCL, Philips, Xiaomi | Rel-18 | Postponed | Hong (Qualcomm) comments and propose to start from SA1 study. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies to Hong. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects the SID for SA2 in Rel-18. Saso (Intel) comments that from procedural perspective this study cannot be done in Rel-18 as it requires SA1 and RAN involvement. Shabnam (Ericsson) shares same view as others that stage 1 work and common understanding of the work needs to happen first, as such propose to note this for Rel-18. Comments Alessio(Nokia) shares same view as others that stage 1 work and common understanding of the work required is needed first, as such propose to note this for Rel-18. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies to Saso and upload r01. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provides r02. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaobo(vivo) replies to Hong(Qualcomm). Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to original proposal and all revisions. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all versions, as previously mentioned by companies, it is premature to start this work in Rel-18 and it needs much more refinement and clarification of requirements to form composed work scope. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the SID, and covert it to a SA1 SID. Aihua(CMCC) suggests to have R18 SID to cover specific use cases. Chi (China Unicom) is supportive of starting this study in Rel-18 and points out that the use cases and potential impacts have been comprehensively discussed in S2-2107637. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107637 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | New SID Proposal on Harmonized Communication and Sensing service (HCS) | Huawei, Hisilicon, vivo, CAICT, China Unicom, China Mobile, China Telecom, ZTE, CATT | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107639 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5G Core network — phase 2 | Huawei, HiSilicon, Alibaba, China Unicom, Convida Wireless, Intel, Toyota, vivo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106812 from S2#146E. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108166 Revised to S2-2108166. | Magnus (Ericsson) provide comments John (Futurewei) asks question. Patrice (Huawei) answers some comments inline. Magnus (Ericsson) answers comments inline below. Dario (Qualcomm) provides an update of the WT3 wording in the draft folder. Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds Magnus (Ericsson) comments and proposes revisions on some WTs Patrice (Huawei) proposes r01, takes on board the comments from Magnus with some updates, and thanks Qualcomm for their support. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Jarmo Wilkens (KPN) proposes r02, based on r01 with an additional WT9) about AF in edge relocation Dario (Qualcomm): before accepting r02 more justification for WT9 should be provided. Shubhranshu (Nokia) proposes to agree r01, and not OK to r02 Patrice (Huawei) supports agreeing r01 for now, and discuss further regarding the added proposal from Jarmo. Magnus O (Ericsson) proposes to endorse r01 as is or approve r01 with some additional revisions to align the Justification. Patrice (Huawei) thanks Magnus (Ericsson) for the constructive approach, incorporates the proposal in r03. Jarmo (KPN) provides more justification for WT9 in r02 Patrice (Huawei) replies to Jarmo (KPN) and thanks KPN for their support. r03 has been uploaded to CC#2 for confirmation. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108166 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5G Core network — phase 2 | Huawei, HiSilicon, Alibaba, China Unicom, Convida Wireless, Intel, Toyota, vivo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107639r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107643 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: new Study on the support for 5WWC, Phase 2 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon, Deutsche Telekom, Broadcom, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Qualcomm, KPN, China Telecom | Rel-18 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): Provides r01 as a clean version out of which companies can propose revision Marco (Huawei): comments to consider revision of WT #2 per contribution S2-2107676, Remove WT#2 Objective e) as described in S2-2107676. Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 and r04 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Curt (Charter) comments that cable needs L2 bridge in this SID. Marco (Huawei) answer to Stefan (Ercisson) ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107648 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Analysis of SA WG1 PIRATES requirements. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon, | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107649 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Proposal on how to handle SA WG1 PIRATES requirements. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107674 | SID NEW | Approval | Study on decoupling of built-in network services from network control in 5GS | IIT Bombay | Rel-18 | Postponed | Laurent (Nokia): concerns with the proposal Pranav(IIT Bombay) responds Stefano (Qualcomm) also expresses concerns with the proposal. Qian (Ericsson) also has concerns with the proposal. Fenqin (Huawei) comments and share the concern as others. Pranav (IIT Bombay) responds ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Stefano (Qualcomm) for clear note taking, we object to the proposal for Rel. 18. Jinguo (ZTE): objects to any version of this Tdoc Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc Qian (Ericsson) also object to this proposal in rel-18. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107676 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Revision of 5WWC SID. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-18 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): suggests to discuss 5WWC SID revision in one thread i.e. the thread associated with Tdoc 7643 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107697 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Study on MPS when access to EPC/5GC is WLAN | Peraton Labs, CISA ECD, Verizon UK Ltd, AT&T, T-Mobile USA | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106796 from S2#146E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2108167 Revised to S2-2108167. | Robert (Peraton Labs) provides r01. Marco (Huawei) provides comments ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108167 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: Study on MPS when access to EPC/5GC is WLAN | Peraton Labs, CISA ECD, Verizon UK Ltd, AT&T, T-Mobile USA | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107697r02. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107727 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Discussion on way forward of FS_Ranging_SL_ARC. | Xiaomi | Rel-18 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107728 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Architecture Enhancement to support Ranging based services and sidelink positioning | Xiaomi | Rel-18 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2108168 Revised to S2-2108168. | LaeYoung (LGE) asks questions. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides comments. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r01 based on comments of Leo. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r02. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r03 by adding more supporting companies. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r03. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Revised |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2108168 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID on Study on Architecture Enhancement to support Ranging based services and sidelink positioning | Xiaomi | Rel-18 | Revision of S2-2107728r03. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107765 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussing the content to be in SA WG2 5WWC | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-18 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): suggests to discuss 5WWC SID revisions in one thread i.e. the thread associated with Tdoc 7643 ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107767 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on NG-RAN timing resiliency | Qualcomm | Rel-18 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) objects to sending this LS out at this time as it basically delays or even results in the risk of dropping the related SID from Rel-18. Furthermore, there are no proposal in RAN3 nor SA5. As usual, coordination with other WGs can happen during the study phase. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies that NG-RAN network timing resiliency is obviously not in scope of SA2. Nokia is of course welcome to propose this work in SA5/RAN3. Devaki (Nokia) comments that we respectfully have a different view on the WG scope - SA2 ToR includes System architecture aspects and that includes UE + RAN + 5GC. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted |
| 9.1.3 | S2-2107773 | SID NEW | Approval | New SID: PWS over non-3GPP access | Apple, Verizon UK Ltd, Broadcom, Convida Wireless | Rel-18 | Revision of (Noted) S2-2106451 from S2#146E. Postponed | Magnus O (Ericsson) proposes that this study is brought to CT1 Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the approval of this SID since there are no corresponding regulatory or other service requirements Leo (Deutsche Telekom) has the same view as Qualcomm and also objects to the approval of this SID in SA2 for Rel-18. ==== Revisions Deadline ==== Krisztian (Apple) suggests to agree the SID, the objections have no technical ground. It's an operator decision to deploy PWS over WLAN as a service improvement to increase the probability of successful warning message delivery, no regulatory requirements required. Also, no new service requirements are foreseen in SA1 to support accessing the service on non-3GPP access. Gerry (Verizon) provides a response Gerry (Verizon) provides a response: Verizon supports the SID proposal as a service improvement. ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Postponed |
| 9.2 | - | - | - | Review of the Work Plan, Rel-17 WID Status Reports | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107128 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108241. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108241 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107128. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107163 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | MINT Status Report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108246. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108246 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | MINT Status Report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107163. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107190 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eNPN Status Report | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108245. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108245 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eNPN Status Report | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107190. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107389 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eEdge_5GC status report | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108248. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108248 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | eEdge_5GC status report | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107389. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107395 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | 5G_ProSe Status Report | CATT | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108247. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108247 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | 5G_ProSe Status Report | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107395. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107548 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | Status report for 5MBS | Huawei,HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107581 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | IoT_SAT_ARCH_EPS Status Report | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2108242. | Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides an update (r01) in drafts Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r02 in drafts. | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2108242 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | IoT_SAT_ARCH_EPS Status Report | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2107581. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107600 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | Report_eNA_ph2 | vivo, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2107710 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | ENS_Ph2 status report | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108240 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | MPS2 Status Report | Peraton Labs (Rapporteur) | Noted | ==== 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Comments Deadline ==== | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108243 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | SA WG2 Status report for MUSIM | Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2108244 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | IIoT status report | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.3 | - | - | - | Planning future meetings | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 9.3 | S2-2107759 | WORK PLAN | Endorsement | SA WG2 work planning | SA WG2 Chair | Noted | Noted | ||
| 11 | - | - | - | Close of e-meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 99 | - | - | - | Withdrawn and Reserved documents | - | - | Docs:=210 | - | |
| 99 | S2-2107644 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3326 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107645 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3203 (Rel-17, 'C'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107352 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0452 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the ML model related information during analytics subscription transfer | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107375 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR3292 (Rel-17, 'F'): NAS Paging reject clarification | Samsung | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107276 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR3153 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of two Editor Notes for eNS_Ph2 | ZTE | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107176 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0008 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to UE triggered Policy provisioning Procedure | Ericsson | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107177 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0009 (Rel-17, 'F'): PC5 Discovery Model Selection | Ericsson | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107178 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0010 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving EN about transmission of Application Layer discovery message | Ericsson | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107179 | CR | Approval | 23.304 CR0011 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding adaptation layer over PC5 for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay | Ericsson | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107008 | LS In | Information | LS from SMPTE: PTP device monitoring Public Committee Draft | SMPTE () | - | Revision of postponed S2-2105364 from S2#146E. Handled at S2#146E. WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2107212 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on NWDAF assisted URSP | China Telecommunications | Rel-18 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn |