Document List for meeting All sessions

IPR call reminder:

"I draw your attention to your obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations' IPR policies. Every Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become essential to the work of 3GPP.

Delegates are asked to take note that they are thereby invited:

to investigate whether their organization or any other organization owns IPRs which are, or are likely to become Essential in respect of the work of 3GPP.
to notify their respective Organizational Partners of all potential IPRs, e.g., for ETSI, by means of the IPR Information Statement and the Licensing declaration forms".

Antitrust policy Reminder:

"I also draw your attention to the fact that 3GPP activities are subject to all applicable antitrust and competition laws and that compliance with said laws is therefore required of any participant of this TSG/WG meeting including the Chairman and Vice Chairman. In case of question I recommend that you contact your legal counsel.

The leadership shall conduct the present meeting with impartiality and in the interests of 3GPP.

Furthermore, I would like to remind you that timely submission of work items in advance of TSG/WG meetings is important to allow for full and fair consideration of such matters."

Statement Regarding Engagement with Companies Added to the
U.S. Export Administration Regulations (EAR) Entity List in 3GPP Activities:

1. Public Information is Not Subject to EAR

3GPP is an open platform where all contributions (including technology protected or not by patent) made by the different Individual Members under the membership of each respective Organizational Partner are publicly available. Indeed, contributions by all and any Individual Members are uploaded to a public file server when received and then the documents are effectively in the public domain.

In addition, since membership of email distribution lists is open to all, documents and emails distributed by that means are considered to be publicly available.

As a result, information contained in 3GPP contributions, documents, and emails distributed at 3GPP meetings or by 3GPP email distribution lists, because it is made available to the public without restrictions upon its further dissemination, is not subject to the export restrictions of the EAR.

Meeting minutes are maintained for 3GPP meetings. Such meeting minutes for 3GPP meetings are made available to the public without restrictions upon its further dissemination. As a result, information, including information conveyed orally, contained in 3GPP meetings is not subject to the export restriction of the EAR; this would include information conveyed during side meetings that may occur during the main meetings, if these meetings are open to any participants and the results of all said meetings are publicly available without restrictions upon their further dissemination.

2. Non-Public Information

Non-public information refers to the information not contained or not intended to be contained in 3GPP contributions, documents or emails. Such non-public information may be disclosed during informal meetings, exchanges, discussions or any form of other communication outside the 3GPP meetings and email distribution lists, and may be subject to the EAR.

3. Other Information

Certain encryption software controlled under the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), even if publicly available, may still be subject to US export controls other than the EAR.

4. Conduct of Meetings

The situation should be considered as "business as usual" during all the meetings called by 3GPP.

5. Responsibility of Individual Members

It should be remembered that contributions, meetings, exchanges, discussions or any form of other communication in or outside the 3GPP meetings are of the accountability, integrity and the responsibility of each Individual Member. In addition, Individual Members remain responsible for ensuring their compliance with all applicable export control regulations, including but not limited to EAR.

Individual Members with questions regarding the impact of laws and regulations on their participation in 3GPP should contact their companies' legal counsels.

AI	TD#	Type	Doc For	Subject	Source	Rel	Comments	e-mail_Discussion	Result
1.2	-	-	-	Start of the meeting - Phase 2	-	-	Docs:=0		-
4.2	-	-	-	Common issues and Incoming LSs - Phase 2	-	-	Docs:=9		-
4.2	S2-2004336	LS In	Action	LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion	IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-TSN-support-in-3GPP-Release-16)	Rel-16	Postponed	Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this LS since we need to analyse and then potentially create CR(s) to address the extensive review comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports Ericsson zhendong (ZTE) has similar view with qualcomm and ericsson ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) also proposes to postpone this LS and comments that CR(s) should be created against Rel-16 only for FASMO items.	Postponed
4.2	S2-2004337	LS In	Action	LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS	RAN WG2 (R2-2005939)	Rel-15	Postponed	Chris (Vodafone) says that unless we get a RAN 3 LS on this topic, we can postpone this RAN 2 LS. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
4.2	S2-2004338	LS In	Action	LS from SA WG6: LS on IP address to GPSI translation	SA WG6 (S6-200947)	Rel-17	Postponed	Laurent (Nokia): Proposes the POSTPONE the LS as there is no INPUT document and the topic would require some Mike (Convida Wireless) agrees that this should be POSTPONED Changhong (Intel) also proposes to POSTPONE it. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
4.2	S2-2004339	LS In	Information	LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on QoS Sustainability Analytics	SA WG6 (S6-200948)	Rel-17	Noted	LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this incoming LS as SA2 is CCed and no action required. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
4.2	S2-2004340	LS In	Information	LS from SA WG4: LS on Media Feature Tag for IMS Data Channel	SA WG4 (S4-200908)	Rel-16	Noted	Thomas Belling (Nokia) suggests noting this incoming LS, as SA2 is only cc ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
4.2	S2-2004631	LS In	Action	LS from SA WG5: LS on network data analysis energy saving	SA WG5 (S5-203360) (S5-203360)	Rel-17	Postponed	Yannick (Nokia) suggests to postpone this LS. We have just received this LS from SA5 in which SA5 asks questions to SA2, and there are no related inputs in this meeting. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
4.2	S2-2004634	LS In	Information	LS from SA WG4: LS on AT Commands for Bit Rate Recommendation	SA WG4 (S4-200880) (S4-200880)	Rel-16	Noted	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
4.2	S2-2004635	LS In	Action	LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address	CT WG4 (C4-203452) (C4-203452)	Rel-16	Postponed	Patrice (Huawei) proposes a draft outgoing LS including copy to CT for handling it before Rel-16 stage 3 freeze. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei and also objects to original draft LS reply. Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the reply LS (or rather not allocate a number to it - no need to send to the CC). The incoming LS can be postponed. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
4.2	S2-2004636	LS In	Information	LS from IETF DRIP: Scope and goals of the Drone Remote ID Protocol Working Group (DRIP) of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)	IETF DRIP (LSs_from_IETF_9June2020) (LSs_from_IETF_9June2020)		Postponed	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone the LS. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
8.5	-	-	-	Study on enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (FS_IIoT)	-	-	Docs:=58		-
8.5	S2-2004329	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004138, merging S2-2003921 and S2-2003942. To handle at CC#4. R14 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003752, to S2-2004701.	Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 that includes embedded questions as well as updated proposal removing QoS association with Survival Time. Yuan (CATT) provides r02 and comments. Sang-Jun provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r05. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds with a proposal for the text in question. Devaki (Nokia) provides r07. Yuan (CATT) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks questions Devaki (Nokia) answers Sebastian's question. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) proposes comments and provides r08 Hui NI (Huawei) provides r09 Yuan (CATT) provides r10. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r11 removing 'shall'. Vijay (Apple) provides r12, merging S2-2003752 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hui Ni(Huawei) comments on r11. Prefers to r10. Shabnam (Ericsson) can accept r11, objects to others and provide comments. Hui Ni (Huawei) responses. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r11 Hui Ni (Huawei) objects r11. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides revised text for the controversial one and asks chairman to consider this small update over r11 to make progress. Hui NI(Huawei) is fine with the proposed changes. Devaki (Nokia) uploads R14 with changes proposed by Ericsson, Huawei and requests SA2 Chairman to add this paper for CC#4. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004701	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT, Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon, Apple, Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004329_R14, merging S2-2003752. Approved		Approved
8.5	-	-	-	Solution for KI#1	-	-	Docs:=5		-
8.5	S2-2003622	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Time Synchronization and remove EN.	Ericsson, Nokia	Rel-17	Approved	Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes 3622 to be merged to 3992. Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes 3622 to be merged to 3939. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) does not believe that this paper has been merged with 3939 as the revision of 3939 does not seem to cover the technical proposal in 3622. Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia, sorry that I missed the email from Samsung. I would like to treat the two papers separately and approve 3622 since there were no comments? Sang-Jun (Samsung) replise to Shabnam, Devaki. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Sang-Jun for understanding, did not see the email on merger until after deadline, as parts of the pCR missing from merged document, let's get them progressed separately. Devaki (Nokia) comments that the chairman's notes should ask whether original version can be approved. (as also agreed by Samsung) ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.5	S2-2003939	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Sync.	Samsung	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004637	Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Dan Wang (China Mobile). Qianghua (Huawei) seeks clarifications. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Qianghua (Huawei). Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) raises a number of questions that need clarification to better understand the solution update. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts r02, replies to Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees this is needed and asks for more clarification Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Qianghua (Huawei) and provides r04. zhendong (ZTE) has similar comments with huawei Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Zhendong (ZTE). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004637	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Sync.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003939. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2004211	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: (g)PTP GM support by DS-TT.	Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004638	Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification Sebastian replies to Dan Wang (China Mobile) Dan (China Mobile) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r01 Hui NI (Huawei) comments whether this is in the scope of the study. zhendong (ZTE) provides proposal Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Huawei and ZTE and clarifies that it is in scope given that a different paper (3570) updates the related key issue 3B to cover the case of DS-TT generating (g)PTP messages. Hui NI(Huawei) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification on Huawei comment and does not agree to original version, ok with r01, have question on r02. Hui Ni (Huawei) responses. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and provides r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) prefers Qualcomm proposed wording and also comments. Hui NI (Huawei) is fine with r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004638	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: (g)PTP GM support by DS-TT.	Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004211. Approved		Approved
8.5	-	-	-	Solution for KI#2	-	-	Docs:=15		-
8.5	S2-2003619	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: UE-UE communication based on generalized Ethernet model.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004639	Qianghua (Huawei) raises strong concerns and proposes to NOTE. zhendong (ZTE) provides the question for clarification György (Ericsson) replies to Huawei comments. György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE question. Devaki (Nokia) also has some concerns with the proposal. György (Ericsson) addresses Nokia's concerns. Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to not prevent solutions from being included in the TR based on subjective views and evaluation comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports capturing the solution in the TR. Devaki (Nokia) comments. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) still holds concerns. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) responds to György. Devaki (Nokia) proposes a way forward. Devaki (Nokia) proposes r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) can only accept r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 to add a Note and Qualcomm as a supporting company Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 based on r01. Devaki (Nokia) Ok with r01 or r04. György (Ericsson) thanks and accepts r03. György (Ericsson) provides r05 based on r03. Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses and r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) can accept r01, r04 or r06, cannot accept other revisions. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei that preventing the documentation of the major part of a new solution is not helpful. György (Ericsson) respectfully requests Nokia to state what is the basis for objecting to the documentation of a major part of the solution on the delay model. Nokia's earlier statement that the solution 'assumes only UE-UPF delay' is clearly incorrect. The solution clearly considers intra-UPF delay and that is in line with TSN principles where TSN bridges also consider the processing delay between ingress and egress ports. It cannot be a basis for objection that Nokia sees other solution options as well - those can also be documented when contributed. Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r04/r06. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki and strongly proposes to agree on r05 Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r06/r04 and object any other revisions. Devaki (Nokia) replies to Sebastian and Gyorgy and comments that exclusion of whole intra-UPF delay (as in rev5) for UE-UE communication is incorrect. Thus the proposal to go with R04/06 without the delay part. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004639	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: UE-UE communication based on generalized Ethernet model.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003619. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003751	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, New Sol: UPF triggered UE-UE TSC communication.	Apple	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004640	Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification Qianghua (Huawei) raises concerns. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) asked for clarification zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification. Devaki (Nokia) also has strong concerns with the solution proposal, technical feasibility. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Vijay (Apple) provides r02 Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Vijay (Apple) responds to Qianghua (Huawei) Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r01,r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004640	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, New Sol: UPF triggered UE-UE TSC communication.	Apple	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003751. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003954	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, new solution .	ZTE	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004641	Qianghua (Huawei) raises strong concerns and proposes to NOTE. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 and response to comments. György (Ericsson) provides comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE and raises further questions Devaki (Nokia) wonders if the solution exposing only internals of UPF needs to be documented in the TR? Asks question for clarification. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. zhendong (ZTE), i am fine with r02 György (Ericsson) provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r03. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r04 and response to comments Qianghua (Huawei) replies to György. György (Ericsson) accepts r04 but asks a question. György (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. György (Ericsson) responds. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004641	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, new solution .	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003954. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003955	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, update the solution 2.	ZTE	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004642	Xiaowan Ke ( vivo) comments and requests to note this paper. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01 Qianghua (Huawei) raise concerns on r01 zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification to huawei Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei)comments on R03 and provides r04. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r05 zhendong (ZTE) provides the r06 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06 Xiaowan (vivo) is fine with r06 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004642	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, update the solution 2.	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003955. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003940	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify UE-to-UE TSC.	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004643	Qianghua (Huawei) comments and proposes to merge to S2-2003992. Sang-Jun (Samsung) agreed to merge prosal from Qianghua (Huawei). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2003992	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the procedures and impacts.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003940, to S2-2004643	Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides meerged revision r01. György (Ericsson) requests updates to the merged document. Devaki (Nokia) comments and requests revision to clarify the comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 and replies to Devaki and György. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and asks further questions. Qianghua (Huawei) responds to György. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04. György (Ericsson) provides r05. Qianghua (Huawei) comments on the ENs. György (Ericsson) responds and provides r06. Qianghua (Huawei) comments back. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. We only accept r06 or r05. Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees with György (Ericsson). Qianghua (Huawei) can live with r06 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004643	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the procedures and impacts.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2003992, merging S2-2003940. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003993	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #2: evaluation and conclusion.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Postponed	György (Ericsson) proposes to note the document. Devaki (Nokia) also believes that this is a pre-mature conclusion thus it is best to NOTE this document. To be clear, we would have objection to any revision of this document during this meeting. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees to postpone this given new solutions are submitted. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
8.5	S2-2004136	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004644	Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. György (Ericsson) comments. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Gyorgy, Qianghua, also merges two valid email threads for the same paper. Devaki (Nokia) also provides r01 (addressing Qualcomm, Ericsson, Huawei comments). György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides further comments on the responses. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) answers. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04. György (Ericsson) provides r05. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06. György (Ericsson) is also OK with r06. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004644	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2004136. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2004137	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#2, Sol #4: AF Request for UE-UE QoS reservations.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Noted	György (Ericsson) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to NOTE this since it is for discussion ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.5	-	-	-	Solution for KI#3A	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.5	S2-2003777	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, New Solution: Mechanism for AF requesting 5G network jitter.	China Mobile	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004645	Devaki (Nokia) comments and asks question for clarification Belen (Ericsson) comments the proposal Dan (China Mobile) reply to Devaki's and Belen's comments and provides r01 Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution Dan(China Mobile)reply to Belen and please clarify your main concern Dan(China Mobile) provides r02 to address Belen's concern Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004645	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, New Solution: Mechanism for AF requesting 5G network jitter.	China Mobile	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003777. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003919	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to KI and sol to add survival time capability exposure .	CATT	Rel-17	Approved	Hui Ni (Huawei) questions whether we should mix KI#3A and KI#5. Yuan (CATT) provides response. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.5	S2-2003621	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3, Sol #5: Update to clarify Exposure of TSC capabilities .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004646	Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 (with some comments). Hui Ni (Huawei) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02, including comments provided by Nokia and Huawei. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004646	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3, Sol #5: Update to clarify Exposure of TSC capabilities .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003621. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003956	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#3A, update the solution 6.	ZTE	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004648	Belen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions zhendong (ZTE) , this paper is merged to noakia S2-2004134 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2004088	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, New Sol: Supporting deterministic communication.	Samsung	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004647	Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) objects to this proposal Yoonseon (Samsung) replies to Belen and Qianghua. Qianghua (Huawei) comments again. Belen (Ericsson) replies to questions and maintains objection to r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 to reflect Huawei concern. Belen (Ericsson) replies to questions and provides r04, objections to initial version, r01, r02 and r03 Yoonseon(Samsung) provides r05, and replies to Belen and Qianghua Belen (Ericsson) comments on r05 . Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 and responses. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06 Devaki (Nokia) raises a question. Yoonseon (Samsung) provides r07, and replies to Devaki. Samsung is ok for r06 and r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r07 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004647	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, New Sol: Supporting deterministic communication.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2004088. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2004227	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#3A, new solution: Burst arrival time adaptation.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Noted	Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Devaki (Nokia) raises follow up questions. Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns with the current proposal and objects to any version of the pCR, comments below. Devaki (Nokia) proposes r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Shabnam and provides r04 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) maintains sustained objection to original and all revisions of this document, provides comments. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.5	S2-2004230	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3, New Sol: Enhancement to 5GS TSN bridge capability reporting and configuration.	Intel	Rel-17	Noted	Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) objects to this proposal Saso (Intel) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and Qianghua (Huawei) Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to not prevent solutions from being included in the TR based on evaluation views. Sebastian (Qualcomm) points out that the E/// paper in S2-2003619 provides a good justification for the solution proposed in this paper and supports including the solution proposed in S2-2004230 into the TR. Belen (Ericsson) replies to QC and Intel. Saso (Intel) thanks Sebastian (Qualcomm) for support and replies to Belen (Ericsson); also provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) has concerns with the aspects where this solution is introducing numerous variants. Provides r02, kindly requests for another revision considering comments in r02. Saso (Intel) provides r03 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03 Belen (Ericsson) objects to r03, and any other previous revision if this document. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.5	S2-2004134	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to resolve ENs and merge solutions 5 & 6.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003956, to S2-2004648	Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and asks for clarification. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02 Devaki (Nokia) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) comments that the chairman's notes should ask whether r02 can be approved? (latest version is r02). ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004648	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to resolve ENs and merge solutions 5 & 6.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004134, merging S2-2003956. Approved		Approved
8.5	-	-	-	KI#3B Update	-	-	Docs:=1		-
8.5	S2-2003570	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B: Update to KI #3B to support PTP over UDP/IP.	NTT DOCOMO, Sennheiser, BBC, EBU, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm, Futurewei	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.5	-	-	-	Solution for KI#3B	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.5	S2-2003581	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.	NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser	Rel-17	Revised, merging S2-2003943, to S2-2004312		Revised
8.5	S2-2004312	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.	NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003581, merging S2-2003943. R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003991, to S2-2004649	Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2003991 and provides r01 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 and comments Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Devaki/Jari and provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) responds. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Jari Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provide r05. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r08 to remove Qualcomm from supporters list Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that the pCR needs to replace 'Timing Domain' with 'Time Domain' since the term Timing Domain does not exist? Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds that 'Timing Domain' is used in several Key Issues and Solutions in the existing TR 23.700-020, so it is proposed to clarify or change the term in the next meeting. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004649	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.	NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser, Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R08 of S2-2004312, merging S2-2003991. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003943	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to Expand Sync Exposure.	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004312		Merged
8.5	S2-2003920	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, New Sol: Activate or deactivate TSN time synchronization per AF request.	CATT	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004651	Yuan (CATT) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) comments. Yuan (CATT) provides response to Hui Ni (Huawei). Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge. Yuan (CATT) merges this paper into 2004112r03 . ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2003957	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#3B, new solution .	ZTE	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004651	Hui Ni (Huawei) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Devaki (Nokia) comments and proposes to consider merge. Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge. zhendong (ZTE) this paper is merged to 4112 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2003987	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update to support Per UE or Per UE Group TSN Activation/deactivation .	Tencent	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.5	S2-2003988	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7/8: Update the Solutions to support TSN time Synchronization over IP.	Tencent	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004650	Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) provides r01 to only cover solution#8. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004650	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update the Solutions to support TSN time Synchronization over IP.	Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003988. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2003991	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to clarify how to determine time announcement information.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004649	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) confirms this is merged into S2-2004312. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2004112	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: Solution for KI #3B: Exposure of Time Synchronization .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003920 and S2-2003957, to S2-2004651	Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) questions if the solution actually works and if so to give more explanation how. Hui NI (Huawei) responses and provide r02. Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge 3920 into 4112 and provides r03. Hui NI(Huawei) fine with r03. Jari (NTT DoCOMO) provides r04 and proposes to focus only to clause 6.7.3. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r05. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments on r06 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Zhendong. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r07 Yuan (CATT) seeks clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Yuan. Yuan (CATT) responds to Jari. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004651	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: Solution for KI #3B: Exposure of Time Synchronization .	Huawei, HiSilicon,CATT, ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2004112, merging S2-2003920 and S2-2003957. Approved		Approved
8.5	-	-	-	Solution for KI#5	-	-	Docs:=8		-
8.5	S2-2003752	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #5, New Sol: IIoT application specific AF providing survival time as part of the QoS container.	Apple	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004701	Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments about the paper motivation Devaki (Nokia) comments and asks question for clarification Shabnam (Ericsson) It is unclear how it relates to KI#5, and how it works. Vijay (Apple) responds to comments and provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) questions what is the difference with this revision and S2-2004329 approach? I think this one can be noted or considered merged with 4329? Devaki (Nokia) also proposes that merging with 4329 (or noting) should be considered Vijay (Apple) accepts the suggestion to merge to 4329 Shabnam (Ericsson) please add Ericsson as supporting company for this pCR. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) corrects mistake, the comment was on the wrong document thread, meant to cosign S2-2004329. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.5	S2-2003921	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #X, New Sol: Use of survival time.	CATT	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004329		Merged
8.5	S2-2003942	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI #5, New Sol: Survival Time Format.	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004329		Merged
8.5	S2-2003958	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#5, Update the key issue#5.	ZTE	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.5	S2-2003959	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#5, new solution .	ZTE	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004652	Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, remove the NG RAN preconfiguration as it is up to NG-RAN to decide how to use this information. Devaki (Nokia) provides revision 2. Hui Ni(Huawei) proposes to merge into S2-2004329. zhendong (ZTE) prefer keeping seperately. zhendong (ZTE), i am fine with r01 zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004652	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#5, new solution .	ZTE, Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003959. Approved		Approved
8.5	S2-2004113	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: Solution for KI#5: Providing Survival Time for Deterministic Applications .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Noted	Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this with S2-2004329. Hui Ni (Huawei) fine to merge. Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to this pCR, and to the principle this solution provides, which contradicts the understanding and scope of SA2 part of the work related to Survival Time as described in the key issue itself. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.5	S2-2004138	P-CR	Approval	23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revised, merging S2-2003921, and S2-2003942 to S2-2004329		Revised
8.5	-	-	-	LS OUT	-	-	Docs:=2		-
8.5	S2-2004139	LS OUT	Approval	[DRAFT] LS on need for survival time for IEEE TSN	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004653	Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 in line with earlier comments (remove 'CUC', add question mark, improve wording). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.5	S2-2004653	LS OUT	Approval	LS on need for survival time for IEEE TSN	SA WG2	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004139. Approved		Approved
8.5	-	-	-	TR Coversheet	-	-	Docs:=1		-
8.5	S2-2004256	TS OR TR COVER	Approval	FS_IIoT TR 23.700-20 Cover sheet for information to TSG SA	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell (Rapporteur)	Rel-17	Noted	Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this, consistent and aligned with Ph 1 meeting decision on other TR Cover sheet handling. Hui Ni (Huawei) agree with Ericsson's comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.6	-	-	-	Study Extended Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (FS_eATSSS)	-	-	Docs:=29		-
8.6	-	-	-	TR Skeleton, Scope	-	-	Docs:=4		-
8.6	S2-2003746	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Skeleton.	ZTE (Rapporteur)	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004654	Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 to update System Impacts clause to include IETF protocols. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004654	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Skeleton.	ZTE (Rapporteur)	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003746. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2003747	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: EATSSS_Ph2 Scope.	ZTE (Rapporteur)	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004655	Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004655	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: EATSSS_Ph2 Scope.	ZTE (Rapporteur)	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003747. Approved		Approved
8.6	-	-	-	Architectural Requirements, Assumptions	-	-	Docs:=4		-
8.6	S2-2003846	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions on Steering Mode.	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004658	Tricci (ZTE) conditional objects this PCR dependent the answer of the question. Laurent (Nokia): Comments Dongeun (Samsung) answers to the question. Tricci (ZTE) asked for further clarification. Stefan (Ericsson) also asks for clarification Dongeun (Samsung) proposed to merge this paper with S2-2003662 (merged text already applied to 3662r06,r07,r08) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.6	S2-2004098	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions for ATSSS.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	R13 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004656	Tricci (ZTE) proposed r01 to indicate that the new architectural components should be conditional for now. Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03 Tricci (ZTE) provides r04 Curt (Charter) provides r05 Marco (Huawei) provides r06 Tricci (ZTE) provides r07 to enforce new added steering functionality to be based on today IETF protocols. Krisztian (Apple) provides r08. Tricci (ZTE) commented r08 - missing figure from Apple Hualin response to Tricci (ZTE) and provide r09. Laurent (Nokia): provides r10 and comments Marco (Huawei): provides r11 and comments Laurent (Nokia): provides r12 and comments Tricci (ZTE):provides r13 to ensure the alignment with IETF for any extension on QUIC/MPQUIC from 3GPP. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hualin(Huawei) response to Tricci (ZTE), we are ok with R13, thanks. Laurent (Nokia) Prefers we approve R012 and comments. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) prefers approving r12. Laurent (Nokia) this mail replaces my previous mail, objects to r00, r01, r06, r07, r08, r09. Prefers we approve R012 and comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides some background information on TLS. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004656	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions for ATSSS.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, ZTE, Apple	Rel-17	Revision_R13 of S2-2004098. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004239	DISCUSSION	Agreement	Energy conscious steering mode for eATSSS.	Google	Rel-17	Noted	Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications on this discussion paper. Pavan (Google) responds to ZTE's questions, and proposes to NOTE the paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.6	-	-	-	New Key Issues	-	-	Docs:=7		-
8.6	S2-2003661	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Modes.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, BT, Apple, Broadcom	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004657	Tricci (ZTE) proposed r01. Tricci (ZTE) resubmitted r01 (forgot the link in the last email). Laurent (Nokia) submitted r02 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004657	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003661. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2003662	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom	Rel-17	R13 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003846, to S2-2004658	Dongeun (Samsung) provides r01. Tricci (ZTE) proposed r02. Laurent (Nokia) submitted r03 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r04 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05 Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06. Laurent (Nokia) submitted r06, r07 and comments Florin (Broadcom) provides r08 with editorial updates. Spencer Dawkins provides r09 with correction to text on QUIC usage of TLS 3.0 (description is in file), added Tencent as supporting. Dongeun (Samsung) provides r10 Krisztian (Apple) provides r11. Laurent (Nokia): provides r12 and comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r12 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r13 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004658	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom, ZTE, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R13 of S2-2003662, merging S2-2003846. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004097	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: KI #x (Additional Steering Mode): New Sol: Aggregated Steering Mode for Multiple traffic.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Postponed	Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarification. Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification Chia-Lin (MediaTek) asked for clarification Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r02 Megha(Intel) provides comments and proposes to note the pCR. Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) doubts the paper assumption. Hua(Huawei) response to Tricci (ZTE). Hualin (Huawei) response to Dongeun(Samsung) Hualin response to Chia-Lin (MediaTek). Hualin(Huawei) response to Laurent (Nokia). Hualin(Huawei) response to Stefan (Ericsson). Hualin (Huawei) response to Megha(Intel). Hualin (Huawei) response to Chunshan(Tencent). Hualin (Huawei) provide r03. Megha(Intel) answers question from Hualin and provides further comments Hualin (Huawei) response to the comments from Stefan(Ericsson). Hualin (Huawei) provide r04. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05 Laurent (Nokia): provides r06 and comments Hualin(Huawei) thanks to Laurent (Nokia) and ok with revision 06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments and proposes to postpone this PCR. Hualin(Huawei) response to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom). Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Laurent's comment Laurent (Nokia) suggests to POSTPONE this P-CR Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to postpone. Megha(Intel) proposes to postpone the pCR. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.6	S2-2004184	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Key Issue #X: Supporting MA PDU with 3GPP access leg over EPC and Non-3GPP access leg over 5GC.	InterDigital Inc., Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004659	Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 and comments ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) is ok with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004659	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Key Issue #X: Supporting MA PDU with 3GPP access leg over EPC and Non-3GPP access leg over 5GC.	InterDigital Inc., Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004184. Approved		Approved
8.6	-	-	-	New Solutions	-	-	Docs:=14		-
8.6	S2-2003697	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: QUIC-LL steering functionality .	Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004660	Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification. Dongeun (Samsung) asks for clarificaiton. Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) asks a question for clarification. Laurent (Nokia) provides a r01 and comments. Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications Tricci (ZTE) asked for additional clarifications Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Susan's (Huawei) questions. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun's (Samsung) questions. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Myungjune's (LGE) question. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) answers Jinguo's (ZTE) questions. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Laurent (Nokia). Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Tricci's (ZTE) questions. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns. Myungjune (LGE) withdraws previous comment. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r03 Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung) questions. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r04. Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause. Florin (Broadcom) provides r05. Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06. Laurent (Nokia): provides r07 and comments Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung). Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) is fine with r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00 Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r06, r07 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004660	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: QUIC-LL steering functionality .	Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2003697. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2003788	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality .	Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R07 agreed. Revised to S2-2004702.	Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments Tricci (ZTE) asked the following clarifications Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification Laurent (Nokia) comments Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns (similar concerns on QUIC-LL, S2-2003697). Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung). Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r02. Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Stefan's (Ericsson) questions for clarification Florin (Broadcom) provides r03. Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause. Florin (Broadcom) responds to Tricci's (ZTE) request and provides r04 : System impact and dependencies on other SDOs work should be identified and captured during the evaluation stage. This should be generally valid for all the proposed solutions. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Broadcom for the support to identify the IETF impacts. Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06 (r05 was a mistake). Laurent (Nokia): provides r and comments Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r08, which deletes just one EN in r07, and provides further comments. Susan (Huawei) provides comments and supports r07. Susan (Huawei) comments. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dongeun (Samsung) responds to Aspotolis (Motorola Mobility) Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00 Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r06, r07, r08 Susan (Huawei) can only accept r07. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004702	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality .	Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003788_R07. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004012	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method MP-QUIC for UDP.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R05.5 agreed. Revised to S2-2004703.	Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification (similar comments to 4013) Susan (Huawei) answers the questions from Samsung. Jinguo(ZTE) provides comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Jinguo. Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarification. Susan (Huawei) replies to Tricci. Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Huawei Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan and Laurent. Florin (Broadcom) asks for clarifications and requests further updates in the document. Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04. Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments Susan (Huawei) is ok with r05. Florin (Broadcom) replies and requests for an EN in both 4012 and 4013 Florin (Broadcom) provides r06 with an EN and clarifies that this is a QUIC based proxy solution. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Susan (Huawei) replies to Florin. Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00 Susan (Huawei) proposes the similar way forward as for 4013 (i.e. create a r05.5 to approve at CC#4) Florin (Broadcom) supports the proposed way forward by Susan (Huawei) Laurent (Nokia) supports the proposed way forward by Susan (Huawei) ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004703	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method MP-QUIC for UDP.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004012_R05.5. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004013	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method QUIC for UDP.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R05.5 agreed. Revised to S2-2004704.	Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification Susan (Huawei) answers the questions from Samsung. Jinguo (ZTE) provides questions.. Dongeun (Samsung) asked for further clarification Susan (Huawei) replies to Jinguo. Susan (Huawei) replies to Dongeun. Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns on the case 1) Chunshan (Tencent) questions on combine QUIC with ATSSS-LL Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Susan (Huawei) replies to Chunshan. Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 and comments Florin (Broadcom) asks for clarifications and requests further updates in the document. Tricci (ZTE) has similar comments as Broadcom and Ericsson Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04. Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Tricci. Susan (Huawei) agrees with r05. Florin (Broadcom) provides r06 with an EN and clarifies that this is a QUIC based proxy solution. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Susan (Huawei) replies to Florin and propose to go with r05. Laurent (Nokia): prefers much R06 Florin (Broadcom) replies to Susan (Huawei) explaining why r06 is the only acceptable version. Susan (Huawei) replies to Laurent. Laurent (Nokia) replies to Susan (Huawei. Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00, r01, r02 Florin (Broadcom) replies to Susan (Huawei) and proposes a way forward. Laurent (Nokia): supports the way forward from Florin (create a r5.5 to approve at CC#4) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports also the way forward proposed from Florin (create a r5.5 to approve at CC#4) Susan (Huawei) replies to Dieter, Laurent and Florin, and agrees with the way forward from Florin (i.e. create a r05.5 to approve at CC#4) ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004704	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method QUIC for UDP.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004013_R05.5. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004014	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering modes.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004661	Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment Megha(Intel) provides comments. Susan (Huawei) replies to Intel, ZTE, Samsung. Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments Susan (Huawei) replies to Laurent. Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 and comments Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Megha(Intel) provides further comments Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04. Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments Stefan (Ericsson) provides r06 Susan (Huawei) is ok with r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): objects to r00, r01, r02, r03; prefers r05 or r06 Megha(Intel) can accept r06. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004661	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Sol: New steering modes.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2004014. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004173	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Replacing 3GPP access leg of MA-PDU Session with PDN connection in EPC.	InterDigital Inc.,	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004662	Myungjune (LGE) provide comments. Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefan (Ericsson) question. Guanzhou (InterDigital) further responds comments and provides revision 01. Laurent (Nokia) submitted r02 and comments ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02. Laurent (Nokia): we can only live with r02 (objection to previous versions) Stefan (Ericsson) prefers r02 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.6	S2-2004662	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: Replacing 3GPP access leg of MA-PDU Session with PDN connection in EPC.	InterDigital Inc.,	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004173. Approved		Approved
8.6	S2-2004293	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: New Solution: QUIC Tunnel Low-Layer (QT-LL) Steering Functionality .	Apple	Rel-17	Revised to S2-2004300	Qing An (Alibaba) proposes to NOTE this document.	Revised
8.6	S2-2004300	P-CR	Approval	23.700-93: KI#x, New Sol: QUIC Tunnel Low-Layer (QT-LL) Steering Functionality	Apple	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004293. Noted	Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification. Qing An (Alibaba) proposes to NOTE this document. Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks a question. Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Alibaba. Adi (Apple) responds to Huawei's comments. Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause. Adi (Apple) responds to ZTE's comments. Adi (Apple) responds to Samsung's comments. Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Ericsson. Adi (Apple) responds to Nokia's comments. Florin (Broadcom) provides r03 . Adi (Apple) provides r04. Dongeun (Samsung) provides r05. Laurent (Nokia): provides r06 and comments Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Samsung. Susan (Huawei) provides comments. Adi (Apple) responds to Huawei. Adi (Apple) responds to Nokia's comments and provides r07. Susan (Huawei) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Adi (Apple) objects r08 and provides comments to Huawei. Susan (Huawei) objects to r04, r05, r06, r07. Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00 and we can leave with r03 and comments Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r05, r06, r07, r08 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.7	-	-	-	Study on supporting UAS Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (FS_ID_UAS-SA2)	-	-	Docs:=67		-
8.7	-	-	-	LSs IN/OUT	-	-	Docs:=5		-
8.7	S2-2003522	LS In	Action	LS from ATIS UAV Ad-Hoc Group: Liaison Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17	ATIS UAV Ad-Hoc Group (FAA NPRM for UAV Remote ID)		Revision of postponed S2-2002624 from S2-138E. Response drafted in S2-2003800. Final response in S2-2004663	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Replied to
8.7	S2-2003800	LS OUT	Approval	[DRAFT] Reply LS on Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17	Qualcomm Wireless GmbH		Response to S2-2003522. R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004663	Chen (OPPO) provides r01 and comments. Chris (Vodafone) says update section 3 during clean-up. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004663	LS OUT	Approval	Reply LS on Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17	SA WG2	-	Revision_R01 of S2-2003800. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004319	LS In	Action	LS from SA WG1: Reply to LS on Clarification of the definition of a UAS	SA WG1 (S1-202267)	Rel-17	Postponed	Steve (Huawei) proposed to note. Stefano (Faccin) suggests postponing the LS. Steve (Huawei) postponing is fine. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
8.7	S2-2004320	LS In	Information	LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on Clarification of requirements for UAS application enablement	SA WG1 (S1-202270)	Rel-17	Noted	Steve (Huawei) proposes to note. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	-	-	-	Architectural Requirements and Assumptions	-	-	Docs:=7		-
8.7	S2-2003716	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Key Issues, all: Update of Architectural Requirements and Assumptions.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004664	Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01. Antoine (Orange) questions r01. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) comments and provides r02. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Antoine (Orange) question. Steve (Huawei) comments. Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification on UAV9. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds. Sherry (Nokia) provides r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification why the interface without any designation nor jurisdiction of 3GPP between TPAE and UTM need to be shown in the diagram? Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 04. Chen (OPPO) provides comments. Sherry (Nokia) provides comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks everyone for the constructive coordination, r04 is fine for us. Comment to the rapporteur added. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) accepts R04. Object to original version. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004664	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Key Issues, all: Update of Architectural Requirements and Assumptions.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003716. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2003794	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Correction to Architectural Requirements.	Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Futurewei, Verizon	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.7	S2-2003795	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon, Nokia	Rel-17	R08 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004665	Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides revision 01. Chen (OPPO) provides revision 02 and comments. Antoine (Orange) comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on revision 02. Steve (Huawei) comments and asks a question. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides revision 03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on revision 03. Dan (China Mobile) comments for clarification Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) asks to clarify/update based on comments below. Antoine (Orange) questions Chen's comment and replies to Shabnam. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 05 and addresses comments. Dan(China Mobile) just ask for clarification Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to question Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification. Chen (OPPO) answers Antoine's question, clarifies wrong understanding. Shabnam (Ericsson) there are some concerns remain, so we provide r06 with some ENs and changes. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 07. Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concern on r06. Guanzhou (InterDigital) repeats concerns on r06/r07. Shabnam (Ericsson) we can only accept this with the proposed update, as I see different interpretation/fulfillment ideas and as such we need to leave it open. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) agreed with Interdigital that that EN is not needed. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Guanzhou concerns. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r08. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) we can accept r08. Guanzhou (InterDigital) accepts r08. Objects to r06 and r07. Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r08 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004665	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon, Nokia, InterDigtial	Rel-17	Revision_R08 of S2-2003795. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004060	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Update to Architectural Assumptions.	China Mobile	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004667	Antoine (Orange) provides r01. Runze (Huawei) supports the rev1 and Huawei cosigns the paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004667	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Update to Architectural Assumptions.	China Mobile, Huawei	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004060. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Reference Architecture	-	-	Docs:=7		-
8.7	S2-2003727	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Reference Architecture Update: Transparency of UAV3 to 3GPP system.	OPPO	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004668	Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) agreed with Interdigital and support r01. Sherry (Nokia) is fine with r01. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) Agrees with Sherry (Nokia) Chen (OPPO) provided r02 and addresses comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r03, removing solution aspect from interface description (i.e. whether goes via two UPFs directly or not). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004668	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Reference Architecture Update: Transparency of UAV3 to 3GPP system.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003727. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004000	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Arch Update: Mapping UAS reference architecture to 5GS system.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Guanzhou (InterDigital) raises concerns and asks for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) has concerns with this proposal Sherry (Nokia) comments that this should be defined as a solution than architecture assumption. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) agrees with Sherr (Nokia) and Dimitrios (Lenovo) Shabnam (Ericsson) shares views by Nokia, T-Mobile and others that this is a potential mapping and not applicable for all, so in its current form would object to both original and r01. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions and the original. Steve (Huawei) comments. Sherry (Nokia) proposes to note the paper. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2004243	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Update to Reference Architecture .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004669	Steve (Huawei) asks about UAV10, UAV5 is underdiscussion elsewhere. Sherry (Nokia) provides r01. Steve (Huawei) comments. Chen (OPPO) provides comments. Sherry (Nokia) provides r02. Sherry (Nokia) provides r03. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) does not see any clarifications. Benefit is not clear. Sherry (Nokia) provides r04. Steve (Huawei) comments. Note? ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Sherry (Nokia) disagree with Huawei's unreasonable comments and arguments. Steve (Huawei) comments on failure to communicate. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004669	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Update to Reference Architecture .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2004243. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004245	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution on 3GPP reference architecture for UAS remote identification and USS discovery .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004670	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) comments enclosed Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for clarification. Sherry (Nokia) provides r01. Hyunsook (LGE) provides comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 02, supports changes to architecture section, expresses concerns about the solution. Sherry (Nokia) provides r03. Steve (Huawei) comments and asks questions for clarification Sherry (Nokia) provides r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks why TPAE is part of the UE? Propose to remove inclusion of TPAE in 3GPP architecture options. Steve (Huawei) comments. Sherry (Nokia) replies. Sherry (Nokia) provides r05. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004670	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution on 3GPP reference architecture for UAS remote identification and USS discovery .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2004245. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for authentication and authorization	-	-	Docs:=10		-
8.7	S2-2003717	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 7: Solution for Authentication and Authorization of UAV .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004671	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed and expresses concerns. Qianghua (Huawei) requests for clarifications. Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification on the proposed solution Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks questions for clarifications. Gerald (Matrixx) asks question for clarification. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) asks question for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 in response to comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments and requests change of solution title. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides comments and supports Rev. 02. Qianghua (Huawei) re-state our requests for clarifications. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Huawei comments and provides r03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for additional clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 04 and co-signs. Jinguo (ZTE) provides r05 and co-signs. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response to the comments. Qianghua (Huawei) responds. Jinguo (ZTE) provides comment. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to ZTE and Huawei comments, can live with the latest revision r06. Jinguo(ZTE) responds. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r06. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004671	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 7: Solution for Authentication and Authorization of UAV .	Ericsson, InterDigital, ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003717. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2003798	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, New Sol: Solution for UAV authentication and authorization by USS/UTM .	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Interdigital, Verizon	Rel-17	R12 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004079 and S2-2004007, to S2-2004672	Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification on 'UUAA pending indication'. Qianghua (Huawei) provides rev01 Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments/questions related to the solutions and difference between 5GC and EPC and asks for clarification and potential update to the proposal. Chen (OPPO) provides r03 and comments. Antoine (Orange) provides r04. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 05 enclosed, plus addresses comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provideds r06 Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 07 enclosed. Qianghua (Huawei) requests for clarification. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) replies to comments. Qianghua (Huawei) accepts the explanation and merging S2-2004007 into S2-2003798. Antoine (Orange) provides r08. Sherry (Nokia) provides r09. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r11. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 10 and replies to comments. Cannot accept r08 or r09. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 12. We cannot accept R11, R08, R09. Sherry (Nokia) can accept r10. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide rev 13, response to Stefano comments Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) indicates Qualcomm cannot accept Rev. 13. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) response to Qualcomm's comment Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r12 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004672	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, New Sol: Solution for UAV authentication and authorization by USS/UTM .	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Interdigital, Verizon, Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R12 of S2-2003798, merging S2-2004079 and S2-2004007. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004002	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Additional CP-based Authentication and Authorisation.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004673	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification Runze (Huawei) provides clarifications on the question from Dimitrios. Runze (Huawei) provides clarification to question from Guanzhou. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano on several questions and provides r02. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 03 enclosed Farooq (AT&T) OK with rev 3 and agrees to the notes. Runze (Huawei) provides r04. Runze (Huawei) changes the solution title and provides r05. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004673	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Additional CP-based Authentication and Authorisation.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2004002. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004003	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Enhanced Secondary Authentication.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004674	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, plus comments Runze (Huawei) provides r02 and answers the questions below from Stefano. Farooq (AT&T) comments. Possibility of merger with S2-2003798 should be considered. Application level behavior description should be minimized. Runze (Huawei) provides rationale why we want the solution a separate one in the TR. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Sherry (Nokia) can accept r02 with the assumption that this solution will be merged into the solution addressed in S2-2003798 in the next meeting. Runze (Huawei) thanks Sherry for supporting r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004674	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Enhanced Secondary Authentication.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004003. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004166	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution for UAV Authentication and Authorization by USS/UTM . using key bootstrapping based on 3GPP credentials.	Interdigital	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Stefano (Qualcomm) suggestion ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2004167	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution for UAV Authentication and Authorization by UTM . using UTM authorization token.	InterDigital	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefano (Qualcomm) concerns. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) replies to comments and suggests the paper to be noted. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for KI#1	-	-	Docs:=3		-
8.7	S2-2004001	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1, New Sol: Support of Aerial UE function in 5G system.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000680. Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.7	S2-2003797	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1, KI#4, New Sol: UAV Identitity Allocation and Usage For Remote Identification.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004675	Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification. Chen (OPPO) supports Interdigital's comments and ask further questions and express concerns. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides answers to Shabnam's questions. Stefano (Faccin) provides rev. 01 and addresses comments. Dan(China Mobile) comments for clarification Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide responses to Dan's comments and provide revision r02 Stefano (Qualcomm) provide rev. 03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) Ok with r03. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004675	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#1, KI#4, New Sol: UAV Identitity Allocation and Usage For Remote Identification.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003797. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for KI#2 and KI#3	-	-	Docs:=7		-
8.7	S2-2003728	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#2, New Solution: Provision of UAV characteristics and issuing of Assigned ID.	OPPO	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004676	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, expresses concerns. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification. Chen (OPPO) provides r02, answers questions and comments. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides comments and questions. Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification Chen (OPPO) answers further questions and provides r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments and rev. 03. Stefano (Qualcomm) corrects previous post, rev. 05 has been provided. Chen (OPPO) provides r06 and comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004676	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#2, New Solution: Provision of UAV characteristics and issuing of Assigned ID.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003728. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2003729	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#2, New Solution: UAS flight authorization and location of network publishing server.	OPPO	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004677	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and addresses comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 03 enclosed Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004677	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#2, New Solution: UAS flight authorization and location of network publishing server.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003729. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004079	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #2&3, New Sol: Authentication and authorization for UAV and UAVC.	CATT	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004672	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests to merge with S2-2003798 Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to merge this with S2-2003798. Yunjing (CATT) is ok to merge with S2-2003798 and clarifies. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.7	S2-2004086	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #2, New Sol: Network Assisted Flight Path Authorization.	Samsung	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004678	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides comments, proposes merger with S2-2003798 Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification. Yoonseon(Samsung) clarifies to Guanzhou and Stefano Faccin Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) comments and questions for clarification. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments. Yoonseon(Samsung) replies to Chris J and Amanda Xiang. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004678	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #2, New Sol: Network Assisted Flight Path Authorization.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004086. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for KI#4	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.7	S2-2003730	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4, New Solution: Local broadcast (upon trigger) and direct commuincations.	OPPO	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to NOTE the paper since it does not reflect any use case addressed by SA1, nor found in the aviation community requirements, and does not address any of the key issues Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to note the pCR. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Stefano (Qualcomm) statement ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2003731	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4: New Solution: Reusing Area of Interest to support UTM/USS geofencing needs.	OPPO	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004679	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution Sherry (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper into 4244. Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and respond to comments from Lenovo and Nokia. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) provides questions for clarification. Chen (OPPO) provides answers to Futurewei's questions. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Sherry (Nokia) can live with r02 with the assumption of further improvement. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004679	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4: New Solution: Reusing Area of Interest to support UTM/USS geofencing needs.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003731. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2003748	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller Tracking .	Apple	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides rev. 01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) re-expresses concerns. Farooq (AT&T) agrees with Stefano's concerns with this proposal. Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns on all the current revisions of the proposal, see comments. Krisztian (Apple) provides r03 and responds to Stefano, Chris and Qianghua. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to note the document, since the revisions are not clarifying why we should focus on what are clearly application layer aspects.. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to the document and its revisions, the document was not updated according to comments to remove the content outside of the scope and question then what is left? Stefano (Qualcomm) also objects. The paper focuses on application layer details outside the scope of SA2 and 3GPP. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2003938	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #4, New Sol: UAV/UAVC Tracking.	Samsung	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides rev. 01 Sherry (Nokia) requests clarification. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm). Stefano (Qualcomm) adds comment and expresses concerns. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Chris J (T-Mobile USA), Stefano (Qualcomm), and Sherry (Nokia), and provides r02. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev2 Shabnam (Ericsson) comments with concern that MO-LR approach is not really suitable, more details in comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Chris J (T-Mobile USA), Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r03. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm) and provides r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this pCR, we don't believe it is correct use of procedure, please see comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r05. Stefano (Faccin) shares Ericsson concern and also objects. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano (Faccin). Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to the paper and all revisions. We do not agree the explanations provided identify necessary requirements, technically the solution assumes a specific application layer design, and we are not convinced the justifications provided for the MO-LT procedure are valid. Sherry (Nokia) shares Qualcomm and Ericsson's concern and also objects.	Noted
8.7	S2-2004080	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAVC tracking and flight route analysis based on NWDAF.	CATT	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004680	Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions on the principle of this solution Yunjing (CATT) clarifies Sherry (Nokia) requests for clarification. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 and adds comments. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) questions for clarification. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Nokia. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Futurewei. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Qualcomm and provides r03. Yunjing (CATT) responses to T-Mobile USA. Shabnam (Ericsson) shared T-Mobile concerns based on current wording of the pCR and asks clarification in the comments. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Shabnam and provides r04. Yunjing (CATT) further clarifies and provides r05. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Yunjing. Yunjing (CATT) replies to Stefano and provides rev06 (revision based on rev04 with NWDAF) and rev07 (revision based on rev05 without NWDAF). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004680	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAVC tracking and flight route analysis based on NWDAF.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2004080. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004081	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller tracking based on LCS mechanism.	CATT	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004681	Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification Sherry (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper into 4244. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies and provides r01. Yunjing (CATT) responses. Yunjing (CATT) proposes to keep S2-2004081 as a separate solution. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 02. Yunjing (CATT) accepts rev. 02. Sherry (Nokia) comments. Yunjing (CATT) replies to Sherry. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004681	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller tracking based on LCS mechanism.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004081. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004171	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Update to Solution# 1: Identification of UAVs in a target area.	Interdigital	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004682	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides revision 01. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments and asks clarification. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) suggest this to merge with Nokia's S2-2004244. Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK to merge with Nokia's S2-2004244. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.7	S2-2004244	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution on Location Exposure to UTM/USS .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004171, to S2-2004682	Sherry (Nokia) provides r01. Yunjing (CATT) provides comments. Sherry (Nokia) answers. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) questions for clarification Yunjing (CATT) proposes to keep S2-2004081 as a separate solution and comments. Sherry (Nokia) answers to Amanda. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, adding EN on who does geofencing. Sherry (Nokia) provides r03 and r04. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r05 and proposes merge of 2004171. Yunjing (CATT) accepts r04. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r06 with ENs and an edit. Sherry (Nokia) provides r06. Sherry (Nokia) provides r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r07. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004682	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Solution on Location Exposure to UTM/USS .	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, InterDigital	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2004244, merging S2-2004171. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for KI#5	-	-	Docs:=8		-
8.7	S2-2003749	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #5, New Sol: UAV Authorisation revocation by UTM.	Apple	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses serious concerns and provides rev. 01. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments Steve (Huawei) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) expresses concerns on proceeding with this and adds comments. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Stefano and Chris and provides r02. Stefano (Qualcomm) again expresses concerns and proposes to note the paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2004004	DISCUSSION	Agreement	KI#2, KI#5: Discussion on solution principles for KI#2 & KI#5.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted since it is not actionable Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes to NOTE the discussion paper Runze (Huawei) agrees to note the paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2004005	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #2, KI#5, New Sol: Network-Assisted UAV Authorization and Monitoring .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004683	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, conditionally objects. Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Runze (Huawei) cannot find r01, and ask the author to provide again. Runze (Huawei) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo) Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Runze and proposes to note. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (QC) and provides r01. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks for the updates and provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004683	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #2, KI#5, New Sol: Network-Assisted UAV Authorization and Monitoring .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004005. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004006	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #5, New Sol: Handling of PDU session established by UAV.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004684	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 with questions for clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification. Hyunsook (LGE) asks a question for clarification Hyunsook (LGE) provides comments. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm). Runze (Huawei) replies to Guanzhou (Interdigital). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004684	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #5, New Sol: Handling of PDU session established by UAV.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004006. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004170	P-CR	Approval	23.754: C2 communication authorization revocation.	InterDigital	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004685	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide revision r02 Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004685	P-CR	Approval	23.754: USS/UTM triggered C2 communication authorization revocation.	InterDigital	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004170. Approved		Approved
8.7	-	-	-	Solutions for KI#6 and KI#7	-	-	Docs:=7		-
8.7	S2-2003750	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV Controller and UAV association .	Apple	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses serious concerns that the solution is based purely on application layer aspects, and provides rev. 01 reserving to object. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r03 Shabnam (Ericsson) we fail to understand the need for the AMF to be in the middle of UAC control change and what benefits adds. Comments further and proposes to note the document unless further clarification made. Krisztian (Apple) provides r04 and responds to Amanda, Chris, Qianghua and Stefano. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to note the solution. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.7	S2-2004007	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI#6, New Sol: UAS authorization considering association of the UAV and UAV controller.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000682 Merged into S2-2004672	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Shabnam (Ericsson) unsure if merger proposal was accepted or not, asks some question. Qianghua (Huawei) responds and thinks this is supposed to merge with S2-2003798 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.7	S2-2004150	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV-UAVC association control.	Samsung	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004686	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provides comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Jungshin (Samsung) replies to questions and provides r02. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides rev03 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03 Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r03. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004686	P-CR	Approval	23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV-UAVC association control.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004150. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004168	P-CR	Approval	23.754: Connectivity setup for C2 communication and association between UAV and UAV-C.	InterDigital	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004687	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) provide comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides revision 02. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev2 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.7	S2-2004687	P-CR	Approval	23.754: UAV/UAV-C initiated connectivity setup for C2 communication and association.	InterDigital	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004168. Approved		Approved
8.7	S2-2004169	P-CR	Approval	23.754: C2 communication switching for change of UAV-C.	InterDigital	Rel-17	Noted	Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) please see comments on 4168 Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 01. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev1 Shabnam (Ericsson) questions if the solution is any different compared to other solns and as description provided on PLMN level and not NF level? Propose to NOTE the pCR unless more details provided. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 02. Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) supports Ericsson and proposes to note. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.7	-	-	-	New Annex	-	-	Docs:=1		-
8.7	S2-2003796	P-CR	Approval	23.754: FS_ID_UAS-SA2: 'Application Layer' Security Infrastructure and Assumptions for UAS Remote Identification Security.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Noted	Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to note this pCR. Steve (Huawei) Also suggests noting. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.8	-	-	-	Study on system enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (FS_5G_ProSe)	-	-	Docs:=112		-
8.8	-	-	-	Architecture assumption, definition	-	-	Docs:=5		-
8.8	S2-2004090	P-CR	Approval	23.752: TR 23.752 alignment with SA#86 outcome.	CATT, OPPO	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2003790	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Architecture Assumption update.	Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Noted	Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted. Sudeep (Apple) proposes this Tdoc to be NOTED. Toon Norp (KPN) proposes this Tdoc to be NOTED. Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes the document to be noted Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, with understanding that there is an SA2 approved SI with SC in scope of the study. Mehrdad (Samsung) supports r01. Dario (Huawei) proposes to note the document. Lars (Sony) proposes to note the document. Sudeep (Apple) maintains the same opinion (document to be NOTED) on version r01 too. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003816	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe Discovery Architecture based on R16 V2X.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Haris (Qualcomm) agrees with comments from CATT and proposes to note this pCR LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to CATT, QC, LGE's comment and provided r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. Changhong (Intel) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) still think the pCR is not needed. Changhong (Intel) shares view from Jianhua and propose to note this paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003934	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Add 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Definition.	ZTE	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004717	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments on r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Hannu (Nokia) provides r02 Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004717	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Add 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Definition.	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003934. Approved		Approved
8.8	-	-	-	KI update	-	-	Docs:=4		-
8.8	S2-2004015	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI2: Update to address compatibility between NR PC5 QoS and Uu QoS features.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000630. Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as the issue is out of scope. LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed text does not make sense for OoC PC5 operation. Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments.. Shabnam (Ericsson) Ericsson objects to this pCR any any revision of it. There is no justification to changing the key issue towards a specific solution. Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed text is not correct. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as the NOTE reads unclear. Dario (Huawei) replies and is fine with noting the paper. LaeYoung (LGE) gives a hug to Dario (Huawei). o==== ^___^====o ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004071	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4: Update to KI#4 to add Remote UE Authorization.	Intel	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2004214	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Key issue on support of UE-NW Relay in LTE Uu coverage for public safety.	Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, FirstNet	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004718	Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted. Sudeep (Apple) asks questions for clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for clarification to Guillaume Haris (Qualcomm) answers questions Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm and objects to the proposal. Toon Norp (KPN) asks questions for clarification. Sudeep (Apple) follows-up with additional observations and supports MediaTek's proposal for the Tdoc to be NOTED. Haris (Qualcomm) responds to comments Adrian (vivo) supports the contribution. Changhong (Intel) shares Guillaume's view and objects to this paper. Haris (Qualcomm) responds to Mediatek Dario (Huawei) shares MediaTek's view and objects to this paper Toon Norp (KPN) request for further clarification Haris (Qualcomm) responds to comments from KPN Toon (KPN) responds to comments from Qualcomm Changhong (Intel) kindly provides reasons for objection. Changhong (Intel) asks to combine the two threads on this paper into this one. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Changhong (Intel) is fine with r01. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with r01. Ihab (FirstNet) supports the contribution. The support for ProSe UE-NW Relay to work when Relay UE is in LTE/EPC coverage only is very important and critical for public safety during our migration process from 4G to 5G. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004718	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Key issue on support of UE-NW Relay in LTE Uu coverage for public safety.	Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, FirstNet	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004214. Approved		Approved
8.8	-	-	-	KI#1 (Direct Discovery)	-	-	Docs:=11		-
8.8	S2-2003850	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #1.	OPPO	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004719	Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for some clarification via comments. Jianhua (OPPO) respond to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provide r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004719	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #1.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003850. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003821	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1, Sol #1 Update: Clarification on metadata.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to Dongeun (Samsung). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to Hong (Qualcomm Inc). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm Inc) suggests to NOTE. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004272	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution 2: V2X based solution- update.	Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, ATT	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004091, to S2-2004720	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged S2-2004091. Walter Dees (Philips) provides some comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02 and clarifications. Changhong (Intel) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004720	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution 2: V2X based solution- update.	Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, ATT, CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004272, merging S2-2004091. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004091	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1, Sol #2: Update to remove ENs and add clarifications.	CATT	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004720	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes S2-2004091 to be merged into S2-2004272. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2003852	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_update user plane architecture.	OPPO	Rel-17	Approved	Gerald (Matrixx) comment with question for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Gerald (Matrixx). Judy (Ericsson) agrees with Jianhua (OPPO) that CHF is not in the scope of 3852, and responded to Gerald (Matrixx). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2004016	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#1,#7, sol#18: update to support ProSe restricted discovery and event based ProSe direct discovery charging.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004721	Haris (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification and could lead to revision Gerald (Matrixx) provided additional comments for the next revision. Runze (Huawei) provides answers to the questions from Haris, and provides r01. Runze (Huawei) provides r02 to address Gerald comments. Gerald (Matrixx) provided further questions for clarification on 5G DDNWF. Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Gerald and r03. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r04 Runze (Huawei) thanks Haris for pointing out the issue and accepts r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004721	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#1,#7, sol#18: update to support ProSe restricted discovery and event based ProSe direct discovery charging.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2004016. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003824	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Evaluation for Solution #1: Restricted Direct Discovery.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Postponed	Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is ok with r01 Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet. Walter (Philips) provides some comments. Changhong (Intel) comments and asks to postpone this paper including any potential revision. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	S2-2003849	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Evaluation and conclusion for KI#1 Direct Discovery.	OPPO, CATT	Rel-17	Postponed	Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01 Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments and requests clarifications Adrain (vivo) proposes to NOTE this paper. Changhong (Intel) proposes to postpone this paper since the SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet. Jianhua (OPPO) responds vivo and Philips LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) OK to postpone. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
8.8	-	-	-	KI#2 (Direct Communication)	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.8	S2-2003719	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#1&2, New Solution: Solution for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004722	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 by adding general and impact clauses. Hao Dong (ZTE) provides comment. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03. Judy (Ericsson) responds and provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Hannu (Nokia). Judy (Ericsson) responded to LaeYoung (LGE) and is fine with r05. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004722	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#1&2, New Solution: Solution for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2003719. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003810	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#1&2, Sol#4: Update to remove EN about PC5 message type.	LG Electronics	Rel-17	Approved	Walter Dees (Philips) requests clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to question from Walter Dees (Philips). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2003946	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update regarding New Group Member Joining Procedures.	ZTE	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004723	LaeYoung (LGE) does not think the proposed change is needed. Hao Dong responds to LaeYoung's comment. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to comment from LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hao Dong (ZTE) is OK with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004723	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update regarding New Group Member Joining Procedures.	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003946. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003948	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update to Clarify Group Information Provision.	ZTE	Rel-17	Noted	LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept the proposed change and proposes to NOTE this paper. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung's comment and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r00 and r01, and asks a Q for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung's Q. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) confirms that this pCR can be NOTED. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004092	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #2, Sol# 5: Update to resolve EN.	CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004724	LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004724	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #2, Sol# 5: Update to resolve EN.	CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004092. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003978	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution#22 updates.	Vivo	Rel-17	Had been merged into S2-2003931. Noted	Hao Dong (ZTE) comments that this paper (S2-2003978) has already been merged into S2-2003931. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003931	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1,2 Sol #22: Update to Remove ENs.	ZTE	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004725	Hao Dong (ZTE) provides r01 which merges S2-2003978 from vivo. Changhong (Intel) provides r02. Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004725	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #1,2 Sol #22: Update to Remove ENs.	ZTE, vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003931. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004093	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#2: Solutions evaluation and conclusion.	CATT, OPPO, Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Postponed	Changhong (Intel) asks to mark it as 'POSTPONED' since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet. Jianhua (OPPO) asks to have some evaluation and conclusion if the solutions are relatively stable. Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Intel as this meeting new solns are being proposed, Postpone all conclusion once TR is stable. Comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine to postponed. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	-	-	-	KI#3 (UE-NW Relay)	-	-	Docs:=3		-
8.8	S2-2003642	DISCUSSION	Agreement	Discussion on ProSe UE-to-Network relays and service continuity for public safety.	AT&T, FirstNet, Samsung	Rel-17	Noted	Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification as to how this document should be handled in view of CC#2. James (AT&T) respond to Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification that we agree with you that it is BAU and our intention is to get a broad consensus on that. Haris(Qualcomm) comments on proposal 4: Each objective in the SID, more so each solution does not have its own timescales. The timescales are common for the whole SID. In this respect it will be a SA2 group decision on when to conclude the SID e.g. based on existing timescales or ask for exception if so required and let SA plenary decide. We don't agree to assigning different timescales to each solution. Ihab(FirstNet) respond to Haris(Qualcomm) concern: I believe that we are facing a unique situation with the study of layer-2 vs. layer-3 especially since layer-2 has a major dependency on RAN work and there is a slight misalignment between RAN and SA2 schedules. Since we are interested in making sure that a complete relay solution is in place in Release 17, we feel that having layer-2 and layer-3 solutions to be independent of each other at this time will help us progressing the work at least for one of the two solutions. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides some further clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments to NOTE the paper as this is ongoing work and jumping to conclusion before RAN even started its work and SA2 documents its own work is premature. James (AT&T) add a comment in support of and in addition to related comments from FirstNet and Samsung: our proposals are aimed to facilitate both RAN and SA2 work in the spirit of the working agreements just reached for the revised SA2 SID. It is about working process and is in no way jumping into any conclusion. We want to clarify issues related to service continuity for public safety. What we are trying to do is to help to reach some clear common understanding so we can progress the solutions to support related features such as SC without risking any possibility that none of the solutions can progress and conclude in R17. Haris (Qualcomm) comments Changhong (Intel) supports the proposal #1 to 3 and disagrees with proposal #4. We should stop the discussion and focus on solution development at this meeting. Wanqiang (Huawei) supports the notion of the paper. Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments and don't prefer to take the paper to CC#2. Deng Qiang (CATT) shares the same view as Jianhua (OPPO). James (AT&T) accepts the comments from the Rapporteurs and agrees to note this discussion paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004201	P-CR	Approval	23.752: UE-to-Network Relay discovery and handling of PDU session parameters with CN based relay selection.	Philips International B.V.	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Wen (vivo) provides comments. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments and provides revision r01. Changhong (Intel) comments. Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from Interdigital and proposes r02. Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from Intel and refers to r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) please see comments on S2-2004202 on your proposal, most of them applies here as well. Walter (Philips) responds to comments from Ericsson and proposes r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) responds that can live with this revision but asks to remove NID/CAGID from the final version of the paper. Changhong (Intel) objects to this paper and any revision since his concern was not resolved in any revision. Walter (Philips) responds to Intel's objection and provides draft revision r04. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004202	P-CR	Approval	23.752: UE-to-Network Relay discovery and handling of PDU session parameters with Remote UE based relay selection.	Philips International B.V.	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from CATT and provides revision r01. Changhong (Intel) comments. Walter Dees (Philips) responds to Intel's comments, and provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) please see comments on your proposal, have concerns on the amount of assumptions made with this paper. Walter (Philips) responds to Ericsson's comments, and provides r03. Walter (Philips) corrected a few mistakes in r03, and provides r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and proposes to NOTE this. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper and askes the author to provide a clean UE based solution next time. Walter (Philips) responds to CATT's objection. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Walter (Philips). Walter (Philips) responds to Ericsson's objection. Walter (Philips) responds to CATT comments. Walter (Philips) suggest people to take a look at draft revision r05. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	-	-	-	Layer-3 Relay	-	-	Docs:=28		-
8.8	S2-2003785	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, Sol #6: Update to L3 UE-to-Network Relay Procedure.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000870. Merged to S2-2004715	LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because 4094 touches similar aspects. Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies the status of S2-2003785. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 and suggests to fully merge into S2-2004094 based on r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) says that S2-2003785r01 is already merged into S2-2004094. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2004020	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #6:Open issues of Solution #6.	Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000493	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Dario (Huawei) replies to comments. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and provides r01. Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) supports r01 and objects r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) OBJECTs to r02 and provides r03. Dario (HW) replies and provides r03 Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Dario (HW). Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Dario (HW) as there is a conflict on r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) accepts r03, r01, and objects to other revisions. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004726	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #6:Open issues of Solution #6.	Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004020. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004094	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to clarify non-IP and LI aspects.	CATT, LG Electronics, Qualcomm Incorporated(?)	Rel-17	Confirm Sources!. R09 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003785, to S2-2004715.	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Tyler Hawbaker (OTD) provides question for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) supports this updated Sol based on r01. Part of S2-2003785 merged into S2-2004094. Deng Qiang (CATT) answers the question and provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc) provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on R04. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc)'s comments. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.). Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to go with r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) object r03 and proposes a way forward. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06 and comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r07 and comments with Ericsson cosigning. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r08. Toon Norp (KPN) still has a question on LI aspects. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Toon Norp (KPN). Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Toon Norp (KPN). Toon Norp (KPN) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Toon Norp (KPN). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Toon (KPN) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). Toon Norp (KPN) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). Ihab (FirstNet) responds to comments regarding Public Safety LI requirements. We are expecting that the LI for public safety users to be the same as the requirements for commercial users. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question to Toon Toon (KPN) answers to Haris Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) only accepts r05 and object all other versions. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital). ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004715	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to clarify non-IP and LI aspects.	CATT, LG Electronics, Samsung, Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004094_R09, merging S2-2003785. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004282	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution to support end-to-end security for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Ericsson, Samsung	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004034, to S2-2004727	Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) questions the proposal and provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responses to Myungjune (LGE). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provide r02. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Hong (Qualcomm Inc) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r03. Lars (Sony) provides comment Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r04 Haris (Qualcomm) comments to r04 Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Answering to Lars Lars (Sony): provides comments Lars (Sony): provides comments Answering to Laurent Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Qualcomm. Haris (Qualcomm) comments and provides r05 Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Lars (Sony). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004727	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution to support end-to-end security for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Ericsson, Samsung, Nokia	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2004282, merging S2-2004034. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004034	P-CR	Approval	23.752: New Solution Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay with support of N3IWF.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004727	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes S2-2004034 to be merged into S2-2004282. Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted or merged with S2-2004282. Mehrdad (Samsung) also suggests to merge this into S2-2004282. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments that this paper has already been merged into S2-2004282r02. Hannu (Nokia) acknowledges the proposal to merge this paper to S2-2004282r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) agrees the proposed merge. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2004289	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New solution to support end-to-end QoS for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004728	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01 and responds to Dengqiang (CATT) and Jianhua (OPPO). Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment on original version and r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung). Jianhua asks another question and provide r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Jianhua. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004728	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New solution to support end-to-end QoS for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004289. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003945	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004729	Changhong (Intel) proposes to mark this paper as 'Merged into S2-2004289' and asks the author to provide a revision in the thread of S2-2004289 to show the missing aspects. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Intel. Toon (KPN) asks for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to KPN and provide r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Changhong (Intel) still proposes to mark this paper either as 'Merged into S2-2004289' or 'NOTED'. Changhong (Intel) can live with r01 after offline talk with Jianhua. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004729	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003945. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003786	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Remote UE.	Samsung	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment on Remote UE QoS report and QNC. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) comments on how to work for the solution. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT, OPPO, LG Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Adrian (vivo) comments. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to remove step 5. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r04 LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions and proposes to NOTE this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) addresses LG's concern and provides r05. Changhong (Intel) comments. Mehrdad provides r06 addressing Intel's request. Mehrdad provides r07 with minor alignment with S2-2004094 wording . Mehrdad (Samsung) provided r06 and r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because r06/r07 can be covered by S2-2004289 or S2-2003945. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks LG to reconsider the position based on r07. LaeYoung (LGE) keeps her position and thinks procedure can be added to the solution from S2-2004289 in the next meeting. Mehrdad (Samsung) accepts LG's position and OK to NOTE this PCR for now. LaeYoung (LGE) provides hug to Mehrdad (Samsung). :) ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004291	P-CR	Approval	23.752: URSP enhancements to support UE-to-Network Relay solutions.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004730	Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004730	P-CR	Approval	23.752: URSP enhancements to support UE-to-Network Relay solutions.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004291. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004032	P-CR	Approval	23.752: New Solution Enhancing URSP rule to determine Relay UE PDU session parameters.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004731	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides comment. Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT). Hannu (Nokia) replies to Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) and agrees. Hannu (Nokia) agrees the changes in r01 and adds EN in r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is ok with r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) agrees with r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is OK with r03. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004731	P-CR	Approval	23.752: New Solution Enhancing URSP rule to determine Relay UE PDU session parameters.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004032. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003853	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Update for solution 6-Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	Noted	Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides R01. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments and objects r02. Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments to r02. Jianhua (OPPO) responds and providesr03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r04. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05 Walter (Philips) comments on r05 and provides r06 Jianhua (OPPO) is fine with r06 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r06 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) OBJECTs to all revisions, and propose to NOTE. Jianhua asks Hong (Qualcomm) whether OK with r02. Hong (Qualcomm) maintains the objection. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004025	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution on service continuity for Layer-3 based UE-to-Network Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	Noted	Changhong (Intel) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Jianhua(OPPO) responds and provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) still doesn't understand what the proposal is and proposes to NOTE this paper. Changhong (Intel) shares concern from LaeYoung, marking it as 'NOTED' is also OK. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LG and Intel, and provides r03 LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions and proposes to NOTE this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Jianhua (OPPO). Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and asks questions. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LG and Fraunhofer HHI, and provide r05 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions because this pCR does not solve service continuity at all, the proposal in r00 to r04 does not work and the proposal in r05 is unclear. Jianhua (OPPO) accepts LaeYoung (LGE) comment. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003839	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Secondary Authentication for a Remote UE.	LG Electronics, LG Uplus	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004732	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment on questioning the necessity of secondary authentication for Remote UE. Myungjune (LGE) answers Deng Qiang (CATT) and clarifies necessity of secondary authentcation. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Myungjune (LGE) answers Deng Qiang (CATT). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Myungjune (LGE) respondes to Xiaoyan (InterDigital). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments. Myungjune (LGE) answers to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.). Shabnam (Ericsson) asks to make this optional and still considering why needed? Is it for L3 relay only or generally needed for UE to nwk Relay? Myungjune (LGE) answers to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r03. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004732	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Secondary Authentication for a Remote UE.	LG Electronics, LG Uplus	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003839. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004033	P-CR	Approval	23.752: New Solution for UE-to-Network Relay authorization.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Postponed	Jianhua(OPPO) comments on out of coverage case Jianhua(OPPO) comments and provides r01. Changhong (Intel) comments. Judy (Ericsson) ask question for clarification. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Changhong. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Jianhua and provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Deng Qiang (CATT) shares the same view as Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) objects to this pCR and proposes to continue to work offline. Changhong (Intel) shares same concern with Judy (Ericsson) and also objects to this paper and any revision. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	S2-2003819	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Support for UE-to-Network Relay mobility state.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Toon Norp (KPN) agrees with comments from LGE and CATT. Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note this document. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) responds CATT, LGE, KPN, Mediatek's comments and it's fine with r02. Changhong (Intel) also proposes to NOTE this paper. Toon Norp (KPN) is fine with adding r02 as a potential solution. Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends once again this be noted. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies to Intel, Mediatek' comments and provide r03 Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Interdigital. Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003944	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Sol: MT data delivery for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	Noted	Wen (vivo) provides the comments: Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks for clarification. Toon Norp (KPN) request clarification on buffering of DL data: Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) requests clarification regarding the assumption on the PC5 link state. Changhong (Intel) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question. Jianhua (OPPO) OK to note it. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003851	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #19.	OPPO	Rel-17	Noted	Changhong (Intel) comments. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responses to Changhong (Intel) and further comments. LaeYoung (LGE) is also wondering the points raised by Changhong (Intel) and Hong (Qualcomm). Jianhua(OPPO) responds and provides r01 Changhong (Intel) is not fully convinced with answers from Jianhua and provides r02. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Changhong (Intel) and would like stick to r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) agrees to r02, and objects other revisions. Changhong (Intel) is also OK with Hong's objection. Jianhua responds Hong. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2003820	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Solution #X: L3 UE-to-Network Relay discovery and connection establishment.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004733	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Jianhua(OPPO) asks question for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to CATT, OPPO and Samsung, and provides r01. Changhong (Intel) comments and provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments and is ok with r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments and provides r03. Changhong (Intel) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies LaeYoung (LGE)' comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05 based on LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Walter Dees (Philips) provides some comments and proposes r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004733	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Solution #X: L3 UE-to-Network Relay discovery and connection establishment.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003820. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003823	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Evaluation for Solution #6: Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Postponed	Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	-	-	-	Layer-2 Relay	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.8	S2-2004019	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to address editor's notes.	Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000494	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Dario (Huawei) replies to comments with r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and provides r02. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r03. Dario (Huawei) provides r04 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm) accepts r02, r03, and objects to other revisions. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) can live with r05 and object any versions to force NW relay to be in Connected state. Deng Qiang (CATT) supports r02, r03, and objects to other revisions and responds to Xiaoyan (Interdigital). Jianhua (OPPO) can only accept r03 Dario (HW) we prefer r05, but we can live with r03 and r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004734	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to address editor's notes.	Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004019. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003977	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution#7 updates, to keep CM_CONNECTED.	Vivo	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004735	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes be merged into S2-2004019. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Wen (vivo) responds to the comments from Xiaoyan and Deng Qiang . Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments . Wen (vivo) responds to the comments from Hong and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Wen (vivo) is ok with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004735	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution#7 updates, to keep CM_CONNECTED.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003977. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004095	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Consideration on network authorization and paging for Remote UE.	CATT	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004736	Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r01 Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004736	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Consideration on network authorization and paging for Remote UE.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004095. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004290	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Additional considerations for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay solution.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Noted	Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) comment the control plane stack should be aligned with S2-2004019. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) objects to r01 and r02. Dario (HW) replies to Deng Qiang proposing to select r02 which does not modify the protocol stack. Dario (HW) objects to r0. Deng Qiang (CATT) objects r01 and r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004017	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Solution for service continuity via UE-to-Network Relay.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000492. To handle at CC#4. R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004713.	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) OBJECTs to all revisions, and propose to NOTE. Shabnam (Ericsson) As already commented, this is RAN scope and as such to be discussed, if RAN groups want to, within RAN study. Objects to the pCR and all revisions. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm, Ericsson and requests that all TDocs be treated fairly. Deng Qiang (CATT) kindly asks the proponents to provide revisions. Dario (Huawei) shows that the objection by Qualcomm and Ericsson is unfounded. Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Dario (Huawei). Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Qualcomm. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Shabnam (Ericsson) unfortunately I see no reason to capture this in SA2 TR, if you look at the impacts parts it is clear that RAN WGs must work on this first. RAN has study item dedicated for this work, so let them progress/start. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004713	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3, New Solution for service continuity via UE-to-Network Relay.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004017_R07. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004160	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Solution for Key Issue 3 - Handover of an L2 UE-NW Relay with Remote UE(s) having an active indirect connection.	Motorola Mobility, Lenovo	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) commented the issue is not in Rel-17 scope. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note the contribution. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the pCR and all its potential revisions since it has no SA2 impacts and also even in RAN will not standardise any of this since HO decision is internal behaviour of the RAN node Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Qualcomm, Oppo and CATT and provides r01 to address objections raised Haris (Qualcomm) responds and objects to r01 as well Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Haris (Qualcomm) Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all revision of the pCR, it is in RAN scope and not SA2. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004018	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI3: New Sol: Authorization of UE-to-Network Relay UE and Remote UE.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004737	Jianhua(OPPO) comments and asks questions for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. LiMeng (Huawei) provides answers. Judy (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01 and answers the questions. Judy (Ericsson) asks further questions how the association between the remote UE(s) and relay UE is built. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) clarifies the questions from Judy. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) propose to NOTE or POSTPONE. Judy (Ericsson) also proposes to POSTPONE. Deng Qiang (CATT) can live with r01 by removing 'L3 UE-to-Network Relay'. Dario (HW) replies to E/// and is OK with Deng Qiang's proposal (go with r01 and remove 'L3 UE-to-Network Relay'). ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004737	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI3: New Sol: Authorization of UE-to-Network Relay UE and Remote UE.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004018. Approved		Approved
8.8	-	-	-	KI#4 (UE-UE Relay)	-	-	Docs:=2		-
8.8	S2-2003947	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4, New Sol: QoS control for UE-to-UE Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004738	Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004738	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4, New Sol: QoS control for UE-to-UE Relay.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003947. Approved		Approved
8.8	-	-	-	Layer-3 Relay	-	-	Docs:=4		-
8.8	S2-2003818	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #10 Update: Support of ProSe Service discovery and QoS flow when using Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004739	Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments on QoS handling part. Adrian (Vivo) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds OPPO, VIVO's comments. Adrian (vivo) responds Interdigital comments. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) Adrian (vivo)'s comments and provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong's Comments and provide r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004739	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #10 Update: Support of ProSe Service discovery and QoS flow when using Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003818. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003718	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Supporting Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004740	Jianhua(OPPO) asks question for clarification. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides responses and r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan (IDCC). Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) responds to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital). Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004740	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Supporting Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003718. Approved		Approved
8.8	-	-	-	Layer-2 Relay	-	-	Docs:=8		-
8.8	S2-2003817	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #9 Update: Support of Privacy when using UE-to-UE Relay.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004741	Jianhua(OPPO) comments and asks questions Adrian(vivo) asks a question. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to OPPO and VIVO's comments and provided r01. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004741	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #9 Update: Support of Privacy when using UE-to-UE Relay.	Interdigital	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003817. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004022	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4, Sol#9:Update for Connection establishment via UE-to-UE Layer-2 Relay.	Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Approved	Hong Cheng (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) supports this contribution. LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Hong (Qualcomm). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2003634	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #11: Update to Stateful UE-to-UE Relay to include a Layer-2 communication option.	Intel	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004742	Jianhua(OPPO) comments no Direction field is need for L2 format and the protocol for L2 relay needs to be determined by RAN2. Saso (Intel) provides r01. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r01 Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Haris (Qualcomm) Haris (Qualcomm) clarifies the request and provides r02 Saso (Intel) is OK with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004742	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, Sol #11: Update to Stateful UE-to-UE Relay to include a Layer-2 communication option.	Intel	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003634. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004021	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, New Sol: Network-Assisted UE-to-UE Relay Discovery and Selection.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004743	Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments on the feasibility of the solution and suggests not to document the solution. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as EPC level-like discovery is out of scope. Haris (Qualcomm) comments and proposes to note this pCR Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. Runze (Huawei) disagrees the solution is out of scope. Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Xiaoyan's comment. Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Mehrdad's comment and provides r02. Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Jianhua's comment. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Runze (Huawei) and proposes to NOTED this paper. Haris (Qualcomm) comments and indicates that even r02 is not ready for approval Runze (Huawei) replies to Haris, addresses the comments from Haris and provides r03. Runze (Huawei) cannot agree the observation from Dengqiang that the SID scope excludes other discovery mechanism than direct discovery. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004743	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #4, New Sol: Network-Assisted UE-to-UE Relay Discovery and Selection.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004021. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003822	P-CR	Approval	23.752: Evaluation for Solution 9: Connection establishment via UE-to-UE Layer-2 Relay.	Interdigital Inc.	Rel-17	Postponed	Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI are not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) propose to NOTE that paper. Jianhua (OPPO) propose all evaluation for Relay related KIs (KI#3 and KI#4) Hannu comments on noting or postponing clause 7 evaluations and clause 8 conclusions in this meeting. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	-	-	-	KI#5 (Path selection)	-	-	Docs:=6		-
8.8	S2-2004023	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI5: Sol.12: Update to address editor's notes .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004744	Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge S2-2004023 into S2-2003784. Mehrdad (Samsung) proposes to either NOTE S2-2004023 or change the status to Merged, as already merged into S2-2003784. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dario (HW) confirm 4023 was merged into 3784. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2003784	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection.	Samsung	Rel-17	R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004023, S2-2003834, to S2-2004744 and S2-2003836 and S2-2003834, to S2-2004744	Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Adrian (vivo) comments. Changhong (Intel) comments. Krisztian (Apple) provides r02 proposing to merge S2-2003834 LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments to r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Vivo and Interl Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Vivo and Intel. Dimitris (Lenovo) requests to clarify the 'Type of Service' in Traffic Descriptors Judy (Ericsson) comments questioning the benefit of QNC status in path selection policy. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Lenovo and Ericsson. Also clarifies that QNC usage is already part of the TR since Incheon. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides further update to Ericsson Dario (Huawei) provides r03 Dimitris (Lenovo) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung) Judy (Ericsson) responded to Mehrdad (Samsung). Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. Krisztian (Apple) provides r06. Toon Norp (KPN) requests for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r07. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r08. Krisztian (Apple) provides r09. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r09. Krisztian (Apple): we are fine to proceed with r08. Changhong (Intel) doesn't agree with the principle of this solution changing UE Policy like this but will not object to this paper in order to appreciate the rounds of revision and merging work. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004744	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection.	Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon, Apple	Rel-17	Revision_R08 of S2-2003784, merging S2-2004023 S2-2003834 and S2-2003836. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003834	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #5, KI#6, New Sol: Policy generation for direct communication Prose Path selection and switching.	Apple	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004744	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes this paper to be merged into S2-2003784. LaeYoung (LGE) has same view with Deng Qiang (CATT) and proposes this paper to be merged into S2-2003784. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge this into S2-2003784. Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. . Krisztian (Apple) provided S2-2003784r02 on the relevant thread. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Hongkun. Hong (Qualcomm Inc) comments and suggest to merge this into existing sol#12 (i.e. clause 6.12). Changhong (Intel) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to either NOTE this or change the status to 'Merged', as already merged into S2-2003784. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Mark it as 'Merged into S2-2003784'. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2003836	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #5, KI#6, New Sol: Functional entities and triggers for initiating policy update for ProSe path selection and switching.	Apple	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004744	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment and question. Changhong (Intel) comments and strongly proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003784. Krisztian (Apple) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because she does not see any value to have this solution as separate from the solution in S2-2003784. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to either NOTE this or change the status to 'Merged', as already merged into S2-2003784. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Mark it as 'Merged into S2-2003784'. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	S2-2003906	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#5, New Sol: Policy based path selection.	LG Electronics, SK Telecom, LG Uplus	Rel-17	Noted	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. LaeYoung (LGE) answers Q from Deng Qiang (CATT). Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment to r01 from Deng Qiang (CATT). Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge this into S2-2003784. LaeYoung (LGE) prefers to keep this solution separate because how to check QoS fulfillment is different in this solution and S2-2003784. Mehrdad (Samsung) question for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Changhong (Intel) shares views from Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides clarification. Samsung is OK with r04. Dimitris (Lenovo) shares view with Qualcomm and Intel Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung). LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Changhong (Intel) replies to LaeYoung's comments. LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Changhong (Intel). Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Intel and LG ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Changhong (Intel) provides comments. Mehrdad replies to Changhong (Intel) and LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) is fine to NOTE this paper. (self-hugging :)) ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	-	-	-	KI#7 (Charging)	-	-	Docs:=8		-
8.8	S2-2003573	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#7 Sol#13: Update to Charging reporting for PC5 Direct Communication .	NEC	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004745	Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments and confirmed the implications on CHF. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) ask question for clarification. Linghang (NEC) responds to Gerald, Hong and Judy, and provides r01. Linghang (NEC) responds to Hong. Linghang (NEC) provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004745	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#7 Sol#13: Update to Charging reporting for PC5 Direct Communication .	NEC	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003573. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003789	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #7: Sol #13&15: Update to clarify the reported info for PC5.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004746	Toon Norp (KPN) asks for clarification on Remote ID Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments and a question for clarification. Judy (Ericsson) responded to Gerald (Matrixx) and Toon Norp (KPN). Toon Norp (KPN) request a revision. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 to address comments from Toon Norp (KPN). Toon Norp (KPN) provides further comments. Toon Norp (KPN) provides r02 to address KPN comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) thanks Toon Norp (KPN) for providing r02 and is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004746	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI #7: Sol #13&15: Update to clarify the reported info for PC5.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003789. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003855	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #14.	OPPO	Rel-17	Approved	Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments Judy (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification. Jianhua(OPPO) responds Ericsson and Matrixx. Gerald (Matrixx) provided r01 for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) is OK with r0, objects to r01, and comments. Jianhua is OK with r0, i.e. the original version. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.8	S2-2004292	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#7 New Solution: Charging support for 5G ProSe over U-plane.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida,	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004747	Gerald (Matrixx) provide comments and suggestions for the revision. Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01. Gerald (Matrixx) supports the revision. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004747	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#7 New Solution: Charging support for 5G ProSe over U-plane.	Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida,	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004292. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004039	P-CR	Approval	23.752: ProSe_Evaluation and conclusion for KI#7.	OPPO, CATT	Rel-17	Postponed	Linghang (NEC) provides comment and proposes to NOTE this pCR. Adrian (vivo) proposes to NOTE this pCR. Changhong (Intel) proposes to POSTPONE this pCR since the SI is not ready to be evaluated. Hannu (Nokia) comments. Adrian (vivo) responds to Nokia. Gerald (Matrixx) with comment. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.8	-	-	-	KI#8 (Service authorization)	-	-	Docs:=5		-
8.8	S2-2004072	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3 and 8, New Solution: Generic Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay service.	Intel	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004748	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Changhong (Intel) replies to Qiang's comment and provides r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask for clarification for R02 on the Remote UE retrieve authorization policy and parameters via NW relay. Changhong (Intel) replies to Xiaoyan's comment and provides r03. Jianhua(OPPO) provides r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004748	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#3 and 8, New Solution: Generic Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay service.	Intel	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2004072. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2004073	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4 and 8, New Solution: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service.	Intel	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003976, to S2-2004749	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. Changhong (Intel) replies to Qiang's comment and provides r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004749	P-CR	Approval	23.752: KI#4 and 8, New Solution: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service.	Intel	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004073, merging S2-2003976. Approved		Approved
8.8	S2-2003976	P-CR	Approval	23.752: New Solution on Service Authorization, Provisioning for UE-to-UE relay.	Vivo	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004749	Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes it to be merged into S2-2004073. Wen (vivo) replies to the comments from Deng Qiang Changhong (Intel) is OK to mark it as 'Merged into S2-2004073' and Comments. Wen (vivo) replies: ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.8	-	-	-	LS out	-	-	Docs:=4		-
8.8	S2-2003856	LS OUT	Approval	[DRAFT] LS on Situation of UE-to-Network Relay and UE-to-UE Relay	OPPO	Rel-17	Postponed	Adrian (vivo) proposes to NOTE this draft LS out. LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this draft LS out. Changhong (Intel) also proposes to NOTE this draft LS out. Jianhua (OPPO) responds .vivo's comments. Jianhua (OPPO) respond to Changhong and LaeYoung Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS and provides comments. Jianhua (OPPO) OK to postpone.. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Postponed
8.8	S2-2004053	DISCUSSION	Agreement	FS_5G_ProSe: Discussion on Relay Security.	MediaTek Inc., Huawei, HiSilicon, Sony, Philips, LG Electronics	Rel-17	Noted	Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to approval of this document since the Discussion analysis and Conclusions are outside of SA2 scope. Guillaume (MediaTek) is surprised by the objection considering Ericsson has a proposal intended to address the security flaws exposed by this document. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees Ericsson's comments that This document goes beyond SA2 scope. Toon Norp (KPN) disagrees with Shabnam's comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to MediaTek via comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.8	S2-2004054	LS OUT	Approval	[DRAFT] LS on Security Requirements for Sidelink/PC5 Relays	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004750	Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r03 Guillaume (MediaTek): r03 is ok ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Changhong (Intel): r03 looks good. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.8	S2-2004750	LS OUT	Approval	LS on Security Requirements for Sidelink/PC5 Relays	SA WG2	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004054. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Study on architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (FS_5MBS)	-	-	Docs:=104		-
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #1 - Architecture 1	-	-	Docs:=13		-
8.9	S2-2003702	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1, Sol#3: Update to add ENs.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Noted	Thomas Belling (Nokia) objects to the contribution Dario (Huawei) objects to the contribution Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and Thomas (Nokia) and OK to note the paper. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.9	S2-2003964	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1 Sol.3: Resolving multiple SMFs and UPFs issue .	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004707	Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185 Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Xiaoyan (CATT). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with the proposal from Thomas (i.e., merging S2-2003964 into S2-2004185), as S2-2004185 reflects the content of S2-2003964 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2003965	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI1: Update to Solution #3: Add support for UE leaving MBS.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004699.	Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides question for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 and objects against r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision r05. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Fenqin He suggest working on another revision until Friday . Thomas (Nokia) provides r07 Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and accept r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenquin. Hans (Ericsson) replies to Fenquin. Fenqin(Huawei) provide feedback. Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin about unclarities in the latest rev. Fenqin(Huawei) Provides feedback Hans (Ericsson) is okey with r05. Objects to all other revisions. Should 3965 be brought up in CC#4, I'm okey trying an update of the latest version. Thomas (Nokia) supports bringing that up in the cc. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004699	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI1: Update to Solution #3: Add support for UE leaving MBS.	Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003965_R07. Approved	Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides question for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 and objects against r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision r05. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Fenqin He suggest working on another revision until Friday . Thomas (Nokia) provides r07 Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and accept r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenquin. Hans (Ericsson) replies to Fenquin. Fenqin(Huawei) provide feedback. Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin about unclarities in the latest rev. Fenqin(Huawei) Provides feedback Hans (Ericsson) is okey with r05. Objects to all other revisions. Should 3965 be brought up in CC#4, I'm okey trying an update of the latest version. Thomas (Nokia) supports bringing that up in the cc. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.9	S2-2004063	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Update to Solution 3: Integrated Multicast and Unicast Transport.	China Mobile	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004707	Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185 Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments proposes to merge this document (to 4185 or others) Andy Bennett (Vice Chair) I see two proposals to merge this with 4185. Is that an agreeable way forward for China Mobile? Aihua (China Mobile) replies, It is acceptiable for us to have this merging suggestion. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2004185	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to address editor´s notes.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R15 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004063, S2-2004219, S2-2004221 and S2-2003964, to S2-2004707.	Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r01 as an attempt to merge S2-2004185 with S2-2003964, S2-2004063, S2-2004219, and S2-2004221 Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a question on its corresponding architecture. Judy (Ericsson) asks question on UDR storage of SMF2 for MBS context. Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a further question for clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r02 and suggest staying with r01. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification on r02. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r03. Dario (Huawei) provides r04. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r05 which adds changes from r03 to r04. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides questions and comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r06 and clarification for the r06. Thomas (Nokia) answers to Chunshan and suggests keeping Rel-5 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r07 based on r05 Thomas (Nokia) replies to Dario and providers rev8 Thomas(Nokia) objects to r03, r05, r06 and r07 Thomas (Nokia) answers to questions of Youngkyo Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) can live with r08 and provides comments. LiMeng (Huawei) answer the questions from Thomas. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r09 and replies to Youngkyo Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r09 Thomas(Nokia) replies to LiMeng Youngkyo (Samsung) provides r10 Thomas (Nokia) is fine with r10 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r10 LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Thomas (Nokia) and provides r11 LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Miguel Judy (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Judy (Ericsson). Thomas(Nokia) replies to Judy. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r12. Thomas (Nokia) prefers rev10 and answers to LiMeng (Huawei) Thomas suggest to work on a further revision until Friday Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) hopes we can all live with one of the revisions and not bring this to CC#4. Qualcomm can live with r10,r11,r12. Thomas (Nokia) provides a rev13. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) supports r13 LiMeng (Huawei) provides a rev14. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Thomas (Nokia) objects to r14 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes to approve r13 LiMeng (Huawei) asks Thomas (Nokia) to read r14 again. LiMeng (Huawei) can only accept r07, r14 and object the rest. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with either r13 or r14. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with either r13 or r14, corrects typo in previous email. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides offline agreement on way forward for 4185, thanks Nokia and Huawei for working out a compromise. Thomas (Nokia) suggest handling this in the cc. Offline an agreement was reached. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004707	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to address editor's notes.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HI Silicon, China Mobile	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004185_R15, merging S2-2004063, S2-2004219, S2-2004221 and S2-2003964. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004219	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution 3 editor's notes removals.	Qualcomm Incororporated	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004707	Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) comments as long as S2-2004185r09 (or minor modifications) is agreeable, we are ok merging this one to 4185. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2004221	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution 3: examples of transport activation and service layer interaction.	Qualcomm Incororporated	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004707	Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r01 with comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) comments as long as S2-2004185r09 (or minor modifications) is agreeable, we are ok merging this one to 4185. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2003967	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1 and KI#7: New Sol: MBS Session Management in IPTV.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. Noted	Judy (Ericsson) asks question. LiMeng (Huawei) answers question from Judy and provides r01. Chunshan (Tencent) asks for clarification. Judy (Ericsson) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia provides r03 zhendong (ZTE) provides the question for clarification Dario (Huawei) replies to Zhendong ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) objects to any revision of this pCR despite revision being provided. The proposal makes certain assumptions which make the proposal more or less useless with added complexity to the system. Ericsson believes the focus of IPTV in 5MBS study should be the 'modern' IPTV (e.g. DVB Multicast ABR) rather than the 'legacy' IPTV. LiMeng (Huawei) replies, suggests to go with r02 proposed by Ericsson and is fine also with r03. Judy (Ericsson) sustains objection to any revision of this pCR. LiMeng (Huawei) requests to discuss the document in CC on Friday. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.9	S2-2004062	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Dynamic multicast/broadcast transmission.	China Mobile, Huawei	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004489	Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification. Thomas (Nokia) asks questions for clarification and comments Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments, wonders if the intention is not already covered by existing solutions (e.g. solution 3) and in that case proposes this document be noted. Aihua (China Mobile) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) suggests this contribution be NOTED Thomas (Nokia) suggests this contribution be NOTED Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Zhendong (ZTE) comments and provides r03. Thomas (Nokia) comments. Judy (Ericsson) comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Aihua(China Mobile) provides r04 to address comments raised. Thomas(Nokia) is fine with r04 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r04 Judy (Ericsson) responded to Aihua(China Mobile) and Xiaoyan (CATT) with question for clarification. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004489	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Dynamic multicast/broadcast transmission.	China Mobile, Huawei, CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2004062. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004279	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, new Solution Integrated Multicast and Unicast Transport with multicast distribution tree established by RAN nodes.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Noted	Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments. Thomas (Nokia) replies to . Xiaoyan Thomas (Nokia) answers to Miguel. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) understood, hopes we can move forward with 4185 and note this one Thomas (Nokia) requests to Note this contribution, as proposal were added to solution 3 via S2-2004185 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #1 - Architecture 2	-	-	Docs:=8		-
8.9	S2-2003679	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #2: Solution 2 update.	Ericsson	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004700.	Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification. Jianhua( OPPO) provide comments. . Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. . LiMeng (Huawei) provides r03 and comments to be clarified. Hans (Ericsson) provides r04 based on r01 from Thomas and r02 from Zhenhua. Hans (Ericsson) provides some answers. Thomas (Nokia) provides comments LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05 Hans (Ericsson) provide r06 (based on r05) . Hans (Ericsson) provide response to Thomas. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) prefers r06. Can live with r05 provided by LiMeng. Fenqin (Huawei) ask some question . Fenqin (Huawei) ask same treatment of this contribution as 3965. Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback. . ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004700	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #2: Solution 2 update.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003679_R06. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004102	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #4: Update to solution 4.	Vivo	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004491	Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. Thomas (Nokia) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question. Zhenhua (vivo) replies Hans (Ericsson). Zhenhua (vivo) replies Thomas (Nokia). LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 and replies to LaeYoung (LGE). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004491	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, Sol #4: Update to solution 4.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004102. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003901	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update on MBS Service initiation procedure.	Samsung	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004492	Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification. Youngkyo (Samsung) replies to the questions and corresponding revision r02. Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification. Thomas (Nokia) previously provided revision r01 and now provides r03 Youngkyo(Samsung) provide further revision r04 Thomas (Nokia) can accept r04 Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Youngkyo (Samsung) provides answer to the comments from Hans(Ericsson). ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004492	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update on MBS Service initiation procedure.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003901. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003960	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI1, new solution Multicast MBS Session establishment linked with unicast PDU session.	ZTE	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004493	Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification. zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification Thomas (Nokia) provides rev1 LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a question for understanding zhendong (ZTE) provides the response and r02 Youngkyo (Samsung) provides further question/comment. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r03 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Thomas (Nokia) provides r04 Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and r05 zhendong (ZTE) provides r06 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) is fine with r06. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004493	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI1, new solution Multicast MBS Session establishment linked with unicast PDU session.	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003960. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #1 - Architecture agnostic	-	-	Docs:=12		-
8.9	S2-2003680	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Xn Handover of MB Sessions .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004494	Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for clarification Hans (Ericsson) replies and provides r02. LiMeng (Huawei) asks question for clarification. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) responds to LiMeng's questions. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004494	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Xn Handover of MB Sessions .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003680. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003681	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: N2 Handover of MB Sessions .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004490	Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge with S2-2003680 and draw a highlighted signalling flow as well as describe the enhancement of the solution. Hans (Ericsson) provides a r02. LiMeng (Huawei) provides a r03 and asks question for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) okey with r04. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004490	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: N2 Handover of MB Sessions .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003681. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003857	P-CR	Approval	23.757: MBS_Solution for session deactivation and activation.	OPPO	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004495	Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Jianhua(OPPO) answers the questions and provide r03. Saad (interdigital) provide comments on r03. Thomas(Nokia) provide r0. Thomas(Nokia) provide r04. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05 Hans (Ericsson) provides comments by a revision r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004495	P-CR	Approval	23.757: MBS_Solution for session deactivation and activation.	OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003857. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003986	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS Multicast UE Context Activation and MBS Session Management without UE IP address .	Tencent	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004496	Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions. Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to OPPO questions. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. Clarifications/update of solution needed. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) asks questions for clarification.. Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Nokia. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides some question for clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. Chunshan (Tencent) object r03. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r04. Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback. Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and ask some question for clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r05 and clarification. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004496	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS Multicast UE Context Activation and MBS Session Management without using UE IP address .	Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2003986. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004105	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Multicast session leg addition due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004497	Dario (Huawei) asks for clarifications. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Dario (Huawei). Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01 and replies to Hans (Ericsson). Zhenhua (vivo) provide r02. Dario (Huawei) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004497	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Multicast session leg addition due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004105. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004176	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS session joining via PDU session establishment and modification procedures.	CATT	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004498	Antoine (Orange) provides r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004498	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS session joining via PDU session establishment and modification procedures.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004176. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #2	-	-	Docs:=5		-
8.9	S2-2004177	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #2, Sol #1: Update to clarify service levels.	CATT	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004708.	Shabnam (Ericsson) Proposes to NOTE or merge the relevant content to revision of S2-2004104, since the two proposals are partially contradictory. Dario (Huawei) Support Ericsson in noting this and discussing 4104. zhendong (ZTE) provides comments Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with merging S2-2004177 to S2-2004104, and have done it by providing S2-2004104r04. Thomas(Nokia) is merging contents of S2-2004295 to S2-2004104 by providing r06. Thomas also provided r05 but asks to ignore it. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic) Thomas (Nokia) proposes to consider this document merged into 4104 and get an uncontroversial version of 4104 (without service continuity) agreed at Friday CC. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2004277	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#2, sol 1, update the solution to fix the EN.	ZTE	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004708.	Dario (Huawei) proposes to note this and discuss 4104 David (Samsung) supports Huawei's proposal zhendong (ZTE), this paper can be marked as merged into 4104 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic) Thomas (Nokia) proposes to consider this document merged into 4104 and get an uncontroversial version of 4104 (without service continuity) agreed at Friday CC. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2004295	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #2, Sol #1 Updates.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	LATE DOC: Rx 25/05, 19:00. Noted	Shabnam (Ericsson) according to the document status remark, the document was late submission so request clarification if it should be NOTED as per chairman's rule on late document. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to NOTE this document.	Noted
8.9	S2-2004104	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, Sol #1: Update of service level.	Vivo, Huawei	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R13 plus change agreed. Revised to S2-2004708.	Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments on introduction of unnecessary classification. Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r03 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04 by merging S2-2004177 to S2-2004104, and provides comments. David (Samsung) provides comments Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r00/r02/r03 Thomas(Nokia) is merging contents of S2-2004295 to S2-2004104 by providing r06. Thomas also provided r05 but asks to ignore it. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r07 David (Samsung) provides r08 Thomas (Nokia) provides r09 David (Samsung) replies to Thomas, provides r10 Thomas (Nokia) objects to r10 and r8 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) objects to r01, 03, 04, 06, 07 and 09, can live with r00, 02 and 08, and suggests to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic) Thomas(Nokia) suggest trying to get a version without service continuity agreed at the Friday call and provides a draft David (Samsung) is OK to discuss this on CC#4 on Friday, leaving EN(s) wherever needed ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004708	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, Sol #1: Update of service level.	Vivo, Huawei, Nokia, ZTE, CATT	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004104_R13 plus change. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #4	-	-	Docs:=2		-
8.9	S2-2004178	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #4, New Sol: QoS support for MBS service.	CATT	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004499	LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Judy (Ericsson) asks additional question. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications and has concerns this solution does not stand on its own. Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies and provides r01. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides one more comment Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Judy (Ericsson). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004499	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #4, New Sol: QoS support for MBS service.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004178. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #6	-	-	Docs:=10		-
8.9	S2-2004059	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#6, Sol#7: Update to clarify functional descriptions and procedures.	Tencent	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004324		Merged
8.9	S2-2004103	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revised, merging S2-2004059, to S2-2004324		Revised
8.9	S2-2004324	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.	Vivo, Tencent	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004103, merging S2-2004059	Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification Zhenhua (vivo) resplies to Fenqin (Huawei) Shabnam (Ericsson) requests clarification/update on some questions to the proposed solution. LaeYoung (LGE) requests clarification/update. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Zhendong (ZTE) LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01. Zhenhua (vivo) provided r01 previously and now provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004500	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.	Vivo, Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004324. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003703	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#6, New Solution: Support Local MBS Service.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004501	Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response and explains why the two ENs are not needed. LaeYoung (LGE) requests clarification/update. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson). Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004501	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#6, New Solution: Support Local MBS Service.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003703. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003930	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#6, New Sol: Local multicast service.	LG Electronics	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004502	Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to question from Fenqin (Huawei). Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answer to Q from Fenqin (Huawei). Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment and r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004502	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#6, New Sol: Local multicast service.	LG Electronics	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003930. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004280	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #6, new Solution Global Unicast Group ID for local Unicast Contents.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004503	Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns regarding location reporting and tracking and its impact on the signalling impact, as warning known from EPS, asks clarifications. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam and provides r02 Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments r03 Thomas(Nokia) is fine with r03 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004503	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #6, new Solution Global Unicast Group ID for local Unicast Contents.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2004280. Approved		Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key issue #7	-	-	Docs:=31		-
8.9	S2-2003700	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7: Update to KI#7 to clarify the switching between unicast and multicast.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004504	Zhenhua (vivo) object to r00. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 and asks Zhenhua (vivo) to reconsider his position. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) provide comments. David (Samsung) provides comments. Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Judy (Ericsson), Fenqin (Huawei), and David (Samsung). Jeffrey (Juniper) follows up on Fenqin (Huawei)'s comments. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments provides r03 Thomas (Nokia) can accept r03 Zhenhua (vivo) can accept r03 and replies to Fenqin (Huawei) Judy (Ericsson) comments and provided r04. David (Samsung) comments and provides r05. Dario (Huawei) provides r06 and comments. Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and provides r07. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dario (Huawei) is fine with r07. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004504	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7: Update to KI#7 to clarify the switching between unicast and multicast.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2003700. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003682	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7 Always RAN based switching within NR coverage.	Ericsson, Nokia, Qualcomm	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004505	LiMeng (Huawei) provides command and r01. Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r01 and provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment. Xiaoyan (CATT) can accept r01, but not r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) and Xiaoyan (CATT). David (Samsung) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. David (Samsung) provides r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dario (Huawei) is fine with r04 (even if this is a purely RAN based solution). Hans (Ericsson) prefers r00, but can live with r01, r02 or r04. David (Samsung) prefers r04; objects to r00, r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004505	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7 Always RAN based switching within NR coverage.	Ericsson, Nokia, Qualcomm	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003682. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003754	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Reliable delivery mode switching between unicast and multicast.	Apple	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004506	Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Jianhua (OPPO) comments and asks questions. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. . Saad (Interdigital) provide comments. Krisztian (Apple) provides r01 and responds to Xiaoyan (CATT). Krisztian (Apple) responds to Hongkun. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Jianhua. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Saad.. Saad (IDCC) are fine with r01 LaeYoung (LGE) provide comments. Krisztian (Apple) provides r02. Krisztian (Apple) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004506	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Reliable delivery mode switching between unicast and multicast.	Apple	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003754. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003791	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution for unicast-multicast delivery mode switch.	Samsung, Convida Wireless	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000891	Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01 David (Samsung) replies to comments by CATT, Huawei and Vivo, and provides r02. Saad (Interdigital) asks question for clarification David (Samsung) replies to Saad. Saad (Interdigital) replies to David. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03. David (Samsung) provides r04, replies to Thomas. Saad (IDCC) is fine with r04 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004507	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution for unicast-multicast delivery mode switch.	Samsung, Convida Wireless	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003791. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003961	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI7, new solution mode switching between unicast and multicast.	ZTE	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004508	Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01 Hans (Ericsson) comments. Propose to merge part of the paper with 3682, and then note 3961. zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) we are fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004508	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI7, new solution mode switching between unicast and multicast.	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003961. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003962	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7, new solution multicast MBS session handover with Dummy QoS Flow.	ZTE	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004509	LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Jianhua(OPPO) asks questions for clarification zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification and r01 Hans (Ericsson) provides comments zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) thanks for the update. I'm fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004509	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7, new solution multicast MBS session handover with Dummy QoS Flow	ZTE	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003962. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003858	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution for lossless multicast and unicast switching.	OPPO	Rel-17	LATE DOC: Rx: 24/05, 14:55. Noted		Noted
8.9	S2-2003859	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution for multicast and unicast switching.	OPPO	Rel-17	LATE DOC: Rx: 24/05, 14:55. Noted		Noted
8.9	S2-2003966	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7, New Solution: Inter-RAN node MBS Session Handover.	Huawei, Hisilicon	Rel-17	R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004223, to S2-2004510	Fenqin (Huawei) provide comment and r02. Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback. Fenqin (Huawei) provide r03. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r04 Thomas (Nokia) provides r05 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r05 Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a question/comment. Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and r06. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision r07. Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and r08. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks a question to Fenqin Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) ok with r08 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004510	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#7, New Solution: Inter-RAN node MBS Session Handover.	Huawei, Hisilicon, OPPO	Rel-17	Revision_R08 of S2-2003966, merging S2-2004223. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004106	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.	Vivo	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004330		Merged
8.9	S2-2004107	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: multicast mode delivery method change without UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revised, merging S2-2004106, to S2-2004330		Revised
8.9	S2-2004330	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004107, merging S2-2004106	Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01 with OPPO as co-signer Dario (Huawei) provides comments and r02. Judy (Ericsson) provides r03 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r05 to add OPPO and Tencent as co-signers ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r05 under the condition that in the next meeting, an EN or solution will be added on the issue of RAN supporting SAI/TMGI in the SIB message. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004511	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.	Vivo, OPPO, Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2004330. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004108	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change from shared to individual due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004331		Merged
8.9	S2-2004109	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change from individual to shared due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revised, merging S2-2004108, to S2-2004331		Revised
8.9	S2-2004331	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2004109, merging S2-2004108	Judy (Ericsson) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Fenqin(Huawei) suggest to postpone this CR. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Fenqin(Huawei) and accept r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004512	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change due to UE mobility.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004331. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004110	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Multicast individual legs detection by RAN node for mode switch.	Vivo	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004513	Dario (Huawei) comments Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 and replies to Dario (Huawei) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004513	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Multicast individual legs detection by RAN node for mode switch.	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004110. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004179	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7 and #8, New Sol: Delivery mode switching using PDU session modification procedures.	CATT	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004514	Antoine (Orange) provides r01. Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) thanks for response. I'm okey with r02. Xiaoyan (CATT) thanks for the confirmation. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004514	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7 and #8, New Sol: Delivery mode switching using PDU session modification procedures.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004179. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004180	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: MBS assistance information to RAN for delivery mode switching.	CATT	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004515	Hans (Ericsson) provides comment . Dario (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Hans (Ericsson) provides comments . Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Hans (Ericsson). Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Dario (Huawei) and provides r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004515	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI #7, New Sol: MBS assistance information to RAN for delivery mode switching.	CATT	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004180. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004223	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution to KI#7: Mobility between 5G MBS supporting and 5G MBS non-supporting NG RAN nodes.	Qualcomm Incororporated	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004510	Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) provide comments and suggest this contribution to be merged into 3966. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #8	-	-	Docs:=1		-
8.9	S2-2003701	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#8: Update KI#8 to clarify switching between unicast and broadcast are not supported.	Ericsson	Rel-17	Approved	LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with original, not OK with r01 LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) and is fine with r00. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) also prefers r0. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.9	-	-	-	Key Issue #9	-	-	Docs:=2		-
8.9	S2-2004224	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution to KI#9: Switching to unicast transport for mobility to E-UTRAN/EPC.	Qualcomm Incororporated	Rel-17	Postponed	Jianhua (OPPO) asks question. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Jianhua (OPPO) question LaeYoung (LGE) provides e-hug to Miguel (Qualcomm) and r01. Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone this contribution. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK to postpone but requests KI#9 be handled at next meeting ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.9	S2-2004229	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Solution to KI#9: Service layer continuity between E-UTRAN/EPC MBMS and NR/5GC MBS.	Qualcomm Incororporated	Rel-17	Postponed	Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone this contribution. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK to postpone but requests KI#9 be handled at next meeting ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.9	-	-	-	Other	-	-	Docs:=20		-
8.9	S2-2003567	P-CR	Approval	23.757: 5MBS terminologies on delivery methods.	Juniper Networks, Vivo, BBC	Rel-17	R16 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004487	Judy (Ericsson) provides S2-2003567r01. LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments for r01 and provides r02. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides comments and r03. Zhenhua (vivo) provides comments for r01~r03 as well as provides r04. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Xiaoyan (CATT). Richard (BBC) provides comments. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Richard (BBC) and Xiaoyan (CATT)'s comments, provides r07 and r07a (as a choice depending on further input). Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r08, based on r07 (since r07a is not a valid revision option it was not considered). Dario (Huawei) provides r09. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Dario (Huawei). Thomas (Nokia) provides r10 Dario (Huawei) provides r12 and asks to ignore r11. Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and provides r13. David (Samsung) comments on r13, prefers r12. Jeffrey (Juniper) prefers clause 4.4 instead of Annex A.X. zhendong (ZTE) also prefer in clause 4.4 David (Samsung) can live with the NOTEs in r13, but provides r14 with Clause 4.4 instead of Annex A.X. Judy (Ericsson) responded to David (Samsung) and can live with r14. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r15 adding one sentence to r14 Jeffrey(Juniper) provides r16. Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r16. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) prefers r13, can live with r14, r15, r16, and responds to Jeffrey(Juniper) and Fenqin (Huawei). Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and prefer r16. David (Samsung) prefers r14, can live with r15, r16. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004487	P-CR	Approval	23.757: 5MBS terminologies on delivery methods.	Juniper Networks, Vivo, BBC	Rel-17	Revision_R16 of S2-2003567. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004162	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Alignment on the use of terminologies for delivery methods.	Juniper Networks, BBC	Rel-17	Noted	Thomas (Nokia) objects to this contribution Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Thomas (Nokia)'s objects; provides r01 Jeffrey (Juniper) provides addition comment to Thomas (Nokia)'s objection Judy (Ericsson) provides comments. David (Samsung) supports Ericsson's proposal. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to David (Samsung)'s support for Ericsson's proposal. Dario (Huawei) comments and proposes to note this contribution. Jeffrey agrees with Dario (Huawei)'s proposal to note this contribution. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.9	S2-2003568	P-CR	Approval	23.757: 5MBS Architecture Assumption/Requirement: ASP traffic Type.	Juniper Networks	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004488	Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification and provides comments to r01. Jeffrey responds to Xiaoyan (CATT) and provides r02. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03. Jeffrey (Juniper) comments on Thomas (Nokia)'s r03. Dario (Huawei) asks for clarification on r03. Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r02, but not r03. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Dario (Huawei)'s question. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments, not OK with original or any revisions up to r03 Dario (Huawei) supports QC's proposal to have note pointing to Evaluation/Conclusion stage. Based on Miguel's proposal and Dario's support, I'm providing r04 . Hans (Ericsson) agrees with Miguel it is late to ammend the Architecture Requirements. Provides r05 with only the Note. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with r05 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Jeffrey (Juniper) provides reason why he strongly prefers r04. Dario (Huawei) prefers r05 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004488	P-CR	Approval	23.757: 5MBS Architecture Assumption/Requirement: ASP traffic Type.	Juniper Networks	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2003568. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003678	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Architecture option 2 update.	Ericsson	Rel-17	R10 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004276, to S2-2004594	Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of 3678 (E///), 3897 A.2 part (Samsung) & 4276 (ZTE) in S2-2003678r01. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a revision r02. Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r01/02 and provides r03. Thomas (Nokia) provides r04. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r05 Chunshan (Tencent) provides the r06 Hans (Ericsson) question the need for N9 interface. David (Samsung) makes a procedural comment, suggests not to consider r06 until a merger is agreed with rest of sourcing companies. Hans (Ericsson) provides r07 (based on r05) with minor and editorial cleanup. David (Samsung) replies to Hans, provides r08. Hans (Ericsson) provides r09 (based on r08). David (Samsung) provides r10 (based on r09). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Hans (Ericsson) prefer r10, okey with r09. Can live with r08 & r07. Object for now to earlier versions. David (Samsung) prefers r08, OK with r10, r07. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004594	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Architecture option 2 update	Ericsson, ZTE. Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R10 of S2-2003678, merging S2-2004276. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2004276	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Update the Architecture A.2.	ZTE	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004594	Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of 4276 with 3678 (E///) and 3897 A.2 part (Samsung) in S2-2003678r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2003698	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Baseline functionality, update to remove EN .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003896, to S2-2004516	Judy (Ericsson) proposes a merged revision of 3698 and 3986 in S2-2003698r02 (I notice that r01 was uploaded hours ago but haven't seen it announced). Thomas (Nokia) comments and provides r01 and r03, and objects against r0 and r02. Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge 3896 into revision of 3698( caution : not 3986; you are referring a wrong tdoc) and provide further revision r04. Judy (Ericsson) thanks Youngkyo(Samsung) for tdoc no. correction and is OK with update. Fenqin(Huawei) ask question for clarification . David (Samsung) replies to Fenqin. Fenqin(Huawei) provides feedback and r05. Thomas(Nokia) provides feedback and r06. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r06. Judy (Ericsson) responded and provide r07. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r07. Youngkyo (Samsung) is OK with r07 also. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Thomas (Nokia) is fine with r07. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004516	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Baseline functionality, update to remove EN .	Ericsson, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R07 of S2-2003698, merging S2-2003896. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003896	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1: Correction on MBS baseline functionality.	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004516	LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Youngkyo (Samsung) replies to the questions and provides the revision r02. Thomas (Nokia) objects against original version and r02 and provided r01. Thomas also suggest noting the document and pursuing the related discussion in S2-2003698 that is a merger attempt. Youngkyo (Samsung) is okay to merge this paper to revision of S2-2003698(Judy/Ericsson). . ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2003699	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Specific architectural requirements and principles, update .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Noted	Thomas (Nokia) objects to the contribution Judy (Ericsson) responded to Thomas (Nokia) and believes the legacy IPTV solution should not restrict the 5MBS solution study. David (Samsung) provides comments. Dario (Huawei) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01. David (Samsung) is OK with r01. Dario (Huawei) is not OK with r01 Thomas(Nokia) maintains the objection, also against r01 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dario (Huawei) objects r00 and r01 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.9	S2-2003897	P-CR	Approval	23.757: KI#1: update Annex A to clarify MBS architecture alternatives .	Samsung	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004517	Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of and 3897 Annex A.2 part with 3678 (E///) and 4276 (ZTE) in S2-2003678r01. 3897r01 with only Annex A.1 part provided. Chunshan (Tencent) provides to be merged into S2-2003982r01. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) opposes the removal of MSF interaction via NEF. Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge S2-2003897r01 is merged into S2-2003982r01, and provide comment to Miguel Griot (Qualcomm)'s concern. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.9	S2-2003982	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-1 .	Tencent	Rel-17	R06 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003897, to S2-2004517	Chunshan (Tencent) provides a r01 to merge the changes of S2-2003897r01. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments (to original and r01). Youngkyo(Samsung) provide a further revision(r02) to the merged version. Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r02. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r03, not ok with r02. Thomas (Nokia) provide r04. Chunshan (Tencent) provide r05. Thomas (Nokia) prefers r04. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Hans (Ericsson) supports Thomas on I-UPF and provides r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Chunshan (Tencent) is ok with r06. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004517	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-1 .	Tencent, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R06 of S2-2003982, merging S2-2003897. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003983	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-2 .	Tencent	Rel-17	Noted	Judy (Ericsson) provides comment, and proposes to note this paper. Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to Judy and requests to withdraw the note proposal. Judy (Ericsson) responded to Chunshan (Tencent). David (Samsung) provides comments Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to Ericsson and Samsung. Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) merges this paper into S2-2003678r06. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Judy (Ericsson) objects to this pCR as we do not see the need of I-UPF for the MBS Session. The attempt to merge 3983 into 3678 was not agreed either. Chunshan (Tencent) questions on Judy's objection and request to withdraw the objection. David (Samsung) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification. Judy (Ericsson) sustains the objection and responds to Chunshan (Tencent) . ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.9	S2-2003989	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Annex #A: MBS Control Plane and User Plane Stack .	Tencent	Rel-17	Postponed	Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) expresses concerns with some aspects of P-CR Youngkyo (Samsung) proposes to note this in this meeting. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01 Chunshan (Tencent) response to Samsung. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a question. Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Samsung. Youngkyo (Samsung) provide a comment. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02. Dario (Huawei) comments Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Dario. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides and additional comment Thomas (Nokia) suggest noting this contribution Hans (Ericsson) provides r03 with updated stacks for A.2. Generally we also think it is a bit premature to bring stacks now, but we can accept r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Youngkyo (Samsung) is okay to note or accept r02, but object r03. Chunshan (Tencent) is okay to accept r02, but object r03. Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone. Hans (Ericsson) also propose to postpone this. Otherwise we can accept r03, but we object earlier versions David (Samsung) supports to postpone. Thomas (Nokia) agrees that it is better to postpone this ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Postponed
8.9	S2-2004158	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Clarification of AF function and Service Layer Aspect for Architecture Alternative 1.	Tencent	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004518	Thomas (Nokia) comments and suggest noting the contribution Lei (Tencent) comments and provided r01 and r02 . Request to discard r01. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r02. Thomas (Nokia) is OK with r02. Also request avoiding hyperlinks to 'fiveeye' server Lei(Tencent) thanks to Thomas and Miguel for confirming. Dario (Huawei) asks question for clarification. Lei(Tencent) provides clarification to Dario (Huawei). Dario (Huawei) is fine with r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.9	S2-2004518	P-CR	Approval	23.757: Clarification of AF function and Service Layer Aspect for Architecture Alternative 1.	Tencent	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004158. Approved		Approved
8.9	S2-2003932	LS OUT	Approval	[DRAFT] LS on sensitive Mission Critical information	Airbus		Noted	Thomas (Nokia) questions need fort the LS Zhenhua (vivo) comments Francois (Airbus) provides clarification Dario (Huawei) comments Saso (Intel) supports sending out the LS Francois (Airbus) responds to Dario's comments Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes the LS to be noted Shabnam (Ericsson) shares similar views as Qualcomm and Nokia and do not support sending the LS. Francois (Airbus) responds to comments from Ericsson and Qualcomm. Thomas(Nokia) again suggest noting the LS. Thomas (Nokia) responds to comments from Francois. Francois (Airbus) responds to Nokia's comment. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Francois and formally objects ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	-	-	-	Study on system enablers for multi-USIM devices (FS_MUSIM)	-	-	Docs:=67		-
8.10	-	-	-	Key Issue #1	-	-	Docs:=27		-
8.10	S2-2003635	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to remove ENs.	Intel	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R12 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004206, S2-2003829 and S2-2004157, to S2-2004709.	Lalith (Samsung) provides r01. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r01. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith (Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes how to handle the overlap with S2-2003893. Saso (Intel) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Steve (Huawei) comments. Saso (Intel) asks Steve (Huawei) if he has a better proposal. Lalith (Samsung) confirms fine with proposed way forward. Curt (Charter) asks for a clarification on implementing forward. Saso (Intel) replies to Curt (Charter). Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks a question for clarification. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks question for clarification. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks question and comments. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) provides r03, which tries to merge S2-2004157. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01. Lalith(Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel) and Curt (Charter). Saso (Intel) disagrees with r03 provided by Myungjune (LGE). Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan, Dieter, Yang; provides r04. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) replies to Saso (Intel) Ouyang(Huawei) ask quesitions for clarification. Saso (Intel) provides a 29.118 reference to Myungjune (LGE) about CS call indicator on SGs. Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei); provides r05. Curt (Charter) asks a question. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports r05. Ouyang(Huawei) askes questions for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE). Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). Yang Xu (OPPO) provides response xiaowan (vivo) provides r06 Lalith (Samsung) comments and supports r06 Saso (Intel) disagrees with r06 and offers r07 Chris provides r08 that merges in S2-2004157. Chris disagrees with r06 for EPS. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r09 based on r08 from VDF Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Chris. Chris (Vodafone) provides TS 23.272 extracts. Ouyang(Huawei) proposes r10. Saso (Intel) objects to r10 Saso (Intel) replies to Chris (Vodafone). Lalith(Samsung) supports Saso (Intel) and responds to Ouyang(Huawei) Ouyang (Huawei) replies to Saso. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lailith(Samsung). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Lailith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei) Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso(Intel). Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r08 and r09. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) object r10 and can agree with r09. Lailith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). We Support Intel, Qualcomm and LGE to document alternative Paging Causes in the Annex. Hence support r09 and object r10. Xiaowan (vivo) agrees r10, r09, r06, r02 and prefers r10, objects to the rest Ouyang(Huawei) insists r10 and objects all other revisions. Saso (Intel) ok with r09; cannot accept r10. Proposes a way forward based on r09 with addition of one EN (in two places). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso. Huawei insists on NOT documenting other causes except voice, Ouyang(Huawei) clarifies HW's position on ENs. Curt (Charter) ok with r09 or r09/with new rev by Saso (Intel). Probably this need to be discussed at CC#4 to get to somewhere. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004709	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to remove ENs.	Intel, Charter Communications	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003635_R12, merging S2-2004206, S2-2003829 and S2-2004157. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003829	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Sol#1: update the handling of paging cause.	Vivo	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004709	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Juan. Yang Xu (OPPO) shares the vivo's view that the Paging Cause needs to added per UE request. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes further comments. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Juan Saso (Intel) asks Xiaowan, Juan, Yang to check 3635r04 Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR as it can be considered merged in 3635 Xiaowan (vivo) agrees to merge S2-2003829 into S2-2003635 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2004264	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify about paging cause values.	Samsung	Rel-17	Noted	Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Lalith (Samsung) provides clarification to the questions. Lalith (Samsung) responsds to Myungjune (LGE). Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Saso (Intel) comments. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Xiaowan (vivo) requests to merge S2-2004264 into S2-2003635 . Lalith (Samsung) responds to Xiaowan. Lalith (Samsung) replies to Myungjune (LGE). Lalith (Samsung) provides r01. Saso (Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE). Xiaowan (vivo) request revision to clarify paging cause 0. Lalith (Samsung) provides r02. Ouyang(Huawei) comments on paging causes. Lalith(Samsungi) responds to Ouyang(Huawei) Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). Curt (Charter) agrees with Intel (Saso). Ouyang(Huawei) comments again on paging causes. Ouyang also proposes to merge this contribution to S2-2003635. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso(Intel). Ouyang(Huawei) objects to the orginal version and any other revisions . Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Ouyang(Huawei) if adding the word ,candidate' in the new Annex will alleviate Huawei's concerns? Lalith(Samsung) proposes to discuss this paper along with 3635 in CC#3 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2004206	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Paging cause usage .	Charter Communications	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004709	Alessio (Nokia) is this an evolution of S2-2003635? If so can we converge on one document? Which also should include S2-2004264? Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) is this an evolution of S2-2003635? If so can we converge on one document? Which also should include S2-2004264? Curt (Charter) asks a question to Saso (intel) Xiaowan(vivo) provides comments Ouyang(Huawei) asks a question for clarification. Curt (Charter) replies to ?? (Ouyang/Huawei) and ?? (Xiaowan/Vivo). Curt (Charter) provides R1. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to curt's question. Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification. Curt (Charter) replies to Xiaowan (vivo). Ouyang (Huawei) ask questions on the additional text. Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Curt (Charter). Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) and provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r02. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Curt(Charter). Ouyang(Huawei) objects to the orginal version and any other revisions . Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) and suggests to see where x3635 is going first before noting this. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2003893	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Update solution #1 of Handling of MT service with Paging Cause.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R04plus Agreed. Revised to S2-2004710.	Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification. Saso (Intel) proposes to revise the proposal as an incremental add-on to Solution #1. Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification Lalith (Samsung) asks for clarification. Alessio(nokia) provides comment and proposes this paper is noted Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comment Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies MediaTek's comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies HW's comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Samsung's comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies OPPO's comment. Steve (Huawei) comments. Alessio(nokia) can you clarify the interaction with PPD I have asked? Do you intend to standardize DSCP values? Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r02 to capture all the comments from Mediatek, OPPO, Samsung and HW Alessio(Nokia) This solution is problematic as the TAS is in HPLMN and the DSCP values are VPLMN specific. Networks in between may change the DSCP value for DIFFSERV operation Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Nokia's comment. Xiaowan (vivo) comments. Alessio(Nokia) In general if there is no guarantee that between the UPF and TAS no change of DSCP value happens, the solution does not work. So maybe you can place an EN to that effect. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Nokia's comment and r03 is provided. Saso (Intel) comments to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to vivo. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r04 to address Saso's comment. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) ok to document r04 if a EN is added 'Editor's Note: it is FFS whether this solution can work if there is no guarantee the DSCP cannot change between TAS and UPF in transport networks outside operators control between TAS in HPLMN and the P-CSCF in VPLMN. Impact on IPX especially is to be considered in roaming case and any requirement on NG.113 by GSMA shall be specified' Steve (Huawei) asks practical questions. Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei). Steve (Huawei) clarifies boiler plate EN, checks how to proceed with depenency. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply comments to HW and Intel. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004710	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Update solution #1 of Handling of MT service with Paging Cause.	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003893_R04plus. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004157	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Solution 1 Update: Align EPS Paging Cause with EPS Paging Policy Differentiation.	Vodafone	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004709	Myungjune (LGE) proposes to merge into S2-2003635. Saso (Intel) checks with Crhis (Vodfaone) whether merge with S2-2003635 is appropriate. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2003974	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004519	Lars (Sony) ask for updated figure 6.2.3.1-1 and procedure text Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and requests more details in the new procedure. Steve (Huawei) provides r01. Steve (Huawei) comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks question for clarification. Steve (Huawei) replies to questions. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides further comments Genadi (Motorola Mobility) responds to comments and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) provides r03. Saso (Intel) comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r04. Saso (Intel) provides r05. Steve (Huawei) is fine with r05 Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004519	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2003974. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003675	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to remove EN .	Sony	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.10	S2-2003637	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to remove ENs.	Intel	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004520	Lars (Sony) ask question for clarification Saso (Intel) replies to Lars (Sony) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments/asks question for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom). Saso (Intel) provides r01. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004520	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to remove ENs.	Intel	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003637. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003715	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Sol#8, Update to remove ENs .	Ericsson	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004588	Myungjune (LGE) provide comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune(LGE). Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) clarifies question. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Lalith(Samsung). Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune(LGE) and ask for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) suggests to add a note. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on Figure 6.8.2-2. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Saso (Intel) and Myungjune(LGE), provides r01. Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification on Figure 6.8.2-2. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Saso (Intel) and provides r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r02. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004588	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1, Sol#8, Update to remove ENs .	Ericsson	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2003715. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004049	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #8: Update to clarify UE impact.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.10	S2-2003837	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Network-based paging filtering.	LG Electronics, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004589	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) asks also questions. Myungjune (LGE) provides answer. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune (LGE) . Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification . Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel) and Lalith (Samsung). Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Wanqiang (Huawei) comment on the updated EN. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Wanqiang (Huawei). Wanqiang (Huawei) responds to Myungjune. Myungjune (LGE) provides r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments. Lalith (Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) and provides r01. Myungjune (LGE) answers to Qian (Ericsson) and provides r03. Myungjune (LGE) provides r04. Andy (Vice Chair) points out that Lalith provided r03, not r01. Alessio (nokia), responds to Saso(Intel). Antoine (Orange) asks how 'silent SMs' are handled. Myungjune (LGE) responds Antoine (Orange). Antoine (Orange) replies. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments. Myungjune (LGE) provides r05. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004589	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Network-based paging filtering.	LG Electronics, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R05 of S2-2003837. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003651	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Using Non-3GPP access to deliver NAS Notification message.	Apple	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000733. Noted	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments the proposal. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Saso (Intel) agrees with Qian Chen (Ericsson). Proposes to NOTE the pCR. Lalith (Samsung) comments for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note the document. Lalith (Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel). Krisztian (Apple) replies to Guillaume. Krisztian (Apple) provides r01 and replies to Xiaowan. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Juan. Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso and Lalith. Saso (Intel) replies to Krisztian (Apple). Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso. Lalith(Samsung) asks question to Krisztian (Apple) Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Krisztian. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Lalith. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Juan zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note this PCR. Antoine (Orange) objects to r00 and r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2003764	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1: New solution: Operator controlled Handling of Paging Cause code.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. Approved	Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification Alessio(Nokia) responds Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and asks for clarification Qian Chen (Ericsson) comments and asks questions. Alessio(nokia) responds to comment by huawei alessio (nokia) provides response to comments by ericsson (Ericsson) Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.10	S2-2003838	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Push Notification via SMS.	LG Electronics, LG Uplus	Rel-17	R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004590	Lars (Sony) ask for updated figure 6.x.2-1 and new rev. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) asks a question for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) responds Lars (Sony) and Chris (T-Mobile USA) and provides r01 . Saso (Intel) provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel). Saso Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE). Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004590	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Push Notification via SMS.	LG Electronics, LG Uplus	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003838. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004270	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Informing network two USIMs belongs to same device.	Samsung, NEC, Airtel, InterDigital	Rel-17	Noted	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note this proposal since it is related to the CN coordination. Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and r01 with new Editor's Notes. Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the comment from Qualcomm to note this document. Saso (Intel) supports Guillaume (MediaTek) and Juan (Qualcomm) and proposes to note this document. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Ulises (InterDigital Inc.) request Mr. SA2 Chairman to add S2-2004270 to the discussions for CC#4 with regards to the scope and priority of this paper in Rel.17 ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2004273	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1: IMS based solution.	vivo Mobile Communications Ltd	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004599	Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions. Adrian (vivo) provides comments and indicates S2-2004273 has been merged with S2-2004233. This thread maybe closed. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2003975	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#1 KI#3, New Sol: N3GPP for MUSIM Service Concurrency.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Noted	Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends this document be noted. Alessio(Nokia) supports MediaTek, the non 3GPP access leveraging is possible but not defining a specific standard solution. Hence, the reliance on non 3GPP access according to existing standards is going to be implementation driven and not in scope of standardization in MUSIM Study. Genadi (Motorola Mobility) seeks clarification. Lalith (Samsung) responds to Guillaume. Saso (Intel) supports Guillaume (MediaTek) and requests this pCR to be NOTED. Steve (Huawei) disagress with noting the pCR and asks for clarificaiton on CP data. Steve (Huawei) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Samsung. Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei). Saso (Intel) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) agree with Saso's comment and we should focus on 3GPP access. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) disagrees with noting. For the record: Saso (Intel) objects to this pCR. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2004233	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, New sol: ePDG connectivity for MT service in Multi-USIM scenarios .	Google	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004273, to S2-2004599	Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Alessio(Nokia) provides comments. Is this solution implying the user plane for both PLMNs is using one PLMN at some point? Pavan (Google) provides some answers, and provides a revision merging S2-2004233 and S2-2004273 Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification from Pavan (Google) and/or Adrian (vivo) Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and request revision. Aditya (Comcast) provides comments supporting the document Pavan (Google) provides some answers, and provides a new revision r2 Myungjune (LGE) asks question for clarification. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Adrian (vivo) responds. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments. Saso (Intel) comments. Adrian (vivo) agrees with the Intel proposal. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004599	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, New sol: ePDG/N3IWF connectivity for MT service in Multi-USIM scenarios .	Google, vivo Mobile Communications Ltd	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004233, merging S2-2004273. Approved		Approved
8.10	-	-	-	Key Issue #2	-	-	Docs:=16		-
8.10	S2-2003894	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Solution for paging collision avoidance .	Qualcomm Incorporated, apple, vivo, CATT	Rel-17	Noted	Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01. Alessio (nokia) it is not clear to us why the UDM should be affected. In a nutshell this indicates to the RAN to alter its paging behaviour for a MUSIM UE. we wonder whether this could be merged into S2-2003766r01 we have created to facilitate such merger.. Lars (Sony) provides r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 and reply comments. Lars (Sony) provides comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Sony's comment. Lars (Sony) replies Juan's comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Lars's comment. Saso (Intel) comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02, object to r03. Lars (Sony) comments. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Lars. Lars (Sony) replies to Xiaowan Lars (Sony) provides r04 Alessio (nokia) reiterates this paper is covered by 3766r01 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides v5 and reply comments. Lars (Sony) cannot accept r05 and reply to comments. Lars (Sony) further comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to Lars. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r06. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Lars (Sony) we can accept r06. Alessio (Nokia) objects to all revisions ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2003636	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #2, New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance.	Intel, Sony, OPPO, InterDigital	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000164	Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks a question for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Saso (Intel). Iskren (NEC) provides comments and also provides r01. Saso (Intel) replies to Malla and Iskren; provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Malla; provides r03. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04. Saso (Intel) is OK with r04 too. Iskren (NEC) provides comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Iskren (NEC). ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004600	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #2, New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance.	Intel, Sony, OPPO, InterDigital, NEC	Rel-17	Revision_R03 of S2-2003636. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003674	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #2: New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance using alt. UE_ID.	Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004591	Antoine (Orange) asks if this can be merged with S2-2004218. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks a question for clarification. Lars (Sony) provides answer to Malla and Antoine. Lars (Sony) provides r01 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r01. Alessio(Nokia) we are also happier to keep the two solutions separate. Iskren (NEC) provides comments. Lars (Sony) provides answer to Iskren. Chris (Vodafone) is OK to keep 4218 and 3674 as separate solutions. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004591	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #2: New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance using alt. UE_ID.	Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless, NEC	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003674. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004218	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging occasion conflict in EPS using offset to the UE Identity Index Value.	Vodafone	Rel-17	Approved	==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.10	S2-2003765	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2, KI#3: New Solution: establishment of association on user plane for paging notification on user plane.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Noted	Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR. Alessio (nokia): the main difference here is the registration mechanism which we propose to happen on the C-plane of the PLMN that delivers the notifications of the user plane of the other PLMN. The security is a detail but here we just propose a symmetric key that is provided by the UE using the NAS security in the source system (so this is a detail on how to provide security which of course SA3 will eventually assess). But really the c-plane registration is the main aspect here. Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification. Alessio (nokia) responds to comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (nokia). Alessio Nokia) reply to Saso that this is a competitive solution that borrows the conecpts of solution 7 at high level (meaning user plane paging) but then it is totally different at stage two level. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) and proposes a way forward. Saso (Intel) proposes r01. Alessio(nokia) retains Nokia solution is r0 Alessio(nokia) provides additional info on their solution which was requested: Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio(nokia): Alessio(nokia) provides r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Saso (Intel) objects to r02 and the original; can accept r01; reasons for objection provided below Alessio(nokia) objects to r01 as it is an intel paper not the nokia solution. Nokia complains heavily Intel is using anticompetitive behaviour to exclude a competing solution to theirs. Saso (Intel) refutes accusations from Alessio(nokia) and sustains objection on r00 and r02; proposes to reconsider moving forward with r01. Alessio(Nokia): I have already objected to Intel's paper in r01. For the rest everyone can see the nature of the comments by intel so we need not reply to them anymore. We will bring updated paper with a picture of a server at the next meeting ?? ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2003766	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging conflict using MUSIM Assistance Information.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004601	Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this pCR (or merge into other CRs). Qian Chen (Ericsson) withdraw the propose on this pCR. Alessio(nokia) provides r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks questions for clarification Saso (Intel) provides r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 based on r02 to remove S1 signalling. Alessio(nokia) objects to r03 as S1 singalling impact is allowed by RAN! Nokia does not consider r02 needed as the soltuion for coodinated leaving USING MUSIM assistacce info is in 3767 and should be kept there there, ... Intel proposes this note is sufficient to kill 3767 but this is not ok as the solution in3767 provides the system operation based on MUSIM assistanc ifnot ti IDNICATE the UE is leaving and condition network behaviour when the UE leaves. So we object to this revision. Nalessio(nokia) responds to dieter. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks additional question Saso (Intel) prefers r02; can live with r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004601	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging conflict using MUSIM Assistance Information.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003766. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003972	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2, New Sol: Paging on Consecutive POs.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004592	Antoine (Orange) comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r01. Alessio(Nokia) provides comments Antoine (Orange) replies to Steve. Steve (Huawei) provides r02. Alessio(nokia) but then this is similar to the Mediatek approach of doing nothing other than in the UE and the network is more aggressive than usual as it suspects there may be lots of MUSIM devices around? I still do not get the way this is MUSIM specific as I cannot detect anywhere anything that triggers the network to become MUSIM oriented for the UE. Steve (Huawei) provides a short comment to the previous long comment Alessio(Nokia) provides a short comment Alessio(Nokia) provides a remark Antoine (Orange) asks clarification on 'specific UE'. Steve (Huawei) provides r03 with specific UE clarificaiton Alessio(nokia) proposes to not this paper and merge with mediatek S2-2004050 Steve (Huawei) disagrees to note the paper. They are not the same. Alessio(nokia) requires clarification on network side behaviour. Steve (Huawei) comments. Alessio(nokia) requires further clarification on network side behaviour. Steve (Huawei) the solution sticks together Antoine (Orange) Interrupts Steve and Alessio for a question. Steve (Huawei) is happy for the interruption and provides a response. Alessio(nokia) proposes r04 Antoine (Orange) Agrees with Alessio that the solution is not fully described. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Steve (Huawei) r04 is ok. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004592	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#2, New Sol: Paging on Consecutive POs.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003972. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004050	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New Sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000949. Approved	Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks questions for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to MediaTek. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to NTT DoCoMo Alessio(nokia) can we at least note somewhere that this is a behavior already supported in the field so people do not claim this shall not be supported ?? ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Approved
8.10	S2-2004051	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device using increased paging repetition.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004593	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) withdraw the previous comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks questions for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo and provides r01. Antoine (Orange) questions the validity of the solution. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. The original and r01 should no longer be considered. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks r02 difference from S2-2003636. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004593	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device using increased paging repetition.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004051. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003895	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Solution for scheduling gap .	Qualcomm Incorporated	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R01 Agreed. Revised in parallel session to S2-2004711.	Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification on TDoc handling for items that are RAN centric (with no SA2 impact). Curt (Charter) comments... Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Mediatek and Charter's comments. Saso (Intel) comments and asks for clarification. Alessio(nokia). Agree with Guillaume this should not be put in TR. Propose to note and provide system requirement to provide scheduling gaps if the solutions we agree on require this. Guillaume (MediaTek) clarifies his point. Alessio(Nokia) OK so it is only us to ask it not to be documented. Just to note that one example of what I was saying is in S2-2003974 23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence. When it is assumed the short RAN GAP can be negotiated. In fact can we merge this paper into S2-2003974? Saso (Intel) asks Alessio(Nokia) to stop spreading confusion Steve (Huawei) comments on merge. Aditya (Comcast) supports Curt (Charter) view on the inclusion of this solution in SA2 Genadi (Motorola Mobility) supports to document the solution and mention in the LS to RAN in S2-2004248. Aditya (Comcast) adds a comment Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01 with the only change to add Comcast as consigner. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to the original Tdoc and rev thereof, subject to discussion during Friday CC on TDoc handling. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004711	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Solution for scheduling gap .	Qualcomm Incorporated, Comcast	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003895_R01. Approved		Approved
8.10	-	-	-	Key Issue #3	-	-	Docs:=15		-
8.10	S2-2003827	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol#4: update to support local leaving negotiation .	Vivo	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004595	Myungjune (LGE) provide comments. Lars (Sony) ask questions and ask Vivo to update the paper Xiaowan Ke (r01) provides r01 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r01. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004595	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol#4: update to support local leaving negotiation .	Vivo	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2003827. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003714	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs .	Ericsson, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Charter Communications	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003828, to S2-2004596	Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01 which merges in S2-2004163 (China Telecom) and S2-2003828 (Vivo) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Yang Xu (OPPO) provides question for clarification Xiaowan (vivo) provides r02 and comments Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r03 and responds to Xiaowan(vivo) Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides responds to Yang Xu (OPPO). Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Xiaowan(vivo) Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and provides r05. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides a question for clarification. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r04. Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and confirms that last revision is r04. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004596	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs .	Ericsson, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Charter Communications	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003714, merging S2-2003828. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004163	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Solution #5 Update: Update for UE setting expected time period to leave.	China Telecom	Rel-17	Noted	Xiaowan (vivo) provide r01. Xiaowan (vivo) provide r02. Alessio(nokia) provides comment: we still need CT1 to validate the short duration leave is suitable to perform common CT1 procedures. If this is not added we prefer r0 (original version) Qian Chen (Ericsson) provide comments and r03. Xiaowan (vivo) provides comment and r04. Lalith(Samsung) asks question to Xiaowan (vivo). Qian Chen (Ericsson) provide comments and r05. Xiaowan(vivo) answers to Lalith(Samsung). Lalith(Samsung) responds to Xiaowan(vivo) Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments to Xiaowan(vivo). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Xiaowan (vivo) only accepts r02, r04, objects the rest; also replies to Qian and Juan. Alessio(Nokia) only accepts r04 Qian Chen(Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions Alessio(nokia) to be fair we can also live with r5. . Pinghui(China Telecom) propose to go with r05 and comments Qian Chen(Ericsson) also propose to go with r05, objects to r02/r04 since they are not logically correct. Alessio(Nokia)does anyone know why the existing EN was not good enough? Do we need this tdoc to be approved? Juan Zhang (Qualcomm)can only accept r05, object r04. Qian Chen(Ericsson) comments that it's fine to NOTE the paper, if no agreement can be reached. Alessio (Nokia) shares the view of Ericsson. Xiaowan(vivo) is also fine to NOTE the paper. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is also fine to NOTE the paper. Andy (Vice Chair) observes that r05 seems to be OK for several companies, hasn't seen an objection. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) clarify comment. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2003828	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol#5: update to support more cases in MUSIM-RAI .	Vivo	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004596	Antoine (Orange) asks if this is considered merged into S2-2004163. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the CR since it's merged into S2-2003714. Qian Chen (Ericsson) withdraw the previous NOTE proposal. And propose to mark the pCR as Merged into S2-2003714. Xiaowan (vivo) confirms to merge S2-2003828 into S2-2003714. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2004267	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove ENs and clarify about non-3GPP access.	Samsung	Rel-17	R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004602	Xiaowan (vivo) request to merge S2-2004267 into S2-2004163 . Qian Chen (Ericsson) Propose to NOTE this pCR Lalith (Samsung) responds to Qian(Ericsson) Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Lalith (Samsung) Lalith(Samsung) agrees with Qian Chen (Ericsson) and provides r01 to handle it. Alessio(Nokia) comments on all revisions Myungjune (LGE) suggests to merge S2-2004267 and S2-2004163. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Alessio(Nokia) Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004602	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove ENs and clarify about non-3GPP access.	Samsung	Rel-17	Revision_R01 of S2-2004267. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003844	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove EN.	China Telecom	Rel-17	Merged into S2-2004597	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) provides further clarifications to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and provides r01. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) indicates merge S2-2003844 into the revision of S2-2003973. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Merged
8.10	S2-2003973	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol #6: Update for data handling after UE leaves.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	R04 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003844, to S2-2004597	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) comments. Lars (Sony) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) provides r02. Alessio(nokia )provides comment: this reads odd 'Alternatively, RAN paging may not be triggered until the UE initiates resume procedure.' Shuyi Tian (China Telecom ) proposes to merge S2-2003844 into S2-2003973 and provides r03. Steve (Huawei) the merge and r03 looks good. Alessio(nokia) comments Xiaowan (vivo) provides r04 and replies comments. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004597	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3, Sol #6: Update for data handling after UE leaves.	Huawei, HiSilicon	Rel-17	Revision_R04 of S2-2003973, merging S2-2003844. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004052	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #3, New Sol: Coordinated leaving for MUSIM device.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004598	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r01 (new title!) Alessio(nokia) asks for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides clarification and r02 ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004598	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #3, New Sol: Coordinated leaving for MUSIM device.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Revision_R02 of S2-2004052. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2003650	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI #3, New Sol: Network coordination when the multiple USIMs in the Multi-USIM device are served by the same serving network.	Apple	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2000736. Noted	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments that it is related to network coordination which is the lower priority, proposed to note the documents. Saso (Intel) also proposes to note the documents. Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the view from Saso (intel) to note this document. Krisztian (Apple) responds to comments. Saso (intel) replies to Krisztian (Apple). Antoine (Orange) provides a procedural comment and a technical comment. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso. Krisztian (Apple) replies to Antoine. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comment and agrees to NOTE the pCR. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2003767	P-CR	Approval	23.761: KI#3 New solution: Coordinated leaving Using MUSIM Assistance Information.	Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI	Rel-17	Noted	Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE this paper sine it overlaps with S2-2003766. Alessio (Nokia) responds to Qian Chen (Ericsson) : we created, bases on discussion on conf call and under guidance of the rapporteur, three papers out of a single one that was covering three key issues, so 3766 covers KI#2, and 3767 covers KI#3 .. Alessio(nokia) provides answer to Juan (QCOM) Saso (Intel) clarifies the recommendation given to Alessio (Nokia) and provides excerpt from the CC minutes; proposes to NOTE this pCR. Alessio(Nokia) the two papers that Qian proposes to merge are totally different and show the procedures for each KI specific aspects. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose further comments and still consider noting the pCR is correct. Genadi (Motorola Mobility) does not see how this solution is relevant to KI#3. Alessio(nokia) the relevance to KI#3 is that the Assistnac einfo can be included in registration requests or SR or RRC messages as events happen. Where is it stated that these are done asynchronously to events only, please? Alessio(nokia) provides r01 to make it even clearer how this is relevant to KI#3 and that this is not a negotiation happening asynchronously to the UE leaving a system. Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides further comments to Alessio (Nokia). Alessio (Nokia) responds to Genadi Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR Alessio(nokia) comment by intel is not comprehensible. Alos, he notes a solution based on his thoughts but we cannot assume Saso's thoughts are absolute... like why is it not possible for a UE to determine a periodicity of absence is beyond my understanding. So we push back to this comment (also adding a note to the 3767 while saying that this note can cause the 3767 doc to be noted is strange! Also the solution is not about periodicity of absence alone! Intel behavior at this meeting is to blanket note all Nokia papers? Is this a company position? Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio(nokia) Alessio(Nokia) we reiterate the periodicity is not the key of this solution! Can Intel read the solution and comment on the procedures? thanks Saso (Intel) disagrees that paging is a valid case for 'periodicity of absence'. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Alessio(nokia) comments that it seems some comments were based on misinterpretation of what I have responded, some assumed that this is scope of KI#2 but in fact we show the assistance info used for KI#3 in related procedure. Hence we would like to propose this paper is progressed as the argument of partial overlap should probably kill 90% of the papers on table as we all use same procedures! Saso (Intel) objects to all revisions of this paper. Alessio (Nokia) notes with interest the comments by Intel, which are not moving us forward. ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Noted
8.10	-	-	-	Other	-	-	Docs:=9		-
8.10	S2-2003981	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Architectural Assumption for MUSIM support.	NTT DOCOMO, Orange, Telecom Italia, Deutsche Telekom	Rel-17	To handle at CC#4. R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004712.	Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 and added Verizon and AT&T as co-signers. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Saso (Intel) comments. Alessio(nokia) proposes r02 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Juan and Saso. Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for this document to be noted. Omkar (CableLabs) asks for this document to be noted. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to CableLabs and MediaTek. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Mediatek's comment. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Juan. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02. Curt (Charter) comments ... Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r02 and provides r03. Xiaowan (vivo) provides comment and r04. Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok with r04. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Charter, ok with r04. Curt (Charter) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r04. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ==== Qian Chen (Ericsson) is fine with r04. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments: Could we remove 'to deploy in a PLMN' in this assumption during the conference call? ==== Ph2 Final Deadline ==== ==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====	Revised
8.10	S2-2004712	P-CR	Approval	23.761: Architectural Assumption for MUSIM support.	NTT DOCOMO, Orange, Telecom Italia, Deutsche Telekom,Verizon, AT&T	Rel-17	Revision of S2-2003981_R05. Approved		Approved
8.10	S2-2004044	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #1: Evaluation and conclusion .	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR. Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and propose to NOTE the pCR. Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel). Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur. (Same for our other evaluation TDocs) ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2004045	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #2: Evaluation and conclusion .	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR. Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel). Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and propose to NOTE the pCR. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to the esteemed Rapporteur. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted
8.10	S2-2004046	P-CR	Approval	23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #3: Evaluation and conclusion.	MediaTek Inc.	Rel-17	Noted	Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR. Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel). Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and Alessio (Nokia), and propose to NOTE the pCR. Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur to note the pCR. ==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====	Noted

TD#

Type

Doc For

Subject

Source

Rel

Comments

e-mail_Discussion

Result

1.2

Start of the meeting - Phase 2

Docs:=0

4.2

Common issues and Incoming LSs - Phase 2

Docs:=9

4.2

S2-2004336

LS In

Action

LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion

IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-TSN-support-in-3GPP-Release-16)

Rel-16

Postponed

Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this LS since we need to analyse and then potentially create CR(s) to address the extensive review comments.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports Ericsson
zhendong (ZTE) has similar view with qualcomm and ericsson
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Devaki (Nokia) also proposes to postpone this LS and comments that CR(s) should be created against Rel-16 only for FASMO items.

Postponed

4.2

S2-2004337

LS In

Action

LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS

RAN WG2 (R2-2005939)

Rel-15

Postponed

Chris (Vodafone) says that unless we get a RAN 3 LS on this topic, we can postpone this RAN 2 LS.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

4.2

S2-2004338

LS In

Action

LS from SA WG6: LS on IP address to GPSI translation

SA WG6 (S6-200947)

Rel-17

Postponed

Laurent (Nokia): Proposes the POSTPONE the LS as there is no INPUT document and the topic would require some
Mike (Convida Wireless) agrees that this should be POSTPONED
Changhong (Intel) also proposes to POSTPONE it.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

4.2

S2-2004339

LS In

Information

LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on QoS Sustainability Analytics

SA WG6 (S6-200948)

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this incoming LS as SA2 is CCed and no action required.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

4.2

S2-2004340

LS In

Information

LS from SA WG4: LS on Media Feature Tag for IMS Data Channel

SA WG4 (S4-200908)

Rel-16

Noted

Thomas Belling (Nokia) suggests noting this incoming LS, as SA2 is only cc
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

4.2

S2-2004631

LS In

Action

LS from SA WG5: LS on network data analysis energy saving

SA WG5 (S5-203360) (S5-203360)

Rel-17

Postponed

Yannick (Nokia) suggests to postpone this LS. We have just received this LS from SA5 in which SA5 asks questions to SA2, and there are no related inputs in this meeting.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

4.2

S2-2004634

LS In

Information

LS from SA WG4: LS on AT Commands for Bit Rate Recommendation

SA WG4 (S4-200880) (S4-200880)

Rel-16

Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

4.2

S2-2004635

LS In

Action

LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address

CT WG4 (C4-203452) (C4-203452)

Rel-16

Postponed

Patrice (Huawei) proposes a draft outgoing LS including copy to CT for handling it before Rel-16 stage 3 freeze.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei and also objects to original draft LS reply.
Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the reply LS (or rather not allocate a number to it - no need to send to the CC). The incoming LS can be postponed.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

4.2

S2-2004636

LS In

Information

LS from IETF DRIP: Scope and goals of the Drone Remote ID Protocol Working Group (DRIP) of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)

IETF DRIP (LSs_from_IETF_9June2020) (LSs_from_IETF_9June2020)

Postponed

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone the LS.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.5

Study on enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (FS_IIoT)

Docs:=58

8.5

S2-2004329

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004138, merging S2-2003921 and S2-2003942. To handle at CC#4. R14 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003752, to S2-2004701.

Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 that includes embedded questions as well as updated proposal removing QoS association with Survival Time.
Yuan (CATT) provides r02 and comments.
Sang-Jun provides r03.
Devaki (Nokia) provides r04.
Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r05.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds with a proposal for the text in question.
Devaki (Nokia) provides r07.
Yuan (CATT) comments.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks questions
Devaki (Nokia) answers Sebastian's question.
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) proposes comments and provides r08
Hui NI (Huawei) provides r09
Yuan (CATT) provides r10.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r11 removing 'shall'.
Vijay (Apple) provides r12, merging S2-2003752
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hui Ni(Huawei) comments on r11. Prefers to r10.
Shabnam (Ericsson) can accept r11, objects to others and provide comments.
Hui Ni (Huawei) responses.
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r11
Hui Ni (Huawei) objects r11.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides revised text for the controversial one and asks chairman to consider this small update over r11 to make progress.
Hui NI(Huawei) is fine with the proposed changes.
Devaki (Nokia) uploads R14 with changes proposed by Ericsson, Huawei and requests SA2 Chairman to add this paper for CC#4.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004701

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT, Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon, Apple, Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004329_R14, merging S2-2003752. Approved

Approved

8.5

Solution for KI#1

Docs:=5

8.5

S2-2003622

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Time Synchronization and remove EN.

Ericsson, Nokia

Rel-17

Approved

Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes 3622 to be merged to 3992.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes 3622 to be merged to 3939.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Devaki (Nokia) does not believe that this paper has been merged with 3939 as the revision of 3939 does not seem to cover the technical proposal in 3622.
Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia, sorry that I missed the email from Samsung. I would like to treat the two papers separately and approve 3622 since there were no comments?
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replise to Shabnam, Devaki.
Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Sang-Jun for understanding, did not see the email on merger until after deadline, as parts of the pCR missing from merged document, let's get them progressed separately.
Devaki (Nokia) comments that the chairman's notes should ask whether original version can be approved.
(as also agreed by Samsung)
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.5

S2-2003939

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Sync.

Samsung

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004637

Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01.
Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Dan Wang (China Mobile).
Qianghua (Huawei) seeks clarifications.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Qianghua (Huawei).
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) raises a number of questions that need clarification to better understand the solution update.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts r02, replies to Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r03.
Qianghua (Huawei) agrees this is needed and asks for more clarification
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Qianghua (Huawei) and provides r04.
zhendong (ZTE) has similar comments with huawei
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Zhendong (ZTE).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004637

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify UL Sync.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003939. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2004211

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: (g)PTP GM support by DS-TT.

Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004638

Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification
Sebastian replies to Dan Wang (China Mobile)
Dan (China Mobile) provides r01
Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r01
Hui NI (Huawei) comments whether this is in the scope of the study.
zhendong (ZTE) provides proposal
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Huawei and ZTE and clarifies that it is in scope given that a different paper (3570) updates the related key issue 3B to cover the case of DS-TT generating (g)PTP messages.
Hui NI(Huawei) provides r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification on Huawei comment and does not agree to original version, ok with r01, have question on r02.
Hui Ni (Huawei) responses.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and provides r03.
Shabnam (Ericsson) prefers Qualcomm proposed wording and also comments.
Hui NI (Huawei) is fine with r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004638

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: (g)PTP GM support by DS-TT.

Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004211. Approved

Approved

8.5

Solution for KI#2

Docs:=15

8.5

S2-2003619

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: UE-UE communication based on generalized Ethernet model.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004639

Qianghua (Huawei) raises strong concerns and proposes to NOTE.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the question for clarification
György (Ericsson) replies to Huawei comments.
György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE question.
Devaki (Nokia) also has some concerns with the proposal.
György (Ericsson) addresses Nokia's concerns.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to not prevent solutions from being included in the TR based on subjective views and evaluation comments.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) supports capturing the solution in the TR.
Devaki (Nokia) comments.
György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia.
Qianghua (Huawei) still holds concerns.
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei.
Qianghua (Huawei) responds to György.
Devaki (Nokia) proposes a way forward.
Devaki (Nokia) proposes r01.
György (Ericsson) provides r02.
Devaki (Nokia) can only accept r01.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 to add a Note and Qualcomm as a supporting company
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 based on r01.
Devaki (Nokia) Ok with r01 or r04.
György (Ericsson) thanks and accepts r03.
György (Ericsson) provides r05 based on r03.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses and r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Devaki (Nokia) can accept r01, r04 or r06, cannot accept other revisions.
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei that preventing the documentation of the major part of a new solution is not helpful.
György (Ericsson) respectfully requests Nokia to state what is the basis for objecting to the documentation of a major part of the solution on the delay model. Nokia's earlier statement that the solution 'assumes only UE-UPF delay' is clearly incorrect. The solution clearly considers intra-UPF delay and that is in line with TSN principles where TSN bridges also consider the processing delay between ingress and egress ports. It cannot be a basis for objection that Nokia sees other solution options as well - those can also be documented when contributed.
Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r04/r06.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki and strongly proposes to agree on r05
Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r06/r04 and object any other revisions.
Devaki (Nokia) replies to Sebastian and Gyorgy and comments that exclusion of whole intra-UPF delay (as in rev5) for UE-UE communication is incorrect.
Thus the proposal to go with R04/06 without the delay part.
Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004639

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: UE-UE communication based on generalized Ethernet model.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003619. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003751

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, New Sol: UPF triggered UE-UE TSC communication.

Apple

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004640

Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments for clarification
Qianghua (Huawei) raises concerns.
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) asked for clarification
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments.
Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification.
Devaki (Nokia) also has strong concerns with the solution proposal, technical feasibility.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01
Vijay (Apple) provides r02
Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Vijay (Apple) responds to Qianghua (Huawei)
Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r01,r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004640

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, New Sol: UPF triggered UE-UE TSC communication.

Apple

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003751. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003954

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, new solution .

ZTE

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004641

Qianghua (Huawei) raises strong concerns and proposes to NOTE.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 and response to comments.
György (Ericsson) provides comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification
György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE and raises further questions
Devaki (Nokia) wonders if the solution exposing only internals of UPF needs to be documented in the TR?
Asks question for clarification.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response.
zhendong (ZTE), i am fine with r02
György (Ericsson) provides r03.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r03.
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r04 and response to comments
Qianghua (Huawei) replies to György.
György (Ericsson) accepts r04 but asks a question.
György (Ericsson) replies to Huawei.
György (Ericsson) responds.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004641

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, new solution .

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003954. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003955

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, update the solution 2.

ZTE

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004642

Xiaowan Ke ( vivo) comments and requests to note this paper.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01
Qianghua (Huawei) raise concerns on r01
zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification to huawei
Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r02.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r03
Qianghua (Huawei)comments on R03 and provides r04.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r05
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r06
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06
Xiaowan (vivo) is fine with r06
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004642

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, update the solution 2.

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003955. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003940

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify UE-to-UE TSC.

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004643

Qianghua (Huawei) comments and proposes to merge to S2-2003992.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) agreed to merge prosal from Qianghua (Huawei).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2003992

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the procedures and impacts.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003940, to S2-2004643

Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides meerged revision r01.
György (Ericsson) requests updates to the merged document.
Devaki (Nokia) comments and requests revision to clarify the comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 and replies to Devaki and György.
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and asks further questions.
Qianghua (Huawei) responds to György.
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and provides r03.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04.
György (Ericsson) provides r05.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments on the ENs.
György (Ericsson) responds and provides r06.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments back.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. We only accept r06 or r05.
Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees with György (Ericsson).
Qianghua (Huawei) can live with r06
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004643

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the procedures and impacts.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2003992, merging S2-2003940. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003993

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #2: evaluation and conclusion.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Postponed

György (Ericsson) proposes to note the document.
Devaki (Nokia) also believes that this is a pre-mature conclusion thus it is best to NOTE this document.
To be clear, we would have objection to any revision of this document during this meeting.
Qianghua (Huawei) agrees to postpone this given new solutions are submitted.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.5

S2-2004136

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004644

Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
György (Ericsson) comments.
Devaki (Nokia) responds to Gyorgy, Qianghua, also merges two valid email threads for the same paper.
Devaki (Nokia) also provides r01 (addressing Qualcomm, Ericsson, Huawei comments).
György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides r02.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides further comments on the responses.
Devaki (Nokia) provides r03.
Devaki (Nokia) answers.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04.
György (Ericsson) provides r05.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06.
György (Ericsson) is also OK with r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004644

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2004136. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2004137

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#2, Sol #4: AF Request for UE-UE QoS reservations.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Noted

György (Ericsson) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to NOTE this since it is for discussion
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.5

Solution for KI#3A

Docs:=12

8.5

S2-2003777

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, New Solution: Mechanism for AF requesting 5G network jitter.

China Mobile

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004645

Devaki (Nokia) comments and asks question for clarification
Belen (Ericsson) comments the proposal
Dan (China Mobile) reply to Devaki's and Belen's comments and provides r01
Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution
Dan(China Mobile)reply to Belen and please clarify your main concern
Dan(China Mobile) provides r02 to address Belen's concern
Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004645

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, New Solution: Mechanism for AF requesting 5G network jitter.

China Mobile

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003777. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003919

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to KI and sol to add survival time capability exposure .

CATT

Rel-17

Approved

Hui Ni (Huawei) questions whether we should mix KI#3A and KI#5.
Yuan (CATT) provides response.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.5

S2-2003621

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3, Sol #5: Update to clarify Exposure of TSC capabilities .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004646

Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 (with some comments).
Hui Ni (Huawei) provides comments.
Belen (Ericsson) provides r02, including comments provided by Nokia and Huawei.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004646

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3, Sol #5: Update to clarify Exposure of TSC capabilities .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003621. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003956

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#3A, update the solution 6.

ZTE

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004648

Belen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions
zhendong (ZTE) , this paper is merged to noakia S2-2004134
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2004088

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, New Sol: Supporting deterministic communication.

Samsung

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004647

Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Belen (Ericsson) objects to this proposal
Yoonseon (Samsung) replies to Belen and Qianghua.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments again.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to questions and maintains objection to r01
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 to reflect Huawei concern.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to questions and provides r04, objections to initial version, r01, r02 and r03
Yoonseon(Samsung) provides r05, and replies to Belen and Qianghua
Belen (Ericsson) comments on r05 .
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 and responses.
Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06
Devaki (Nokia) raises a question.
Yoonseon (Samsung) provides r07, and replies to Devaki.
Samsung is ok for r06 and r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r07
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004647

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, New Sol: Supporting deterministic communication.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2004088. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2004227

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#3A, new solution: Burst arrival time adaptation.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Devaki (Nokia) provides r01.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02
Devaki (Nokia) raises follow up questions.
Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns with the current proposal and objects to any version of the pCR, comments below.
Devaki (Nokia) proposes r03.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Shabnam and provides r04
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) maintains sustained objection to original and all revisions of this document, provides comments.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.5

S2-2004230

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3, New Sol: Enhancement to 5GS TSN bridge capability reporting and configuration.

Intel

Rel-17

Noted

Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Belen (Ericsson) objects to this proposal
Saso (Intel) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and Qianghua (Huawei)
Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to not prevent solutions from being included in the TR based on evaluation views.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) points out that the E/// paper in S2-2003619 provides a good justification for the solution proposed in this paper and supports including the solution proposed in S2-2004230 into the TR.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to QC and Intel.
Saso (Intel) thanks Sebastian (Qualcomm) for support and replies to Belen (Ericsson); also provides r01.
Devaki (Nokia) has concerns with the aspects where this solution is introducing numerous variants.
Provides r02, kindly requests for another revision considering comments in r02.
Saso (Intel) provides r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03
Belen (Ericsson) objects to r03, and any other previous revision if this document.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.5

S2-2004134

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to resolve ENs and merge solutions 5 & 6.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003956, to S2-2004648

Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and asks for clarification.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02
Devaki (Nokia) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Devaki (Nokia) comments that the chairman's notes should ask whether r02 can be approved? (latest version is r02).
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004648

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to resolve ENs and merge solutions 5 & 6.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004134, merging S2-2003956. Approved

Approved

8.5

KI#3B Update

Docs:=1

8.5

S2-2003570

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B: Update to KI #3B to support PTP over UDP/IP.

NTT DOCOMO, Sennheiser, BBC, EBU, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm, Futurewei

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.5

Solution for KI#3B

Docs:=12

8.5

S2-2003581

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.

NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser

Rel-17

Revised, merging S2-2003943, to S2-2004312

Revised

8.5

S2-2004312

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.

NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003581, merging S2-2003943. R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003991, to S2-2004649

Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2003991 and provides r01
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 and comments
Devaki (Nokia) comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Devaki/Jari and provides r03
Devaki (Nokia) responds.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Jari
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04.
Qianghua (Huawei) provide r05.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r08 to remove Qualcomm from supporters list
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that the pCR needs to replace 'Timing Domain' with 'Time Domain' since the term Timing Domain does not exist?
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds that 'Timing Domain' is used in several Key Issues and Solutions in the existing TR 23.700-020, so it is proposed to clarify or change the term in the next meeting.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004649

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for support of PTP over IP.

NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Sennheiser, Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R08 of S2-2004312, merging S2-2003991. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003943

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to Expand Sync Exposure.

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004312

Merged

8.5

S2-2003920

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, New Sol: Activate or deactivate TSN time synchronization per AF request.

CATT

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004651

Yuan (CATT) provides r01.
Hui Ni (Huawei) comments.
Yuan (CATT) provides response to Hui Ni (Huawei).
Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge.
Yuan (CATT) merges this paper into 2004112r03 .
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2003957

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#3B, new solution .

ZTE

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004651

Hui Ni (Huawei) comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Devaki (Nokia) comments and proposes to consider merge.
Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge.
zhendong (ZTE) this paper is merged to 4112
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2003987

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update to support Per UE or Per UE Group TSN Activation/deactivation .

Tencent

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.5

S2-2003988

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7/8: Update the Solutions to support TSN time Synchronization over IP.

Tencent

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004650

Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) provides r01 to only cover solution#8.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004650

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update the Solutions to support TSN time Synchronization over IP.

Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003988. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2003991

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to clarify how to determine time announcement information.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004649

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) confirms this is merged into S2-2004312.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2004112

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: Solution for KI #3B: Exposure of Time Synchronization .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003920 and S2-2003957, to S2-2004651

Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) questions if the solution actually works and if so to give more explanation how.
Hui NI (Huawei) responses and provide r02.
Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge 3920 into 4112 and provides r03.
Hui NI(Huawei) fine with r03.
Jari (NTT DoCOMO) provides r04 and proposes to focus only to clause 6.7.3.
Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r05.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments on r06
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Zhendong.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r07
Yuan (CATT) seeks clarification.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Yuan.
Yuan (CATT) responds to Jari.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004651

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: Solution for KI #3B: Exposure of Time Synchronization .

Huawei, HiSilicon,CATT, ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2004112, merging S2-2003920 and S2-2003957. Approved

Approved

8.5

Solution for KI#5

Docs:=8

8.5

S2-2003752

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #5, New Sol: IIoT application specific AF providing survival time as part of the QoS container.

Apple

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004701

Dan Wang (China Mobile) comments about the paper motivation
Devaki (Nokia) comments and asks question for clarification
Shabnam (Ericsson) It is unclear how it relates to KI#5, and how it works.
Vijay (Apple) responds to comments and provides r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) questions what is the difference with this revision and S2-2004329 approach? I think this one can be noted or considered merged with 4329?
Devaki (Nokia) also proposes that merging with 4329 (or noting) should be considered
Vijay (Apple) accepts the suggestion to merge to 4329
Shabnam (Ericsson) please add Ericsson as supporting company for this pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) corrects mistake, the comment was on the wrong document thread, meant to cosign S2-2004329.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.5

S2-2003921

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #X, New Sol: Use of survival time.

CATT

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004329

Merged

8.5

S2-2003942

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI #5, New Sol: Survival Time Format.

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004329

Merged

8.5

S2-2003958

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#5, Update the key issue#5.

ZTE

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.5

S2-2003959

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#5, new solution .

ZTE

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004652

Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, remove the NG RAN preconfiguration as it is up to NG-RAN to decide how to use this information.
Devaki (Nokia) provides revision 2.
Hui Ni(Huawei) proposes to merge into S2-2004329.
zhendong (ZTE) prefer keeping seperately.
zhendong (ZTE), i am fine with r01
zhendong (ZTE) provides r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004652

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#5, new solution .

ZTE, Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003959. Approved

Approved

8.5

S2-2004113

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: Solution for KI#5: Providing Survival Time for Deterministic Applications .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Noted

Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this with S2-2004329.
Hui Ni (Huawei) fine to merge.
Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to this pCR, and to the principle this solution provides, which contradicts the understanding and scope of SA2 part of the work related to Survival Time as described in the key issue itself.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.5

S2-2004138

P-CR

Approval

23.700-20: KI#X, New Sol: Survival Time for Deterministic Applications.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revised, merging S2-2003921, and S2-2003942 to S2-2004329

Revised

8.5

LS OUT

Docs:=2

8.5

S2-2004139

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] LS on need for survival time for IEEE TSN

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004653

Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 in line with earlier comments (remove 'CUC', add question mark, improve wording).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.5

S2-2004653

LS OUT

Approval

LS on need for survival time for IEEE TSN

SA WG2

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004139. Approved

Approved

8.5

TR Coversheet

Docs:=1

8.5

S2-2004256

TS OR TR COVER

Approval

FS_IIoT TR 23.700-20 Cover sheet for information to TSG SA

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

Noted

Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this, consistent and aligned with Ph 1 meeting decision on other TR Cover sheet handling.
Hui Ni (Huawei) agree with Ericsson's comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.6

Study Extended Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (FS_eATSSS)

Docs:=29

8.6

TR Skeleton, Scope

Docs:=4

8.6

S2-2003746

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Skeleton.

ZTE (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004654

Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 to update System Impacts clause to include IETF protocols.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004654

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Skeleton.

ZTE (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003746. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2003747

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: EATSSS_Ph2 Scope.

ZTE (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004655

Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004655

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: EATSSS_Ph2 Scope.

ZTE (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003747. Approved

Approved

8.6

Architectural Requirements, Assumptions

Docs:=4

8.6

S2-2003846

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions on Steering Mode.

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004658

Tricci (ZTE) conditional objects this PCR dependent the answer of the question.
Laurent (Nokia): Comments
Dongeun (Samsung) answers to the question.
Tricci (ZTE) asked for further clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) also asks for clarification
Dongeun (Samsung) proposed to merge this paper with S2-2003662 (merged text already applied to 3662r06,r07,r08)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.6

S2-2004098

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions for ATSSS.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

R13 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004656

Tricci (ZTE) proposed r01 to indicate that the new architectural components should be conditional for now.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
Tricci (ZTE) provides r04
Curt (Charter) provides r05
Marco (Huawei) provides r06
Tricci (ZTE) provides r07 to enforce new added steering functionality to be based on today IETF protocols.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r08.
Tricci (ZTE) commented r08 - missing figure from Apple
Hualin response to Tricci (ZTE) and provide r09.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r10 and comments
Marco (Huawei): provides r11 and comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r12 and comments
Tricci (ZTE):provides r13 to ensure the alignment with IETF for any extension on QUIC/MPQUIC from 3GPP.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hualin(Huawei) response to Tricci (ZTE), we are ok with R13, thanks.
Laurent (Nokia) Prefers we approve R012 and comments.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) prefers approving r12.
Laurent (Nokia) this mail replaces my previous mail, objects to r00, r01, r06, r07, r08, r09. Prefers we approve R012 and comments.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides some background information on TLS.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004656

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Architectural Requirements and Assumptions for ATSSS.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, ZTE, Apple

Rel-17

Revision_R13 of S2-2004098. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004239

DISCUSSION

Agreement

Energy conscious steering mode for eATSSS.

Google

Rel-17

Noted

Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications on this discussion paper.
Pavan (Google) responds to ZTE's questions, and proposes to NOTE the paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.6

New Key Issues

Docs:=7

8.6

S2-2003661

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Modes.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, BT, Apple, Broadcom

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004657

Tricci (ZTE) proposed r01.
Tricci (ZTE) resubmitted r01 (forgot the link in the last email).
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r02
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004657

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003661. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2003662

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom

Rel-17

R13 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003846, to S2-2004658

Dongeun (Samsung) provides r01.
Tricci (ZTE) proposed r02.
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r03
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r04
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05
Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06.
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r06, r07 and comments
Florin (Broadcom) provides r08 with editorial updates.
Spencer Dawkins provides r09 with correction to text on QUIC usage of TLS 3.0 (description is in file), added Tencent as supporting.
Dongeun (Samsung) provides r10
Krisztian (Apple) provides r11.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r12 and comments
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r12
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r13
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004658

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Key Issue for R17 ATSSS: Additional Steering Methods.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Broadcom, ZTE, Deutsche Telekom, Ericsson, Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R13 of S2-2003662, merging S2-2003846. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004097

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: KI #x (Additional Steering Mode): New Sol: Aggregated Steering Mode for Multiple traffic.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Postponed

Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarification.
Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) asked for clarification
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments
Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r02
Megha(Intel) provides comments and proposes to note the pCR.
Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) doubts the paper assumption.
Hua(Huawei) response to Tricci (ZTE).
Hualin (Huawei) response to Dongeun(Samsung)
Hualin response to Chia-Lin (MediaTek).
Hualin(Huawei) response to Laurent (Nokia).
Hualin(Huawei) response to Stefan (Ericsson).
Hualin (Huawei) response to Megha(Intel).
Hualin (Huawei) response to Chunshan(Tencent).
Hualin (Huawei) provide r03.
Megha(Intel) answers question from Hualin and provides further comments
Hualin (Huawei) response to the comments from Stefan(Ericsson).
Hualin (Huawei) provide r04.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05
Laurent (Nokia): provides r06 and comments
Hualin(Huawei) thanks to Laurent (Nokia) and ok with revision 06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): comments
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments and proposes to postpone this PCR.
Hualin(Huawei) response to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom).
Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Laurent's comment
Laurent (Nokia) suggests to POSTPONE this P-CR
Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to postpone.
Megha(Intel) proposes to postpone the pCR.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.6

S2-2004184

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Key Issue #X: Supporting MA PDU with 3GPP access leg over EPC and Non-3GPP access leg over 5GC.

InterDigital Inc., Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004659

Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 and comments
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) is ok with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004659

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Key Issue #X: Supporting MA PDU with 3GPP access leg over EPC and Non-3GPP access leg over 5GC.

InterDigital Inc., Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Apple, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004184. Approved

Approved

8.6

New Solutions

Docs:=14

8.6

S2-2003697

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: QUIC-LL steering functionality .

Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004660

Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification.
Dongeun (Samsung) asks for clarificaiton.
Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification.
Jinguo(ZTE) asks a question for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia) provides a r01 and comments.
Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications
Tricci (ZTE) asked for additional clarifications
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Susan's (Huawei) questions.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun's (Samsung) questions.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Myungjune's (LGE) question.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) answers Jinguo's (ZTE) questions.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Laurent (Nokia).
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Tricci's (ZTE) questions.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r02.
Myungjune (LGE) provides comment.
Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns.
Myungjune (LGE) withdraws previous comment.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r03
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Myungjune (LGE).
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung) questions.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r04.
Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause.
Florin (Broadcom) provides r05.
Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r07 and comments
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung).
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) is fine with r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00
Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r06, r07
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004660

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: QUIC-LL steering functionality .

Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2003697. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2003788

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality .

Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R07 agreed. Revised to S2-2004702.

Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments
Tricci (ZTE) asked the following clarifications
Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification
Laurent (Nokia) comments
Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns (similar concerns on QUIC-LL, S2-2003697).
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Dongeun (Samsung).
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r02.
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) responds to Stefan's (Ericsson) questions for clarification
Florin (Broadcom) provides r03.
Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause.
Florin (Broadcom) responds to Tricci's (ZTE) request and provides r04 : System impact and dependencies on other SDOs work should be identified and captured during the evaluation stage. This should be generally valid for all the proposed solutions.
Tricci (ZTE) responded to Broadcom for the support to identify the IETF impacts.
Dongeun (Samsung) provides r06 (r05 was a mistake).
Laurent (Nokia): provides r and comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides comments
Apostolis (Motorola Mobility) provides r08, which deletes just one EN in r07, and provides further comments.
Susan (Huawei) provides comments and supports r07.
Susan (Huawei) comments.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dongeun (Samsung) responds to Aspotolis (Motorola Mobility)
Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00
Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r06, r07, r08
Susan (Huawei) can only accept r07.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004702

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality .

Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003788_R07. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004012

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method MP-QUIC for UDP.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R05.5 agreed. Revised to S2-2004703.

Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification (similar comments to 4013)
Susan (Huawei) answers the questions from Samsung.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides comments
Susan (Huawei) replies to Jinguo.
Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification
Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarification.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Tricci.
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments
Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan.
Tricci (ZTE) responded to Huawei
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan and Laurent.
Florin (Broadcom) asks for clarifications and requests further updates in the document.
Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments
Susan (Huawei) is ok with r05.
Florin (Broadcom) replies and requests for an EN in both 4012 and 4013
Florin (Broadcom) provides r06 with an EN and clarifies that this is a QUIC based proxy solution.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Susan (Huawei) replies to Florin.
Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00
Susan (Huawei) proposes the similar way forward as for 4013 (i.e. create a r05.5 to approve at CC#4)
Florin (Broadcom) supports the proposed way forward by Susan (Huawei)
Laurent (Nokia) supports the proposed way forward by Susan (Huawei)
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004703

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method MP-QUIC for UDP.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004012_R05.5. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004013

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method QUIC for UDP.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R05.5 agreed. Revised to S2-2004704.

Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification
Susan (Huawei) answers the questions from Samsung.
Jinguo (ZTE) provides questions..
Dongeun (Samsung) asked for further clarification
Susan (Huawei) replies to Jinguo.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Dongeun.
Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification
Dongeun (Samsung) raised concerns on the case 1)
Chunshan (Tencent) questions on combine QUIC with ATSSS-LL
Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Chunshan.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 and comments
Florin (Broadcom) asks for clarifications and requests further updates in the document.
Tricci (ZTE) has similar comments as Broadcom and Ericsson
Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments
Susan (Huawei) replies to Tricci.
Susan (Huawei) agrees with r05.
Florin (Broadcom) provides r06 with an EN and clarifies that this is a QUIC based proxy solution.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Susan (Huawei) replies to Florin and propose to go with r05.
Laurent (Nokia): prefers much R06
Florin (Broadcom) replies to Susan (Huawei) explaining why r06 is the only acceptable version.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Laurent.
Laurent (Nokia) replies to Susan (Huawei.
Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00, r01, r02
Florin (Broadcom) replies to Susan (Huawei) and proposes a way forward.
Laurent (Nokia): supports the way forward from Florin (create a r5.5 to approve at CC#4)
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports also the way forward proposed from Florin (create a r5.5 to approve at CC#4)
Susan (Huawei) replies to Dieter, Laurent and Florin, and agrees with the way forward from Florin (i.e. create a r05.5 to approve at CC#4)
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004704

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering method QUIC for UDP.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004013_R05.5. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004014

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering modes.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004661

Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification
Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment
Megha(Intel) provides comments.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Intel, ZTE, Samsung.
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments
Susan (Huawei) replies to Laurent.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 and comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides comments
Megha(Intel) provides further comments
Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r04.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 and comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r06
Susan (Huawei) is ok with r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to r00, r01, r02, r03; prefers r05 or r06
Megha(Intel) can accept r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004661

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Sol: New steering modes.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2004014. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004173

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Replacing 3GPP access leg of MA-PDU Session with PDN connection in EPC.

InterDigital Inc.,

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004662

Myungjune (LGE) provide comments.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefan (Ericsson) question.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) further responds comments and provides revision 01.
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r02 and comments
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02.
Laurent (Nokia): we can only live with r02 (objection to previous versions)
Stefan (Ericsson) prefers r02
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.6

S2-2004662

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: Replacing 3GPP access leg of MA-PDU Session with PDN connection in EPC.

InterDigital Inc.,

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004173. Approved

Approved

8.6

S2-2004293

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: New Solution: QUIC Tunnel Low-Layer (QT-LL) Steering Functionality .

Apple

Rel-17

Revised to S2-2004300

Qing An (Alibaba) proposes to NOTE this document.

Revised

8.6

S2-2004300

P-CR

Approval

23.700-93: KI#x, New Sol: QUIC Tunnel Low-Layer (QT-LL) Steering Functionality

Apple

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004293. Noted

Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification.
Qing An (Alibaba) proposes to NOTE this document.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides comment
Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification
Laurent (Nokia) submitted r01 and comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks a question.
Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Alibaba.
Adi (Apple) responds to Huawei's comments.
Tricci (ZTE) provided comments - please provide information in system impact clause.
Adi (Apple) responds to ZTE's comments.
Adi (Apple) responds to Samsung's comments.
Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Ericsson.
Adi (Apple) responds to Nokia's comments.
Florin (Broadcom) provides r03 .
Adi (Apple) provides r04.
Dongeun (Samsung) provides r05.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r06 and comments
Adi (Apple) responds to comments from Samsung.
Susan (Huawei) provides comments.
Adi (Apple) responds to Huawei.
Adi (Apple) responds to Nokia's comments and provides r07.
Susan (Huawei) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Adi (Apple) objects r08 and provides comments to Huawei.
Susan (Huawei) objects to r04, r05, r06, r07.
Laurent (Nokia): we object to r00 and we can leave with r03 and comments
Dongeun (Samsung) only accepts r05, r06, r07, r08
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.7

Study on supporting UAS Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (FS_ID_UAS-SA2)

Docs:=67

8.7

LSs IN/OUT

Docs:=5

8.7

S2-2003522

LS In

Action

LS from ATIS UAV Ad-Hoc Group: Liaison Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17

ATIS UAV Ad-Hoc Group (FAA NPRM for UAV Remote ID)

Revision of postponed S2-2002624 from S2-138E. Response drafted in S2-2003800. Final response in S2-2004663

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Replied to

8.7

S2-2003800

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] Reply LS on Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17

Qualcomm Wireless GmbH

Response to S2-2003522. R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004663

Chen (OPPO) provides r01 and comments.
Chris (Vodafone) says update section 3 during clean-up.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004663

LS OUT

Approval

Reply LS on Statement on UAV Remote ID Priority in Release 17

SA WG2

Revision_R01 of S2-2003800. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004319

LS In

Action

LS from SA WG1: Reply to LS on Clarification of the definition of a UAS

SA WG1 (S1-202267)

Rel-17

Postponed

Steve (Huawei) proposed to note.
Stefano (Faccin) suggests postponing the LS.
Steve (Huawei) postponing is fine.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.7

S2-2004320

LS In

Information

LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on Clarification of requirements for UAS application enablement

SA WG1 (S1-202270)

Rel-17

Noted

Steve (Huawei) proposes to note.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

Architectural Requirements and Assumptions

Docs:=7

8.7

S2-2003716

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Key Issues, all: Update of Architectural Requirements and Assumptions.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004664

Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01.
Antoine (Orange) questions r01.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) comments and provides r02.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Antoine (Orange) question.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification on UAV9.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r03.
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification why the interface without any designation nor jurisdiction of 3GPP between TPAE and UTM need to be shown in the diagram?
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 04.
Chen (OPPO) provides comments.
Sherry (Nokia) provides comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks everyone for the constructive coordination, r04 is fine for us. Comment to the rapporteur added.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) accepts R04. Object to original version.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004664

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Key Issues, all: Update of Architectural Requirements and Assumptions.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003716. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2003794

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Correction to Architectural Requirements.

Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Futurewei, Verizon

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.7

S2-2003795

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon, Nokia

Rel-17

R08 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004665

Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides revision 01.
Chen (OPPO) provides revision 02 and comments.
Antoine (Orange) comments.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on revision 02.
Steve (Huawei) comments and asks a question.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides revision 03.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on revision 03.
Dan (China Mobile) comments for clarification
Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks to clarify/update based on comments below.
Antoine (Orange) questions Chen's comment and replies to Shabnam.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 05 and addresses comments.
Dan(China Mobile) just ask for clarification
Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to question
Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification.
Chen (OPPO) answers Antoine's question, clarifies wrong understanding.
Shabnam (Ericsson) there are some concerns remain, so we provide r06 with some ENs and changes.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 07.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concern on r06.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) repeats concerns on r06/r07.
Shabnam (Ericsson) we can only accept this with the proposed update, as I see different interpretation/fulfillment ideas and as such we need to leave it open.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) agreed with Interdigital that that EN is not needed.
Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Guanzhou concerns.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r08.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) we can accept r08.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) accepts r08. Objects to r06 and r07.
Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r08
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004665

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon, Nokia, InterDigtial

Rel-17

Revision_R08 of S2-2003795. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004060

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Update to Architectural Assumptions.

China Mobile

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004667

Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
Runze (Huawei) supports the rev1 and Huawei cosigns the paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004667

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Update to Architectural Assumptions.

China Mobile, Huawei

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004060. Approved

Approved

8.7

Reference Architecture

Docs:=7

8.7

S2-2003727

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Reference Architecture Update: Transparency of UAV3 to 3GPP system.

OPPO

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004668

Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) agreed with Interdigital and support r01.
Sherry (Nokia) is fine with r01.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) Agrees with Sherry (Nokia)
Chen (OPPO) provided r02 and addresses comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r03, removing solution aspect from interface description (i.e. whether goes via two UPFs directly or not).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004668

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Reference Architecture Update: Transparency of UAV3 to 3GPP system.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003727. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004000

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Arch Update: Mapping UAS reference architecture to 5GS system.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Guanzhou (InterDigital) raises concerns and asks for clarification.
Dimitris (Lenovo) has concerns with this proposal
Sherry (Nokia) comments that this should be defined as a solution than architecture assumption.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) agrees with Sherr (Nokia) and Dimitrios (Lenovo)
Shabnam (Ericsson) shares views by Nokia, T-Mobile and others that this is a potential mapping and not applicable for all, so in its current form would object to both original and r01.
Steve (Huawei) provides r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions and the original.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Sherry (Nokia) proposes to note the paper.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2004243

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Update to Reference Architecture .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004669

Steve (Huawei) asks about UAV10, UAV5 is underdiscussion elsewhere.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r01.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Chen (OPPO) provides comments.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r02.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r03.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Steve (Huawei) does not see any clarifications. Benefit is not clear.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r04.
Steve (Huawei) comments. Note?
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Sherry (Nokia) disagree with Huawei's unreasonable comments and arguments.
Steve (Huawei) comments on failure to communicate.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004669

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Update to Reference Architecture .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2004243. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004245

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution on 3GPP reference architecture for UAS remote identification and USS discovery .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004670

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) comments enclosed
Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for clarification.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r01.
Hyunsook (LGE) provides comments.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 02, supports changes to architecture section, expresses concerns about the solution.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r03.
Steve (Huawei) comments and asks questions for clarification
Sherry (Nokia) provides r04.
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks why TPAE is part of the UE? Propose to remove inclusion of TPAE in 3GPP architecture options.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Sherry (Nokia) replies.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004670

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution on 3GPP reference architecture for UAS remote identification and USS discovery .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2004245. Approved

Approved

8.7

Solutions for authentication and authorization

Docs:=10

8.7

S2-2003717

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 7: Solution for Authentication and Authorization of UAV .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004671

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed and expresses concerns.
Qianghua (Huawei) requests for clarifications.
Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification on the proposed solution
Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks questions for clarifications.
Gerald (Matrixx) asks question for clarification.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) asks question for clarification.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 in response to comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments and requests change of solution title.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides comments and supports Rev. 02.
Qianghua (Huawei) re-state our requests for clarifications.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Huawei comments and provides r03.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for additional clarification.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 04 and co-signs.
Jinguo (ZTE) provides r05 and co-signs.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response to the comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) responds.
Jinguo (ZTE) provides comment.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to ZTE and Huawei comments, can live with the latest revision r06.
Jinguo(ZTE) responds.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004671

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 7: Solution for Authentication and Authorization of UAV .

Ericsson, InterDigital, ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003717. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2003798

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, New Sol: Solution for UAV authentication and authorization by USS/UTM .

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Interdigital, Verizon

Rel-17

R12 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004079 and S2-2004007, to S2-2004672

Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification on 'UUAA pending indication'.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides rev01
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments/questions related to the solutions and difference between 5GC and EPC and asks for clarification and potential update to the proposal.
Chen (OPPO) provides r03 and comments.
Antoine (Orange) provides r04.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 05 enclosed, plus addresses comments.
Jinguo(ZTE) provideds r06
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 07 enclosed.
Qianghua (Huawei) requests for clarification.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) replies to comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) accepts the explanation and merging S2-2004007 into S2-2003798.
Antoine (Orange) provides r08.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r09.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r11.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 10 and replies to comments. Cannot accept r08 or r09.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 12. We cannot accept R11, R08, R09.
Sherry (Nokia) can accept r10.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide rev 13, response to Stefano comments
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) indicates Qualcomm cannot accept Rev. 13.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) response to Qualcomm's comment
Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r12
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004672

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, New Sol: Solution for UAV authentication and authorization by USS/UTM .

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Interdigital, Verizon, Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R12 of S2-2003798, merging S2-2004079 and S2-2004007. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004002

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Additional CP-based Authentication and Authorisation.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004673

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification
Runze (Huawei) provides clarifications on the question from Dimitrios.
Runze (Huawei) provides clarification to question from Guanzhou.
Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano on several questions and provides r02.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 03 enclosed
Farooq (AT&T) OK with rev 3 and agrees to the notes.
Runze (Huawei) provides r04.
Runze (Huawei) changes the solution title and provides r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004673

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Additional CP-based Authentication and Authorisation.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2004002. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004003

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Enhanced Secondary Authentication.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004674

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, plus comments
Runze (Huawei) provides r02 and answers the questions below from Stefano.
Farooq (AT&T) comments. Possibility of merger with S2-2003798 should be considered. Application level behavior description should be minimized.
Runze (Huawei) provides rationale why we want the solution a separate one in the TR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Sherry (Nokia) can accept r02 with the assumption that this solution will be merged into the solution addressed in S2-2003798 in the next meeting.
Runze (Huawei) thanks Sherry for supporting r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004674

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1 KI#2 KI#5, New Sol: Enhanced Secondary Authentication.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004003. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004166

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution for UAV Authentication and Authorization by USS/UTM . using key bootstrapping based on 3GPP credentials.

Interdigital

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted.
Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Stefano (Qualcomm) suggestion
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2004167

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution for UAV Authentication and Authorization by UTM . using UTM authorization token.

InterDigital

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefano (Qualcomm) concerns.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) replies to comments and suggests the paper to be noted.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

Solutions for KI#1

Docs:=3

8.7

S2-2004001

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1, New Sol: Support of Aerial UE function in 5G system.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000680. Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.7

S2-2003797

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1, KI#4, New Sol: UAV Identitity Allocation and Usage For Remote Identification.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004675

Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Chen (OPPO) supports Interdigital's comments and ask further questions and express concerns.
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides answers to Shabnam's questions.
Stefano (Faccin) provides rev. 01 and addresses comments.
Dan(China Mobile) comments for clarification
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide responses to Dan's comments and provide revision r02
Stefano (Qualcomm) provide rev. 03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) Ok with r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004675

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#1, KI#4, New Sol: UAV Identitity Allocation and Usage For Remote Identification.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, AT&T, Verizon

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003797. Approved

Approved

8.7

Solutions for KI#2 and KI#3

Docs:=7

8.7

S2-2003728

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#2, New Solution: Provision of UAV characteristics and issuing of Assigned ID.

OPPO

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004676

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, expresses concerns.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Chen (OPPO) provides r02, answers questions and comments.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides comments and questions.
Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification
Chen (OPPO) answers further questions and provides r03.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments and rev. 03.
Stefano (Qualcomm) corrects previous post, rev. 05 has been provided.
Chen (OPPO) provides r06 and comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004676

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#2, New Solution: Provision of UAV characteristics and issuing of Assigned ID.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003728. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2003729

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#2, New Solution: UAS flight authorization and location of network publishing server.

OPPO

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004677

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution
Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and addresses comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 03 enclosed
Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004677

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#2, New Solution: UAS flight authorization and location of network publishing server.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003729. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004079

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #2&3, New Sol: Authentication and authorization for UAV and UAVC.

CATT

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004672

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests to merge with S2-2003798
Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to merge this with S2-2003798.
Yunjing (CATT) is ok to merge with S2-2003798 and clarifies.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.7

S2-2004086

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #2, New Sol: Network Assisted Flight Path Authorization.

Samsung

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004678

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides comments, proposes merger with S2-2003798
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Yoonseon(Samsung) clarifies to Guanzhou and Stefano Faccin
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) comments and questions for clarification.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments.
Yoonseon(Samsung) replies to Chris J and Amanda Xiang.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004678

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #2, New Sol: Network Assisted Flight Path Authorization.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004086. Approved

Approved

8.7

Solutions for KI#4

Docs:=12

8.7

S2-2003730

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4, New Solution: Local broadcast (upon trigger) and direct commuincations.

OPPO

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to NOTE the paper since it does not reflect any use case addressed by SA1, nor found in the aviation community requirements, and does not address any of the key issues
Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to note the pCR.
Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Stefano (Qualcomm) statement
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2003731

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4: New Solution: Reusing Area of Interest to support UTM/USS geofencing needs.

OPPO

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004679

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution
Sherry (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper into 4244.
Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and respond to comments from Lenovo and Nokia.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) provides questions for clarification.
Chen (OPPO) provides answers to Futurewei's questions.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Sherry (Nokia) can live with r02 with the assumption of further improvement.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004679

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4: New Solution: Reusing Area of Interest to support UTM/USS geofencing needs.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003731. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2003748

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller Tracking .

Apple

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides rev. 01.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) re-expresses concerns.
Farooq (AT&T) agrees with Stefano's concerns with this proposal.
Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns on all the current revisions of the proposal, see comments.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r03 and responds to Stefano, Chris and Qianghua.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to note the document, since the revisions are not clarifying why we should focus on what are clearly application layer aspects..
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to the document and its revisions, the document was not updated according to comments to remove the content outside of the scope and question then what is left?
Stefano (Qualcomm) also objects. The paper focuses on application layer details outside the scope of SA2 and 3GPP.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2003938

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #4, New Sol: UAV/UAVC Tracking.

Samsung

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides rev. 01
Sherry (Nokia) requests clarification.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm).
Stefano (Qualcomm) adds comment and expresses concerns.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Chris J (T-Mobile USA), Stefano (Qualcomm), and Sherry (Nokia), and provides r02.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev2
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments with concern that MO-LR approach is not really suitable, more details in comments.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Chris J (T-Mobile USA), Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r03.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm) and provides r04.
Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this pCR, we don't believe it is correct use of procedure, please see comments.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson), and provides r05.
Stefano (Faccin) shares Ericsson concern and also objects.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefano (Faccin).
Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to the paper and all revisions. We do not agree the explanations provided identify necessary requirements, technically the solution assumes a specific application layer design, and we are not convinced the justifications provided for the MO-LT procedure are valid.
Sherry (Nokia) shares Qualcomm and Ericsson's concern and also objects.

Noted

8.7

S2-2004080

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAVC tracking and flight route analysis based on NWDAF.

CATT

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004680

Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions on the principle of this solution
Yunjing (CATT) clarifies
Sherry (Nokia) requests for clarification.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 and adds comments.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) questions for clarification.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments.
Yunjing (CATT) responses to Nokia.
Yunjing (CATT) responses to Futurewei.
Yunjing (CATT) responses to Qualcomm and provides r03.
Yunjing (CATT) responses to T-Mobile USA.
Shabnam (Ericsson) shared T-Mobile concerns based on current wording of the pCR and asks clarification in the comments.
Yunjing (CATT) responses to Shabnam and provides r04.
Yunjing (CATT) further clarifies and provides r05.
Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Yunjing.
Yunjing (CATT) replies to Stefano and provides rev06 (revision based on rev04 with NWDAF) and rev07 (revision based on rev05 without NWDAF).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004680

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAVC tracking and flight route analysis based on NWDAF.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2004080. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004081

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller tracking based on LCS mechanism.

CATT

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004681

Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification
Sherry (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper into 4244.
Yunjing (CATT) clarifies and provides r01.
Yunjing (CATT) responses.
Yunjing (CATT) proposes to keep S2-2004081 as a separate solution.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 02.
Yunjing (CATT) accepts rev. 02.
Sherry (Nokia) comments.
Yunjing (CATT) replies to Sherry.
Yunjing (CATT) clarifies.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004681

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#4, New Sol: UAV and UAV Controller tracking based on LCS mechanism.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004081. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004171

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Update to Solution# 1: Identification of UAVs in a target area.

Interdigital

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004682

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses concerns
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides revision 01.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments and asks clarification.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) suggest this to merge with Nokia's S2-2004244.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK to merge with Nokia's S2-2004244.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.7

S2-2004244

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution on Location Exposure to UTM/USS .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004171, to S2-2004682

Sherry (Nokia) provides r01.
Yunjing (CATT) provides comments.
Sherry (Nokia) answers.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) questions for clarification
Yunjing (CATT) proposes to keep S2-2004081 as a separate solution and comments.
Sherry (Nokia) answers to Amanda.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, adding EN on who does geofencing.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r03 and r04.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r05 and proposes merge of 2004171.
Yunjing (CATT) accepts r04.
Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r06 with ENs and an edit.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r06.
Sherry (Nokia) provides r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r07.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004682

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Solution on Location Exposure to UTM/USS .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, InterDigital

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2004244, merging S2-2004171. Approved

Approved

8.7

Solutions for KI#5

Docs:=8

8.7

S2-2003749

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #5, New Sol: UAV Authorisation revocation by UTM.

Apple

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses serious concerns and provides rev. 01.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides comments
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) expresses concerns on proceeding with this and adds comments.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Stefano and Chris and provides r02.
Stefano (Qualcomm) again expresses concerns and proposes to note the paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2004004

DISCUSSION

Agreement

KI#2, KI#5: Discussion on solution principles for KI#2 & KI#5.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) suggests the paper to be noted since it is not actionable
Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes to NOTE the discussion paper
Runze (Huawei) agrees to note the paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2004005

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #2, KI#5, New Sol: Network-Assisted UAV Authorization and Monitoring .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004683

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed, conditionally objects.
Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Runze (Huawei) cannot find r01, and ask the author to provide again.
Runze (Huawei) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo)
Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Runze and proposes to note.
Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (QC) and provides r01.
Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks for the updates and provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004683

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #2, KI#5, New Sol: Network-Assisted UAV Authorization and Monitoring .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004005. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004006

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #5, New Sol: Handling of PDU session established by UAV.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004684

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 with questions for clarification.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Hyunsook (LGE) asks a question for clarification
Hyunsook (LGE) provides comments.
Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm).
Runze (Huawei) replies to Guanzhou (Interdigital).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004684

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #5, New Sol: Handling of PDU session established by UAV.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004006. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004170

P-CR

Approval

23.754: C2 communication authorization revocation.

InterDigital

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004685

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide revision r02
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004685

P-CR

Approval

23.754: USS/UTM triggered C2 communication authorization revocation.

InterDigital

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004170. Approved

Approved

8.7

Solutions for KI#6 and KI#7

Docs:=7

8.7

S2-2003750

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV Controller and UAV association .

Apple

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) expresses serious concerns that the solution is based purely on application layer aspects, and provides rev. 01 reserving to object.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r03
Shabnam (Ericsson) we fail to understand the need for the AMF to be in the middle of UAC control change and what benefits adds. Comments further and proposes to note the document unless further clarification made.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r04 and responds to Amanda, Chris, Qianghua and Stefano.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) proposes to note the solution.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.7

S2-2004007

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI#6, New Sol: UAS authorization considering association of the UAV and UAV controller.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000682 Merged into S2-2004672

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Shabnam (Ericsson) unsure if merger proposal was accepted or not, asks some question.
Qianghua (Huawei) responds and thinks this is supposed to merge with S2-2003798
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.7

S2-2004150

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV-UAVC association control.

Samsung

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004686

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Jungshin (Samsung) replies to questions and provides r02.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) provides rev03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03
Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004686

P-CR

Approval

23.754: KI #6, New Sol: UAV-UAVC association control.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004150. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004168

P-CR

Approval

23.754: Connectivity setup for C2 communication and association between UAV and UAV-C.

InterDigital

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004687

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) Revision 01 enclosed
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) provide comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides revision 02.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev2
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.7

S2-2004687

P-CR

Approval

23.754: UAV/UAV-C initiated connectivity setup for C2 communication and association.

InterDigital

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004168. Approved

Approved

8.7

S2-2004169

P-CR

Approval

23.754: C2 communication switching for change of UAV-C.

InterDigital

Rel-17

Noted

Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) please see comments on 4168
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 01.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) comments on changes made to rev1
Shabnam (Ericsson) questions if the solution is any different compared to other solns and as description provided on PLMN level and not NF level? Propose to NOTE the pCR unless more details provided.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides Revision 02.
Stefano Faccin (Qualcomm) supports Ericsson and proposes to note.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.7

New Annex

Docs:=1

8.7

S2-2003796

P-CR

Approval

23.754: FS_ID_UAS-SA2: 'Application Layer' Security Infrastructure and Assumptions for UAS Remote Identification Security.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to note this pCR.
Steve (Huawei) Also suggests noting.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.8

Study on system enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (FS_5G_ProSe)

Docs:=112

8.8

Architecture assumption, definition

Docs:=5

8.8

S2-2004090

P-CR

Approval

23.752: TR 23.752 alignment with SA#86 outcome.

CATT, OPPO

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2003790

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Architecture Assumption update.

Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted.
Sudeep (Apple) proposes this Tdoc to be NOTED.
Toon Norp (KPN) proposes this Tdoc to be NOTED.
Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes the document to be noted
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, with understanding that there is an SA2 approved SI with SC in scope of the study.
Mehrdad (Samsung) supports r01.
Dario (Huawei) proposes to note the document.
Lars (Sony) proposes to note the document.
Sudeep (Apple) maintains the same opinion (document to be NOTED) on version r01 too.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003816

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe Discovery Architecture based on R16 V2X.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) comments.
Haris (Qualcomm) agrees with comments from CATT and proposes to note this pCR
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to CATT, QC, LGE's comment and provided r01.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) still think the pCR is not needed.
Changhong (Intel) shares view from Jianhua and propose to note this paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003934

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Add 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Definition.

ZTE

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004717

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01.
Hao Dong (ZTE) comments on r01.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Hannu (Nokia) provides r02
Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004717

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Add 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Definition.

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003934. Approved

Approved

8.8

KI update

Docs:=4

8.8

S2-2004015

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI2: Update to address compatibility between NR PC5 QoS and Uu QoS features.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000630. Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as the issue is out of scope.
LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed text does not make sense for OoC PC5 operation.
Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments..
Shabnam (Ericsson) Ericsson objects to this pCR any any revision of it. There is no justification to changing the key issue towards a specific solution.
Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed text is not correct.
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as the NOTE reads unclear.
Dario (Huawei) replies and is fine with noting the paper.
LaeYoung (LGE) gives a hug to Dario (Huawei). o==== ^___^====o
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004071

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4: Update to KI#4 to add Remote UE Authorization.

Intel

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2004214

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Key issue on support of UE-NW Relay in LTE Uu coverage for public safety.

Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, FirstNet

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004718

Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted.
Sudeep (Apple) asks questions for clarification.
Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for clarification to Guillaume
Haris (Qualcomm) answers questions
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm and objects to the proposal.
Toon Norp (KPN) asks questions for clarification.
Sudeep (Apple) follows-up with additional observations and supports MediaTek's proposal for the Tdoc to be NOTED.
Haris (Qualcomm) responds to comments
Adrian (vivo) supports the contribution.
Changhong (Intel) shares Guillaume's view and objects to this paper.
Haris (Qualcomm) responds to Mediatek
Dario (Huawei) shares MediaTek's view and objects to this paper
Toon Norp (KPN) request for further clarification
Haris (Qualcomm) responds to comments from KPN
Toon (KPN) responds to comments from Qualcomm
Changhong (Intel) kindly provides reasons for objection.
Changhong (Intel) asks to combine the two threads on this paper into this one.
Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01
Changhong (Intel) is fine with r01.
Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with r01.
Ihab (FirstNet) supports the contribution. The support for ProSe UE-NW Relay to work when Relay UE is in LTE/EPC coverage only is very important and critical for public safety during our migration process from 4G to 5G.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004718

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Key issue on support of UE-NW Relay in LTE Uu coverage for public safety.

Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, FirstNet

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004214. Approved

Approved

8.8

KI#1 (Direct Discovery)

Docs:=11

8.8

S2-2003850

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #1.

OPPO

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004719

Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for some clarification via comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) respond to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provide r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004719

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #1.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003850. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003821

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1, Sol #1 Update: Clarification on metadata.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Dongeun (Samsung) asked for clarification
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to Dongeun (Samsung).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to NOTE the paper.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to Hong (Qualcomm Inc).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm Inc) suggests to NOTE.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004272

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution 2: V2X based solution- update.

Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, ATT

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004091, to S2-2004720

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged S2-2004091.
Walter Dees (Philips) provides some comments.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02 and clarifications.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004720

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution 2: V2X based solution- update.

Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, ATT, CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004272, merging S2-2004091. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004091

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1, Sol #2: Update to remove ENs and add clarifications.

CATT

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004720

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes S2-2004091 to be merged into S2-2004272.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2003852

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_update user plane architecture.

OPPO

Rel-17

Approved

Gerald (Matrixx) comment with question for clarification.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Gerald (Matrixx).
Judy (Ericsson) agrees with Jianhua (OPPO) that CHF is not in the scope of 3852, and responded to Gerald (Matrixx).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2004016

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#1,#7, sol#18: update to support ProSe restricted discovery and event based ProSe direct discovery charging.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004721

Haris (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification and could lead to revision
Gerald (Matrixx) provided additional comments for the next revision.
Runze (Huawei) provides answers to the questions from Haris, and provides r01.
Runze (Huawei) provides r02 to address Gerald comments.
Gerald (Matrixx) provided further questions for clarification on 5G DDNWF.
Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Gerald and r03.
Haris (Qualcomm) provides r04
Runze (Huawei) thanks Haris for pointing out the issue and accepts r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004721

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#1,#7, sol#18: update to support ProSe restricted discovery and event based ProSe direct discovery charging.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2004016. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003824

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Evaluation for Solution #1: Restricted Direct Discovery.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Postponed

Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is ok with r01
Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet.
Walter (Philips) provides some comments.
Changhong (Intel) comments and asks to postpone this paper including any potential revision.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

S2-2003849

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Evaluation and conclusion for KI#1 Direct Discovery.

OPPO, CATT

Rel-17

Postponed

Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01
Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments and requests clarifications
Adrain (vivo) proposes to NOTE this paper.
Changhong (Intel) proposes to postpone this paper since the SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds vivo and Philips
LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper.
Jianhua (OPPO) OK to postpone.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.8

KI#2 (Direct Communication)

Docs:=12

8.8

S2-2003719

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#1&2, New Solution: Solution for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004722

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 by adding general and impact clauses.
Hao Dong (ZTE) provides comment.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03.
Judy (Ericsson) responds and provides r04.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05.
Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from LaeYoung (LGE).
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Hannu (Nokia).
Judy (Ericsson) responded to LaeYoung (LGE) and is fine with r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004722

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#1&2, New Solution: Solution for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003719. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003810

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#1&2, Sol#4: Update to remove EN about PC5 message type.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

Approved

Walter Dees (Philips) requests clarification.
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to question from Walter Dees (Philips).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2003946

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update regarding New Group Member Joining Procedures.

ZTE

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004723

LaeYoung (LGE) does not think the proposed change is needed.
Hao Dong responds to LaeYoung's comment.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to comment from LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Hao Dong (ZTE) is OK with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004723

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update regarding New Group Member Joining Procedures.

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003946. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003948

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1, 2 Sol #4: Update to Clarify Group Information Provision.

ZTE

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept the proposed change and proposes to NOTE this paper.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung's comment and provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r00 and r01, and asks a Q for clarification.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung's Q.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Hao Dong (ZTE) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) confirms that this pCR can be NOTED.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004092

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #2, Sol# 5: Update to resolve EN.

CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004724

LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004724

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #2, Sol# 5: Update to resolve EN.

CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004092. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003978

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution#22 updates.

Vivo

Rel-17

Had been merged into S2-2003931. Noted

Hao Dong (ZTE) comments that this paper (S2-2003978) has already been merged into S2-2003931.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003931

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1,2 Sol #22: Update to Remove ENs.

ZTE

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004725

Hao Dong (ZTE) provides r01 which merges S2-2003978 from vivo.
Changhong (Intel) provides r02.
Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004725

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #1,2 Sol #22: Update to Remove ENs.

ZTE, vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003931. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004093

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#2: Solutions evaluation and conclusion.

CATT, OPPO, Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Postponed

Changhong (Intel) asks to mark it as 'POSTPONED' since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet.
Jianhua (OPPO) asks to have some evaluation and conclusion if the solutions are relatively stable.
Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Intel as this meeting new solns are being proposed, Postpone all conclusion once TR is stable. Comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine to postponed.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

KI#3 (UE-NW Relay)

Docs:=3

8.8

S2-2003642

DISCUSSION

Agreement

Discussion on ProSe UE-to-Network relays and service continuity for public safety.

AT&T, FirstNet, Samsung

Rel-17

Noted

Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification as to how this document should be handled in view of CC#2.
James (AT&T) respond to Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification that we agree with you that it is BAU and our intention is to get a broad consensus on that.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments on proposal 4: Each objective in the SID, more so each solution does not have its own timescales. The timescales are common for the whole SID. In this respect it will be a SA2 group decision on when to conclude the SID e.g. based on existing timescales or ask for exception if so required and let SA plenary decide. We don't agree to assigning different timescales to each solution.
Ihab(FirstNet) respond to Haris(Qualcomm) concern: I believe that we are facing a unique situation with the study of layer-2 vs. layer-3 especially since layer-2 has a major dependency on RAN work and there is a slight misalignment between RAN and SA2 schedules. Since we are interested in making sure that a complete relay solution is in place in Release 17, we feel that having layer-2 and layer-3 solutions to be independent of each other at this time will help us progressing the work at least for one of the two solutions.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides some further clarification.
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments to NOTE the paper as this is ongoing work and jumping to conclusion before RAN even started its work and SA2 documents its own work is premature.
James (AT&T) add a comment in support of and in addition to related comments from FirstNet and Samsung: our proposals are aimed to facilitate both RAN and SA2 work in the spirit of the working agreements just reached for the revised SA2 SID. It is about working process and is in no way jumping into any conclusion. We want to clarify issues related to service continuity for public safety. What we are trying to do is to help to reach some clear common understanding so we can progress the solutions to support related features such as SC without risking any possibility that none of the solutions can progress and conclude in R17.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments
Changhong (Intel) supports the proposal #1 to 3 and disagrees with proposal #4. We should stop the discussion and focus on solution development at this meeting.
Wanqiang (Huawei) supports the notion of the paper.
Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments and don't prefer to take the paper to CC#2.
Deng Qiang (CATT) shares the same view as Jianhua (OPPO).
James (AT&T) accepts the comments from the Rapporteurs and agrees to note this discussion paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004201

P-CR

Approval

23.752: UE-to-Network Relay discovery and handling of PDU session parameters with CN based relay selection.

Philips International B.V.

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Wen (vivo) provides comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments and provides revision r01.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from Interdigital and proposes r02.
Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from Intel and refers to r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) please see comments on S2-2004202 on your proposal, most of them applies here as well.
Walter (Philips) responds to comments from Ericsson and proposes r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds that can live with this revision but asks to remove NID/CAGID from the final version of the paper.
Changhong (Intel) objects to this paper and any revision since his concern was not resolved in any revision.
Walter (Philips) responds to Intel's objection and provides draft revision r04.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004202

P-CR

Approval

23.752: UE-to-Network Relay discovery and handling of PDU session parameters with Remote UE based relay selection.

Philips International B.V.

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Walter Dees (Philips) responds to comments from CATT and provides revision r01.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Walter Dees (Philips) responds to Intel's comments, and provides r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) please see comments on your proposal, have concerns on the amount of assumptions made with this paper.
Walter (Philips) responds to Ericsson's comments, and provides r03.
Walter (Philips) corrected a few mistakes in r03, and provides r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and proposes to NOTE this.
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper and askes the author to provide a clean UE based solution next time.
Walter (Philips) responds to CATT's objection.
Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Walter (Philips).
Walter (Philips) responds to Ericsson's objection.
Walter (Philips) responds to CATT comments.
Walter (Philips) suggest people to take a look at draft revision r05.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

Layer-3 Relay

Docs:=28

8.8

S2-2003785

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, Sol #6: Update to L3 UE-to-Network Relay Procedure.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000870. Merged to S2-2004715

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because 4094 touches similar aspects.
Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies the status of S2-2003785.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 and suggests to fully merge into S2-2004094 based on r01.
Mehrdad (Samsung) says that S2-2003785r01 is already merged into S2-2004094.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2004020

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #6:Open issues of Solution #6.

Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000493

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Dario (Huawei) replies to comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and provides r01.
Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r02.
Deng Qiang (CATT) supports r01 and objects r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) OBJECTs to r02 and provides r03.
Dario (HW) replies and provides r03
Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Dario (HW).
Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Dario (HW) as there is a conflict on r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) accepts r03, r01, and objects to other revisions.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004726

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #6:Open issues of Solution #6.

Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004020. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004094

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to clarify non-IP and LI aspects.

CATT, LG Electronics, Qualcomm Incorporated(?)

Rel-17

Confirm Sources!. R09 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003785, to S2-2004715.

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01.
Tyler Hawbaker (OTD) provides question for clarification.
Mehrdad (Samsung) supports this updated Sol based on r01. Part of S2-2003785 merged into S2-2004094.
Deng Qiang (CATT) answers the question and provides r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc) provides r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04.
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on R04.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc)'s comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital).
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.).
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to go with r03.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) object r03 and proposes a way forward.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06 and comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r07 and comments with Ericsson cosigning.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r08.
Toon Norp (KPN) still has a question on LI aspects.
Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Toon Norp (KPN).
Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Toon Norp (KPN).
Toon Norp (KPN) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Toon Norp (KPN).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Toon (KPN) responds to Hong (Qualcomm).
Toon Norp (KPN) responds to Hong (Qualcomm).
Ihab (FirstNet) responds to comments regarding Public Safety LI requirements. We are expecting that the LI for public safety users to be the same as the requirements for commercial users.
Haris (Qualcomm) asks question to Toon
Toon (KPN) answers to Haris
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) only accepts r05 and object all other versions.
Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital).
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004715

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to clarify non-IP and LI aspects.

CATT, LG Electronics, Samsung, Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004094_R09, merging S2-2003785. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004282

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution to support end-to-end security for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Ericsson, Samsung

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004034, to S2-2004727

Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification.
Guillaume (MediaTek) questions the proposal and provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responses to Myungjune (LGE).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provide r02.
Myungjune (LGE) provides comment.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc) responds to Myungjune (LGE).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Myungjune (LGE).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r03.
Lars (Sony) provides comment
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r04
Haris (Qualcomm) comments to r04
Laurent (Nokia): provides comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Answering to Lars
Lars (Sony): provides comments
Lars (Sony): provides comments Answering to Laurent
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Qualcomm.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments and provides r05
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Lars (Sony).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004727

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution to support end-to-end security for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

Qualcomm Incorporated, AT&T, Ericsson, Samsung, Nokia

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2004282, merging S2-2004034. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004034

P-CR

Approval

23.752: New Solution Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay with support of N3IWF.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004727

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes S2-2004034 to be merged into S2-2004282.
Guillaume (MediaTek) requests this document to be noted or merged with S2-2004282.
Mehrdad (Samsung) also suggests to merge this into S2-2004282.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments that this paper has already been merged into S2-2004282r02.
Hannu (Nokia) acknowledges the proposal to merge this paper to S2-2004282r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) agrees the proposed merge.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2004289

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New solution to support end-to-end QoS for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004728

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment.
Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions for clarification.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01 and responds to Dengqiang (CATT) and Jianhua (OPPO).
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment on original version and r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung).
Jianhua asks another question and provide r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Jianhua.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004728

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New solution to support end-to-end QoS for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004289. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003945

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004729

Changhong (Intel) proposes to mark this paper as 'Merged into S2-2004289' and asks the author to provide a revision in the thread of S2-2004289 to show the missing aspects.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Intel.
Toon (KPN) asks for clarification.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to KPN and provide r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Changhong (Intel) still proposes to mark this paper either as 'Merged into S2-2004289' or 'NOTED'.
Changhong (Intel) can live with r01 after offline talk with Jianhua.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004729

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003945. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003786

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS handling for Remote UE.

Samsung

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment on Remote UE QoS report and QNC.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question for clarification.
Jianhua (OPPO) comments on how to work for the solution.
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT, OPPO, LG
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01.
Adrian (vivo) comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to remove step 5.
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides r04
LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions and proposes to NOTE this paper.
Mehrdad (Samsung) addresses LG's concern and provides r05.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Mehrdad provides r06 addressing Intel's request.
Mehrdad provides r07 with minor alignment with S2-2004094 wording .
Mehrdad (Samsung) provided r06 and r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because r06/r07 can be covered by S2-2004289 or S2-2003945.
Mehrdad (Samsung) asks LG to reconsider the position based on r07.
LaeYoung (LGE) keeps her position and thinks procedure can be added to the solution from S2-2004289 in the next meeting.
Mehrdad (Samsung) accepts LG's position and OK to NOTE this PCR for now.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides hug to Mehrdad (Samsung). :)
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004291

P-CR

Approval

23.752: URSP enhancements to support UE-to-Network Relay solutions.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004730

Changhong (Intel) provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004730

P-CR

Approval

23.752: URSP enhancements to support UE-to-Network Relay solutions.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004291. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004032

P-CR

Approval

23.752: New Solution Enhancing URSP rule to determine Relay UE PDU session parameters.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004731

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment.
Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides comment.
Changhong (Intel) provides r01.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT).
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) and agrees.
Hannu (Nokia) agrees the changes in r01 and adds EN in r02.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is ok with r02.
Changhong (Intel) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) agrees with r03.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is OK with r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004731

P-CR

Approval

23.752: New Solution Enhancing URSP rule to determine Relay UE PDU session parameters.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004032. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003853

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Update for solution 6-Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

Noted

Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides R01.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments and objects r02.
Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments to r02.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds and providesr03.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r04.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05
Walter (Philips) comments on r05 and provides r06
Jianhua (OPPO) is fine with r06
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r06
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) OBJECTs to all revisions, and propose to NOTE.
Jianhua asks Hong (Qualcomm) whether OK with r02.
Hong (Qualcomm) maintains the objection.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004025

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution on service continuity for Layer-3 based UE-to-Network Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

Noted

Changhong (Intel) provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper.
Jianhua(OPPO) responds and provides r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) still doesn't understand what the proposal is and proposes to NOTE this paper.
Changhong (Intel) shares concern from LaeYoung, marking it as 'NOTED' is also OK.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LG and Intel, and provides r03
LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions and proposes to NOTE this paper.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung (LGE).
LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Jianhua (OPPO).
Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and asks questions.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LG and Fraunhofer HHI, and provide r05
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions because this pCR does not solve service continuity at all, the proposal in r00 to r04 does not work and the proposal in r05 is unclear.
Jianhua (OPPO) accepts LaeYoung (LGE) comment.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003839

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Secondary Authentication for a Remote UE.

LG Electronics, LG Uplus

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004732

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment on questioning the necessity of secondary authentication for Remote UE.
Myungjune (LGE) answers Deng Qiang (CATT) and clarifies necessity of secondary authentcation.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Myungjune (LGE) answers Deng Qiang (CATT).
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Myungjune (LGE) respondes to Xiaoyan (InterDigital).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) answers to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.).
Shabnam (Ericsson) asks to make this optional and still considering why needed? Is it for L3 relay only or generally needed for UE to nwk Relay?
Myungjune (LGE) answers to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides r02.
Changhong (Intel) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004732

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Secondary Authentication for a Remote UE.

LG Electronics, LG Uplus

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003839. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004033

P-CR

Approval

23.752: New Solution for UE-to-Network Relay authorization.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Postponed

Jianhua(OPPO) comments on out of coverage case
Jianhua(OPPO) comments and provides r01.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Judy (Ericsson) ask question for clarification.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Changhong.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Jianhua and provides r01.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Judy (Ericsson).
Deng Qiang (CATT) shares the same view as Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) objects to this pCR and proposes to continue to work offline.
Changhong (Intel) shares same concern with Judy (Ericsson) and also objects to this paper and any revision.
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

S2-2003819

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Support for UE-to-Network Relay mobility state.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment.
Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02.
Toon Norp (KPN) agrees with comments from LGE and CATT.
Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note this document.
Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) responds CATT, LGE, KPN, Mediatek's comments and it's fine with r02.
Changhong (Intel) also proposes to NOTE this paper.
Toon Norp (KPN) is fine with adding r02 as a potential solution.
Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends once again this be noted.
Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies to Intel, Mediatek' comments and provide r03
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper.
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Interdigital.
Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003944

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Sol: MT data delivery for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

Noted

Wen (vivo) provides the comments:
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks for clarification.
Toon Norp (KPN) request clarification on buffering of DL data:
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) requests clarification regarding the assumption on the PC5 link state.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question.
Jianhua (OPPO) OK to note it.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003851

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #19.

OPPO

Rel-17

Noted

Changhong (Intel) comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responses to Changhong (Intel) and further comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) is also wondering the points raised by Changhong (Intel) and Hong (Qualcomm).
Jianhua(OPPO) responds and provides r01
Changhong (Intel) is not fully convinced with answers from Jianhua and provides r02.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Changhong (Intel) and would like stick to r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) agrees to r02, and objects other revisions.
Changhong (Intel) is also OK with Hong's objection.
Jianhua responds Hong.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2003820

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Solution #X: L3 UE-to-Network Relay discovery and connection establishment.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004733

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Jianhua(OPPO) asks question for clarification.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comment.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to CATT, OPPO and Samsung, and provides r01.
Changhong (Intel) comments and provides r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and propose to NOTE the paper.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments and is ok with r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments and provides r03.
Changhong (Intel) provides r04.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies LaeYoung (LGE)' comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05 based on LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Walter Dees (Philips) provides some comments and proposes r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004733

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Solution #X: L3 UE-to-Network Relay discovery and connection establishment.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003820. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003823

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Evaluation for Solution #6: Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Postponed

Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI is not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

Layer-2 Relay

Docs:=12

8.8

S2-2004019

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to address editor's notes.

Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000494

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Dario (Huawei) replies to comments with r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments and provides r02.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides r03.
Dario (Huawei) provides r04
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) accepts r02, r03, and objects to other revisions.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) can live with r05 and object any versions to force NW relay to be in Connected state.
Deng Qiang (CATT) supports r02, r03, and objects to other revisions and responds to Xiaoyan (Interdigital).
Jianhua (OPPO) can only accept r03
Dario (HW) we prefer r05, but we can live with r03 and r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004734

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to address editor's notes.

Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004019. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003977

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution#7 updates, to keep CM_CONNECTED.

Vivo

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004735

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes be merged into S2-2004019.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Wen (vivo) responds to the comments from Xiaoyan and Deng Qiang .
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments .
Wen (vivo) responds to the comments from Hong and provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Wen (vivo) is ok with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004735

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution#7 updates, to keep CM_CONNECTED.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003977. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004095

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Consideration on network authorization and paging for Remote UE.

CATT

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004736

Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r01
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004736

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Consideration on network authorization and paging for Remote UE.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004095. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004290

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Additional considerations for Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay solution.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Changhong (Intel) provides r01.
Dario (Huawei) comments and provides r02.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comment the control plane stack should be aligned with S2-2004019.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) objects to r01 and r02.
Dario (HW) replies to Deng Qiang proposing to select r02 which does not modify the protocol stack.
Dario (HW) objects to r0.
Deng Qiang (CATT) objects r01 and r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004017

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Solution for service continuity via UE-to-Network Relay.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000492. To handle at CC#4. R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004713.

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) OBJECTs to all revisions, and propose to NOTE.
Shabnam (Ericsson) As already commented, this is RAN scope and as such to be discussed, if RAN groups want to, within RAN study. Objects to the pCR and all revisions.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm, Ericsson and requests that all TDocs be treated fairly.
Deng Qiang (CATT) kindly asks the proponents to provide revisions.
Dario (Huawei) shows that the objection by Qualcomm and Ericsson is unfounded.
Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Dario (Huawei).
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02.
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Qualcomm.
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Shabnam (Ericsson) unfortunately I see no reason to capture this in SA2 TR, if you look at the impacts parts it is clear that RAN WGs must work on this first. RAN has study item dedicated for this work, so let them progress/start.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004713

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3, New Solution for service continuity via UE-to-Network Relay.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004017_R07. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004160

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Solution for Key Issue 3 - Handover of an L2 UE-NW Relay with Remote UE(s) having an active indirect connection.

Motorola Mobility, Lenovo

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) commented the issue is not in Rel-17 scope.
Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note the contribution.
Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the pCR and all its potential revisions since it has no SA2 impacts and also even in RAN will not standardise any of this since HO decision is internal behaviour of the RAN node
Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Qualcomm, Oppo and CATT and provides r01 to address objections raised
Haris (Qualcomm) responds and objects to r01 as well
Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Haris (Qualcomm)
Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all revision of the pCR, it is in RAN scope and not SA2.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004018

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI3: New Sol: Authorization of UE-to-Network Relay UE and Remote UE.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004737

Jianhua(OPPO) comments and asks questions for clarification.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
LiMeng (Huawei) provides answers.
Judy (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments.
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01 and answers the questions.
Judy (Ericsson) asks further questions how the association between the remote UE(s) and relay UE is built.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) clarifies the questions from Judy.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) propose to NOTE or POSTPONE.
Judy (Ericsson) also proposes to POSTPONE.
Deng Qiang (CATT) can live with r01 by removing 'L3 UE-to-Network Relay'.
Dario (HW) replies to E/// and is OK with Deng Qiang's proposal (go with r01 and remove 'L3 UE-to-Network Relay').
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004737

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI3: New Sol: Authorization of UE-to-Network Relay UE and Remote UE.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Mediatek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004018. Approved

Approved

8.8

KI#4 (UE-UE Relay)

Docs:=2

8.8

S2-2003947

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4, New Sol: QoS control for UE-to-UE Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004738

Changhong (Intel) provides r01.
Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004738

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4, New Sol: QoS control for UE-to-UE Relay.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003947. Approved

Approved

8.8

Layer-3 Relay

Docs:=4

8.8

S2-2003818

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #10 Update: Support of ProSe Service discovery and QoS flow when using Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004739

Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments on QoS handling part.
Adrian (Vivo) comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds OPPO, VIVO's comments.
Adrian (vivo) responds Interdigital comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) Adrian (vivo)'s comments and provides r01.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies Hong's Comments and provide r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004739

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #10 Update: Support of ProSe Service discovery and QoS flow when using Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003818. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003718

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Supporting Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004740

Jianhua(OPPO) asks question for clarification.
Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides responses and r01.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan (IDCC).
Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) responds to Hong (Qualcomm Inc.).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital).
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004740

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Supporting Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003718. Approved

Approved

8.8

Layer-2 Relay

Docs:=8

8.8

S2-2003817

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #9 Update: Support of Privacy when using UE-to-UE Relay.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004741

Jianhua(OPPO) comments and asks questions
Adrian(vivo) asks a question.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) responds to OPPO and VIVO's comments and provided r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies Hong (Qualcomm Inc.)'s comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004741

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #9 Update: Support of Privacy when using UE-to-UE Relay.

Interdigital

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003817. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004022

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4, Sol#9:Update for Connection establishment via UE-to-UE Layer-2 Relay.

Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Approved

Hong Cheng (Qualcomm) comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) supports this contribution.
LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Hong (Qualcomm).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2003634

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #11: Update to Stateful UE-to-UE Relay to include a Layer-2 communication option.

Intel

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004742

Jianhua(OPPO) comments no Direction field is need for L2 format and the protocol for L2 relay needs to be determined by RAN2.
Saso (Intel) provides r01.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r01
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Haris (Qualcomm)
Haris (Qualcomm) clarifies the request and provides r02
Saso (Intel) is OK with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004742

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, Sol #11: Update to Stateful UE-to-UE Relay to include a Layer-2 communication option.

Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003634. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004021

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, New Sol: Network-Assisted UE-to-UE Relay Discovery and Selection.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004743

Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments on the feasibility of the solution and suggests not to document the solution.
Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as EPC level-like discovery is out of scope.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments and proposes to note this pCR
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments.
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments.
Runze (Huawei) disagrees the solution is out of scope.
Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Xiaoyan's comment.
Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Mehrdad's comment and provides r02.
Runze (Huawei) provides answers to Jianhua's comment.
Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Runze (Huawei) and proposes to NOTED this paper.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments and indicates that even r02 is not ready for approval
Runze (Huawei) replies to Haris, addresses the comments from Haris and provides r03.
Runze (Huawei) cannot agree the observation from Dengqiang that the SID scope excludes other discovery mechanism than direct discovery.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004743

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #4, New Sol: Network-Assisted UE-to-UE Relay Discovery and Selection.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004021. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003822

P-CR

Approval

23.752: Evaluation for Solution 9: Connection establishment via UE-to-UE Layer-2 Relay.

Interdigital Inc.

Rel-17

Postponed

Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper since this SI are not ready for evaluation and conclusion yet.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) propose to NOTE that paper.
Jianhua (OPPO) propose all evaluation for Relay related KIs (KI#3 and KI#4)
Hannu comments on noting or postponing clause 7 evaluations and clause 8 conclusions in this meeting.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

KI#5 (Path selection)

Docs:=6

8.8

S2-2004023

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI5: Sol.12: Update to address editor's notes .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004744

Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge S2-2004023 into S2-2003784.
Mehrdad (Samsung) proposes to either NOTE S2-2004023 or change the status to Merged, as already merged into S2-2003784.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (HW) confirm 4023 was merged into 3784.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2003784

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection.

Samsung

Rel-17

R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004023, S2-2003834, to S2-2004744 and S2-2003836 and S2-2003834, to S2-2004744

Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01.
Adrian (vivo) comments.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r02 proposing to merge S2-2003834
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r02.
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments to r02.
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Vivo and Interl
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Vivo and Intel.
Dimitris (Lenovo) requests to clarify the 'Type of Service' in Traffic Descriptors
Judy (Ericsson) comments questioning the benefit of QNC status in path selection policy.
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Lenovo and Ericsson. Also clarifies that QNC usage is already part of the TR since Incheon.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides further update to Ericsson
Dario (Huawei) provides r03
Dimitris (Lenovo) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung)
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Mehrdad (Samsung).
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r04.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r06.
Toon Norp (KPN) requests for clarification.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r07.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r08.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r09.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r09.
Krisztian (Apple): we are fine to proceed with r08.
Changhong (Intel) doesn't agree with the principle of this solution changing UE Policy like this but will not object to this paper in order to appreciate the rounds of revision and merging work.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004744

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection.

Samsung, Huawei, HiSilicon, Apple

Rel-17

Revision_R08 of S2-2003784, merging S2-2004023 S2-2003834 and S2-2003836. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003834

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #5, KI#6, New Sol: Policy generation for direct communication Prose Path selection and switching.

Apple

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004744

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes this paper to be merged into S2-2003784.
LaeYoung (LGE) has same view with Deng Qiang (CATT) and proposes this paper to be merged into S2-2003784.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge this into S2-2003784.
Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. .
Krisztian (Apple) provided S2-2003784r02 on the relevant thread.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Hongkun.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc) comments and suggest to merge this into existing sol#12 (i.e. clause 6.12).
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to either NOTE this or change the status to 'Merged', as already merged into S2-2003784.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Mark it as 'Merged into S2-2003784'.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2003836

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #5, KI#6, New Sol: Functional entities and triggers for initiating policy update for ProSe path selection and switching.

Apple

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004744

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment and question.
Changhong (Intel) comments and strongly proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003784.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because she does not see any value to have this solution as separate from the solution in S2-2003784.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to either NOTE this or change the status to 'Merged', as already merged into S2-2003784.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Mark it as 'Merged into S2-2003784'.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

S2-2003906

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#5, New Sol: Policy based path selection.

LG Electronics, SK Telecom, LG Uplus

Rel-17

Noted

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment.
LaeYoung (LGE) answers Q from Deng Qiang (CATT).
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment to r01 from Deng Qiang (CATT).
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge this into S2-2003784.
LaeYoung (LGE) prefers to keep this solution separate because how to check QoS fulfillment is different in this solution and S2-2003784.
Mehrdad (Samsung) question for clarification.
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Mehrdad (Samsung).
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments and propose to NOTE the paper.
Changhong (Intel) shares views from Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides clarification. Samsung is OK with r04.
Dimitris (Lenovo) shares view with Qualcomm and Intel
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Mehrdad (Samsung).
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Changhong (Intel) replies to LaeYoung's comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Changhong (Intel).
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Intel and LG
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Changhong (Intel) provides comments.
Mehrdad replies to Changhong (Intel) and LaeYoung (LGE).
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine to NOTE this paper. (self-hugging :))
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

KI#7 (Charging)

Docs:=8

8.8

S2-2003573

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#7 Sol#13: Update to Charging reporting for PC5 Direct Communication .

NEC

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004745

Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments and confirmed the implications on CHF.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides comments.
Judy (Ericsson) ask question for clarification.
Linghang (NEC) responds to Gerald, Hong and Judy, and provides r01.
Linghang (NEC) responds to Hong.
Linghang (NEC) provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004745

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#7 Sol#13: Update to Charging reporting for PC5 Direct Communication .

NEC

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003573. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003789

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #7: Sol #13&15: Update to clarify the reported info for PC5.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004746

Toon Norp (KPN) asks for clarification on Remote ID
Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments and a question for clarification.
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Gerald (Matrixx) and Toon Norp (KPN).
Toon Norp (KPN) request a revision.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 to address comments from Toon Norp (KPN).
Toon Norp (KPN) provides further comments.
Toon Norp (KPN) provides r02 to address KPN comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) thanks Toon Norp (KPN) for providing r02 and is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004746

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI #7: Sol #13&15: Update to clarify the reported info for PC5.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003789. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003855

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Solution update for solution #14.

OPPO

Rel-17

Approved

Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments
Judy (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification.
Jianhua(OPPO) responds Ericsson and Matrixx.
Gerald (Matrixx) provided r01 for clarification.
Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) is OK with r0, objects to r01, and comments.
Jianhua is OK with r0, i.e. the original version.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.8

S2-2004292

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#7 New Solution: Charging support for 5G ProSe over U-plane.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida,

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004747

Gerald (Matrixx) provide comments and suggestions for the revision.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01.
Gerald (Matrixx) supports the revision.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004747

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#7 New Solution: Charging support for 5G ProSe over U-plane.

Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida,

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004292. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004039

P-CR

Approval

23.752: ProSe_Evaluation and conclusion for KI#7.

OPPO, CATT

Rel-17

Postponed

Linghang (NEC) provides comment and proposes to NOTE this pCR.
Adrian (vivo) proposes to NOTE this pCR.
Changhong (Intel) proposes to POSTPONE this pCR since the SI is not ready to be evaluated.
Hannu (Nokia) comments.
Adrian (vivo) responds to Nokia.
Gerald (Matrixx) with comment.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.8

KI#8 (Service authorization)

Docs:=5

8.8

S2-2004072

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3 and 8, New Solution: Generic Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay service.

Intel

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004748

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Changhong (Intel) replies to Qiang's comment and provides r02.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask for clarification for R02 on the Remote UE retrieve authorization policy and parameters via NW relay.
Changhong (Intel) replies to Xiaoyan's comment and provides r03.
Jianhua(OPPO) provides r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004748

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#3 and 8, New Solution: Generic Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay service.

Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2004072. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2004073

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4 and 8, New Solution: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service.

Intel

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003976, to S2-2004749

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment.
Changhong (Intel) replies to Qiang's comment and provides r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004749

P-CR

Approval

23.752: KI#4 and 8, New Solution: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service.

Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004073, merging S2-2003976. Approved

Approved

8.8

S2-2003976

P-CR

Approval

23.752: New Solution on Service Authorization, Provisioning for UE-to-UE relay.

Vivo

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004749

Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes it to be merged into S2-2004073.
Wen (vivo) replies to the comments from Deng Qiang
Changhong (Intel) is OK to mark it as 'Merged into S2-2004073' and Comments.
Wen (vivo) replies:
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.8

LS out

Docs:=4

8.8

S2-2003856

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] LS on Situation of UE-to-Network Relay and UE-to-UE Relay

OPPO

Rel-17

Postponed

Adrian (vivo) proposes to NOTE this draft LS out.
LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this draft LS out.
Changhong (Intel) also proposes to NOTE this draft LS out.
Jianhua (OPPO) responds .vivo's comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) respond to Changhong and LaeYoung
Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS and provides comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) OK to postpone..
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.8

S2-2004053

DISCUSSION

Agreement

FS_5G_ProSe: Discussion on Relay Security.

MediaTek Inc., Huawei, HiSilicon, Sony, Philips, LG Electronics

Rel-17

Noted

Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to approval of this document since the Discussion analysis and Conclusions are outside of SA2 scope.
Guillaume (MediaTek) is surprised by the objection considering Ericsson has a proposal intended to address the security flaws exposed by this document.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees Ericsson's comments that This document goes beyond SA2 scope.
Toon Norp (KPN) disagrees with Shabnam's comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to MediaTek via comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.8

S2-2004054

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] LS on Security Requirements for Sidelink/PC5 Relays

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004750

Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02.
Haris (Qualcomm) provides r03
Guillaume (MediaTek): r03 is ok
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Changhong (Intel): r03 looks good.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.8

S2-2004750

LS OUT

Approval

LS on Security Requirements for Sidelink/PC5 Relays

SA WG2

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004054. Approved

Approved

8.9

Study on architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (FS_5MBS)

Docs:=104

8.9

Key Issue #1 - Architecture 1

Docs:=13

8.9

S2-2003702

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1, Sol#3: Update to add ENs.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Noted

Thomas Belling (Nokia) objects to the contribution
Dario (Huawei) objects to the contribution
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and Thomas (Nokia) and OK to note the paper.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.9

S2-2003964

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1 Sol.3: Resolving multiple SMFs and UPFs issue .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004707

Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185
Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification.
LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Xiaoyan (CATT).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with the proposal from Thomas (i.e., merging S2-2003964 into S2-2004185), as S2-2004185 reflects the content of S2-2003964
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2003965

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI1: Update to Solution #3: Add support for UE leaving MBS.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004699.

Thomas (Nokia) provides r01.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02.
zhendong (ZTE) provides question for clarification
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 and objects against r02
Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback.
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision r05.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Fenqin
He suggest working on another revision until Friday .
Thomas (Nokia) provides r07
Thomas (Nokia) provides feedback to Fenqin.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and accept r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenquin.
Hans (Ericsson) replies to Fenquin.
Fenqin(Huawei) provide feedback.
Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin about unclarities in the latest rev.
Fenqin(Huawei) Provides feedback
Hans (Ericsson) is okey with r05. Objects to all other revisions.
Should 3965 be brought up in CC#4, I'm okey trying an update of the latest version.
Thomas (Nokia) supports bringing that up in the cc.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004699

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI1: Update to Solution #3: Add support for UE leaving MBS.

Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003965_R07. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004063

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Update to Solution 3: Integrated Multicast and Unicast Transport.

China Mobile

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004707

Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185
Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments proposes to merge this document (to 4185 or others)
Andy Bennett (Vice Chair) I see two proposals to merge this with 4185. Is that an agreeable way forward for China Mobile?
Aihua (China Mobile) replies, It is acceptiable for us to have this merging suggestion.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2004185

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to address editor´s notes.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R15 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004063, S2-2004219, S2-2004221 and S2-2003964, to S2-2004707.

Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r01 as an attempt to merge S2-2004185 with S2-2003964, S2-2004063, S2-2004219, and S2-2004221
Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a question on its corresponding architecture.
Judy (Ericsson) asks question on UDR storage of SMF2 for MBS context.
Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a further question for clarification.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against r02 and suggest staying with r01.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification on r02.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r03.
Dario (Huawei) provides r04.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r05 which adds changes from r03 to r04.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides questions and comments.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r06 and clarification for the r06.
Thomas (Nokia) answers to Chunshan and suggests keeping Rel-5
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r07 based on r05
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Dario and providers rev8
Thomas(Nokia) objects to r03, r05, r06 and r07
Thomas (Nokia) answers to questions of Youngkyo
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) can live with r08 and provides comments.
LiMeng (Huawei) answer the questions from Thomas.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments
Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r09 and replies to Youngkyo
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r09
Thomas(Nokia) replies to LiMeng
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides r10
Thomas (Nokia) is fine with r10
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r10
LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Thomas (Nokia) and provides r11
LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Miguel
Judy (Ericsson) asks question for clarification.
LiMeng (Huawei) answers to Judy (Ericsson).
Thomas(Nokia) replies to Judy.
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r12.
Thomas (Nokia) prefers rev10 and answers to LiMeng (Huawei)
Thomas suggest to work on a further revision until Friday
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) hopes we can all live with one of the revisions and not bring this to CC#4. Qualcomm can live with r10,r11,r12.
Thomas (Nokia) provides a rev13.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) supports r13
LiMeng (Huawei) provides a rev14.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Thomas (Nokia) objects to r14
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes to approve r13
LiMeng (Huawei) asks Thomas (Nokia) to read r14 again.
LiMeng (Huawei) can only accept r07, r14 and object the rest.
Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with either r13 or r14.
Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with either r13 or r14, corrects typo in previous email.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides offline agreement on way forward for 4185, thanks Nokia and Huawei for working out a compromise.
Thomas (Nokia) suggest handling this in the cc. Offline an agreement was reached.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004707

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to address editor's notes.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HI Silicon, China Mobile

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004185_R15, merging S2-2004063, S2-2004219, S2-2004221 and S2-2003964. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004219

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution 3 editor's notes removals.

Qualcomm Incororporated

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004707

Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) comments as long as S2-2004185r09 (or minor modifications) is agreeable, we are ok merging this one to 4185.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2004221

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution 3: examples of transport activation and service layer interaction.

Qualcomm Incororporated

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004707

Thomas Belling (Nokia) provides r01 with comments and suggest merging into S2-2004185
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) comments as long as S2-2004185r09 (or minor modifications) is agreeable, we are ok merging this one to 4185.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2003967

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1 and KI#7: New Sol: MBS Session Management in IPTV.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Noted

Judy (Ericsson) asks question.
LiMeng (Huawei) answers question from Judy and provides r01.
Chunshan (Tencent) asks for clarification.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
Thomas (Nokia provides r03
zhendong (ZTE) provides the question for clarification
Dario (Huawei) replies to Zhendong
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) objects to any revision of this pCR despite revision being provided. The proposal makes certain assumptions which make the proposal more or less useless with added complexity to the system. Ericsson believes the focus of IPTV in 5MBS study should be the 'modern' IPTV (e.g. DVB Multicast ABR) rather than the 'legacy' IPTV.
LiMeng (Huawei) replies, suggests to go with r02 proposed by Ericsson and is fine also with r03.
Judy (Ericsson) sustains objection to any revision of this pCR.
LiMeng (Huawei) requests to discuss the document in CC on Friday.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.9

S2-2004062

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Dynamic multicast/broadcast transmission.

China Mobile, Huawei

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004489

Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification.
Thomas (Nokia) asks questions for clarification and comments
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments, wonders if the intention is not already covered by existing solutions (e.g. solution 3) and in that case proposes this document be noted.
Aihua (China Mobile) provides r01.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) suggests this contribution be NOTED
Thomas (Nokia) suggests this contribution be NOTED
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02.
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Zhendong (ZTE) comments and provides r03.
Thomas (Nokia) comments.
Judy (Ericsson) comments.
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Judy (Ericsson).
Aihua(China Mobile) provides r04 to address comments raised.
Thomas(Nokia) is fine with r04
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r04
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Aihua(China Mobile) and Xiaoyan (CATT) with question for clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004489

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Dynamic multicast/broadcast transmission.

China Mobile, Huawei, CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2004062. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004279

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, new Solution Integrated Multicast and Unicast Transport with multicast distribution tree established by RAN nodes.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Noted

Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to . Xiaoyan
Thomas (Nokia) answers to Miguel.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) understood, hopes we can move forward with 4185 and note this one
Thomas (Nokia) requests to Note this contribution, as proposal were added to solution 3 via S2-2004185
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.9

Key Issue #1 - Architecture 2

Docs:=8

8.9

S2-2003679

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #2: Solution 2 update.

Ericsson

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004700.

Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification.
Jianhua( OPPO) provide comments. .
Thomas (Nokia) provides r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02.
Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. .
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r03 and comments to be clarified.
Hans (Ericsson) provides r04 based on r01 from Thomas and r02 from Zhenhua.
Hans (Ericsson) provides some answers.
Thomas (Nokia) provides comments
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05
Hans (Ericsson) provide r06 (based on r05) .
Hans (Ericsson) provide response to Thomas.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) prefers r06. Can live with r05 provided by LiMeng.
Fenqin (Huawei) ask some question .
Fenqin (Huawei) ask same treatment of this contribution as 3965.
Hans (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin.
Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback. .
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004700

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #2: Solution 2 update.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003679_R06. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004102

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #4: Update to solution 4.

Vivo

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004491

Hans (Ericsson) provides comments.
Thomas (Nokia) provides comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies Hans (Ericsson).
Zhenhua (vivo) replies Thomas (Nokia).
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to LaeYoung (LGE).
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 and replies to LaeYoung (LGE).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004491

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, Sol #4: Update to solution 4.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004102. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003901

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update on MBS Service initiation procedure.

Samsung

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004492

Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification.
Youngkyo (Samsung) replies to the questions and corresponding revision r02.
Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification.
Thomas (Nokia) previously provided revision r01 and now provides r03
Youngkyo(Samsung) provide further revision r04
Thomas (Nokia) can accept r04
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides answer to the comments from Hans(Ericsson).
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004492

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update on MBS Service initiation procedure.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003901. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003960

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI1, new solution Multicast MBS Session establishment linked with unicast PDU session.

ZTE

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004493

Xiaoyan (CATT) requests for clarification.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification
Thomas (Nokia) provides rev1
LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a question for understanding
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response and r02
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides further question/comment.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r03
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Thomas (Nokia) provides r04
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and r05
zhendong (ZTE) provides r06
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) is fine with r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004493

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI1, new solution Multicast MBS Session establishment linked with unicast PDU session.

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003960. Approved

Approved

8.9

Key Issue #1 - Architecture agnostic

Docs:=12

8.9

S2-2003680

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Xn Handover of MB Sessions .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004494

Thomas (Nokia) provides r01.
Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for clarification
Hans (Ericsson) replies and provides r02.
LiMeng (Huawei) asks question for clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) responds to LiMeng's questions.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004494

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Xn Handover of MB Sessions .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003680. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003681

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: N2 Handover of MB Sessions .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004490

Thomas (Nokia) provides r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge with S2-2003680 and draw a highlighted signalling flow as well as describe the enhancement of the solution.
Hans (Ericsson) provides a r02.
LiMeng (Huawei) provides a r03 and asks question for clarification.
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) okey with r04.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004490

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: N2 Handover of MB Sessions .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003681. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003857

P-CR

Approval

23.757: MBS_Solution for session deactivation and activation.

OPPO

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004495

Thomas (Nokia) provides r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02.
Jianhua(OPPO) answers the questions and provide r03.
Saad (interdigital) provide comments on r03.
Thomas(Nokia) provide r0.
Thomas(Nokia) provide r04.
Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments by a revision r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004495

P-CR

Approval

23.757: MBS_Solution for session deactivation and activation.

OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003857. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003986

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS Multicast UE Context Activation and MBS Session Management without UE IP address .

Tencent

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004496

Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions.
Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to OPPO questions.
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments. Clarifications/update of solution needed.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01.
Thomas (Nokia) asks questions for clarification..
Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Nokia.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides some question for clarification.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03.
Chunshan (Tencent) object r03.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r04.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and ask some question for clarification.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r05 and clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004496

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS Multicast UE Context Activation and MBS Session Management without using UE IP address .

Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003986. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004105

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Multicast session leg addition due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004497

Dario (Huawei) asks for clarifications.
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Dario (Huawei).
Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01 and replies to Hans (Ericsson).
Zhenhua (vivo) provide r02.
Dario (Huawei) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004497

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: Multicast session leg addition due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004105. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004176

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS session joining via PDU session establishment and modification procedures.

CATT

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004498

Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004498

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #1, New Sol: MBS session joining via PDU session establishment and modification procedures.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004176. Approved

Approved

8.9

Key Issue #2

Docs:=5

8.9

S2-2004177

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #2, Sol #1: Update to clarify service levels.

CATT

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004708.

Shabnam (Ericsson) Proposes to NOTE or merge the relevant content to revision of S2-2004104, since the two proposals are partially contradictory.
Dario (Huawei) Support Ericsson in noting this and discussing 4104.
zhendong (ZTE) provides comments
Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with merging S2-2004177 to S2-2004104, and have done it by providing S2-2004104r04.
Thomas(Nokia) is merging contents of S2-2004295 to S2-2004104 by providing r06. Thomas also provided r05 but asks to ignore it.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic)
Thomas (Nokia) proposes to consider this document merged into 4104 and get an uncontroversial version of 4104 (without service continuity) agreed at Friday CC.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2004277

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#2, sol 1, update the solution to fix the EN.

ZTE

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004708.

Dario (Huawei) proposes to note this and discuss 4104
David (Samsung) supports Huawei's proposal
zhendong (ZTE), this paper can be marked as merged into 4104
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic)
Thomas (Nokia) proposes to consider this document merged into 4104 and get an uncontroversial version of 4104 (without service continuity) agreed at Friday CC.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2004295

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #2, Sol #1 Updates.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

LATE DOC: Rx 25/05, 19:00. Noted

Shabnam (Ericsson) according to the document status remark, the document was late submission so request clarification if it should be NOTED as per chairman's rule on late document.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to NOTE this document.

Noted

8.9

S2-2004104

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, Sol #1: Update of service level.

Vivo, Huawei

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R13 plus change agreed. Revised to S2-2004708.

Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments on introduction of unnecessary classification.
Dario (Huawei) replies and provides r02.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r03
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04 by merging S2-2004177 to S2-2004104, and provides comments.
David (Samsung) provides comments
Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r00/r02/r03
Thomas(Nokia) is merging contents of S2-2004295 to S2-2004104 by providing r06. Thomas also provided r05 but asks to ignore it.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r07
David (Samsung) provides r08
Thomas (Nokia) provides r09
David (Samsung) replies to Thomas, provides r10
Thomas (Nokia) objects to r10 and r8
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) objects to r01, 03, 04, 06, 07 and 09, can live with r00, 02 and 08, and suggests to POSTPONE this document (and other documents on the similar topic)
Thomas(Nokia) suggest trying to get a version without service continuity agreed at the Friday call and provides a draft
David (Samsung) is OK to discuss this on CC#4 on Friday, leaving EN(s) wherever needed
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004708

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, Sol #1: Update of service level.

Vivo, Huawei, Nokia, ZTE, CATT

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004104_R13 plus change. Approved

Approved

8.9

Key Issue #4

Docs:=2

8.9

S2-2004178

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #4, New Sol: QoS support for MBS service.

CATT

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004499

LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification
Judy (Ericsson) asks additional question.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications and has concerns this solution does not stand on its own.
Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies and provides r01.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides one more comment
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02.
Judy (Ericsson) comments.
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Judy (Ericsson).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004499

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #4, New Sol: QoS support for MBS service.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004178. Approved

Approved

8.9

Key Issue #6

Docs:=10

8.9

S2-2004059

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#6, Sol#7: Update to clarify functional descriptions and procedures.

Tencent

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004324

Merged

8.9

S2-2004103

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revised, merging S2-2004059, to S2-2004324

Revised

8.9

S2-2004324

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.

Vivo, Tencent

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004103, merging S2-2004059

Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification
Zhenhua (vivo) resplies to Fenqin (Huawei)
Shabnam (Ericsson) requests clarification/update on some questions to the proposed solution.
LaeYoung (LGE) requests clarification/update.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to LaeYoung (LGE).
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Zhendong (ZTE)
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) provided r01 previously and now provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004500

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #6, Sol #7: Update to clarify ENs.

Vivo, Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004324. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003703

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#6, New Solution: Support Local MBS Service.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004501

Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response and explains why the two ENs are not needed.
LaeYoung (LGE) requests clarification/update.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson).
Thomas (Nokia) provides r02
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004501

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#6, New Solution: Support Local MBS Service.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003703. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003930

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#6, New Sol: Local multicast service.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004502

Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and ask for clarification
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to question from Fenqin (Huawei).
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answer to Q from Fenqin (Huawei).
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment and r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004502

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#6, New Sol: Local multicast service.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003930. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004280

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #6, new Solution Global Unicast Group ID for local Unicast Contents.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004503

Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns regarding location reporting and tracking and its impact on the signalling impact, as warning known from EPS, asks clarifications.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam and provides r02
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments r03
Thomas(Nokia) is fine with r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004503

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #6, new Solution Global Unicast Group ID for local Unicast Contents.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004280. Approved

Approved

8.9

Key issue #7

Docs:=31

8.9

S2-2003700

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7: Update to KI#7 to clarify the switching between unicast and multicast.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004504

Zhenhua (vivo) object to r00.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 and asks Zhenhua (vivo) to reconsider his position.
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02.
Judy (Ericsson) provide comments.
David (Samsung) provides comments.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Judy (Ericsson), Fenqin (Huawei), and David (Samsung).
Jeffrey (Juniper) follows up on Fenqin (Huawei)'s comments.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments provides r03
Thomas (Nokia) can accept r03
Zhenhua (vivo) can accept r03 and replies to Fenqin (Huawei)
Judy (Ericsson) comments and provided r04.
David (Samsung) comments and provides r05.
Dario (Huawei) provides r06 and comments.
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and provides r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Huawei) is fine with r07.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004504

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7: Update to KI#7 to clarify the switching between unicast and multicast.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2003700. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003682

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7 Always RAN based switching within NR coverage.

Ericsson, Nokia, Qualcomm

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004505

LiMeng (Huawei) provides command and r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r01 and provides r02.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment.
Xiaoyan (CATT) can accept r01, but not r02.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) and Xiaoyan (CATT).
David (Samsung) provides comments.
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03.
David (Samsung) provides r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Huawei) is fine with r04 (even if this is a purely RAN based solution).
Hans (Ericsson) prefers r00, but can live with r01, r02 or r04.
David (Samsung) prefers r04; objects to r00, r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004505

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7 Always RAN based switching within NR coverage.

Ericsson, Nokia, Qualcomm

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003682. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003754

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Reliable delivery mode switching between unicast and multicast.

Apple

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004506

Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments.
Jianhua (OPPO) comments and asks questions.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provide comments. .
Saad (Interdigital) provide comments.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r01 and responds to Xiaoyan (CATT).
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Hongkun.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Jianhua.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Saad..
Saad (IDCC) are fine with r01
LaeYoung (LGE) provide comments.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r02.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004506

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Reliable delivery mode switching between unicast and multicast.

Apple

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003754. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003791

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution for unicast-multicast delivery mode switch.

Samsung, Convida Wireless

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000891

Xiaoyan (CATT) asks questions for clarification.
LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification
Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01
David (Samsung) replies to comments by CATT, Huawei and Vivo, and provides r02.
Saad (Interdigital) asks question for clarification
David (Samsung) replies to Saad.
Saad (Interdigital) replies to David.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03.
David (Samsung) provides r04, replies to Thomas.
Saad (IDCC) is fine with r04
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004507

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution for unicast-multicast delivery mode switch.

Samsung, Convida Wireless

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003791. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003961

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI7, new solution mode switching between unicast and multicast.

ZTE

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004508

Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01
Hans (Ericsson) comments. Propose to merge part of the paper with 3682, and then note 3961.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) we are fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004508

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI7, new solution mode switching between unicast and multicast.

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003961. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003962

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7, new solution multicast MBS session handover with Dummy QoS Flow.

ZTE

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004509

LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification
Jianhua(OPPO) asks questions for clarification
zhendong (ZTE) provides the clarification and r01
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) thanks for the update. I'm fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004509

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7, new solution multicast MBS session handover with Dummy QoS Flow

ZTE

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003962. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003858

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution for lossless multicast and unicast switching.

OPPO

Rel-17

LATE DOC: Rx: 24/05, 14:55. Noted

Noted

8.9

S2-2003859

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution for multicast and unicast switching.

OPPO

Rel-17

LATE DOC: Rx: 24/05, 14:55. Noted

Noted

8.9

S2-2003966

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7, New Solution: Inter-RAN node MBS Session Handover.

Huawei, Hisilicon

Rel-17

R08 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004223, to S2-2004510

Fenqin (Huawei) provide comment and r02.
Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r02.
Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback.
Fenqin (Huawei) provide r03.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r04
Thomas (Nokia) provides r05
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r05
Youngkyo (Samsung) ask a question/comment.
Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and r06.
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision r07.
Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and r08.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks a question to Fenqin
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) ok with r08
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004510

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#7, New Solution: Inter-RAN node MBS Session Handover.

Huawei, Hisilicon, OPPO

Rel-17

Revision_R08 of S2-2003966, merging S2-2004223. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004106

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.

Vivo

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004330

Merged

8.9

S2-2004107

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: multicast mode delivery method change without UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revised, merging S2-2004106, to S2-2004330

Revised

8.9

S2-2004330

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004107, merging S2-2004106

Zhenhua (vivo) provide r01 with OPPO as co-signer
Dario (Huawei) provides comments and r02.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r03
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r05 to add OPPO and Tencent as co-signers
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r05 under the condition that in the next meeting, an EN or solution will be added on the issue of RAN supporting SAI/TMGI in the SIB message.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004511

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Mode switch between multicast and unicast.

Vivo, OPPO, Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2004330. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004108

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change from shared to individual due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004331

Merged

8.9

S2-2004109

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change from individual to shared due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revised, merging S2-2004108, to S2-2004331

Revised

8.9

S2-2004331

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004109, merging S2-2004108

Judy (Ericsson) provides r01.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Judy (Ericsson).
Fenqin(Huawei) suggest to postpone this CR.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Fenqin(Huawei) and accept r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004512

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Delivery method change due to UE mobility.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004331. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004110

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Multicast individual legs detection by RAN node for mode switch.

Vivo

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004513

Dario (Huawei) comments
Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 and replies to Dario (Huawei)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004513

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: Multicast individual legs detection by RAN node for mode switch.

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004110. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004179

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7 and #8, New Sol: Delivery mode switching using PDU session modification procedures.

CATT

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004514

Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments.
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies and provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) thanks for response. I'm okey with r02.
Xiaoyan (CATT) thanks for the confirmation.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004514

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7 and #8, New Sol: Delivery mode switching using PDU session modification procedures.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004179. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004180

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: MBS assistance information to RAN for delivery mode switching.

CATT

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004515

Hans (Ericsson) provides comment .
Dario (Huawei) asks questions for clarification
Hans (Ericsson) provides comments .
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Hans (Ericsson).
Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Dario (Huawei) and provides r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004515

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI #7, New Sol: MBS assistance information to RAN for delivery mode switching.

CATT

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004180. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004223

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution to KI#7: Mobility between 5G MBS supporting and 5G MBS non-supporting NG RAN nodes.

Qualcomm Incororporated

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004510

Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification
Fenqin (Huawei) provide comments and suggest this contribution to be merged into 3966.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

Key Issue #8

Docs:=1

8.9

S2-2003701

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#8: Update KI#8 to clarify switching between unicast and broadcast are not supported.

Ericsson

Rel-17

Approved

LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with original, not OK with r01
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) and is fine with r00.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) also prefers r0.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.9

Key Issue #9

Docs:=2

8.9

S2-2004224

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution to KI#9: Switching to unicast transport for mobility to E-UTRAN/EPC.

Qualcomm Incororporated

Rel-17

Postponed

Jianhua (OPPO) asks question.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Jianhua (OPPO) question
LaeYoung (LGE) provides e-hug to Miguel (Qualcomm) and r01.
Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone this contribution.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK to postpone but requests KI#9 be handled at next meeting
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.9

S2-2004229

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Solution to KI#9: Service layer continuity between E-UTRAN/EPC MBMS and NR/5GC MBS.

Qualcomm Incororporated

Rel-17

Postponed

Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone this contribution.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK to postpone but requests KI#9 be handled at next meeting
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.9

Other

Docs:=20

8.9

S2-2003567

P-CR

Approval

23.757: 5MBS terminologies on delivery methods.

Juniper Networks, Vivo, BBC

Rel-17

R16 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004487

Judy (Ericsson) provides S2-2003567r01.
LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments for r01 and provides r02.
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides comments and r03.
Zhenhua (vivo) provides comments for r01~r03 as well as provides r04.
Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Xiaoyan (CATT).
Richard (BBC) provides comments.
Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Richard (BBC) and Xiaoyan (CATT)'s comments, provides r07 and r07a (as a choice depending on further input).
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r08, based on r07 (since r07a is not a valid revision option it was not considered).
Dario (Huawei) provides r09.
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Dario (Huawei).
Thomas (Nokia) provides r10
Dario (Huawei) provides r12 and asks to ignore r11.
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Dario (Huawei) and provides r13.
David (Samsung) comments on r13, prefers r12.
Jeffrey (Juniper) prefers clause 4.4 instead of Annex A.X.
zhendong (ZTE) also prefer in clause 4.4
David (Samsung) can live with the NOTEs in r13, but provides r14 with Clause 4.4 instead of Annex A.X.
Judy (Ericsson) responded to David (Samsung) and can live with r14.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r15 adding one sentence to r14
Jeffrey(Juniper) provides r16.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r16.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) prefers r13, can live with r14, r15, r16, and responds to Jeffrey(Juniper) and Fenqin (Huawei).
Fenqin (Huawei) provide feedback and prefer r16.
David (Samsung) prefers r14, can live with r15, r16.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004487

P-CR

Approval

23.757: 5MBS terminologies on delivery methods.

Juniper Networks, Vivo, BBC

Rel-17

Revision_R16 of S2-2003567. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004162

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Alignment on the use of terminologies for delivery methods.

Juniper Networks, BBC

Rel-17

Noted

Thomas (Nokia) objects to this contribution
Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Thomas (Nokia)'s objects; provides r01
Jeffrey (Juniper) provides addition comment to Thomas (Nokia)'s objection
Judy (Ericsson) provides comments.
David (Samsung) supports Ericsson's proposal.
Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to David (Samsung)'s support for Ericsson's proposal.
Dario (Huawei) comments and proposes to note this contribution.
Jeffrey agrees with Dario (Huawei)'s proposal to note this contribution.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.9

S2-2003568

P-CR

Approval

23.757: 5MBS Architecture Assumption/Requirement: ASP traffic Type.

Juniper Networks

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004488

Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification and provides comments to r01.
Jeffrey responds to Xiaoyan (CATT) and provides r02.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03.
Jeffrey (Juniper) comments on Thomas (Nokia)'s r03.
Dario (Huawei) asks for clarification on r03.
Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r02, but not r03.
Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Dario (Huawei)'s question.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments, not OK with original or any revisions up to r03
Dario (Huawei) supports QC's proposal to have note pointing to Evaluation/Conclusion stage.
Based on Miguel's proposal and Dario's support, I'm providing r04 .
Hans (Ericsson) agrees with Miguel it is late to ammend the Architecture Requirements. Provides r05 with only the Note.
Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with r05
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Jeffrey (Juniper) provides reason why he strongly prefers r04.
Dario (Huawei) prefers r05
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004488

P-CR

Approval

23.757: 5MBS Architecture Assumption/Requirement: ASP traffic Type.

Juniper Networks

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003568. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003678

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Architecture option 2 update.

Ericsson

Rel-17

R10 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004276, to S2-2004594

Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of 3678 (E///), 3897 A.2 part (Samsung) & 4276 (ZTE) in S2-2003678r01.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a revision r02.
Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r01/02 and provides r03.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r04.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the r05
Chunshan (Tencent) provides the r06
Hans (Ericsson) question the need for N9 interface.
David (Samsung) makes a procedural comment, suggests not to consider r06 until a merger is agreed with rest of sourcing companies.
Hans (Ericsson) provides r07 (based on r05) with minor and editorial cleanup.
David (Samsung) replies to Hans, provides r08.
Hans (Ericsson) provides r09 (based on r08).
David (Samsung) provides r10 (based on r09).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hans (Ericsson) prefer r10, okey with r09. Can live with r08 & r07. Object for now to earlier versions.
David (Samsung) prefers r08, OK with r10, r07.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004594

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Architecture option 2 update

Ericsson, ZTE. Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R10 of S2-2003678, merging S2-2004276. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2004276

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Update the Architecture A.2.

ZTE

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004594

Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of 4276 with 3678 (E///) and 3897 A.2 part (Samsung) in S2-2003678r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2003698

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Baseline functionality, update to remove EN .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003896, to S2-2004516

Judy (Ericsson) proposes a merged revision of 3698 and 3986 in S2-2003698r02 (I notice that r01 was uploaded hours ago but haven't seen it announced).
Thomas (Nokia) comments and provides r01 and r03, and objects against r0 and r02.
Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge 3896 into revision of 3698( caution : not 3986; you are referring a wrong tdoc) and provide further revision r04.
Judy (Ericsson) thanks Youngkyo(Samsung) for tdoc no. correction and is OK with update.
Fenqin(Huawei) ask question for clarification .
David (Samsung) replies to Fenqin.
Fenqin(Huawei) provides feedback and r05.
Thomas(Nokia) provides feedback and r06.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r06.
Judy (Ericsson) responded and provide r07.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r07.
Youngkyo (Samsung) is OK with r07 also.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Thomas (Nokia) is fine with r07.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004516

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Baseline functionality, update to remove EN .

Ericsson, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2003698, merging S2-2003896. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003896

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1: Correction on MBS baseline functionality.

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004516

LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification
Youngkyo (Samsung) replies to the questions and provides the revision r02.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against original version and r02 and provided r01.
Thomas also suggest noting the document and pursuing the related discussion in S2-2003698 that is a merger attempt.
Youngkyo (Samsung) is okay to merge this paper to revision of S2-2003698(Judy/Ericsson).
.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2003699

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Specific architectural requirements and principles, update .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Noted

Thomas (Nokia) objects to the contribution
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Thomas (Nokia) and believes the legacy IPTV solution should not restrict the 5MBS solution study.
David (Samsung) provides comments.
Dario (Huawei) provides comments.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r01.
David (Samsung) is OK with r01.
Dario (Huawei) is not OK with r01
Thomas(Nokia) maintains the objection, also against r01
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Huawei) objects r00 and r01
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.9

S2-2003897

P-CR

Approval

23.757: KI#1: update Annex A to clarify MBS architecture alternatives .

Samsung

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004517

Hans (Ericsson) provides a merge of and 3897 Annex A.2 part with 3678 (E///) and 4276 (ZTE) in S2-2003678r01. 3897r01 with only Annex A.1 part provided.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides to be merged into S2-2003982r01.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) opposes the removal of MSF interaction via NEF.
Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay to merge S2-2003897r01 is merged into S2-2003982r01, and provide comment to Miguel Griot (Qualcomm)'s concern.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.9

S2-2003982

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-1 .

Tencent

Rel-17

R06 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003897, to S2-2004517

Chunshan (Tencent) provides a r01 to merge the changes of S2-2003897r01.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments (to original and r01).
Youngkyo(Samsung) provide a further revision(r02) to the merged version.
Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r02.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r03, not ok with r02.
Thomas (Nokia) provide r04.
Chunshan (Tencent) provide r05.
Thomas (Nokia) prefers r04.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification.
Hans (Ericsson) supports Thomas on I-UPF and provides r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Chunshan (Tencent) is ok with r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004517

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-1 .

Tencent, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003982, merging S2-2003897. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003983

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Annex A: Update the 5G MBS Architecture-2 .

Tencent

Rel-17

Noted

Judy (Ericsson) provides comment, and proposes to note this paper.
Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to Judy and requests to withdraw the note proposal.
Judy (Ericsson) responded to Chunshan (Tencent).
David (Samsung) provides comments
Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) responses to Ericsson and Samsung.
Chunshan Xiong (Tencent) merges this paper into S2-2003678r06.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) objects to this pCR as we do not see the need of I-UPF for the MBS Session. The attempt to merge 3983 into 3678 was not agreed either.
Chunshan (Tencent) questions on Judy's objection and request to withdraw the objection.
David (Samsung) comments.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification.
Judy (Ericsson) sustains the objection and responds to Chunshan (Tencent) .
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.9

S2-2003989

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Annex #A: MBS Control Plane and User Plane Stack .

Tencent

Rel-17

Postponed

Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification
Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) expresses concerns with some aspects of P-CR
Youngkyo (Samsung) proposes to note this in this meeting.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01
Chunshan (Tencent) response to Samsung.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a question.
Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Samsung.
Youngkyo (Samsung) provide a comment.
Chunshan (Tencent) provides r02.
Dario (Huawei) comments
Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Dario.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides and additional comment
Thomas (Nokia) suggest noting this contribution
Hans (Ericsson) provides r03 with updated stacks for A.2. Generally we also think it is a bit premature to bring stacks now, but we can accept r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Youngkyo (Samsung) is okay to note or accept r02, but object r03.
Chunshan (Tencent) is okay to accept r02, but object r03.
Dario (Huawei) proposes to postpone.
Hans (Ericsson) also propose to postpone this. Otherwise we can accept r03, but we object earlier versions
David (Samsung) supports to postpone.
Thomas (Nokia) agrees that it is better to postpone this
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.9

S2-2004158

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Clarification of AF function and Service Layer Aspect for Architecture Alternative 1.

Tencent

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004518

Thomas (Nokia) comments and suggest noting the contribution
Lei (Tencent) comments and provided r01 and r02 . Request to discard r01.
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is OK with r02.
Thomas (Nokia) is OK with r02.
Also request avoiding hyperlinks to 'fiveeye' server
Lei(Tencent) thanks to Thomas and Miguel for confirming.
Dario (Huawei) asks question for clarification.
Lei(Tencent) provides clarification to Dario (Huawei).
Dario (Huawei) is fine with r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.9

S2-2004518

P-CR

Approval

23.757: Clarification of AF function and Service Layer Aspect for Architecture Alternative 1.

Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004158. Approved

Approved

8.9

S2-2003932

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] LS on sensitive Mission Critical information

Airbus

Noted

Thomas (Nokia) questions need fort the LS
Zhenhua (vivo) comments
Francois (Airbus) provides clarification
Dario (Huawei) comments
Saso (Intel) supports sending out the LS
Francois (Airbus) responds to Dario's comments
Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes the LS to be noted
Shabnam (Ericsson) shares similar views as Qualcomm and Nokia and do not support sending the LS.
Francois (Airbus) responds to comments from Ericsson and Qualcomm.
Thomas(Nokia) again suggest noting the LS.
Thomas (Nokia) responds to comments from Francois.
Francois (Airbus) responds to Nokia's comment.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Francois and formally objects
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

Study on system enablers for multi-USIM devices (FS_MUSIM)

Docs:=67

8.10

Key Issue #1

Docs:=27

8.10

S2-2003635

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to remove ENs.

Intel

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R12 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004206, S2-2003829 and S2-2004157, to S2-2004709.

Lalith (Samsung) provides r01.
Xiaowan (vivo) provides r01.
Yang Xu (OPPO) comments
Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung).
Lalith (Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel).
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes how to handle the overlap with S2-2003893.
Saso (Intel) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Saso (Intel) asks Steve (Huawei) if he has a better proposal.
Lalith (Samsung) confirms fine with proposed way forward.
Curt (Charter) asks for a clarification on implementing forward.
Saso (Intel) replies to Curt (Charter).
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks a question for clarification.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks question for clarification.
Yang Xu (OPPO) asks question and comments.
Xiaowan (vivo) provides r02.
Myungjune (LGE) provides r03, which tries to merge S2-2004157.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01.
Lalith(Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel) and Curt (Charter).
Saso (Intel) disagrees with r03 provided by Myungjune (LGE).
Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan, Dieter, Yang; provides r04.
Myungjune (LGE) provides comment.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) replies to Saso (Intel)
Ouyang(Huawei) ask quesitions for clarification.
Saso (Intel) provides a 29.118 reference to Myungjune (LGE) about CS call indicator on SGs.
Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei); provides r05.
Curt (Charter) asks a question.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports r05.
Ouyang(Huawei) askes questions for clarification.
Saso (Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE).
Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei).
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides response
xiaowan (vivo) provides r06
Lalith (Samsung) comments and supports r06
Saso (Intel) disagrees with r06 and offers r07
Chris provides r08 that merges in S2-2004157. Chris disagrees with r06 for EPS.
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r09 based on r08 from VDF
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Chris.
Chris (Vodafone) provides TS 23.272 extracts.
Ouyang(Huawei) proposes r10.
Saso (Intel) objects to r10
Saso (Intel) replies to Chris (Vodafone).
Lalith(Samsung) supports Saso (Intel) and responds to Ouyang(Huawei)
Ouyang (Huawei) replies to Saso.
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lailith(Samsung).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Lailith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei)
Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang (Huawei).
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso(Intel).
Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r08 and r09.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) object r10 and can agree with r09.
Lailith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). We Support Intel, Qualcomm and LGE to document alternative Paging Causes in the Annex. Hence support r09 and object r10.
Xiaowan (vivo) agrees r10, r09, r06, r02 and prefers r10, objects to the rest
Ouyang(Huawei) insists r10 and objects all other revisions.
Saso (Intel) ok with r09; cannot accept r10. Proposes a way forward based on r09 with addition of one EN (in two places).
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso. Huawei insists on NOT documenting other causes except voice,
Ouyang(Huawei) clarifies HW's position on ENs.
Curt (Charter) ok with r09 or r09/with new rev by Saso (Intel). Probably this need to be discussed at CC#4 to get to somewhere.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004709

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to remove ENs.

Intel, Charter Communications

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003635_R12, merging S2-2004206, S2-2003829 and S2-2004157. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003829

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Sol#1: update the handling of paging cause.

Vivo

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004709

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Juan.
Yang Xu (OPPO) shares the vivo's view that the Paging Cause needs to added per UE request.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes further comments.
Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Juan
Saso (Intel) asks Xiaowan, Juan, Yang to check 3635r04
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR as it can be considered merged in 3635
Xiaowan (vivo) agrees to merge S2-2003829 into S2-2003635
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2004264

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify about paging cause values.

Samsung

Rel-17

Noted

Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification.
Lalith (Samsung) provides clarification to the questions.
Lalith (Samsung) responsds to Myungjune (LGE).
Myungjune (LGE) provides comment.
Saso (Intel) comments.
Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE).
Xiaowan (vivo) requests to merge S2-2004264 into S2-2003635 .
Lalith (Samsung) responds to Xiaowan.
Lalith (Samsung) replies to Myungjune (LGE).
Lalith (Samsung) provides r01.
Saso (Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE).
Xiaowan (vivo) request revision to clarify paging cause 0.
Lalith (Samsung) provides r02.
Ouyang(Huawei) comments on paging causes.
Lalith(Samsungi) responds to Ouyang(Huawei)
Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei).
Curt (Charter) agrees with Intel (Saso).
Ouyang(Huawei) comments again on paging causes. Ouyang also proposes to merge this contribution to S2-2003635.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso(Intel).
Ouyang(Huawei) objects to the orginal version and any other revisions .
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Ouyang(Huawei) if adding the word ,candidate' in the new Annex will alleviate Huawei's concerns?
Lalith(Samsung) proposes to discuss this paper along with 3635 in CC#3
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004206

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Paging cause usage .

Charter Communications

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Merged into S2-2004709

Alessio (Nokia) is this an evolution of S2-2003635? If so can we converge on one document? Which also should include S2-2004264?
Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) is this an evolution of S2-2003635? If so can we converge on one document? Which also should include S2-2004264?
Curt (Charter) asks a question to Saso (intel)
Xiaowan(vivo) provides comments
Ouyang(Huawei) asks a question for clarification.
Curt (Charter) replies to ?? (Ouyang/Huawei) and ?? (Xiaowan/Vivo).
Curt (Charter) provides R1.
Xiaowan (vivo) replies to curt's question.
Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification.
Curt (Charter) replies to Xiaowan (vivo).
Ouyang (Huawei) ask questions on the additional text.
Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei)
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Curt (Charter).
Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei).
Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) and provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r02.
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Curt(Charter). Ouyang(Huawei) objects to the orginal version and any other revisions .
Curt (Charter) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) and suggests to see where x3635 is going first before noting this.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2003893

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Update solution #1 of Handling of MT service with Paging Cause.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R04plus Agreed. Revised to S2-2004710.

Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification.
Saso (Intel) proposes to revise the proposal as an incremental add-on to Solution #1.
Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification
Lalith (Samsung) asks for clarification.
Alessio(nokia) provides comment and proposes this paper is noted
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comment
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies MediaTek's comment.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies HW's comment.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Samsung's comments.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies OPPO's comment.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Alessio(nokia) can you clarify the interaction with PPD I have asked? Do you intend to standardize DSCP values?
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r02 to capture all the comments from Mediatek, OPPO, Samsung and HW
Alessio(Nokia) This solution is problematic as the TAS is in HPLMN and the DSCP values are VPLMN specific. Networks in between may change the DSCP value for DIFFSERV operation
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Nokia's comment.
Xiaowan (vivo) comments.
Alessio(Nokia)
In general if there is no guarantee that between the UPF and TAS no change of DSCP value happens, the solution does not work. So maybe you can place an EN to that effect.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Nokia's comment and r03 is provided.
Saso (Intel) comments to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to vivo.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r04 to address Saso's comment.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Alessio(Nokia) ok to document r04 if a EN is added 'Editor's Note: it is FFS whether this solution can work if there is no guarantee the DSCP cannot change between TAS and UPF in transport networks outside operators control between TAS in HPLMN and the P-CSCF in VPLMN. Impact on IPX especially is to be considered in roaming case and any requirement on NG.113 by GSMA shall be specified'
Steve (Huawei) asks practical questions.
Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei).
Steve (Huawei) clarifies boiler plate EN, checks how to proceed with depenency.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply comments to HW and Intel.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004710

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Update solution #1 of Handling of MT service with Paging Cause.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003893_R04plus. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004157

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Solution 1 Update: Align EPS Paging Cause with EPS Paging Policy Differentiation.

Vodafone

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004709

Myungjune (LGE) proposes to merge into S2-2003635.
Saso (Intel) checks with Crhis (Vodfaone) whether merge with S2-2003635 is appropriate.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2003974

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004519

Lars (Sony) ask for updated figure 6.2.3.1-1 and procedure text
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and requests more details in the new procedure.
Steve (Huawei) provides r01.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Yang Xu (OPPO) asks question for clarification.
Steve (Huawei) replies to questions.
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides further comments
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) responds to comments and provides r02.
Steve (Huawei) provides r03.
Saso (Intel) comments.
Steve (Huawei) provides r04.
Saso (Intel) provides r05.
Steve (Huawei) is fine with r05
Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004519

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003974. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003675

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to remove EN .

Sony

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.10

S2-2003637

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to remove ENs.

Intel

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004520

Lars (Sony) ask question for clarification
Saso (Intel) replies to Lars (Sony)
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments/asks question for clarification.
Saso (Intel) replies to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom).
Saso (Intel) provides r01.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004520

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to remove ENs.

Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003637. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003715

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Sol#8, Update to remove ENs .

Ericsson

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004588

Myungjune (LGE) provide comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune(LGE).
Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification.
Myungjune (LGE) clarifies question.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Lalith(Samsung).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune(LGE) and ask for clarification.
Myungjune (LGE) suggests to add a note.
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on Figure 6.8.2-2.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Saso (Intel) and Myungjune(LGE), provides r01.
Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification on Figure 6.8.2-2.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Saso (Intel) and provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004588

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1, Sol#8, Update to remove ENs .

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003715. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004049

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #8: Update to clarify UE impact.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.10

S2-2003837

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Network-based paging filtering.

LG Electronics, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004589

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) asks also questions.
Myungjune (LGE) provides answer.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Myungjune (LGE) .
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification.
Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification .
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel) and Lalith (Samsung).
Myungjune (LGE) provides r01.
Wanqiang (Huawei) comment on the updated EN.
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Wanqiang (Huawei).
Wanqiang (Huawei) responds to Myungjune.
Myungjune (LGE) provides r02.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments.
Lalith (Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) and provides r01.
Myungjune (LGE) answers to Qian (Ericsson) and provides r03.
Myungjune (LGE) provides r04.
Andy (Vice Chair) points out that Lalith provided r03, not r01.
Alessio (nokia), responds to Saso(Intel).
Antoine (Orange) asks how 'silent SMs' are handled.
Myungjune (LGE) responds Antoine (Orange).
Antoine (Orange) replies.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) provides r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004589

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Network-based paging filtering.

LG Electronics, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003837. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003651

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Using Non-3GPP access to deliver NAS Notification message.

Apple

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000733. Noted

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments the proposal.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments.
Saso (Intel) agrees with Qian Chen (Ericsson). Proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Lalith (Samsung) comments for clarification.
Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung).
Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification
Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note the document.
Lalith (Samsung) replies to Saso (Intel).
Krisztian (Apple) replies to Guillaume.
Krisztian (Apple) provides r01 and replies to Xiaowan.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Juan.
Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso and Lalith.
Saso (Intel) replies to Krisztian (Apple).
Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso.
Lalith(Samsung) asks question to Krisztian (Apple)
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Krisztian.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to Lalith.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Juan zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note this PCR.
Antoine (Orange) objects to r00 and r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2003764

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1: New solution: Operator controlled Handling of Paging Cause code.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Approved

Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments.
Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification
Alessio(Nokia) responds
Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and asks for clarification
Qian Chen (Ericsson) comments and asks questions.
Alessio(nokia) responds to comment by huawei
alessio (nokia) provides response to comments by ericsson (Ericsson)
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.10

S2-2003838

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Push Notification via SMS.

LG Electronics, LG Uplus

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004590

Lars (Sony) ask for updated figure 6.x.2-1 and new rev.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) asks a question for clarification.
Myungjune (LGE) responds Lars (Sony) and Chris (T-Mobile USA) and provides r01 .
Saso (Intel) provides r02.
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel).
Saso Intel) replies to Myungjune (LGE).
Myungjune (LGE) provides r03.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004590

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Push Notification via SMS.

LG Electronics, LG Uplus

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003838. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004270

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Informing network two USIMs belongs to same device.

Samsung, NEC, Airtel, InterDigital

Rel-17

Noted

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note this proposal since it is related to the CN coordination.
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and r01 with new Editor's Notes.
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the comment from Qualcomm to note this document.
Saso (Intel) supports Guillaume (MediaTek) and Juan (Qualcomm) and proposes to note this document.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Ulises (InterDigital Inc.) request Mr. SA2 Chairman to add S2-2004270 to the discussions for CC#4 with regards to the scope and priority of this paper in Rel.17
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004273

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1: IMS based solution.

vivo Mobile Communications Ltd

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004599

Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions.
Adrian (vivo) provides comments and indicates S2-2004273 has been merged with S2-2004233. This thread maybe closed.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2003975

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#1 KI#3, New Sol: N3GPP for MUSIM Service Concurrency.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Noted

Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends this document be noted.
Alessio(Nokia) supports MediaTek, the non 3GPP access leveraging is possible but not defining a specific standard solution. Hence, the reliance on non 3GPP access according to existing standards is going to be implementation driven and not in scope of standardization in MUSIM Study.
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) seeks clarification.
Lalith (Samsung) responds to Guillaume.
Saso (Intel) supports Guillaume (MediaTek) and requests this pCR to be NOTED.
Steve (Huawei) disagress with noting the pCR and asks for clarificaiton on CP data.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Samsung.
Saso (Intel) replies to Steve (Huawei).
Saso (Intel) comments.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) agree with Saso's comment and we should focus on 3GPP access.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) disagrees with noting.
For the record: Saso (Intel) objects to this pCR.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004233

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, New sol: ePDG connectivity for MT service in Multi-USIM scenarios .

Google

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004273, to S2-2004599

Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions.
Saso (Intel) seeks clarification.
Alessio(Nokia) provides comments. Is this solution implying the user plane for both PLMNs is using one PLMN at some point?
Pavan (Google) provides some answers, and provides a revision merging S2-2004233 and S2-2004273
Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification from Pavan (Google) and/or Adrian (vivo)
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides comments and request revision.
Aditya (Comcast) provides comments supporting the document
Pavan (Google) provides some answers, and provides a new revision r2
Myungjune (LGE) asks question for clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Adrian (vivo) responds.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments.
Saso (Intel) comments.
Adrian (vivo) agrees with the Intel proposal.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004599

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, New sol: ePDG/N3IWF connectivity for MT service in Multi-USIM scenarios .

Google, vivo Mobile Communications Ltd

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004233, merging S2-2004273. Approved

Approved

8.10

Key Issue #2

Docs:=16

8.10

S2-2003894

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Solution for paging collision avoidance .

Qualcomm Incorporated, apple, vivo, CATT

Rel-17

Noted

Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01.
Alessio (nokia) it is not clear to us why the UDM should be affected. In a nutshell this indicates to the RAN to alter its paging behaviour for a MUSIM UE. we wonder whether this could be merged into S2-2003766r01 we have created to facilitate such merger..
Lars (Sony) provides r02
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 and reply comments.
Lars (Sony) provides comment.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Sony's comment.
Lars (Sony) replies Juan's comment.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Lars's comment.
Saso (Intel) comments.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02, object to r03.
Lars (Sony) comments.
Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Lars.
Lars (Sony) replies to Xiaowan
Lars (Sony) provides r04
Alessio (nokia) reiterates this paper is covered by 3766r01
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides v5 and reply comments.
Lars (Sony) cannot accept r05 and reply to comments.
Lars (Sony) further comments.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to Lars.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Lars (Sony) we can accept r06.
Alessio (Nokia) objects to all revisions
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2003636

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #2, New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance.

Intel, Sony, OPPO, InterDigital

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000164

Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks a question for clarification.
Saso (Intel) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO).
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Saso (Intel).
Iskren (NEC) provides comments and also provides r01.
Saso (Intel) replies to Malla and Iskren; provides r02.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Saso (Intel) replies to Malla; provides r03.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04.
Saso (Intel) is OK with r04 too.
Iskren (NEC) provides comments.
Saso (Intel) replies to Iskren (NEC).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004600

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #2, New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance.

Intel, Sony, OPPO, InterDigital, NEC

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003636. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003674

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #2: New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance using alt. UE_ID.

Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004591

Antoine (Orange) asks if this can be merged with S2-2004218.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks a question for clarification.
Lars (Sony) provides answer to Malla and Antoine.
Lars (Sony) provides r01
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r01.
Alessio(Nokia) we are also happier to keep the two solutions separate.
Iskren (NEC) provides comments.
Lars (Sony) provides answer to Iskren.
Chris (Vodafone) is OK to keep 4218 and 3674 as separate solutions.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004591

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #2: New Sol: Paging Reception with PO collision avoidance using alt. UE_ID.

Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless, NEC

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003674. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004218

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging occasion conflict in EPS using offset to the UE Identity Index Value.

Vodafone

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.10

S2-2003765

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2, KI#3: New Solution: establishment of association on user plane for paging notification on user plane.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR.
Alessio (nokia): the main difference here is the registration mechanism which we propose to happen on the C-plane of the PLMN that delivers the notifications of the user plane of the other PLMN. The security is a detail but here we just propose a symmetric key that is provided by the UE using the NAS security in the source system (so this is a detail on how to provide security which of course SA3 will eventually assess). But really the c-plane registration is the main aspect here.
Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification.
Alessio (nokia) responds to comments.
Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (nokia).
Alessio Nokia) reply to Saso that this is a competitive solution that borrows the conecpts of solution 7 at high level (meaning user plane paging) but then it is totally different at stage two level.
Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) and proposes a way forward.
Saso (Intel) proposes r01.
Alessio(nokia) retains Nokia solution is r0
Alessio(nokia) provides additional info on their solution which was requested:
Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio(nokia):
Alessio(nokia) provides r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Saso (Intel) objects to r02 and the original; can accept r01; reasons for objection provided below
Alessio(nokia) objects to r01 as it is an intel paper not the nokia solution. Nokia complains heavily Intel is using anticompetitive behaviour to exclude a competing solution to theirs.
Saso (Intel) refutes accusations from Alessio(nokia) and sustains objection on r00 and r02; proposes to reconsider moving forward with r01.
Alessio(Nokia): I have already objected to Intel's paper in r01. For the rest everyone can see the nature of the comments by intel so we need not reply to them anymore. We will bring updated paper with a picture of a server at the next meeting ??
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2003766

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging conflict using MUSIM Assistance Information.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004601

Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this pCR (or merge into other CRs).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) withdraw the propose on this pCR.
Alessio(nokia) provides r01
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks questions for clarification
Saso (Intel) provides r02
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 based on r02 to remove S1 signalling.
Alessio(nokia) objects to r03 as S1 singalling impact is allowed by RAN!
Nokia does not consider r02 needed as the soltuion for coodinated leaving USING MUSIM assistacce info is in 3767 and should be kept there there, ... Intel proposes this note is sufficient to kill 3767 but this is not ok as the solution in3767 provides the system operation based on MUSIM assistanc ifnot ti IDNICATE the UE is leaving and condition network behaviour when the UE leaves. So we object to this revision.
Nalessio(nokia) responds to dieter.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks additional question
Saso (Intel) prefers r02; can live with r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004601

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2: New solution: Resolving paging conflict using MUSIM Assistance Information.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003766. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003972

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2, New Sol: Paging on Consecutive POs.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004592

Antoine (Orange) comments.
Steve (Huawei) provides r01.
Alessio(Nokia) provides comments
Antoine (Orange) replies to Steve.
Steve (Huawei) provides r02.
Alessio(nokia) but then this is similar to the Mediatek approach of doing nothing other than in the UE and the network is more aggressive than usual as it suspects there may be lots of MUSIM devices around? I still do not get the way this is MUSIM specific as I cannot detect anywhere anything that triggers the network to become MUSIM oriented for the UE.
Steve (Huawei) provides a short comment to the previous long comment
Alessio(Nokia) provides a short comment
Alessio(Nokia) provides a remark
Antoine (Orange) asks clarification on 'specific UE'.
Steve (Huawei) provides r03 with specific UE clarificaiton
Alessio(nokia) proposes to not this paper and merge with mediatek S2-2004050
Steve (Huawei) disagrees to note the paper. They are not the same.
Alessio(nokia) requires clarification on network side behaviour.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Alessio(nokia) requires further clarification on network side behaviour.
Steve (Huawei) the solution sticks together
Antoine (Orange) Interrupts Steve and Alessio for a question.
Steve (Huawei) is happy for the interruption and provides a response.
Alessio(nokia) proposes r04
Antoine (Orange) Agrees with Alessio that the solution is not fully described.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) r04 is ok.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004592

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#2, New Sol: Paging on Consecutive POs.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003972. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004050

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New Sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000949. Approved

Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks questions for clarification.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to MediaTek.
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to NTT DoCoMo
Alessio(nokia) can we at least note somewhere that this is a behavior already supported in the field so people do not claim this shall not be supported ??
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Approved

8.10

S2-2004051

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device using increased paging repetition.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004593

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) withdraw the previous comments.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks questions for clarification.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo and provides r01.
Antoine (Orange) questions the validity of the solution.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02.
The original and r01 should no longer be considered.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks r02 difference from S2-2003636.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to NTT DoCoMo.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004593

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #2, New sol: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device using increased paging repetition.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004051. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003895

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Solution for scheduling gap .

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R01 Agreed. Revised in parallel session to S2-2004711.

Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification on TDoc handling for items that are RAN centric (with no SA2 impact).
Curt (Charter) comments...
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply Mediatek and Charter's comments.
Saso (Intel) comments and asks for clarification.
Alessio(nokia). Agree with Guillaume this should not be put in TR. Propose to note and provide system requirement to provide scheduling gaps if the solutions we agree on require this.
Guillaume (MediaTek) clarifies his point.
Alessio(Nokia) OK so it is only us to ask it not to be documented. Just to note that one example of what I was saying is in
S2-2003974
23.761: KI#1, Sol #2: Procedure Updates for Negotiated Absence.
When it is assumed the short RAN GAP can be negotiated. In fact can we merge this paper into S2-2003974?
Saso (Intel) asks Alessio(Nokia) to stop spreading confusion
Steve (Huawei) comments on merge.
Aditya (Comcast) supports Curt (Charter) view on the inclusion of this solution in SA2
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) supports to document the solution and mention in the LS to RAN in S2-2004248.
Aditya (Comcast) adds a comment
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01 with the only change to add Comcast as consigner.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to the original Tdoc and rev thereof, subject to discussion during Friday CC on TDoc handling.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004711

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Solution for scheduling gap .

Qualcomm Incorporated, Comcast

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003895_R01. Approved

Approved

8.10

Key Issue #3

Docs:=15

8.10

S2-2003827

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol#4: update to support local leaving negotiation .

Vivo

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004595

Myungjune (LGE) provide comments.
Lars (Sony) ask questions and ask Vivo to update the paper
Xiaowan Ke (r01) provides r01
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Myungjune (LGE) is fine with r01.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004595

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol#4: update to support local leaving negotiation .

Vivo

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2003827. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003714

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs .

Ericsson, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Charter Communications

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003828, to S2-2004596

Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01 which merges in S2-2004163 (China Telecom) and S2-2003828 (Vivo)
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides question for clarification
Xiaowan (vivo) provides r02 and comments
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r03 and responds to Xiaowan(vivo)
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides responds to Yang Xu (OPPO).
Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Xiaowan(vivo)
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and provides r05.
Yang Xu (OPPO) provides a question for clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r04.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and confirms that last revision is r04.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004596

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs .

Ericsson, Motorola Mobility, Lenovo, Charter Communications

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003714, merging S2-2003828. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004163

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Solution #5 Update: Update for UE setting expected time period to leave.

China Telecom

Rel-17

Noted

Xiaowan (vivo) provide r01.
Xiaowan (vivo) provide r02.
Alessio(nokia) provides comment: we still need CT1 to validate the short duration leave is suitable to perform common CT1 procedures. If this is not added we prefer r0 (original version)
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provide comments and r03.
Xiaowan (vivo) provides comment and r04.
Lalith(Samsung) asks question to Xiaowan (vivo).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provide comments and r05.
Xiaowan(vivo) answers to Lalith(Samsung).
Lalith(Samsung) responds to Xiaowan(vivo)
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments to Xiaowan(vivo).
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Xiaowan (vivo) only accepts r02, r04, objects the rest; also replies to Qian and Juan.
Alessio(Nokia) only accepts r04
Qian Chen(Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions
Alessio(nokia) to be fair we can also live with r5. .
Pinghui(China Telecom) propose to go with r05 and comments
Qian Chen(Ericsson) also propose to go with r05, objects to r02/r04 since they are not logically correct.
Alessio(Nokia)does anyone know why the existing EN was not good enough? Do we need this tdoc to be approved?
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm)can only accept r05, object r04.
Qian Chen(Ericsson) comments that it's fine to NOTE the paper, if no agreement can be reached.
Alessio (Nokia) shares the view of Ericsson.
Xiaowan(vivo) is also fine to NOTE the paper.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is also fine to NOTE the paper.
Andy (Vice Chair) observes that r05 seems to be OK for several companies, hasn't seen an objection.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) clarify comment.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2003828

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol#5: update to support more cases in MUSIM-RAI .

Vivo

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004596

Antoine (Orange) asks if this is considered merged into S2-2004163.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the CR since it's merged into S2-2003714.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) withdraw the previous NOTE proposal. And propose to mark the pCR as Merged into S2-2003714.
Xiaowan (vivo) confirms to merge S2-2003828 into S2-2003714.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2004267

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove ENs and clarify about non-3GPP access.

Samsung

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004602

Xiaowan (vivo) request to merge S2-2004267 into S2-2004163 .
Qian Chen (Ericsson) Propose to NOTE this pCR
Lalith (Samsung) responds to Qian(Ericsson)
Qian Chen (Ericsson) responds to Lalith (Samsung)
Lalith(Samsung) agrees with Qian Chen (Ericsson) and provides r01 to handle it.
Alessio(Nokia) comments on all revisions
Myungjune (LGE) suggests to merge S2-2004267 and S2-2004163.
Lalith(Samsung) responds to Alessio(Nokia)
Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004602

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove ENs and clarify about non-3GPP access.

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004267. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003844

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove EN.

China Telecom

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004597

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) responds to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) provides further clarifications to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and provides r01.
Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) indicates merge S2-2003844 into the revision of S2-2003973.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.10

S2-2003973

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol #6: Update for data handling after UE leaves.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003844, to S2-2004597

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Steve (Huawei) comments.
Lars (Sony) provides r01
Steve (Huawei) provides r02.
Alessio(nokia )provides comment: this reads odd 'Alternatively, RAN paging may not be triggered until the UE initiates resume procedure.'
Shuyi Tian (China Telecom ) proposes to merge S2-2003844 into S2-2003973 and provides r03.
Steve (Huawei) the merge and r03 looks good.
Alessio(nokia) comments
Xiaowan (vivo) provides r04 and replies comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004597

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3, Sol #6: Update for data handling after UE leaves.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003973, merging S2-2003844. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004052

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #3, New Sol: Coordinated leaving for MUSIM device.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004598

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qualcomm.
Chris J (T-Mobile USA) requests change of solution title.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r01 (new title!)
Alessio(nokia) asks for clarification.
Guillaume (MediaTek) provides clarification and r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004598

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #3, New Sol: Coordinated leaving for MUSIM device.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004052. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2003650

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI #3, New Sol: Network coordination when the multiple USIMs in the Multi-USIM device are served by the same serving network.

Apple

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2000736. Noted

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments that it is related to network coordination which is the lower priority, proposed to note the documents.
Saso (Intel) also proposes to note the documents.
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the view from Saso (intel) to note this document.
Krisztian (Apple) responds to comments.
Saso (intel) replies to Krisztian (Apple).
Antoine (Orange) provides a procedural comment and a technical comment.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments
Krisztian (Apple) replies to Saso.
Krisztian (Apple) replies to Antoine.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comment and agrees to NOTE the pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2003767

P-CR

Approval

23.761: KI#3 New solution: Coordinated leaving Using MUSIM Assistance Information.

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, OPPO, Fraunhofer HHI

Rel-17

Noted

Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE this paper sine it overlaps with S2-2003766.
Alessio (Nokia) responds to Qian Chen (Ericsson) : we created, bases on discussion on conf call and under guidance of the rapporteur, three papers out of a single one that was covering three key issues, so 3766 covers KI#2, and 3767 covers KI#3 ..
Alessio(nokia) provides answer to Juan (QCOM)
Saso (Intel) clarifies the recommendation given to Alessio (Nokia) and provides excerpt from the CC minutes; proposes to NOTE this pCR.
Alessio(Nokia) the two papers that Qian proposes to merge are totally different and show the procedures for each KI specific aspects.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose further comments and still consider noting the pCR is correct.
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) does not see how this solution is relevant to KI#3.
Alessio(nokia) the relevance to KI#3 is that the Assistnac einfo can be included in registration requests or SR or RRC messages as events happen. Where is it stated that these are done asynchronously to events only, please?
Alessio(nokia) provides r01 to make it even clearer how this is relevant to KI#3 and that this is not a negotiation happening asynchronously to the UE leaving a system.
Genadi (Motorola Mobility) provides further comments to Alessio (Nokia).
Alessio (Nokia) responds to Genadi
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR
Alessio(nokia) comment by intel is not comprehensible. Alos, he notes a solution based on his thoughts but we cannot assume Saso's thoughts are absolute... like why is it not possible for a UE to determine a periodicity of absence is beyond my understanding. So we push back to this comment (also adding a note to the 3767 while saying that this note can cause the 3767 doc to be noted is strange! Also the solution is not about periodicity of absence alone! Intel behavior at this meeting is to blanket note all Nokia papers? Is this a company position?
Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio(nokia)
Alessio(Nokia) we reiterate the periodicity is not the key of this solution! Can Intel read the solution and comment on the procedures? thanks
Saso (Intel) disagrees that paging is a valid case for 'periodicity of absence'.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Alessio(nokia) comments that it seems some comments were based on misinterpretation of what I have responded, some assumed that this is scope of KI#2 but in fact we show the assistance info used for KI#3 in related procedure. Hence we would like to propose this paper is progressed as the argument of partial overlap should probably kill 90% of the papers on table as we all use same procedures!
Saso (Intel) objects to all revisions of this paper.
Alessio (Nokia) notes with interest the comments by Intel, which are not moving us forward.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

Other

Docs:=9

8.10

S2-2003981

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Architectural Assumption for MUSIM support.

NTT DOCOMO, Orange, Telecom Italia, Deutsche Telekom

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R05 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004712.

Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 and added Verizon and AT&T as co-signers.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment.
Saso (Intel) comments.
Alessio(nokia) proposes r02
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Juan and Saso.
Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for this document to be noted.
Omkar (CableLabs) asks for this document to be noted.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to CableLabs and MediaTek.
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Mediatek's comment.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Juan.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r02.
Curt (Charter) comments ...
Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r02 and provides r03.
Xiaowan (vivo) provides comment and r04.
Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok with r04.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Charter, ok with r04.
Curt (Charter) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO).
Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r04.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Qian Chen (Ericsson) is fine with r04.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments: Could we remove 'to deploy in a PLMN' in this assumption during the conference call?
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.10

S2-2004712

P-CR

Approval

23.761: Architectural Assumption for MUSIM support.

NTT DOCOMO, Orange, Telecom Italia, Deutsche Telekom,Verizon, AT&T

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003981_R05. Approved

Approved

8.10

S2-2004044

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #1: Evaluation and conclusion .

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and propose to NOTE the pCR.
Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel).
Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur.
(Same for our other evaluation TDocs)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004045

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #2: Evaluation and conclusion .

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and propose to NOTE the pCR.
Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to the esteemed Rapporteur.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004046

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #3: Evaluation and conclusion.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and Alessio (Nokia), and propose to NOTE the pCR.
Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur to note the pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004047

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #7: Evaluation and conclusion.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and Alessio (Nokia), and propose to NOTE the pCR.
Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur to note the pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004048

P-CR

Approval

23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #8: Evaluation and conclusion.

MediaTek Inc.

Rel-17

Noted

Saso (Intel) thinks it is premature to work on evaluations and conclusions in this meeting and proposes to NOTE the pCR.
Alessio(nokia) Agrees with Saso (intel).
Qian Chen (Ericsson) supports Saso (Intel) and Alessio (Nokia), and propose to NOTE the pCR.
Guillaume (MediaTek) accepts the recommendation from the Rapporteur to note the pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004248

LS OUT

Approval

LS on Potential RAN impact for support of Multi-USIM devices

Intel

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Noted

Xiaowan (vivo) thinks it is really beneficial to LS to RAN for SA2 progress and provides suggestions.
Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaowan (vivo) and provides r01.
Alessio (Nokia) provides comments and proposes to note this LS
Curt (Charter) provides r01.
Curt (Charter) meant r02 as provided in server.
Ouyang(Huawei) asks a question for clarification.
xiawan(vivo) clarifies the value of the LS.
Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang (Huawei).
Xiaowan(vivo) provides r03.
Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and provides r04.
Alessio(Nokia) so is this meant to be a LS to RAN plenary encouraging them to let RAN WGs work on MUSIM in Q3? Then we ask to not this LS as this is not procedurally correct.
Saso (Intel) provides r05.
Saso (Intel) replies to Wanqiang (Huawei).
Curt (Charter) asks a question from Saso (intel).
Curt (Charter) provides r06.
Wanqiang(Huawei) provides r07 to move forward
Saso (Intel) is ok with both r06 and r07
Lars (Sony) provides r08.
Alessio(Nokia) reiterates objection to sending LS like this one.
Guillaume (MediaTek) chimes in and provides r09.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Saso (Intel) comments.
Qian Chen (Ericsson) is fine with r09.
Alessio(Nokia). Exactly because the TR is not mature we have to postpone the sending of a LS. When we send it, we will want a LS with clear questions which help SA2 to progress if answered and not an open ended LS which may not find a response we can use. So we object to this LS being sent as already said in several occasions.
Xiaowan (vivo) is fine with r09 and replies to Alessio
Alessio (Nokia) Responds to xiaowan ke
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.10

S2-2004334

TS OR TR COVER

Approval

Cover sheet for presentation of TR 23.761 to TSG SA#88

Intel (Rapporteur)

Rel-17

Created at CC#1. Noted

Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this, consistent and aligned with Ph 1 meeting decision on other TR Cover sheet handling.
Alessio(Nokia) supports Ericsson.
Guillaume (MediaTek) fails to understand the reasoning from Ericsson.
Shabnam (Ericsson) expresses their concerns at the language used by MediaTek and hope we continue to work professionally.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Saso (Intel) agrees with Guillaume (MediaTek).
Alessio(Nokia) comments
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

Study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G (FS_5GSAT_ARCH)

Docs:=42

8.11

LSs IN/OUT

Docs:=8

8.11

S2-2003516

LS In

Action

LS from RAN WG2: LS on dependencies on AS design for mobility management aspects of NTN in 5GS

RAN WG2 (R2-1916470)

Revision of postponed S2-2002610 from S2-138E. To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2003517

LS In

Action

LS from RAN WG2: LS on LS on system level design assumptions for satellite in 5GS

RAN WG2 (R2-1916620)

Revision of postponed S2-2002611 from S2-138E. To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2003520

LS In

Action

LS from SA WG3LI: Response LS on the 'LS OUT on Location of UEs and associated key issues'

SA WG3LI (S3i200056)

Revision of postponed S2-2002621 from S2-138E. To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2003556

LS In

Action

LS from RAN WG3: Response LS on Location of UEs and associated key issues

RAN WG3 (R3-202824)

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2003565

LS In

Action

LS from RAN WG2: Response LS on Location of UEs and associated key issues

RAN WG2 (R2-2004266)

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2004633

LS OUT

Approval

[DRAFT] LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G

Qualcomm

Rel-17

Created at meeting. R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004688

Jean Yves (Thales) sharing initial comments and concerns on proposed LS OUT
Haris (Qualcomm) provides initial version of LS
Hucheng (CATT) supports comments from Jean Yves (Thales).
Haris (Qualcomm) comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01
Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Qualcomm's comment : conclude means identify solutions, and name it.
Haris (Qualcomm) indicates is ok with r01
Hucheng(CATTT) agrees with Stefan's view on 'earth-fixed cell', and asks for a question for clarification.
Hannu (Nokia) shares the concern of Hucheng (CATT) and provides r02.
Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r02
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Haris (Qualcomm) and issues a COWS warning on the LS.
Stefan (Ericsson) objects to original revision.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Haris and can accept either version r01 or r02.
Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that we should go with r01.
Jean Yves (Thales) ok for r01
Chris (Vodafone) says that r01 seems logical, but we should postpone final agreement/editing to cc#4 and see what the conclusion is for KI#10 in S2-2004031.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004688

LS OUT

Approval

LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G

SA WG2

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004633. To handle at CC#4. Approved

Approved

8.11

S2-2004632

LS In

Action

LS from CT WG1: Reply to LS on PLMN selection solutions for satellite access

CT WG1 (C1-203791) (C1-203791)

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.11

Solutions Update

Docs:=7

8.11

S2-2003689

Approval

23.737 CR0006 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#1: Updates to Solution#1

Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004689

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions on r01
Hannu (Nokia) agrees the concerns raised by Stefan (Ericsson) and asks some more questions.
Haris (Qualcomm) asks relationship with open items in idle mode procedures of RAN WID and TR 38.821
Saso (Intel) replies to Haris (Qualcomm)
Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to previous comments on fixed cells and radio cells
Hannu (Nokia) supports the comment from Saso (Intel) on the RAN2 and RAN3 LS.
Haris (Qualcomm) comments
Jinguo (ZTE) comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r02
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
Jean Yves (Thales) agrees Stefan proposal to move forward and close study (for KI#1)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01 and r03 but not r00 or r02.
Hannu (Nokia) cannot accept r01 but r02 and r03 are OK.
Stefan (Ericsson) objects to r01. OK with r02 or r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004689

Approval

23.737 CR0006R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#1: Updates to Solution#1

Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2003689. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003688

Approval

23.737 CR0005 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#12: Handling of Cell ID in Solution #12

Ericsson

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004690

Chris (Vodafone) provides r01 as CN selection for LI needs network based positioning
Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions
Chris (Vodafone) provides r03 aligning LI with r01
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r02
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides answer to Stefan
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r02, r03 or r04 but not other versions.
Hannu (Nokia) supports r04.
Tyler (OTD) also prefers r04.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004690

Approval

23.737 CR0005R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#12: Handling of Cell ID in Solution #12

Ericsson

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003688. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003687

Approval

23.737 CR0004 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#13: Additional description and evaluation of Solution #13

Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004691

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Hannu (Nokia) objects to r01. Nokia can still agree the initial version.
Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarifications
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides requested clarifications to Stefan.
Stephen (Qualcomm) responds to objection from Hannu to r01.
Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for clarification
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm).
Antoine (Orange) asks questions on r01.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Relja (TNO) asks for some clarifications and based on the response possibly some updates.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r03
Stefan (Ericsson) replies
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Antoine (Orange)
Relja (TNO) would like to clarify one aspect of the solution.
Hannu (Nokia) supports r02.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Haris.
Hannu (Nokia) asks question from Relja (TNO)
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Chris (Vodafone) uploaded r04 then Outlook crashed
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01 or r04 but not other versions.
Hucheng(CATT) replies comments from Haris (Qualcomm)
Hannu (Nokia) comments on solution r04 and replies to Stephen and Chris.
Hannu (Nokia) answers to Chris.
Hannu (Nokia) answers to Haris (Qualcomm)
Chris (Vodafone) says that, to allow progress, he won't object to r03/r02/r01/r00 provided that the minutes record that 'it is agreed that the
NG-RAN needs to ensure that the CN is in the country that the UE is located without the use of UE based information'.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004691

Approval

23.737 CR0004R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Sol#13: Additional description and evaluation of Solution #13

Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003687. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2004209

Approval

23.737 CR0013 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of Editor's Notes (ENs)

TNO

Rel-17

WITHDRAWN

Relja (TNO) would like to WITHDRAW document S2-2004209.

Withdrawn

8.11

Overall Evaluation

Docs:=4

8.11

S2-2003672

Approval

23.737 CR0002 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI #1 solutions evaluation

Thales, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, TNO, Hughes Network Systems Ltd., ESA

Rel-17

Confirm CR Number - CR states

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Hannu (Nokia) provides r02.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01 and r02 but not r00.
Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to approve r02.
Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to go with r02.
Hannu (Nokia) supports r02.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004692

Approval

23.737 CR0002R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI #1 solutions evaluation

Thales, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, TNO, Hughes Network Systems Ltd., ESA

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2003672. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2004030

Approval

23.737 CR0011 (Rel-17, 'F'): Key Issue 10 solution evaluation

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales, TNO

Rel-17

R03 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004693

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Hannu (Nokia) provides r02.
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01 or r03 but not other versions.
Hannu (Nokia) supports r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004693

Approval

23.737 CR0011R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Key Issue 10 solution evaluation

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales, TNO

Rel-17

Revision_R03 of S2-2004030. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

Conclusions

Docs:=11

8.11

S2-2003673

Approval

23.737 CR0003 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI #1 conclusions

Thales, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, TNO, Hughes Network Systems Ltd., ESA

Rel-17

Confirm CR Number - CR states

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Hannu (Nokia) objects to r01. Nokia can still agree the initial version.
Jean Yves (Thales) requires for clarifications
Stephen (Qualcomm) responds to objection from Hannu to r01.
Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to request for clarification from Jean Yves
Jean Yves (Thales) replies to Stephen response following request for clarification from Jean Yves, and ask for precise concepts.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm).
Hannu (Nokia) provides r02 to merge the main aspects of 3799 to 3673.
Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for r02
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r03
Hannu (Nokia) provides r04 to update changes and to add Intel as supporting company
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on r04
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Jean Yves (Thales) agrees with Ericsson comments
Haris (Qualcomm) comments
Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r04
Saso (Intel) provides r05
Saso (Intel) provides r06
Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to use r04 or r05 instead of r06
Haris (Qualcomm) provides r06
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Haris
Hannu (Nokia) asks question from Haris and replies to earlier question.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01, r03, r05 or r06 but not other versions.
Hucheng(CATT) proposes to go with r04 or r05.
Stefan (Ericsson) prefers r04 but can live with r05. Objects to r06
Jean Yves (Thales) can live with r05 also
Hannu (Nokia) prefers r04, can live with r05 and objects to r06.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004694

Approval

23.737 CR0003R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): KI #1 conclusions

Thales, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, TNO, Hughes Network Systems Ltd., ESA, Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R06 of S2-2003673. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003799

Approval

23.737 CR0007 (Rel-17, 'F'): Conclusion on KI#1 and KI#2

Intel

Rel-17

R05 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003990, to S2-2004695

Hucheng (CATT) asks for a clarification.
Saso (Intel replies to Hucheng (CATT).
Hucheng (CATT) comments.
Saso (Intel) provides r01.
Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to split KI #1 and KI #2 conclusions to separate documents.
Saso (Intel) is OK to consider the KI #1 part of 3799 merged into 3673 and re-focus 3799 on KI#2 only; r02 provided.
Saso (Intel) replies to Stefan (Ericsson)
Stephen (Qualcomm) requests clarification on r02 for KI#2
Saso (Intel) offers a clarification to Stephen (Qualcomm)
Hannu agrees with r01 from Saso (Intel) and updates KI #1 part of 3673 accordingly (in another email).
Relja (TNO) supports Conclusions on KI#2 provided in S2-2003799r02.
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r03
Saso (Intel) OK with r03; provides minor update in r04
Relja (TNO) OK with r04; provides minor update in r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r03, r04 or r05 but not other versions.
Saso (Intel) OK with any of r03, r04 or r05. Proposes to agree r05.
Saso (Intel) replies to Relja (TNO).
Hannu (Nokia) supports r05.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004695

Approval

23.737 CR0007R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Conclusion on KI#1 and KI#2

Intel

Rel-17

Revision_R05 of S2-2003799, merging S2-2003990. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003833

Approval

23.737 CR0008 (Rel-17, 'F'): Conclusion update on KI #5

Samsung

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R03 Agreed. Revised S2-2004705.

Stefan (Ericsson) asks a question for clarification
Dongeun (Samsung) clarifies
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Dongeun (Samsung) responses to TNO and provides r02.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Dongeun (Samsung) is ok with r03
Hucheng (CATT) can not accept r02 and r03.
Dongeun (Samsung) replies to Hucheng (CATT)
Hucheng (CATT) comments and provides a proposal.
Dongeun (Samsung) accepts the proposals by Hucheng (CATT) that requires to reword the text as follows:
Whether and when QoS limitation defined in Solution #11 needs to be considered for UPF selection may be discussed in the normative work.
Samsung will seek for an agreement by Relja (TNO) and Stefan (Ericsson) for the above text in CC#4:
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to put this paper to CC#4.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004705

Approval

23.737 CR0008R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Conclusion update on KI #5

Samsung

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003833_R03. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003900

Approval

23.737 CR0009 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update the conclusion for KI#4

CATT

Rel-17

This CR was agreed

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003990

Approval

23.737 CR0010 (Rel-17, 'F'): Conclusion on solutions for Key Issue #2

TNO

Rel-17

Confirm CR Number - CR states Merged into S2-2004695

Hucheng (CATT) comments and proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003799.
Hannu (Nokia) supports the proposal from Hucheng to have one conclusion paper per key issue.
Relja (TNO) supports the proposal from Hucheng to merge S2-2003990 into S2-2003799. S2-2003799 should contain Conclusion on KI#2.
Relja (TNO) responds to comments of Hucheng (CATT).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.11

S2-2004031

Approval

23.737 CR0012 (Rel-17, 'F'): Key Issue 10 conclusions

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales, TNO

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R09 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004706.

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Jean Yves (Thales) asks for clarifications on r01
Stefan (Ericsson) agress with Jean Yves
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Hannu (Nokia) asks if the RAN impact in r02 can be taken out?
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r03
Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Qualcomm.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) comments.
Chris (Vodafone) proposes to postpone decision on S2-2004031 until the status and quality of any agreed revisions of S2-2003687, S2-2003688 and S2-2004030 are known.
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r01 or r03 but not other versions. We also agree with postponement as another option.
Stefan (Ericsson) objects to r01 and r03
Hannu (Nokia) proposes 4031 for CC #4 and replies to Chris.
Chris (Vodafone) says that treating this at CC#4 is fine. We need to see the outcome of the solution 12 and 13 updates, and then see if the evaluation in 4030 is accurate. Overall it is necessary that we record that 'it is agreed that the NG-RAN needs to ensure that the CN is in the country that the UE is located without the use of UE based information'.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004706

Approval

23.737 CR0012R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Key Issue 10 conclusions

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Thales, TNO

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004031_R09. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2003755

DISCUSSION

Agreement

Support activation of backhaul-aware UPF selection.

Samsung

Rel-17

Noted

Relja (TNO) asks for clarification of the term 'activation'.
Dongeun (Samsung) clarifies
Relja (TNO) ask additional question for clarification.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.11

Other

Docs:=4

8.11

S2-2003970

TS OR TR COVER

Approval

Presentation of Report to TSG: TR 23.737 Version 17.1.0 ' Study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G'

THALES

Rel-17

Noted

Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the r00
Antoine (Orange): This should be Noted since the TR has already been approved.
Hannu (Nokia) can agree with Qualcomm on at least one 5GSAT paper, to note this document.
Jean Yves (Thales)-proposing this document- I understand the point. Important is to effectively finalise last outstanding conclusions in TR 23.737 in this meeting. I'll refer to you/chair for best process observance for SA liaison.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Noted

8.11

S2-2004026

SID REVISED

Approval

Change of rapporteur on SID 'Study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G'

THALES

Rel-17

Noted

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====Puneet (Chair): Since the TR 23.737 was approved and any CRs will be implemented by MCC there is no need to change the rapporteur name in the SID. Puneet (Chair) changes the status from Approved to Noted.

Noted

8.11

S2-2003696

WID REVISED

Approval

Change of rapporteur on WID 'Integration of satellite systems in the 5G architecture'

THALES

Rel-17

Original agreed. Revised to S2-2004696

Hucheng (CATT) comments on the WID name and provides r01.
Jean Yves (Thales) objects on comments on the WID name
Haris (Qualcomm) supports Thales and objects to r01
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004696

WID REVISED

Approval

Change of rapporteur on WID 'Integration of satellite systems in the 5G architecture'

THALES

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2003696. To handle at CC#4. Approved

Approved

8.11

New Key Issues

Docs:=4

8.11

S2-2004263

DISCUSSION

Discussion

New KIs and Solutions for support of satellite access in 5G in TR 23.737 .

Qualcomm Incorporated

Noted

Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to NOTE the document for same reasons, see SA2 #139E_CC#3_FS_5GSAT_ARCH.ppt
Hannu (Nokia) issues a COWS alert on S2-2004263.
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the document (it is indicated as a Discussion Paper, but actually is a pCR and 23.737 is already under change control).
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports noting the document.
Relja (TNO) supports the proposal to NOTE the document.

Noted

8.11

S2-2004265

Approval

23.737 CR0014 (Rel-17, 'B'): New KI: Addition of new Key Issue for Minimization of 5GCN Impacts

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to NOTE the document also because it introduces new key Issues, see status in SA2 #139E_CC#3_FS_5GSAT_ARCH.ppt
Hannu (Nokia) issues a COWS alert on S2-2004265.
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the CR because it introduces a new Key Issue.
Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Jean Yves (Thales) and Saso (Intel) to note proposed new Key Issues.
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports noting the document.
Relja (TNO) supports the proposal to NOTE the document. At this stage the focus should be on finalization of the study item and not on introducing new KIs.

Noted

8.11

S2-2004266

Approval

23.737 CR0015 (Rel-17, 'B'): New KI: Addition of new Key Issue on accessing PLMNs in the same country

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to NOTE the document also because it introduces new key Issues, see status in SA2 #139E_CC#3_FS_5GSAT_ARCH.ppt
Hannu (Nokia) issues a COWS alert on S2-2004266.
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the CR because it introduces a new Key Issue.
Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Jean Yves (Thales) and Saso (Intel) to note proposed new Key Issues.
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports noting the document.
Relja (TNO) supports the proposal to NOTE the document due to the motivation listed in the previous Emails related to this topic.

Noted

8.11

S2-2004268

Approval

23.737 CR0016 (Rel-17, 'B'): New KI: Addition of new Key Issue on Supporting SV transfer between Earth Stations

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Jean Yves (Thales) proposes to NOTE the document also because it introduces new key Issues, see status in SA2 #139E_CC#3_FS_5GSAT_ARCH.ppt
Hannu (Nokia) issues a COWS alert on S2-2004268.
Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the CR because it introduces a new Key Issue.
Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Jean Yves (Thales) and Saso (Intel) to note proposed new Key Issues.
Guillaume (MediaTek) supports noting the document.
Relja (TNO) supports the proposal to NOTE the document. The study should be finalized and does not allow for introduction of new KIs at this stage.

Noted

8.11

New Solutions

Docs:=4

8.11

S2-2004269

Approval

23.737 CR0017 (Rel-17, 'B'): KI #X, #1, #2, #10, New Sol: Solution for Key Issue for Minimization of 5GCN Impacts

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

R01 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004697

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Puneet (Chair) seeks clarification on the status of 4269.
Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions for clarifications
Hannu (Nokia) shares the concerns of Stefan (Ericsson).
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides answers to comments and questions from Stefan and Hannu
Hannu (Nokia) replies.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides a response to Hannu.
Hannu (Nokia) comments r03.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004697

Approval

23.737 CR0017R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): KI #X, #1, #2, #10, New Sol: Solution for Key Issue for Minimization of 5GCN Impacts

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Revision_R01 of S2-2004269. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.11

S2-2004271

Approval

23.737 CR0018 (Rel-17, 'B'): KI #13, #x, #y, New Sol: Solution for Key Issue for accessing PLMNs in the same country

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

R02 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004698

Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Tyler H. (OTD) agrees with Stefan's (Ericsson) questions/issues with this solution
Jean Yves (Thales) agrees with Stefan's (Ericsson) and Tyler (OTD) questions/issues with this solution
Hannu (Nokia) supports comments by Stefan and Tyler.
Stephen replies to comments and questions from Stefan, Jean Ives, Tyler and Hannu
Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r02
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Stephen.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r02
Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Hannu.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.11

S2-2004698

Approval

23.737 CR0018R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): KI #13, #x, #y, New Sol: Solution for Key Issue for accessing PLMNs in the same country

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Revision_R02 of S2-2004271. This CR was agreed

Agreed

8.12

Study on architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services - Phase 2 (FS_eV2XARC_Ph2)

Docs:=19

8.12

S2-2003623

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Skeleton of FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 TR 23.776.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

Approved

==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Approved

8.12

S2-2003631

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Scope of FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 TR 23.776.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

R04 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004751

Adrian (vivo) provides r01
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Adrian (vivo) is happy.
Shabnam (Ericsson) is not happy ??, we have framed the scope in relation to Vulnerable roadside UE but I wonder how we determine that? Should we not stick to Pedestrian UEs and wording from the study item, see comments.
Adrian (vivo) provides r03 and responds to all.
Hao Dong (ZTE) comments that 'battery constrained UE' is not accurate.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) comments.
Hao Dong (ZTE) agrees with the proposal regarding 'Pedestrian UE' from Hong.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04.
Ouyang (Huawei) prefers to develop the definition of VRU in next meeting.
Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r05.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) supports r04, and objects to r05.
LaeYoung (LGE) prefers r04, but can live with r05.
Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r04.
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.12

S2-2004751

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Scope of FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 TR 23.776.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

Revision_R04 of S2-2003631. Approved

Approved

8.12

S2-2003937

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Add Pedestrian UE Definition.

ZTE

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Lei (Tencent) provide comments and provides r02 .
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to the comment and provides r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r03.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung's Q on r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to response from Hao Dong (ZTE).
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to comments from LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r04.
Lei (Tencent) comments Hao Dong (ZTE) and LaeYoung(LGE), provide r04.
Lei (Tencent) confirms there should be only one r04. Ok with the 04 by ZTE.
Guillaume (MediaTek) suggests this document as well as any revision to define Pedestrian UE to be noted.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to comment from MediaTek.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r05.
Adrian (vivo) agrees with MediaTek the document should be noted if term pedestrian UE is defined.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Hao Dong (ZTE) comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to comment from Hao Dong (ZTE).
Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this pCR (any all revisions) since the definition is not really being accurately reflected and I could not find any stage 1 defn either.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with Shabnam to NOTE this pCR (any all revisions).
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2003808

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: Support of VRU cluster head operation.

LG Electronics

Rel-17

Postponed

Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification on this KI proposal
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to questions from Dimitris (Lenovo).
Adrian (vivo) provides comments.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 with editorial changes.
LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r01 and provides comments.
Ouyang(Huawei ) asks a question for clarification
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Q from Ouyang (Huawei).
Hoyeon (Samsung) has concern to define additional application-level information by 3GPP.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides response to comment from Hoyeon (Samsung).
Changhong (Intel) comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to comment from Changhong (Intel).
Adrian (vivo) comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to cheer Adrian (vivo) up.
Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to note the PCR.
LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Hoyeon (Samsung).
Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====

Postponed

8.12

S2-2003809

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: DRX for pedestrian UEs.

LG Electronics, Interdigital

Rel-17

R07 Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2003936, S2-2004065, to S2-2004752, S2-2004246, S2-2004065, to S2-2004752 and S2-2004297 and S2-2004246 and S2-2004065, to S2-2004752

LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 that is a version trying to merge with S2-2004246 (Nokia) and S2-2004297 (Qualcomm).
Sherry (Nokia) provides r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r03, and responds to Laeyoung (LGE) and Sherry (Nokia).
Adrian (vivo) provides r04, and comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05.
Lei (Tencent) provides r06, and comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r07.
Lei(Tencent) is fine with r07.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.12

S2-2004752

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: DRX for pedestrian UEs.

LG Electronics, Interdigital, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Tencent

Rel-17

Revision_R07 of S2-2003809, merging S2-2003936 S2-2004065 S2-2004246 and S2-2004297. Approved

Approved

8.12

S2-2003912

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: Power efficient transmission.

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Changhong (Intel) comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) share same view as expressed by Intel and LGE, scope as described is so far RAN issue. Propose to note the pCR.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) share same view as expressed by Ericsson, Intel and LGE. The pCR.shall be NOTED
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2003913

P-CR

Approval

23.776: KI x: New solution: Enhance Uu RRC inactive state to optimize PC5 transmission .

Huawei, HiSilicon

Rel-17

Postponed

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to POSTPONE this paper.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also proposes to POSTPONE this paper and provides further comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Postponed

8.12

S2-2003936

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New Key Issue for Pedestrian UE Communication.

ZTE

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004752

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed bullets are related to Application layer operations or not considered in the scope.
Hoyeon (Samsung) comments
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to comments and provides r01.
Dimitris (Lenovo) questions if this paper should be merged with S2-2003809
Interdigital (Saad) provides comments on r01
Hao Dong (ZTE) agrees to merge this paper and it could be marked as 'Merged into S2-2003809'.
LaeYoung (LGE) thanks to Hao Dong (ZTE) and proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003809.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.12

S2-2003979

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Key issue for identifying the pedestrian UE.

Vivo

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed bullet is supported by Application layer and not the scope.
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments.
Saad (Interdigital) agrees with CATT and LGE.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2003980

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Key issue of power efficiency for PUE.

Vivo

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed bullet is too broad and reads same to the scope.
Changhong (Intel) shares view from LaeYoung (LGE) and proposes to NOTE it.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2004065

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: V2X communication efficiency for VRU .

Tencent

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004752

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed KI is related to Application layer operations.
Lei(ZTE) proposes comments/responses.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question regarding Lei (Tencent)'s comment.
Lei (Tencent) provide response and correct the company name within bracket in previous comment.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to answers from Lei (Tencent).
Lei (Tencent) comments and provides r01.
Adrian (vivo) comments and provides r02.
Ouyang(Huawei) ask a question for clarification.
Lei(Tencent) provide comments to Ouyang(Huawei).
Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lei.
Hoyeon(Samsung) asks questions for clarification to understand the proposal.
Adrian (vivo) provides comments.
Lei(Tencent) replies to Ouyang (Huawei).
Lei (Tencent) provides response to Adrian(vivo).
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question.
Lei (Tencent) respond to questions from Hoyeon(Samsung) and provide r03 .
Lei (Tencent) responds to LaeYoung(LGE).
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r04 and comments.
Lei (Tencent) provides comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes that we consider this document as merged to S2-2003809 since both are discussing battery efficiency aspects? See comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003809.
Lei(Tencent) respond to Shabnam(Ericsson) and LaeYoung (LGE).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.12

S2-2004246

P-CR

Approval

23.776: Authorization and provisioning to support power saving over PC5 .

Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004752

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003809 (LGE, Interdigital).
Sherry comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question for clarification.
Sherry (Nokia) replies.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.12

S2-2004294

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: Support of RSU assisted power efficient PC5 communication.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Saad (Idcc) has a question on r01
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Saad (IDCC).
Saad (IDCC) responds to the Hong's (QCOM) reply
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) comments on RSU
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r02.
Hong (Qualcomm responds to Leo (Deutsche Telekom).
Shabnam (Ericsson) Ericsson objects to all revisions of this pCR, this is not in scope of the study, see comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to Shabnam.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2004296

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New Solution: RSU assisted power efficient PC5 communication.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Noted

Hoyeon(Samsung) asks questions for clarification to understand the proposal.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responses to Hoyeon(Samsung).
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to POSTPONE this contribution to the next meeting.
Shabnam (Ericsson) Ericsson objects to all revisions of this pCR, this is not in scope of the study as indicated also for S2-2004295.
Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a following question.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Noted

8.12

S2-2004297

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New KI: QoS aware power efficient PC5 communication.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

Merged into S2-2004752

LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2003809 (LGE, Interdigital).
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Merged

8.12

S2-2004298

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New Solution: QoS aware power efficient PC5 communication.

Qualcomm Incorporated

Rel-17

To handle at CC#4. R06 Agreed. Revised to S2-2004714

LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Changhong (Intel) has same comment with LY.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) responds to LaeYoung (LGE).
Lei (Tencent) comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes revision, also addressing other comments.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01 for further updates.
Hong (Qualcomm Inc.) provides r02.
Hoyeon (Samsung) comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) asks further update.
Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03, and responds to Hoyeon (Samsung).
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r04 with addition of EN of what the RAN dependencies that need to be addressed in RAN.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05.
Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06.
==== Ph2 Revisions Deadline ====
Hoyeon (Samsung) can leave with r06 for now, but may revisit exposure of transmission time cycle to applications.
Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to the original Tdoc and rev thereof, subject to discussion during Friday CC on TDoc handling.
Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Guillaume (MediaTek).
==== Ph2 Final Deadline ====
==== Ph2 Close of meeting ====

Revised

8.12

S2-2004714

P-CR

Approval

23.776: New Solution: QoS aware power efficient PC5 communication.

Qualcomm Incorporated, LG Electronics

Rel-17

Revision of S2-2004298_R06. Approved

Approved

CC#3

SA2#139E_CC#3 (Cancelled)

Docs:=0

CC#4

SA2#139E_CC#4

Docs:=0

11.2

Close of Phase 2 of the meeting

Docs:=0